Garbage, absolute garbage. The place was dirty and fly infested. There was no restroom. We were ignored for about 10 minutes before being helped. The food was horrible and made my wife and I sick. How anyone could consider this place good is beyond me. read more

We love this place! Solid, consistent quality pizza. The best local pizza place I've ever visited. Nothing flashy, just good quality food. We left Whitman years ago, but found ourselves in town last weekend, so we decided to visit. The food is still consistently excellent. I had a toasted Italian sub with quality meat and a good ratio. Delicious chicken tenders which I was happy to finish off for my wife. The chicken wings I heard were delicious, which I can only take my daughter's word for as I didn't get a chance to eat them. Didn't get a pizza this time around, but the time we there previously the pizza was as good as I remember. When we used to live in Whitman, we hit this place at least once a week. I remember, picking up a pizza one night, got the chance to talk with owners and I was raving about the pizza sauce. I remember the expression on their face, they had a twinkle of pride in their eye. That sauce meant something to them. I also remember their teenage kids working behind the counter. Last week, one of those kids was again behind the counter, bearded and chatting up with the locals. So great to see a thriving family business! I gotta say, I miss this place so much and will always make my way in when in the area. read more

The new space is large, attractive and welcoming...with plenty of seats and tv's. It is nice to be able to peek into the immaculate kitchen! The subs have tons of fillings and the bread always fresh. My favorite is the Greek pocket ...iceberg is nice and chilled, tomatoes juicy, terrific feta ...all tossed with a homemade Greek dressing stuffed into a very tender pita pocket! Yummy...makes us satisfied every time. Just tried their small pizza ....delicious crispy crust, plenty of cheese and perfectly sweet tomato sauce. The Hawaiian with jalepenos hit the spot! read more

tastes soo good! best pizza restaurant in the south shore. Not too pricey either for a great bite!

Da Best Italian Calzone I ever had! Absolutely love their gravy, it's top notch. Wish I had the recipe!

Delicious! Always good food, good service. Some of the best onion rings! Love their meatball subs and kids love their fingers and fries..

Great subs... good service... i recommend the chicken cutlet toasted with peppers and onions. I was really hoping for a good steak tip sub and theirs is not so great. seemed over-cooked meat kinda tough... not so good. read more

pizza is only ok and they always rip you off when you order xtra cheese by charging you for it and clearly not putting it on the pizza. In addition they always have fox news on the tv and I find it gross that someone dumb enough to buy fox's constant self serving lies is making my pizza. read more

My favorite pizza place in my hometown. Not only do they have huge slices of pizza, they have the BEST chicken wraps ever. Their salads are soooo good. I love the family owned aspect. The new restaurant is so beautiful and gives a great ambiance with it's "Whitman History" vibe. read more

I'm not a regular at Supreme, but sometimes I pop in here when I'm in the center of town doing some other things. The people who work there are always friendly. The food is good sub shop food. Their buffalo chicken sandwich is one of my favorite things they offer. The pizza doesn't set itself apart from anyone, but it is a good pie. You can't go wrong if you're looking for a good quick lunch and you happen to be in Whitman. It's also a good Friday night, to lazy to cook so I'll order pizza kind of place. read more

While the pizza is average and slightly more than I'd like to see costwise, I really like supreme. Multi generationally owner operated and it shows. The service is quick and pleasant and the menu is well prepared. The buffalo chicken calzone is the best in the area, the best I've had even. Overall it's nice to have good, non-franchise town pizza. read more

Went here for the first time today with my girlfriend. Ordered an antipasto salad and a goldfever sub. Paid over $9 for a handful of greens and stale, moldy peta bread. My friend had to go up twice because they messed up her sub by toasting it and not putting cheese on it. The older woman who took our order wrote it all down but was still aggravated with us coming up to fix what we had asked for. Never coming here again, what a waste of time, money and calories! Wishing we had gone with Venus.. read more

Been here a few times, always busy, which we all know is a good sign. Salads are awesome, plenty of chicken, Love the fact they include pita bread, and the dressings are great. Definitely plan on going back. read more

I grew up eating at supreme, and I see no difference since they have moved to the bigger location still the same great food and service. Best buffalo chicken pizza and Italian subs. Never had better any where else. Also the cheese fries are amazing. read more

Great subs, huge calzones, and quick service. The owners son knows the regulars and greets you by name when you walk through the door.

Let it be said that I am a long-time (ie, 30 years+) devotee of Marcello's. Recently, however, Supreme has been sliding into the number one spot for local sandwich joints. That's due to a combination of good subs, killer calzones, and ridiculously nice staff. Make sure you're ready to talk about your day when you come to pick up your order--they will ask how you're doing. And while it's clearly just pleasant chatter, everyone I've ever spoken with here seems genuinely interested in what you have to say. Food-wise, beware the highly addictive calzones. They'll keep you coming back. And unless you're a competitive eater or have 10 of your closest friends over, don't order the large. It's just inhumanly big. Small or large, they're perfectly cooked, oozing with cheese and stuffed to the brim. A steak and cheese calzone with a cup of marinara is a religion-changing experience here. High marks for Supreme! read more

This is the best sub shop in town! Ive never had a bad meal here. The owners always seem to be working hard and this shows with how they interact with their customers. Very clean and very good food! read more

Talking about an upgrade!!! Is clean organized and good is been here for over 30 years small town awesome food

The chicken dinner is everything. I have been eating here 10+ years and EVERYTHING on the menu has stayed consistently great. The staff are amazing. They even knew to call me when my boyfriend left his phone there because they get to know their customers and remember them. Supreme is life. Don't @ me. read more

