Eat at your own risk! This restaurant isn't Supreme when ordering online. The new name is Oh! My Deli My entire order was horrible. The fries tasted like they were pre cooked and being sitting in grease, not fresh at all. I asked for crispy wings and they were under cooked. The fish were mediocre. I don't normally leave reviews but that was a waste of money and time. read more

Ordered a Family 6 piece w/ okra instead of fries... 1st mistake! okra is frozen and not fresh. 2nd mistake-- allowing them to cover w/ aluminum foil without holes in order to keep it crispy. The Cole slaw was absolutely nasty! No sauce just shre cabbage with vinegar . The hush puppies are sweet and nasty as well. The cocktail sauce is fake! Cheap ingredients through it all! if you're choosing between them and jj's-- pick jj's!!! I'm apologizing to my family after spending $33. They said I could've made that at home and saved time, money, and taste! read more

My Wife lived in the area 10 years ago and wanted to go back to one of her favorite places. Located in a strip mall, I'm expecting the worst: lousy food cooked in old oil with a bad after taste. Oh no!! I was wrong in every respect. Friendly service; clean dining area with beautiful clean shiny wood surfaces. The food was hot and perfectly fried. They must use nice fresh oil because the food was fantastic. Delicious. Great dining experience read more

See all

It always hurts when I have to leave a poor review, especially to a Black owned business but this has been earned. The catfish was mushy and clearly frozen and cooked at too low of temperature and not long enough. It severely lacked corn meal and/or seasoning. The bathroom was disgusting, the place is dated at least 30 years, and the service was minimal at best. To put it bluntly, This place shouldn't be open for business. read more

I don't get on this side of town too often. Came in a little bit after closing, didn't realize it, but the young man at the counter was courteous and took my order. The food, as always was delicious. A solid staple of my old neighborhood and it's always a pleasure when I get a chance to eat here. read more

Amazing, amazing, amazing. I am a pescatarian, so grabbing a meal to go is something very difficult, because there are rare food establishments which sells seafood. Nevertheless, I spotted this restaurant and fell in love. The staff was extremely helpful and joyful. I ordered fish only, 3 piece whitening, with salad. My brother also ordered 1 piece of whitening. The food was a 10/10. Possibly the best seafood restaurant near by. I would definitely recommend this spot to any/everyone. Last but not least, pricing is reasonable. read more

Supreme Fish Delight - Location - Seafood Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

I got sick aft the catfish the French fries was soaked in grease seem to have different people there....a few years ago I would eat here two to three times a week not anymore read more

Supreme Fish Delight - Catfish and fries - Seafood Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

I went to this place on June 05,2024. I ordered the 2 pc Whiting fish and 6 shrimps. I got serious food poisoning from here. I called this place and spoke with SHUN who was MICK NASTY PLAIN RUDE DUDE. I will never patronize this place ever again. I will report it to the health dept. The place did not look tidy when I walked into this place. So that shouldn't been a que to not buy anything from here. Sooooo be very weary of this place. And the fish needs seasoning. It was plain no flavor!!!!!! I WOULD NOT RECOMMEND THIS PLACE!!!!! read more

The food is prettt good however the service is horrible. I called ahead and they put me on hold. I drove to the store I was still on hold. There was no one in line. The young lady just put tue phone on the counter. I came in and order my food with no line and she never picked up the phone. Been on hold for over 30 minutes. I want to say something but I am afraid they might do something to my food. Poor service in our community. read more

Fried fish! Comfort food. There's not a whole lot that has to be said. Either you do it right or you don't. You don't hear much talk about fried fish on cooking shows. It is what it is. You get the right piece of fish, you get a good breading; seasoned to taste. You heat your fresh grease to the right temp (roughly 350-375*) and you bring them together. This place did all that! I ordered a fish dinner with 10 pieces of whiting, fries, coleslaw and hush puppies. Everything was as can be expected. The fries weren't impressive, but everything else was so good that we didn't need fries anyway. There aren't fancy words to describe this type of food, those that know, can understand what it means when someone walks into the party with fried fish and everyone stops talking for about 10 minutes as they dive in. "That's some good fish, Bo!" read more

Supreme Fish Delight - View from the dining room - Seafood Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

