We found this restaurant one late September day on our way out to Montauk. It is near the eastern tip of the barrier island and Dune Road. Beautiful location with bay views and the marina. On a Sunday afternoon, looked mainly like regulars coming in around noon. The lobsters and clams were excellent as was the service. The menu was varied for a Sunday Brunch/Lunch and a great value compared to other restaurants of its location type and customer base. Afterwards, we walked about 200 yards to watch the folks fishing off the rocks both into the Bay and the Ocean. read more

Have not been here in years and wow delicious what an upgrade...best food in Hampton Bays, i think so , so cute, drinks are cute. Walked right in and ate right away! read more

Cuisine: 7 Service: 6 Decor: 8 Value: 6 Overall: 7 On a busy Saturday night with a beautiful sunset, this nice looking beachside restaurant was popping. Five of us walked in and were told that the outside patio was full. However, we were lucky enough to get the only indoor table left. Looking over the menu, we started with a handful of appetizers to share. The dozen Raw Topneck Clams were clean and briny, just how I like them. Fried Calamari was excellent too, crispy and super tender. The Grilled Peach & Burrata was good, but the peach could have been sweeter. Unfortunately, the New England Clam Chowder was too salty and smoky from the bacon. It covered much of the clam flavor that I was looking for. Still decent. However, the Crab Cakes taste more like potato croquettes. These were really bad. Skip! As for the entrees, we were all very impressed with the House Burger. Talk about a perfectly medium rare cooked thick beef patty, nicely charred and juicy. The Pan Seared Scallops with a lobster corn salad was delightful. Lastly, the Vegan Rosa Tagliatelle had a robust garlicky tomato sauce, although we didn't really taste any cashew. Located in by the water with such a gorgeous backdrop, I guess the high prices were expected, and the portion sizes are not bad. Service was friendly when available, but somewhat absent at times. Regardless, I would be satisfied with a meal here whenever I'm back in Hampton Bay. read more

See all

Came here with family and this place was great. Beautiful atmosphere and the staff were great. We chose to sit outside and they had beautiful outdoor seating on the water enclosed off and it was very nice. The inside is very nice as well, but it was beautiful day so we chose to eat outside. The food here was good and what I liked is it doesn't get packed like there other restaurants Oaklands they own right next to them. I feel the younger crowd flocks to Oaklands and Sundays is more the older crowd. Either way both restaurants are great. I got a burger and my wife got fish and chips and both were great! I would definitely come back and look forward to trying different items off the menu. Food 9/10 Staff 10/10 Ambiance 10/10 Parking accessibility 10/10 Look forward to coming back and highly recommend! read more

See all

The food at Sundays on the Bay is solid -- fresh and well-prepared, with a menu that delivers exactly what you'd expect from a waterside spot. Unfortunately, the service and management leave much to be desired. Staff were noticeably unfriendly, and the wait for service was unreasonably long, even though there were plenty of empty tables available outside. Despite the space, the host refused to seat us there, which felt more like poor management than policy. The vibe is very local, which can be charming if you're familiar with the scene, but don't expect much in the way of hospitality. Could be worth a visit for the food and view -- just don't come hungry or in a rush. read more

See all

This was meh. We came here for their weekly twin lobster special (two twin lobsters with corn and a potato for $55). We were able to walk in with no reservation on a Monday night and were quickly seated. After a round of drinks, we started with a few appetizers - New England Clam Chowder (because I'm on a mission to sample them all), some oysters on the half shell and baked clams. The oysters had no flavor and lacked that "fresh out of the water" salinity, the New England Clam Chowder tasted like someone threw a bunch of extra herbs into a can of Progresso and the baked clams were bland and overdone. Despite all of this I was still hopeful that my steamed lobster would be fine...how bad can you mess up lobster, right? I don't know where they get these lobsters from that they're this cheap, but they were also a bit rubbery but still edible, so I drowned mine with butter and made the best of it. The seafood stuffing I added on for $8 was overdone and burnt. Honestly, the best part of this meal was the corn. The ambiance here is probably what draws folks in since it's right on the water, but there's nothing else redeeming about this place. I'd skip it. read more

