Although they remain the cheapest lunch specials in the area, I'm sad to report the sushi lunch in particular the maki has been now consistently mediocre. I'm not sure if it's a matter of the couple new "chefs" they seem to have now rotating during lunch hours, but the maki is much smaller and filed litre with rice. Its fair to say, i am a regular, however they have yet to offer anything on the house during any of my lunches here. Now that the maki is more often a "meh" than a "woop" I might actually need to start shopping around again. read more

Great price and consistently good execution. Food is fresh and the staff are great. Huge selection and lots of veggie options. Prices are amazing and 2 people can eat for under $40. read more

It is just okay... Maybe 2.5 - 3 stars. This place use to be the best in mid-town back in the days - I was here 10 years ago. 10 years fast forward - the decor still looks the same. What I use to portray as a happening place is not what it once use to be. The walls has newspaper articles saying, Susur has dined at the BEST Japanese restaurant, but that was back in 2007? Stickers on the front window saying best of 2002, 2004, etc and I think it stopped at 06? That was all sooo long ago. I just feel this place just did not grow with the urbanization of Toronto. A certain sad nostalgia depicting what it used to be but no more. With new delish sushi joints opening up all over Toronto - compared to them, this place is just subpar. The ingredients used are nothing special - ie: they use imitation crap meat in ALMOST all the roles. I couldn't differentiate the rainbow roll from a california roll - except yes, the rainbow has the sliced sashimi on top. The cucumber salad was again, filled with avocados, imitation crab, and cucumbers, without the rice - same base as rainbow, and California roll. So, I felt like I ate California roll 3x in three different presentations. Sigh... Sushi Supreme no more. It's priced cheaply and I guess that's an attraction. But, I don't think I'll be coming back if I had a choice. read more

4/5! we ordered from this place and the fish was very fresh! We ordered 4 rolls for 2 people and it was more than enough food. I recommend the spicy crunchy salmon and the sushi supreme roll! Enjoy :) read more

Our drop by place for sushi after kids' morning class. Food here are fresh and good price. Will definitely show up every week.

Service is great and prompt . Food is delicious with great options , and price point is within budget.

This little hub was a nice lunch experience that cost me $6.95 for an assortment of five rolls that included Avocado, which, despite being "mushy" and falling apart were nonetheless tasty. These were flanked by Spicy Salmon/ Tuna rolls which were, in my eyes a misnomer and again not spicy enough to my experienced South Asian buds. Service was average. read more

Great place. Good food, plenty of it at cheap prices. We usually do takeout since we live in the neighbourhood. If you've only had their sushi you should try their noodles - you'll be doing yourself a favor. Shame that Rick (the owner) isn't there much anymore - he must be at their downtown location - it doesn't have as much spirit when he's not there - but Mrs. Rick keeps an eye on the place. Staff these days could be a little friendlier. You can tell it's a great place because there are four sushi restaurants within three blocks and this is the only one that's busy ALL the time. read more

This review is more directly based upon my delivery service. After seeing the 4 star rating I was excited to try a new sushi joint -- that would also deliver to my door. After the hour and 15 minute wait, I had to call to make sure my order was still even coming. The lady on the phone was very short and not very friendly, nor did she apologize for the fact my order still hadn't been sent yet. Any roll described as crispy was spongey. Any roll that was to be warm, was cold and tasteless. No discount, no compromise or compensation. I won't be back. read more

Their portions are good and the price is good. However, the food quality is not amazing, it is just medium quality.

Delivery took over an hour. After an hour I called and was told it was on it way and ended up coming 20 minutes later. They should specify it is free delivery AND will take over an hour. My avocado salad was simply some iceberg lettuce topped with avocado and no dressing. The rice on my sushi wasn't sticky enough and was falling off. The best thing of the meal was the sweet potato tempura, but even that had been in the box for so long that they were mushy and no longer crunchy. Needless to say I was pretty disappointed after all the good reviews. Would not recommend. read more

Although we don't live in the area anymore, this is still our favourite sushi restaurant. The fish is always super fresh and expertly prepared and the price is very reasonable. The party platters are a particularly great value. We find the Gold easily feeds 4 adults with some to take home for later. We always appreciate the complimentary tea and the orange slices at the end of the meal. The service is attentive and the restaurant is clean. read more

Love this place! Prices are affordable and the sushi is really good. At the end of your meal they give you a sliced orange, which is always so juicy. I don't know where they get them but the best oranges I've ever tasted. read more

My star rating here is completely based on delivery experience. While I understand there are busy nights, it took over 1.5 hours for us to get our food. We called after an hour and were told that it was on its way. It showed up 45 mins later, and we live 5 mins away. Next time it would be great for the restaurant to acknowledge they are behind and suggest we pick up our food. While soups where cold, the rest of the food was quite good. read more

Its good... The rolls are ridiculously affordable. Like very reasonable. The rolls are twice the size of normal ones too which is great and they come usually in pieces of 8. So for 8 dollars you get 16 pieces of maki which is awesome! Just don't expect it to knock your socks off, this is a great weeknight hubby and wife restaurant and the servers are nice, quiet but nice:) read more

I love this place. Definitely my favourite sushi place in this area. Owners are nice, sushi's got good portioning and delivery is free ! Rice to fish ratio on the maki is perfect. Great value for you money. read more

I love this place because it is so cost effective and the food is super. I am a salmon sushi lover and this restaurant does not disappoint. Nice warm atmosphere inside and the upper floor is fun too. Used to be an Italian restaurant and so it has that trattoria vibe to it which is neat. The service is speedy and the tea gets replenished frequently. Orange slices at the end of the meal were a nice touch too. We've already been to this place twice and we just moved to the area. It's great! read more