THE WORST EVER!!! I stopped in and ordered a Sandwich and some Whiting on my way home which is about 50 miles away. I use to come to this Restaurant many years ago before I moved and it was good. OMG!!! On my way home, I started smelling the spoiled fish. It was so bad, I almost couldn't bear it. When I got home, I open the container and saw the inside of the fish was a gray color and the skin was so tough, I could barely pull it apart. This Fish was obviously old and spoiled and shame on this Restaurant for serving this to people! ABSOLUTELY AWFUL!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Great fish and great breakfast! The breakfast is like home cooked food. The fish prices are reasonable too. I have not had the wings from here. read more

Supreme Fish Delight - the inside of a restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

I usually have an okay experience, but the young lady at the register with glasses was terrible. First, I called my order in and told them how long I would take. They asked. She does not have my order and asks did I call them. Then, she does not put my order in at all. After other people after me get their food I got up front. I ask her did she put it in to them. She says yes, but she did not print my ticket. Which mean they did not get my order. ‍ read more

I ordered two trout dinners. The fish was fried too hard and did not have any seasoning, it smelled like the oil was old and stale, as well as being very greasy. They also got the order wrong. This was a takeout order, I got in my car and returned these orders to them within a few minutes of opening them. I will NEVER GO TO THIS RESTURANT AGAIN. This place doesn't even deserve an one, it's that poor. read more

god awful fish do not go the fish is over cooked fries are unsalted. sign in front says no returns. i will not be returning with my business. read more

Supreme Fish Delight - a tray of fish and chips - Seafood Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

Worst fish I ever had. Ordered a family 10 piece whitening. The fish was over cooked ,bland tasting, and tasted old. Did not taste like it was cooked fresh. Very disappointed. read more

Came here for the first time today and I must say it was super yummy! The food is fresh and cooked to order so expect to wait maybe 10-15min. I ordered the fish supreme sandwich w/ Whiting. They make homemade tartar sauce that I was a fan of as well. The two ladies in the front were really nice and despite the place being extremely dated it was clean. There's plenty of parking on the front and side of the building. Over all 4 stars. I will be back when I'm on this side of town again. read more

Supreme Fish Delight - Fish supreme w/ whiting! A true winner - Seafood Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

Haven't been here in a while. I was hungry but didn't want to drive to far. I'm glad I stop bc I ordered the Combo#1 which is a 2piece fish/fries n hush puppies. When I got home I realized they gave me 3pieces of fish! Don't know if thts standard but the Fish tastes great! I sub my fries for okra n the hush P was good! I will be going back!! read more

Supreme Fish Delight - Whitening n okra - Seafood Near Me - Decatur, Georgia

I don't know if it's because of the pandemic or what but this place has really lost its touch. Customer service was horrible. The cashier was on FT while I was placing my order. The boss or whoever he is was too busy running his mouth on the lobby. I will not be returning. read more

I was brought here by a friend who is a super fan of their hush puppies. Now the best hush puppies I ever had were Wilson, NC at Parkers BBQ. Hands down best hush puppies EVER. But OK I'm open to trying new things. I have to give it up for this place. Second best hush puppies I ever had. Fish was crispy and seasoned well. Green beans were good, a bit mushy, but not completely overcooked. Fries were average. Shrimp, excellent. In all, I'd say it was worth the price and the wait. I'll be back at least for the hush puppies... read more

See all

I stood there 10 minutes and no one offer to o take my order or ask if I place an order. Basically I was ignored so I left

I got 2 meals. Fried Shrimp, fries and fried whiting with buffalo wings. Both meals came with fries and hush puppies. The shrimp was good and the hush puppies were delicious. The fish was bland and dry. We have eaten from here before and it was ok so I am gonna chalk it up to a bad cooking night. read more

The customer service was wonderful. It's not too often anymore you go somewhere and get complimentary anything. My daughter was whining about something to drink and I didn't have enough.... She gave my baby a small lemonade.... That's a community business! Kudos to Fish Supreme and specifically Ms. Latoya. Of course, the food was "Supreme" ! read more

I didn't like the fish or hash puppies. The fish was tiny and full of oil! The hash puppies were gummy and old. This place reminds me of why I don't eat at places like this! Never again read more