Sundays On The Bay - Flavorless oysters and New England clam chowder that tastes like Progresso - Seafood Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Returned to Sundays after several seasonal visits the past couple of years only to be met with disappointment. We were met and greeted immediately and cheerfully and led to a deck table overlooking the marina. Excellent. We were introduced by our smiling, upbeat server Anna (who'd, coincidentally, served us last summer too!). We ordered the clams in garlic white wine sauce, 2 lobster specials (2 lobsters each with 1/2 ear of corn, baked potato and drawn butter) and a bottle of Sancerre to enjoy with it all. I had a perfect spicy Bloody Mary to start off with too! The clams arrived in quick fashion with a small warm baguette. I highly recommend this dish! The clams were each 1/2 dollar sized, cooked perfectly and nestled in a wonderful wine & garlic sauce. Yum! The baguette was perfectly crusty outside and cushiony inside to soak up the clam bowl goodness. Then...the lobsters...served as we've seen in the past. Two steamed 1- 11/4 pound crustaceans with corn & potato side. However, the corn was pretty flavorless & unappealing and all 4 lobsters, sadly & unexpectedly, noticeably overcooked. A shame. Additionally the lobster special price had risen by 10% from $50/pp to $55/pp. A disappointing evening after all. Doesn't mean we won't write it off as an off night and try again...but stirred the "lobster is pretty ubiquitous around here & I'm well qualified to buy it & cook it myself served with better corn & save a lot on the wine" conversation. My prior visits have been 10s and Anna is terrific, so we'll likely return...but the "ubiquitous lobster" talk is gaining traction. read more

See all

I will NEVER come back to eat here. The service was horribly slow and forgetful. Specifically, our waitress KAITLYN was apparently complaining to the rest of the staff about my family. She consistently messed up bringing out basic things like utensils and refilling water. They took almost 15 minutes to make 3 coffees (while not even ASKING half of our group), and it got to a point where we just cancelled it to get the check. Later on, we found out that she was offered help from another server but REFUSED. Obviously she needed it, but it seems like she wanted the guaranteed 20% tip for herself. We made sure she got none of it, but not before even more issues. Their prices are insane for mediocre food: either way too much salt or unseasoned. Never mind how we had to send back a steak that looked like pure coal (supposed to be medium well) and an incorrect size of lobster. Our bill was thousands of dollars for our large group. That would have been fine if the service wasn't as horrible as it was. At the end of the night, we wanted to let management know of how unhappy we were. The manager that night, BRI (TAKE NOTE), walked away mid conversation with my uncle. She was so incredibly rude to us and wouldn't even hear us! We just want to leave at this point so we split up the check so we can finally pay. KAITLYN then proceeded to tell us that WE had to hurry up because they had another large party that had been waiting. WE WOULD HAVE BEEN OUT OF THERE if they hadn't been so slow!! Don't blame us for something we had no control of!! Either way, the cards are processed, but one of my aunts has CHASE fraud alert on large purchases. We were talking, so she didn't see it at first. No big deal, right? She just had to text back YES and it would go through. However, before they could even let my aunt know it came up as fraud, BRI accused us of trying to skip out on the check and CALLED THE COPS after shouting to "get the fuck out of my restaurant"!! Who says that in front of FOUR CHILDREN (my cousins)!!! Please heed this as a warning if you were ever thinking about dining at Sunday's. As long as BRI AND KAITLYN still work there, you can expect snotty remarks and a mediocre experience at best. read more

Wonderful place! The location was perfect (weather helped out), service was prompt and friendly, and the food was amazing. All around great! Started off with the Oysters (cooked), got the Fish Tacos...Fish Sandwich and Lobster Roll. Lobster Roll was mine and delicious! Totally worth the price. The view helped as well, and we were in and out pretty quickly. Highly recommend stopping by if in the area. read more

See all

We came on a Saturday night, party of 7. Make a reservation! Julia was lovely. We sat inside which was fine. A lot of windows and there was a pleasant breeze. No a/c. We came specifically for steamed lobster and we weren't disappointed. I really liked the coleslaw too (sweet with a little vinegar). The staff was friendly. Good place for families and friends. read more

Sundays On The Bay - Steamed 2lb Lobster - Seafood Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

Great place. Hosted my sisters night before/rehearsal party and it went well. We needed additional seating and the staff made that happen in a timely fashion. Briana was good to work with in coordinating the details ahead of time. read more

Sundays On The Bay - Seafood Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

8/8/23 Twin lobsters were on our mind this evening. We ordered one each of our lobsters stuffed with their amazing stuffing. Our server Ryane was very attentive, We opted to bring a few claws and a tail home to make lobster salad tomorrow, I'm sure it will be wonderfully delicious. Sundays on the bay is always a lovely setting and a special treat. read more

