I never ordered an entire cake from a bakery for delivery. I did order a strawberry cake for the first time through DoorDash from Sugar Rush. The quality of the cake was exceptional. It was very tender with a perfect "crumb" and used real strawberries. The buttercream frosting was right on point-definitely top quality. The cake was wonderfully decorated. I've included a picture. I'm a cake fanatic so it's not unusual for me to keep trying cake from different bakeries. It's a great hobby. read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - Strawberry buttercream cake. - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

Order the rainbow cake just straight sugar no flavor at all and it was very dry was very disappointed. Will not order this anymore

The ABSOLUTE best business on the Far East side of Columbus. We've gotta custom cake or cupcakes for every family birthday for 6 years running and they never disappoint. read more

See all

I visited the new location with my family on a Saturday afternoon. It's literally two doors down from the old one. I love, love, love the new look. The owner greeted us and was extremely patient and attentive to me and my kids. She gave details of whatever we asked about and made suggestions. SO much to choose from. They even have coffee and spirits infused cupcake options. The kids got a cake pop and freeze dried candy. I looked over the menu and IG page and wanted to try the Blackout! My fiance was given the suggestion to try the All Dolled Up. I also ordered a cookie dough donut. The donut was delicious, of course. I asked for a fork, and they gave us these pretty rainbow colored forks. Super cute! I didn't love how much lime the Blackout had, but it was so cute, lol My fiance didn't mind it, so we swapped. The owner checked in on us, asking how everything was. I gave my opinion, and she offered me the All Dolled Up on the house. How sweet?! Also, my son dropped his cake pop, hugging the GIANT gummy bear decor. MELTDOWN!!! She replaced it when she realized what had happened. We chilled for a second to enjoy our treats , drinks, and even a little football on the TVs. Excellent customer service. Nice place to grab something sweet for the kids or even yourself. A drink for adults or shaje fur the kids and chill. With the new space, I'm sure we'll be back when we need a sweet treat. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED. read more

See all

Omg looooved my daughter's cake! She had a unicorn theme party! The staff specifically Mandy was very helpful and every time I called I asked for her because she made great suggestions and continued to help me for 3 days. The party goers said the cake and cupcakes tasted amazing! I will definitely order again for my daughter's second party. Place was super clean and staff was generous and friendly when I came in to pick up they even gave me a reminder on how to store the cake. This place made my daughter's FIRST birthday so magical! read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - Birthday Cake - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

I ordered a custom churro flavored cake for my husband's birthday, and it was perfect! Decorations were exactly what I wanted (simple, focusing on flavor) and the cake tasted INCREDIBLE. Super rich and tasted exactly like a fresh churro. I'm not a fan of frosting in general (I usually scrape it off and just eat the cake, heretical I know) but even I concede that it was phenomenal. And overall, price was completely in line with the quality that we received (and a friend was surprised it wasn't more!). I would 100% recommend this place for anyone getting a custom event cake! read more

Very spacious inside with wide selections of goodies. The blueberry lemon cake and the cupcakes are very good. read more

See all

The vanilla funfetti cake was perfect. It's light and the frosting is just right - not too sweet, super perfect mouth feel. The chocolate is not as chocolatey as I like but if you're looking for a light milk chocolate flavor it's delicious. read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - The vanilla funfetti cake was perfect. It's light and the frosting is just right - not too sweet, super perfect mouth feel. - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

See all

I'll start by saying that I've only experienced Sugar Rush once and it was specifically for their cupcakes. My friend's boyfriend put an order in for us and even delivered them. He's a sweetie. I got a lemon blueberry cupcake with blueberry icing and I couldn't put it down. There were whole blueberries inside, sort of like a muffin, but it was all cake. It was gone in a flash. My friend went with the red velvet and raved about it as well. I'm not in the Reynoldsburg area very often but I know my first cupcake from here won't be my last. read more

I've been to Sugar Rush twice now, and while the place is good overall, the cookies didn't win me over. I followed the directions to heat them up, but they were still dry and bland. The cowboy cookie? Let's just say, it should've stayed on the ranch--way too salty! But the pineapple upside-down cookie cake? Absolute heaven. Definitely recommend that one. As for the cupcakes and cakes, they were both delicious--those alone are worth the trip. The ambiance is really cool too. I love the colors, and they've got a pinball machine that adds a fun, modern vibe to the whole place. Definitely a spot with a unique, playful theme. Would I go back? Absolutely. I still need to try their drinks and those over-the-top shakes (though I might need to bring a small army to help me out). The staff? Great both times. If I had one suggestion, besides maybe working on those cookies, it'd be this: they should start offering insulin at the door--just kidding (but not really)! Thanks for the sugar rush, Sugar Rush! read more

