Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Susquehanna Smokehouse

    4.2 (11 reviews)
    Open 3:00 pm - 9:30 PM

    Susquehanna Smokehouse Photos

    Susquehanna Smokehouse - Mac and cheese with a couple of meats - Diners Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania
    Susquehanna Smokehouse - Indoors - Diners Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania
    Susquehanna Smokehouse - Outside - Diners Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania
    Susquehanna Smokehouse - Menu - Diners Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania
    Susquehanna Smokehouse - Menu - Diners Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania
    Susquehanna Smokehouse - Menu - Diners Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania
    Susquehanna Smokehouse - Hours - Diners Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania
    Susquehanna Smokehouse - My pup playing with the house dog in back of the Smokehouse - Diners Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania
    Susquehanna Smokehouse - Hush puppies and organic Ketchup - Diners Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania
    Susquehanna Smokehouse - the outside of the smokehouse - Diners Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania
    Susquehanna Smokehouse - Pulled Pork and Brisket Sampler - Diners Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania

    See all

    Susquehanna Smokehouse - a car parked in front of the smokehouse - Diners Near Me - Milton, Pennsylvania

    Business Info

    SUSQUEHANNA SMOKEHOUSE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    More like Susquehanna Smokehouse

    Recommended Reviews - Susquehanna Smokehouse

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Delicious food, large servings. Definitely call ahead for reservations. It's cash or check only!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Very good fresh food. I had the fried haddock but I heard the chef talking about a local beef. Will be back

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of M. F.
    0
    28
    8

    6 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    This is a must try!!! The food is absolutely delicious!!! The owners and staff are incredible!! Definitely my favorite place to eat!!

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Susquehanna Smokehouse

    Review Highlights - Susquehanna Smokehouse

    It might not look like much but it's a great, quiet little place just outside Lewisburg on the river.

    Mentioned in 3 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Diners 318 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Fire & Ice Smokehouse & Creamery - Pulled chicken with fries

    Fire & Ice Smokehouse & Creamery

    4.6(41 reviews)
    34.9 mi
    $$

    If you enjoy smoked meats, you will love this place! Everything on the menu meets the greatest…read moreexpectations. Great people behind the counter and a bright and clean restaurant. Out door dining is available. And THEN! The home made ice cream; creative flavors that will satisfy a connoisseur's palette.

    Great BBQ joint in the Mountains…read more Fire & Ice Smokehouse & Creamery delivers a deliciously smoky experience that's hard to beat in central PA. The ribs and sliced brisket sandwich were the clear stars--perfectly tender, full of flavor, and cooked just right with a nice smoky bark. The smoked mac and cheese was another standout--creamy, rich, and packed with that deep, smoky goodness that takes comfort food to the next level. Chicken was flavorful and decent. Just not my style as I enjoy a hot & fast style. The atmosphere was relaxed and inviting, with a casual setup where you can sit wherever you want and order at the counter. The service was quick and efficient, and our food came out hot and fresh in no time. Portion sizes were generous, definitely worth the price and enough to leave you satisfied. The sauces were solid--a nice variety to choose from and they complemented the meats well. Nothing too out of the ordinary, but they did the job. If you're a sauce lover, you'll appreciate the options, though the meat definitely shines on its own without needing much help. All in house created which personally I thought they be better knocks a star off. Overall, it was a great experience from start to finish--excellent BBQ, cozy vibes, and smooth service. Definitely worth the visit if you're craving top-notch smoked meats and hearty sides in the Pennsylvanian mountains.

    Photos
    Fire & Ice Smokehouse & Creamery - Meat sampler, mac and cheese, deviled eggs. Oh and cornbread!!

    Meat sampler, mac and cheese, deviled eggs. Oh and cornbread!!

    Fire & Ice Smokehouse & Creamery - Chicken wrap with cole slaw, green beans side.

    Chicken wrap with cole slaw, green beans side.

    Fire & Ice Smokehouse & Creamery - All the sauces

    See all

    All the sauces

    Smokehouse Bar-B-Que - Dining Room

    Smokehouse Bar-B-Que

    3.0(10 reviews)
    30.6 mi
    $$

    Had this as catering for my daughter's wedding. The couple chose it, not my first choice. The food…read morewas delicious but from there a total disaster. We initially met and discussed everything from plates and silverware to bbq sauce. The owner wrote it all down, took our deposit and then lost the paper and didn't remember he booked the event!!! Flash forward to day of event. We ask for square plates discussing at length the tiny plates that we did tasting off of and how we didn't care for those. Told there was a size a little larger we would have at the wedding. When they set the tables the dinner plate was the same as those used for hors d'oeuvres with the smallest ROUND mismatched plate set on top for salad. We had linen napkins set out they lay to the side and placed paper wrapped plastic silverware on top. Water was supposed to be on the tables was never refreshed. The Bbq sauce that we had discussed at length was not on the tables only 20 prefilled little cups were available after I asked for them. We paid extra for family style table service. This was the most unorganized service. They didn't utilize trays but carried out two bowls to a table at a time. It was a very long drawn out process. We discussed the need for a bartender was assured one was available to us for the entirety of the reception. Then day of the wedding was told they would be leaving before the end of the reception and that we needed to pay additional money to the bartenders for them to stay. We made our own desserts but requested paper products for dessert table so they would match other plates. These were the same plates we ate dinner off of. They ran out quickly and then was told they weren't contracted to provide those. I stated we had discussed it, but the owner wasn't there so our dessert table didn't have plates until they dug some out of the van..The same little square plates!!