I used to go to the Supreme Fish Delight on Moreland Avenue in Atlanta all the time. It was a beautiful crispy whiting dream. Then I moved to Decatur. I was craving SPF really badly, and it was my b-day so I broke down and went into the SPF near my house on Wesley Chapel. I was starving, and it was like 100 degrees inside, but I waited patiently the 15 minutes for our "family pack" of fresh, hot, crispy, fishy goodness. I had no problem waiting as I knew everything was cooked fresh, even though there was only one other customer in the joint. We got our sack and jumped in the car to drive the one mile home. I couldn't wait and opened the bag, grabbed some fries and stuffed them in my hole. eeech! They were cold. I was dumbfounded - but...how? I stammered. I felt around desperately for the fish and hush puppies...they burnt my fingers satisfyingly...I quickly pressed my sore digits into the cold fries to soothe them. Eeech! Nothing worse than inexplicably cold krinkle cut fries. Or so I thought. When we got home, the husband calmy took the fries to the microwave, and I turned away with tears in my eyes, unwilling to watch the soggy warm nightmare I was about to eat. I dug a shaky hand into the fish sack and took a huge bite of my piping hot whiting...Eeech! It was gross. Wrong. It didn't taste like fish even, it was over cooked and the fish was rubbery and dry, not teasingly flakey and moist like my memories on Moreland. I slathered on the SPF tartar sauce, which WAS still tasty, and choked down the piece anyway. I grabbed another fish, hoping that was just a fluke, but no. It was even worse. The grease must not have been changed in fifty years, the coating flaked off at your touch and was an ominous blackish brown. I wasn't even sure it was whiting anymore. I sighed and pushed my food away. I couldn't eat it. The husband admitted he found it all quite vile as well, and we gave up...resorting to Toblerone and ice cream for our meal instead. Disgusting. Fifteen minute wait and fifteen dollars for hot and cold disgusting food. Not to mention the zombie like service when we were there picking up our food. I am very disappointed. I can never ever go back there. read more

The food is good but man are they slow and they have the tendency to run out of things sometimes. For example I got here about 8:20pm and its 8:51 pm and counting. My fav is the supreme fish sandwich combo and I also like the fish salad. But like I said they are SLOW! This is not the place to come when your starving or in a rush . read more

I called at 10:45 to place an order and the lady on the phone answered with a horrible attitude & even said they were closed. I didn't believe her because online says 11:30 so I drove there and they were open with the signs on. read more

This had to be joke! I only came here because the one near panola rd was closed. I ordered 2 dinners tilapia and whiting. The fish was greasy, broken hunks, and the fries were Luke warm. I was very disappointed. I should have known better because they usually allow you to view your food when it's a to go order well at least other resturants do. My teenager threw his food in the trash. Very angry customer! read more

Great food. Clean area. Can watch tv while eating or waiting for food. Great customer service. Thanks.

Not good. Food was greasy. The people were nice though. I thought I was going to have some great southern fish, but it was more like southern grease. Even the cake was dry. read more

the food is great and the service is good love the breakfast salmon and grits and eggs, great price for breakfast....

so even though i know this is supreme fish delight and i love the food from here. they are slow as hell. do not go here ever unless you have an eternity to wait. i mean seriously wtf???? i get you dont get paid that much, but still how can you have a business and have people waiting for 30 minutes for some fish and fries. i swear i could have rebuilt a jet engine in the time i waited. good thing there are other locations. read more

The people isn't friendly,tried to address a issue with some wings that wasn't all the way cooked and no seasoning at all,and the fish was very bland and taste old,and fries was very hard overcooked.The server took it back to the manager,he never came out the back at all,he told the server that it looks like I ate the wings,and I told her that you could see that I picked over them to see if they were done and I also told her that I was getting sick on my stomach from the that I did try to eat and all they was oh well! and the manager still wouldn't make himself present,that was very disrespectful as a manager and I've been a very long customer 10+yrs. and it wasn't right,bad customer service and it haven't been the same quality anyway since these Asian people has taken over anyway,I've brought or told over 50+ customers to them in the past,but now they have lost a good customer and probably a lot more after I tell my family and friends too,I'll take my business up the street back to J&J Chicken & Wings,they have been better with their customer service and quality,it was the that the manager should have out and address his problem instead of hiding behind the wall, that wasn't professional at all, I'm 58 yrs old and I didn't have no reason at all to make something like this up over some $4.00 wings,and $5.00 fish lunch special,I'm not broke and I'm not petty,normally don't complain 98%of the time about anything. read more