We have been to this place before and got cupcakes which were delicious. Came back again and met the manager, she was lovely and informative. The place is very creative and colorful. Got a cake this past Friday and had it today everyone loved it. Not over powering with sweetness and was the perfect amount of icing. My aunt said "I hate to say it but I fcking love this cake omg I need another slice" must have would recommend 10/10 I did have a shake as well and it was perfect. Loved all of it. read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - Rainbow Cake - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

Best cake pops that I've ever had. The pineapple upside down cupcake is also a favorite.

Had an idea for my son's 25th birthday; he likes the Witcher book series and show. I found three cakes online, called the bakery, and spoke with Frank. Frank is familiar with the series, and I asked him liberty to do what he wanted based on the pictures I sent. Let's just say I was thrilled with the outcome! I chose cookies and cream cake, it was very moist and their buttercream is fabulous! Everything you see is edible. I will definitely come here again. Never mind the bent hilt of the sword, I live thirty minutes away, and I didn't have my car cool enough while driving. read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

See all

Really cute little shop inside of a strip mall. Definitely pay attention to the writing on the doors as their building sign isn't currently up. They were happy to do a custom order - and even went as far as to purchase a mold specifically for the custom order we made. The order was entirely ordered over the phone with no issue - and we just came in later and picked it up. Everyone was super friendly when I came to pick up the treat. It was perfectly packaged and very fresh (made that morning!). It survived a car trip easily. The cupcakes were absolutely delicious too. Their Chocolate tastes like a standard Chocolate (more cocoa-based than some?), so if you have the chance, go for their unique flavor options. I definitely recommend their Cookies and Cream sponge flavor for a unique flavor compared to most baked goods. Cupcakes have stayed good and fresh for over a week now in their original packaging from Sugar Rush. Definitely would order here again! Love how open they were to a weird custom order - and how good it looked and tasted! read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - Exterior - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

See all

The best desserts in Columbus . Unique and tasty. The creative drinks are a plus too. I love that they support other small local businesses by promoting their stuff in their shop. read more

See all

My favorite thing no doubt is the mashup cookies!!! You must try some. These are better than the other cookie places in my opinion. We have tried several different flavors and they all were so delicious! My favorite was the OH my buckeye for all the peanut butter & chocolate lovers. My fiancés favorite was the cosmic chocolate. They always have different flavors and they never disappoint. They do also have a variety of cupcakes with tons of different flavors that change weekly. They also have a variety of different desserts. read more

I ordered the almond cake. It was the most amazing cake I have ever had in my life everybody at my party raved about it .Also, the decorations were beautifully done. Will buy my cake here every time all the time! read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

The cookies were large and well designed. We split a Chai and Hot Chocolate cookie. These are the currently popular "monster" cookies so probably could be split between 4 people. The Peppermint and marshmallow topping on the Hot Cocoa cookie made it feel fresh and innovative. The chai tea cookie was fresh and gooey on the inside. Would have been fun to try warmed up. Right now there isn't really seating inside the small bakery so didn't try one of their signature shakes or larger items. read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

Got Cake?! Sugar Rush does!! I've ordered two birthday cakes from here and I've been impressed with both. I opted for them to freestyle the cakes with my desired theme. One cake was vanilla and the other confetti! There cakes are seriously delicious and some of the best Ive tasted. Both cakes were super fresh (soft and moist)and kept well if you store it properly. The buttercream is perfect as well. It's solid like butter and not hard like other traditional butter creams. The inside of the cake is 4 thick layers which goes a long way when serving. I would recommend asking the best method to cut it so you don't butcher it or cause it to fall to one side. Their cakes comes in a nice sturdy box which makes it easy to carry and store in your fridge without messing it up. These cakes will cost you a bit more than what you'll pay at a grocery store, but it's so worth it it. These cakes are fresh not frozen like store cakes, taste great and you can get any design you want. A themed cake will cost you about $100. Again, you won't be disappointed. Sugar rush offers other treats such as candies, cookies, cupcakes etc. I have tried the cupcakes and they have some really good flavors. The blueberry lemon was a fav, but to be honest the cupcakes-cake was just ok for me. Cupcakes can be a bit more dryer bc they are small. Again, their cakes are amazing in design and flavor!! They've gained a repeat customer with me!!! read more