    Don't get me wrong, the food was amazing! However, we hired them as a wedding caterer and the day…read moreof they did not deliver. Let me be clear, up until the wedding day they were amazing. Communication was good, the food was good, meeting up with them and planning was good. However, the day of they served food for an hour and then stopped serving. They then proceeded to throw out all the left over food. Our guests got one plate, didn't have enough time to get seconds before everything was thrown out. Mind you, we booked them as a caterer for a BUFFET service. They also ran out of drinks 30 minutes into the meal, and they said they "did what they were required to do". Our guests were thirsty and it wasn't until we had to have a very strong discussion with them that they went out to get more beverages. The groom had to be pulled on his special day to deal with this. Unfortunately, the wedding day was during an unexpected heat wave. Imagine that, no drinks during a heat wave? Not even water? A caterer running out of beverages during a heat wave with paid buffet service? When we went to the food tasting and left our deposit with them, they assured us that they would give us any left overs. They even suggested it would be good to bring it to the bridal party for them to eat the next day before heading home. That was a great idea, but they threw it all out. This was a big concern of ours, and they reassured me they were not like other caterers saying, "It's your food. You paid for it. It's yours." They then stated that "legally" they could not give us the food unless we had a refrigerator. We explained that the venue had a refrigerator, and they just brushed it off. They also jacked up the price by about 20% because they said they would have to hire more help to work the day of the wedding to meet requirements. However, we only saw 1 extra person from their team working there. While we weren't happy about it, we understood and we paid it trusting that everything would be taken care of. The owner was very rude, disrespectful, loud, and vulgar the day of the wedding. It was completely unwarranted and unexpected because up until then, they were great. Super kind and easy going, until the day of. They did not even let us know that drinks were running low, so that we could find a solution. We didn't find out until we were bone dry, and at that point we had a problem. Would I recommend their food? Absolutely. Very delicious. Best BBQ I ever had. Would I recommend their service? No. Sadly, they did not deliver. By the end of the night our guests were hungry, and thirsty. Not something you would expect when you pay for a premium buffet service. I am fully aware they may try to respond to this and give all the excuses as to why they did this. One of them saying that we paid "late". They require payments a month before-hand, but with the current global situation, we didn't even know we were having a wedding until 3 weeks before the date. However, we gave him the money agreed upon at that point. We paid full the day of the wedding. We complied to their requests. We provided everything they asked. Don't let their kindness fool you. It was not worth the stress the day of the wedding. It was not a good experience for the bride, the groom, the family, or the guests. ***They partner with a wine-slushy company. They were great. Good pricing and he even gave us free wine for our guests because of the situation. He even brought extra wine just in case. We ended up paying extra for it, but it was needed and we were happy to pay for it. They were prepared for the heat wave, and we recommend them fully.

    Photos
    Smokehouse Bar-B-Que - Beef Brisket Sandwich

    Beef Brisket Sandwich

    Smokehouse Bar-B-Que - Chicken thigh with a side of Mac 'n' Cheese

    Chicken thigh with a side of Mac 'n' Cheese

    Smokehouse Bar-B-Que - Macaroni & Cheese

    See all

    Macaroni & Cheese

    Stampede Barbecue - Complimentary peanuts in the shell and their own brewed beer

    Stampede Barbecue

    4.1(214 reviews)
    71.2 mi
    $$

    The food is about what I remember, w/ hit or miss items where you like some things more than…read moreothers. But the vibe got a total upgrade! Step thru the doors & be transported back in time, to maybe an old saloon in the Wild West- the bartenders darn bow ties, a fire crackles ahead, & an old-timey piano plays in the background. And if that doesn't grab you, the wood-fired brewery using hand pumps should! Rarely do I make exceptions for atmosphere to win out over food, but the setting more than makes up for any shortcomings the BBQ might have. Put this place on your list!

    I wanted to love this place! Super cute and cozy log cabin type vibe. Order up front and take a…read morebuzzer to go get your food yourself. No waiters. Went on prime rib night. $27 for an 8 oz with one side. It came out like warm for us both and super thin with a lot of fat so I might have gotten 4oz of meat to eat. We left hungry. Roll was nothing special, sat ontop of pr so soggy. Coleslaw was good, French fries were ok but such a tiny portion. One place to play games chess and checkers infront of a very nice fireplace that they had lit. The beer was not good, not 3 options that were light on the % of alcohol so I got a wine instead. They advertise pr night and there micro brews so I as expecting a lot better from both. We would come again to try sandwiches and sit by the fire. Very disappointing in all though!

    Photos
    Stampede Barbecue - Interior

    Interior

    Stampede Barbecue - Pulled Pork with BBQ regular sauce

    Pulled Pork with BBQ regular sauce

    Stampede Barbecue - Bar area

    See all

    Bar area

    Susquehanna Smokehouse - diners - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...