I haven't yet been disappointed!....I usually stick with the same old thing when ordering here but that's just because I'm craving it. But for once, I decided to try something new and got the chicken stir fry wrap and it was delicious! You get your choice of wheat or white wrap which is a plus considering most places don't even offer wheat!! Can't wait to try something new! read more

This place is great. Food is so good and fairly priced. Everything subs, salads, calzones. It's always hot and consistent. Delivery literally just took ten minutes, guess we're the only ones hiding from the heat and watching tv today. Haha...go there read more

Supreme is a great local pizza shop with some of the best customer service you will find in such an establishment. The buffalo chicken calzone is outstanding, probably the best I've ever had. Simply put, the family that run the place know what they are doing and have been in business for over 20 years now. The help is also very courteous. Pizza is typical New England Greek-style, but always good and never burnt. The appetizers are very good, and the menu has a great variety to choose from. The wait can sometimes be quite long, and the prices a bit higher than other places. But the service more than makes up for these minor shortcomings. All in all, great food and service with plenty of seating and standing room for takeout customers. read more

I've been ordering here for years. Only but the best and it's delicious! Yeah sometimes they have been a little late with deliveries but always correct food and always hot and fresh which I can't complain. The service is nice and friendly. Best pizza shop/food place in Whitman and most of the south shore! I will be a customer here for awhile. I awarded supreme 5 stars because that's what they have given me in food and in service read more

I've been going here and ordering from here for years and have never been disappointed with the food or the service. My favorites: Greek salad with steak tips, Turkey sub, cheese pizza. This place is my old reliable! read more

Supreme pizza has the absolutely nicest employees. This is the only place my kids will go to. Their grilled chicken salad is outstanding.

I've lived in the Whitman/Hanson area for 14 years, and it took me about 13.5 to check out Supreme. From the outside it seems like a great place -- it's kept well, it has a *lot* of tables inside, and it's right in the center of town -- but once you get in there you just have to wonder how it came to this... It's not that the food tasted bad or the service was poor; I've had far worse chicken caesar before and the kid at the counter was friendly. The problem stemmed from two sources. First, I couldn't help but wonder why my hands were sopping wet after eating only half of my wrap. I realize caesar dressing can be runny, but c'mon! Second, for the size of the place and the location, Supreme should be busy-busy-busy, but at midday on a Saturday afternoon, I was the only customer. To me, this is the most important factor. Perhaps the next time I go in my wrap will be put together well and I won't find a drop of dressing on my hands, but the mere fact that NO ONE is going to Supreme in the middle of a Saturday when their competitors are bustling does not present a good sign that the food will be any better. Supreme is worth a shot, I guess, but don't expect too much. read more

The poster Sean P probably owns the competition he is full of excrement. Not only do they have a bathroom the right of the registers, I have lived in Whitman five years and been here repeatedly and never once seen a fly, fruit or otherwise. My impression from the strict management is he would die before he allows one! I have never waited more than five mins, and that was because I was second in line. This place does such a business in town, the food couldn't remotely make anyone sick it isn't there long enough. Either he, or his wife is nuts. How anyone could listen to an obvious troll is actually what is beyond me! If you are in town definitely try this place, totally worth the trip. Oh and FYI, the food prices are great for what you get. read more

Love their Greek salad. They do creamy greek dressing and actual kalamata olives, but since not everyone likes these, I always ask. The staff is super friendly and you do get the feeling that they care about their customers. This type if service is rare this day in age and it is appreciated. I also like their fries and chicken fingers. My husband gets the ham, egg and cheese sub- loves it. read more

Best sub and pizza place in the area. Food is fresh and consistent. Family owned business with great service. They know all their customers.

Always ordering here when I'm lazy to make dinner. The subs are really good, my fav are steak n cheese and their Italian sub. My girlfriend loves their salads but I'm not a fan. The mozzarella sticks are awesome, the chicken wings and chicken fingers are awesome...... There's a couple of girls there that always seems miserable and hates life, but the other friendly and awesome staff makes up for it. read more

Ordered grilled chicken dinner plate and the wings with fries for delivery in a Thursday evening. Delivery took almost an hour! Way too long. The food was ok. Nothing great but it was edible. read more

Friendly people, great food, always fresh, is why I keep going back to Supreme in Whitman. Never had a bad meal there. Try their Supreme special pizza. read more

Got both orders completely wrong. I ordered a buffalo chicken calzone. Did not come with marinara or blue cheese. Was told they don't include either without specifically asking for it. Also a turkey and stuffing sub. On the menu it said it came with cranberry sauce. When asked over the phone I said I didn't want anything extra on it and because of that they didn't include the cranberry sauce. Food is good though. read more

A great pizza spot in Whitman! The subs are amazing and the apps are delicious and very generous. To top it off, their new location is beautiful. Never disappointing! A must try read more

Supreme's food is awesome! But this one time I ordered food for pickup over the phone and I wanted to order something off the menu that was on the website, when I told the girl what I wanted she told me that she had no idea what I was talking about. Normally not a problem but I just want the menu up to date so I don't encounter any more problems like this. Other than that I would deff ineptly recommend supreme m, and their food. read more

I have been eating Supreme pizza my whole life. Buffalo chicken calzone is to die for. The quality is always consistent and the authentic Greek service is a nice touch. read more

I really enjoy Supreme. The food is always very fresh, and the people friendly. You can see right into their kitchen when you are there and it is always very clean. read more

I've had many good experiences going here. Every time the food has been ready in the time frame I was given over the phone. The staff is extremely friendly and always asks how my day was and thanks me for coming in. Their steak and cheese sub is great. read more