See all

Stopped by this little gem off Broad Street beside Pet Supplies Plus and Target. Amazing doesn't do it justice. Whatever you think of when ordering a milk shake, it will all change after your visit to Sugar Rush. This picture does not do it justice. We ordered a peanut butter shake and a strawberry shake. That is what is in this picture. WHAT!!!! The cupcakes and cookies come with it. Cupcakes were so moist and the cookies were so packed with flavors that it weighed a ton. We WILL be back. read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

Loved the selection. Friendly service. I got some creme brûlée cupcakes that were fabulous.

Buyer beware --- these folks are not professionals and are frankly, unkind.... Very disappointed in not only the cake we received but the customer service. I ordered a $200+ two-tier cake for my daughter's birthday. While I was appreciative that they were able to give me a cake within a week notice the end product was disappointing. Not only was the cake nearly falling over after one hour out of the refrigerator, the icing was behind the writing of her name on the cake was a different dark color and looked botched. And frankly , the piping did not look professional. I could've overlooked the piping had everything else not been a disaster. When we took the top tier off, we found a support rod in the top tier and a support rod in the bottom tier but nothing that went through the entirety of the cake (see photos of the separate rods not connected and not going through both tiers) I emailed the business and they seemed apologetic and assured that they would call me to discuss and when they didn't call me within a week I emailed again with no response. Today I called them to discuss it and they gave me a story that some child was in a hospital so that's why they didn't get back to me. That may have been the case, and of course, a very unfortunate situation, but it seemed as though they were trying to guilt me about their lack of communication instead of being accountable to anything. When I started discussing the issues what we had with the cake, they were very defensive. They told me that having dark splotches all over the icing was normal, even though it aesthetically ruined the cake, and as I was telling them about the lack of support in the cake to keep it from leaning, someone was in the background saying that oh I saw them put it through and the very rude gentleman on the phone told me "I don't want call you a liar but..." I would never order a cake if I didn't want pay the price for it so this wasn't about getting money from them but a legitimate grievance to which they took no responsibility. In fact, they got defensive and extremely rude on the phone that I told them I could no longer engage in the conversation and ended the phone call because they were being nasty and I will not tolerate being spoken to like that and called a liar. As any mom would, I went to great lengths to organize a wonderful birthday party, and the cake was supposed to be the centerpiece, but this shop failed to deliver what they said they would with the cake, and also had a lack of politeness and customer service. Do yourself a favor and find a more reputable cake shop that does professional work and provides basic customer service. read more

What a find!!! I stumbled across this place as I was visiting a nearby store and was thrilled upon walking in. The place is SO cute, and their treats are gorgeous. I was so excited to find such a great place on the eastside of Columbus! Items we've tried so far- Vanilla cake pop, chocolate cakesicle, pistachio macarons, vanilla tie-dye macarons, buckeye cupcakes, the whipped frosting cookies and cream cupcakes, and fruity pebbles cupcakes. We have enjoyed everything, but our two favorite things were the cookies and cream and buckeye cupcakes. Wowowow!! I'll definitely be ordering my husband's cookies and cream birthday cake from here! The only thing I didn't love was the macarons, but that's because I'm a little picky with macaron flavors and don't like them to be overly sweet. The macs were beautiful and well made, just a little too sweet for my taste. But the kids and my husband loved them. I saw on their Instagram page that back in December they had a cake decorating class to learn to decorate a drip cake, and I hope they do more events like that in the future because I would LOVE to attend! On top of their tasty baked goods, they also have other treats including super cool looking milkshakes. And the staff was very friendly and helpful both times I stopped in! One question I have though- Why doesn't this store have a sign?? Honestly, being next to CosmoProf, I had no idea that this was a sweet shop next to it. I thought their colorful storefront was a continuation of the beauty supply store. Hopefully it's just a temporary issue and a sign is on the way! read more

See all

I am giving this place a 5-star review because of my love for milkshakes, chocolate chip cookies, and customer service. Now that I got that out of the way, you should come on out and check this spot out. There are a few things in life that I love, and on that shortlist of things, milkshakes rank high up there. I just absolutely love a great milkshake, and this place has them. My go-to shake of cookies and cream is how I determine if a business will be a bust or not. It's so hard to make one of those sweet OREO infused goodness for some reason, but this place does it flawlessly. I was a little hesitant at first because the shakes can be a little bit intimidating. How can a shake be fierce?, look at the pictures that I have included with this review. You get a lot of shakes, a cookie, and a cupcake in the same order. When I got my shake, I was like, oh my Gawd, what is this monstrosity. Rest assured that everything is freaking delicious!!! read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - Cookie and cream shake - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