Sundays On The Bay - Twin lobster special, one with a side of fries and one with a house salad. Always a great sunset overlooking the boat dock! - Seafood Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

A Sunday in Hell I wish I could give this restaurant a lower rating. I was here for a special occasion for a family member. This is my second time here. Last time the overall experience was decent at best. This time it's was horrible. The service was horrendous. We had a large party that they couldn't handle. We asked for items over and over again before we got them. The staff was incompetent. The food was overpriced and bland. Some people ordered steaks and they were overcooked and rubbery. The fish had no flavor. My cod was a dry piece of fish with no flavor. When we complained about the service they turned it around and blamed us. The service was so slow and then they tried to rush us out saying they needed the table. One of the staff walked away while we were explaining everything and it escalated from there. They add a 20 percent automatic tip for larger parties which I never have an issue in restaurants but they deserved zero tip for what they put us through. Apparently we aren't the only people that had issues with them. Almost 2000 spent to be cursed out at the end of the night. Save your money and go somewhere else. I wouldn't go back there even they offered me a free dinner. As bad as this review is it's actually a lot worse. read more

Omg sundays in Hamptons Bays! Steer clear! We just went for a memorial and the bill was 2k, yes 2k! The waitress apparently said we were complaining about service when we were oblivious to this information. Anyway,the service was awful, steak charred, no utensils, delayed drinks etc and the restaurant was 75% empty! So no escape goat there. Then they tried to rush us to pay after they served us cake with no coffee orders. We then requested coffees and they took forever and all cakes were eaten so we cancelled. We then reviewed the bill which was full of errors so had to be rerun. In the interim, the pregnant employee named Bree told my brother to get the fk out of the restaurant. Yup you read that right. I was in the car and went back in to speak to the manager ( there is none over an estate dispute so employees can do what they want and they know it bc they have job security). I went to speak to the pregnant employee who was at the front and she said you can leave or I'm calling the cops. I urged her to do so! The cops came and apologized for this behavior especially as my sister wept over her late husband! Lisa a staff member perfusively applogized and attempted to diffuse the whole situation. Just steer clear this place is drama. The best part was the waitress who started all of this still walked away with a $400.00 tip! Love it read more

Sundays On The Bay - This was a memorial tribute and this is what we experienced! - Seafood Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

We had a large group and this restaurant was extremely accommodating. They did everything possible to make us feel welcomed. The food was excellent and the prices extremely reasonable for the area. I took off one star because the server made it very obvious she did not want to serve a large group that evening. She was polite but had the eye roll attitude down to a science and never cracked a smile. Young woman and definitely not meant to be a waitress but she did do her job. She received 20% tip automatically because we were such a large group so I guess she felt she didn't need to be friendly. read more

Location was next to water which is beautiful. The waitresses were nice and we were quickly seated on a high table which can be shared with strangers. We didn't mind because we had a great view of the water for the sunset. Food was good but we had originally decided it order a appetizers to share among 3. We got quite a few things, the kale salad, the crab dip, crab cakes, tuna wontons and mussels in wine. We were surprised to see how little comes with the crab cakes and tuna wontons. The crab dip is really delicious but be aware there is a lot of cheese. Only only negative review would be that since i gave up pork we originally did not know that the award winning clam chowder had bacon in it! It's not noted in the menu which i think definitely should! The scallops entree also has chorizo on it and the baked clams also had bacon in it. read more

See all

Amazing Hamptons, Bayfront-Marina Vibe, Staff, Food, Outdoor Seating, Sunsets, Indoor Seating, Music and the SUNSETS are incredible. I love Sundays, you will too. read more

We are a party of 12. Why do we have just 0ne server. We are sitting around waiting and watching some members of our party enjoy their dinners while the rest of us salivated. Water was not replaced and deser read more

Back again for jumbo shrimp appetizer, followed by the most delicious hot lobster roll with side salad! Incredibly light, flavorful and savory. Staff attentive and efficient. Sun is shining over Shinnecock Bay today!! read more

Great food! Beautiful interior makeover! The 1 1/4 twin lobster special was cooked to perfection. Great kale salad. My friends ordered the crab pasta, salmon, and the Bronzino. They all love their dishes! I was Server was very attentive and informative on all the dishes. read more