The wait for a table is horrible even if it isnt busy. They only had 1 waiter which is probably the reason why I wasnt seated right away. Anyway, the food also took a while to make. Prices are reasonable. Their crunchy salmon roll is divine though. Probably wont come back unless im desperate for some sushi. read more

Definitely one of the best price:quality ratios I've come across in the city. The lunch prices are insanely cheap. The salmon always tastes fresh. Relatively friendly staff. My only criticism is the salad they serve with the lunch specials is topped with an unbearably sweet dressing which is a bummer as I love the traditional vinegar/sesame style dressing you usually get at Japanese restaurants. Great place though. read more

I must say that I have had sushi from this place for several years now and usually it was good and at a good price. Unfortunately, I ordered take out from there a couple weeks ago and did not have a good experience. I had the sashimi appetizer and unfortunately the fish was not good... at all. It was very old and terrifyingly chewy. I tried but I couldn't eat it. I had to throw it all out. I love their salmon salad roll but again, it wasn't very good either this time around. I used to love this place but it seems the quality is now beginning to match the price. Great service though! I've never had a problem with the staff. I just hope they step it up a bit again to avoid this place falling into the ground. read more

I was coming for lunch for last few years. Last two times made me feel that I am not going to come anymore. I have ordered lunch, when I came for pick up, I was told that kitchen forgot to cook it. No apologies, nothing... Yesterday I have ordered hot and sour soup and that was my usual choice. Ate a few spoons before I realized that I cannot eat it. This time they put SOOO much of vinegar, that I have burnt my tongue. It still sore and blue. I felt seek for the rest of the day. I wonder if they ever try what they make. So be careful they may screw up the recipe in dangerous way... Saying that I gave them 40% tip for that. Definitely my last time. read more

My FAV. Place to go after work for yummy dinner ... Minute I sit I have my soup water front of me with friendly smile of a staff member ... Food is always yummy fresh for perfection !! Thank you everyone your team is awesome... See you soon ! Cheers, Tundi read more

Great value and great fresh fish! One of my top sushi restaurant choices. Love the finishing touch of orange slices at the end of the meal to cleanse the palate. Very refreshing and pleasant touch to end the meal. It's the small things that count and I love it! read more

Yummy goodness! I love Supreme Sushi! Great atmosphere and friendly service. You've got to love a sushi place that uses REAL WASABI! They have a great selection and I have never had a complaint at the quality or price of their meals! A good one for takeout too! I love love love their seaweed salad and their dressing is divine! A sure favourite. read more

I love this place! The food and service is always great and fast. And it's not pricey, really good rolls though and there bento boxes are awesome! Just can be busy around dinner time so be sure to call ahead and reserve! read more

Nothing supreme about this place AT ALL. Really don't know why they would need a second floor. Ordered a lunch special - salmon roll and mango roll - and a salmon pizza and my girlfriend got the spicy chicken. I used to work at a sushi place and the salmon roll is by far the worse I have had. They didn't even have mango sauce for the mango roll and salmon pizza was very bland. The only decent food was the spicy chicken. So if you're craving for Japanese food, I would highly advise you not to come here, it will only ruin your appetite!!! Come here only if you want some Korean spicy chicken. read more

This is an absolutely awesome lunch spot - probably the superior choice when compared to any sushi joints in the area. The supreme bento box at $10 is unbeatable in terms of value. Foods are cooked and seasoned very well, that complemented with quick/friendly service and clean/well maintained establishment easily made this place a personal favorite!!! read more

The sushi is very good. They are really generous with the toppings. Lunch specials are a great value. I wouldn't take anyone here to impress them, but it's tasty and a good enough value I keep coming back. read more

I order from here once a week. The fish is very consistent and fresh. Reasonably priced.

Terrible service. Quality of the sushi was barely ok. Never ever again. Very rude staff. They were running around, non-responsive. One of the staff dropped bunch of plates and just left it there. read more

Yummy, fresh, casual, reasonable prices, in my hood and just discovered, will go back!

Hands down, best sushi around. Fresh food, great selection, amazing value and friendly proprietors. Love this place and have NEVER been disappointed. read more

This place gives you value for money. Very good sushi and always excellent service. Make sure to try ACC roll!

This is my favourite sushi place in Toronto- consistently great food at an awesome price point. I always go here and do take-out. Highly recommend. read more

That's my favorite place for sushi in the area around Yonge and Davisville. The prices are reasonable and it is always fresh. My only disappointment is that they offer delivery in a very limited area and not to where I live. Hopefully they will expand their delivery area soon. read more

By far the worst Sushi my wife and I ever had. We ended up throwing out our whole dinner as it was a to-go and didn't find out until we got home...and like the other reviewer said, I NEVER throw out food either! read more

Best service in the city. It is super cheap but great value.

We live in the nieghbourhood and this is our "go to" sushi joint. It's not the best sushi I've ever had (I'd put it around the 80th percentile) but the food it cheap and (unlike most sushi places in Toronto) the service is really, really solid. read more

This is my favourite sushi place. Very reasonable prices and interesting vegetarian maki roll options, like the tempura sweet potato asparagus rolls (I always get them). I guess the other non-vegetarian rolls are pretty standard, but I don't eat those so can't really comment. The bento boxes are very generous and well priced. For 2 people our bill is usually less than $25, including tax and tip, without drinks. Over all the years I've been going, I've always found the service is good and attentive. There is street parking nearby but it can be hard to find a spot if you don't know the area. read more

I've been coming here for 10 years and still loving it! Prices are reasonable, rolls are big, friendly staff.