Omg so the other day my husband dashed a slice rainbow cake and it was absolutely amazing the cupcakes were pretty good too but that cake, that frosting! So since my birthday is next week I decided that I wanted a Sugar Rush cake so my daughter bought me a tie dye rainbow cake and oh sweet Jesus!!!! My husband and I have decided that this is our new favorite cake and our new go to place for cakes!!! If the frosting feels stiff or hard initially (on both cakes or cupcakes) it is because it's cold and or came out of the freezer because once it comes to room temperature, the taste is unbelievable! read more

See all

We will be repeat customers for sure. I needed a last minute birthday cake back in June & the owner of Sugar Rush was amazing! He took time to sit with me, gave suggestions - which his suggestions were perfect for flavors. Cake was ready exactly on time of pick up, super easy ordering process. Very clean, cute bakery. Display case stocked with goodies & cute creations. It was a little pricey cake - $110 - but when we tasted the cake (almond & chocolate layers), best tasting cake we have ever had! You can tell he spares no expense on ingredients used. Icing layers were done perfect - tasted amazing too. They provide very nice travel boxes for the cakes, allowing easy transport. The cake was fresh for days in the fridge afterwards. So happy I found this place, will never go anywhere else for cakes read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

I found this cute shop on our neighborhood Facebook page. There isn't a sign on top of the building, but the windows are decorated and the door is clearly labeled. The decor was a colorful candy shop. They have a lot of different cupcakes to choose from and many other sweet treats. We started with 6 cupcakes and loved them all. The only issue was we ate them before they made it to room temp, but a quick zap in the microwave for 5 seconds, made them moist and yummy. My favorite was the buckeye and strawberry lemonade cupcake. Our next visit we are excited to try a milkshake and hot chocolate bomb, that others keep raving about! read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - Cupcakes - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

This place is the cutest and offers such a variety of unique sweet treats! We tried cookies, cupcakes, and hot chocolate bombs, and it was all very delicious. The prices are great for the quality. Parking is easy, there's a huge lot in front of the store, as it's part of a strip of stores. It's also very cute inside, although I didn't get any pictures because I was so focused on checking out the goodies. Next time! We will definitely be back. read more

See all

The best cake and cupcakes in Columbus Ohio. I had a cake from here for a birthday party I attended and loved it so much I got my boyfriend's birthday cake from here. The owner of this place really cares about her customers and I love that I've never had bad customer service here. read more

When you enter Sugar Rush you're greeted with bright colored decor and friendly staff! They have a selection of cupcakes, donuts and cookies here. We opted for the cookies -- s'mores and snickerdoodle. When I got home I microwaved mine and it made the cookie so satisfying gooey! The outside was a bit overcooked, but I enjoyed this treat overall. The cookies are large enough to share, however. When we're back in the area I'll be certain to make a return visit! read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - The inside - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

See all

In ordered gender reveal cupcakes. The owner insisted they put colored sprinkles (called it something else) the cupcakes were hard to eat without making a mess. There were pink sprinkles inside of the box so we knew before we even had one. I was rather disappointed after spending quite a bit on 2 dozen cupcakes. Would I order from here again probably not. read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - The cupcake with a bunch of pink sprinkles. - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

We went to a mommy and me (mother/son) cake decorating class. My son has significant ADHD and has a lot of difficulty sitting still. They were so patient with him. We received step by step instructions how to decorate our cake and we had the best time. The best part...the cake was amazing. The icing was not waxy and the cake (bread) as my so. called it, was absolutely delicious. We will definitely be going back. read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - our decorated cake - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

Stopped by to check out the goodies yesterday. Wowza! The cookies are ginormous. Cupcakes were beautiful too. After several minutes of drooling, I selected a S'mores cookie. It was beautiful Ly topped with graham cracker crumbs and tons on mini marshmallows. Trust me - these cookies are super sweet. Not only oversized but dense and heavy.one cookie is more than enough for two to share. My only beef and it's a big one is that this gorgeous confection was packaged in a big styrofoam takeout container . Very unappealing. The competition has beautiful boxes and really make a statement. read more