See all

great spot. first off dog friendly outdoor heated experience. Food was really good but portion size was smaller than expected. Everything looked great, and the staff was really kind. They struck up conversation after conversation and we even met the owners. Seems they too live here and in florida like I do. Overall the view, mixed with the staff stories, the meal, the seafood and most importantly I loved the electro music outside, it had me grooving in my seat while waiting for food. so cool. definitely a must. and a repeat read more

Excellent lobster dinner we always come back and bring family and friends. Been coming here for years

Best meal in the Hamptons. Took advantage of mid-week lobster special; (2) 1.5# lobsters with basket of fries for $45. Stuffed my face! Lobster steamed perfectly, pre-cracked for easy enjoyment, lemons & butter on side, generous basket of crispy, hot, fries. Added seafood stuffing for $7 to 1 lobster- a crackery, buttery, mix of baby shrimp/scallops pressed on a flat top. Wasn't like any seafood stuffing I've had, but I enjoyed it. Place was packed at sunset, leaving quick seating only at bar. Beautiful views! Live music was a bit dated, as was the crowd- but room was high energy, everyone happily having a good time. Did not find Clam Chowder award winning- reminded me of if you merged smokey bean soup with NE clam chowder, one overpowers the other- but wasn't offensive, just better on a winter day. Every shore town has a place like this, the "keep it simple stupid" place where you stick to the basics- steamed lobsters, mussels, etc. you're going to have feast of a lifetime. Go nouveau, probably going to be disappointed. Swing by Ponquogue Beach on way to or fro & you have yourself a perfect evening. read more

See all

Great atmosphere, not that the food doesn't matter but siting by the bay makes the food taste all that better. Had the soft shell crab, while my wife had the mussels. With a glass of wine whet could be more relaxing. read more

We had the twin lobster special. perfectly cooked and good service to go with it. I wish they took reservations for less than six people.

The worst costumer service ever! The waitress and the MANGER called my friend broke because we were asking a question about the bill. Then she never came back after to get our bill once we put our card down. Had to go up to the host stand to pay. The manger was extremely rude. They were so judgmental of me and friends, calling us broke and ask if we "cant afford it?" After we paid the bill and tip over 20 %. I could never recommend this place because of how bad the costumer service was. read more

Great food and service. Views are amazing. It's even better when the weather is warm because you can sit outside. The fish is fresh and the lobsters delicious. read more

I just love coming to a restaurant and then knowing that I will be writing a five star for the visit. This place is not close to my house. The drive was 1:15 minutes, 67 miles into Hampton Bays from Mineola. It was totally worth it. It was a beautiful day and I can only image how nice it is sitting outside in the summer. It's still a little chilly in April. It was very easy to come here and traffic and parking are still not an issue now. We stayed outside for awhile just to enjoy the view. We finally headed in and settled in for dinner. This was a Kiwanis meeting and we had the whole restaurant to ourselves along with our own menu. We definitely packed the place and some people were hanging out by the nice bar in it's own room. The server were very attentive to us. They came right over for drink orders and let us settle in for a few minutes before that took our dinner orders from the special menu and gave us salads Everyone enjoyed anything ordered. I had the Flounder Primavera. (spring vegetable stuffed local flounder over a cream bechamel sauce with blistered tomatoes and a basil pesto.) It was fresh-delicious-tasty and hot. Really, it was perfect. My wife loved the flatiron steak and my friends enjoyed the swordfish schnitzel and chicken francaise. The cake they served at the end was also finished by everyone. The perfect finishing touch was when I asked for my coffee to go. No problem at all. It was handed to me with a smile. KUDOs to the team at Sundays on the Bay. read more

See all

I am changing my original review after seeing the lobster roll my friend ordered at Cowfish yesterday. I originally said that the lobster roll was tiny compared to all other restaurants. now I say it's minuscule and ridiculous to spend money on something that can be finished in two large bites. You will be so disappointed in this meal. Restaurant could have everything if they had a better menu, more food on plate and a hostess with a friendlier disposition! I hope next season the menu will be better and priced accordingly to amount of food served on plate...the view is the draw, why not make the food great too? read more

My family and I just left after spending several thousand dollars. Unfortunately, we regretted it and will not be returning as their customer service was awful. Service was extremely slow. Wrong food was repeatedly brought out. They give themselves a 20% tip for extremely poor service. Place is run by morons who seem to be clueless that the paying customers have better options!! Don't waste your money or time!! read more

Sundays on the Bay, but on Thursday! One star is for the view, seafood is not fresh and no taste. Should have gone to the restaurant next door. No WiFi for customers. Nothing is good there. My fish sandwich without tartar sauce and fish is dry and no taste. My Fish tacos didn't come with fries but the other table comes with fries. Is ok no good fries as well read more

See all

Had a wonderful dinner at Sunday's tonight. My watermelon-with-heirloom tomatoes was fantastic! And my burger delivered just the way I ordered it, and especially delicious. My bf LOVED his lobster roll and ceasar salad. The croutons - I tasted one - are fantastic. Our server Molly was helpful and delightful, and made sure we had everything we needed for a really nice time. And the chef's wife came by a few times to check on how we were doing, and was justly proud of her husband's dishes. In all it was a lovely dinner, and we will be back! read more

This a old school fish restaurant which I truly love. I enjoyed my mussel dish with white broth full of flavor indeed a party in mouth. My husband loved did I say his love his lobster dish, I did get a taste. The lobster was tender sweet truly delicious. We shared a a organic salad that was perfect with fresh veggies drizzled with lovely oil and vinegar. read more

Sundays On The Bay - Seafood Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Always great view and great fish n chips!! Nice apps and saladsa sit outside and enjoy the ocean life

What's a trip to the Hamptons without a visit to Sundays. Known for its "twofer" people flock here for it. It's two 1 1/4 lb Lobsters with choice of either a small salad, fries or cole slaw. All for $45. The place was jammin on a Tuesday night at 6:30pm when we arrived. And while we enjoyed our drinks (Sam Adams for me and Rum and Coke for my wife) we watched waiters delivering meal after meal. At Least 75% were the Twofer. We started with the crab dip and boy was it rich. A concoction of crab, cream and cheese served piping hot with slices of crusty bread. NOT Keto friendly . My wife had the Twofer and I the Seared Tuna with Bok Choy and Kimchi enfused spring rolls. We ate our meals on the covered patio while enjoying a beautiful sunset. read more

Sundays On The Bay - Crab Dip - Seafood Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

Came to Sundays on the Bay by boat with my wife and kids. The restaurant has a great vibe, service was also great and the food was excellent. We sat outside and had a great view. I strongly recommend it!!!!!! read more

I've not had a bad experience here with the food no matter if it's peak season or off season. The service has been more off than on when it's peak season, but what do you expect from college kids who are just here for the summer? The menu is very concise and to the point, and I really appreciate that. Seriously everything from their apps to mains to desserts have been great, I'm not usually a fan of fusion cuisine but they actually do it well here. Plus during the week, they offer a twin lobster dinner special with the works for a great price too. Love that they have indoor and a covered outdoor seating areas as well as 2 bars and nice views. Depending on when you are there, you can also see the resident snowy own perched on the nearby steeple. It's a great spot to come to after a day on the beach for a cocktail or a meal and to people watch. And since they are open year round, it's a nice quiet place for lunch /dinner without the crazy crowds as well! Will be returning over and over again. read more

See all

I ordered a pork chop dinner and it was amazing. I really like the food there and the atmosphere.

Fab fish n chips n they have malt vinrgar Prompt service Cordial staff The very best view read more

What a wonderful experience in dining we had tonight at Sunday's on the Bay at the Shinnecock inlet. This was our first visit, party of 4. We started our night arriving an hour early to have a chance to sit out on the deck and have a drink. Evando was our bartender. He took great care of us, seeing that our drinks were fine and replenished. We then went inside to our table. Social distancing was in effect and all staff were masked. Our waitress named Tayler was extremely pleasant send took the time to chat with us add ar placed our order. We gave her our app order first, then followed up with the dinner order. For apps, we ordered the fried calamari (tender and delicious, with tentacles) and tomatoe sauce on the side. We also ordered thr crab cakes (2) that was fried, served with vegetable chutney and spicy mayo. The crab cakes were delicious! For dinner, we ordered 3 lobster specials. (Mon- Thurs 2 lobsters, side of fries for $35, stuffing additional). 1 lobster dish was stuffed with baby scallops and shrimp. The lobsters were perfect and very tasty, all prepared to be easy to eat. I enjoyed my stuffed lobsters!!! Thr fourth dish was a swordfish dinner which was enjoyed as well. Our first trip to Sundays (I don't know what took us this long) was amazing. Evando and Tayler took great care of our party! Total bill with tip $284 I highly recommend Sundays to you all! SYOY! read more

See all