This was my first time ordering from Sugar Rush. I submitted an order request online and they got back to me two days later. On my request I uploaded pictures of what I wanted. But confirmed when I placed the order over the phone. Pick up was smooth. I did have a little issue with the i looking like an L to me. But when I asked if they could fix it they did it in 2 mins. The taste of the cake was very good. Mine was a simple vanilla but it was so moist and airy. I will definitely be ordering again read more

See all

I have to give Sugar Rush 2 stars. To start off when I got to the store I noticed there were 2 Sugar Rush stores. I was confused as to which one to go to, but luckily I walked into the correct one. I think you should make it not confusing for new people mistakenly going to the wrong store. I see it is your new location spot, probably bigger space. Lots of food choices from cupcakes, cakes, cookies, cake pops, and adult drinks. The gentleman that was working was really nice and had great attitude. There were three other females working and they weren't friendly ( no smiles ). I'm big on how people are treating customers and employees. I saw someone walked up to the adult bar area asking for something and they were completely being ignored. I thought that was rude. Anyways I order 1 thing and that was a slice of rainbow cake. The cake took FOREVER to come out. I was sitting and waiting and waiting.... Y'all it took them 10min to cut a slice of cake and to drizzle icing on the plate. It was cute presentation and the retro fork was a nice added touch. But for real nobody doesn't want to wait 10min for a slice. There were only 4 families in there at that time. Another issue while eating my cake was, if you are making a place to not only cater to everyone with children present. You shouldn't be playing music that has offensive cuss words. When the song was playing, I saw a mother eyes open wide when she heard the words and hope her daughter didn't hear the words. Luckily the gentleman went running to the back to change the song. Lastly the prices it all depends on what you choose but it is pricey. Would I come back to here to give it a try possibly down the road. read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - Rainbow Cake - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

Picked up Littleman from the sitter and in a sweet voice he said,"Momma, can we go to SugarRush?" I couldn't resist his sweetness, so to Sugar Rush Columbus we went and picked up tasty treats. Did you know they make donuts now? Littleman chowed down on the donut he picked out and said it was 100,050 out of 10 I'd say that's a pretty delicious donut! All of the treats we have had have been super delicious and fun! When we get their treats for events all the guests always rave at how fun and neat everything is. The shop is always clean and numerous safety measures such as masks and gloves are always put in place , the owner and staff are friendly, fun, and provide top notch service and items. A favorite for our family. read more

See all

We love Sugar Rush for special occasions or just a stop in after school for a treat. You cannot go wrong with the cupcakes, but I love the cookies and macaroons! Constantly changing up flavors and items on the menu. They did a fantastic job on a custom birthday cake that looked and tasted great. Plus, you're supporting a local women-owned business who's family is active in the community! Now, if we can just get some doughnuts on the regular! :) read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - Extreme Shake! - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

Warning! If you order a cake and they make a mistake (like give you the wrong flavor), they will NOT give you a refund. Not even a percentage of a refund. For a cake that was $147 I was offered a coupon for my next order or a free milkshake‍. So lame, no thank you! I will not be going back. read more

We came for cupcakes, cake pops, and cocoa bombs. After two small milkshakes, 9 cupcakes, a chocolate bomb, and two cake pops we spent $54 dollars. The place is cute and the owner is super nice but we had two gripes. First, the cupcakes fell apart badly and were very crumbly. Second, our $11 small milkshake was half whipped cream. That was a Major bummer. This is a really cute store and definitely worth a visit but that will be our only stop for just fun. I may order a cake in the future though because they look AMAZING and very, very well done!! read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - The entrance - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

What can I say?! This place was awesome! I needed a cake kind of last minute and I had reached out to several cake places to do a custom cake. Everyone was booked but Sugar Rush had no issues helping me out. I ordered an awesome cake for my fiancé's 50th birthday and people at his birthday dinner absolutely loved the cake! We ordered a number cake with the '5' in lemon and the '0' in salted caramel. You can have them put whatever you want on the cake. We got so many raves from people that my dad has requested a cake from here for his next birthday and my sister-in-law is looking into ordering a cake as well! Thank you so much for the wonderful cake and making his day so special. Bonus: when I was picking up the cake they had so many yummy items in the case that we are planning another trip up there to pick up a few of those items! read more

Sugar Rush Columbus - Lemon #5 and salted caramel #0 with added buckeyes and naked fruit! - Desserts Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

See all