You can't beat this local establishment for pizza and so much more. Try the Stromboli or the calzone or the cheesesteak or the salads! To go or dine in. Service is great - a group of us go every week and it's always a great experience. They just got new tables which dressed up the interior. They also serve beer on tap and in bottle/can. And wine. Don't sleep on the dinner specials. They are always fabulous! read more

Swarthmore Pizza - Florentine pizza! Delish! - Pizza Near Me - Swarthmore, Pennsylvania

Just stopped by today Wed 9/03/'25 for a cheesesteak to-go. Ordered it with pepperoni and extra cheese. Hadn't been there for quite a while and grabbed one of their new menus,too. They have been kinda hit-and-miss in the last few years as you can read on other reviews here. Best cheesesteak I've had in a while! Like 5 stars good. Beef was chopped up super well and cheese was nice and melty.Italian roll was fresh and kinda chewy--must get their rolls from Amoroso's bakery,I guess? Very good,will stop there again for take-out. read more

Swarthmore Pizza - new menu 2025 - Pizza Near Me - Swarthmore, Pennsylvania

See all

Found this place while helping my son move into the area and it was outstanding. The pizza was great and the pasta was amazing.

Delicious and friendly. We ordered Christmas dinner for 12 and were very impressed! Lasagna and meatballs, plus salad and cannoli were so so good read more

Bad service took 1 hour for one cheesesteak Was also mid Wasted most of our sleepover Poor (Blank) it was birthday RUN FOR THE HILLS!!!!! read more

Woah holy miserable-atude from the brick oven set! I think it's time to see the ole brick oven bs for what it is, peeps! I've tried their fresh mozzarella pizza, buffalo chicken white pizza, and cheesesteak Stromboli, all delish! I don't normally like pizza but I like Swarthmore Pizza's creations. White buffalo? Thin-ish crust, floury tasting at edges, but has a buttery taste too. Buffalo sauce was that vinegar twang with a kick of spice. Chicken meat is cubed, not the canned pulled stuff. Cheese was baked on, not stringy, just how I like it for my Buffalo flava. The mozz pizza was perfect cooking timing so it didn't turn rubbery or gooey, but was hot and retained its raw flavor. Basil was still green, slightly dried, full of its regular zest. Cheesesteak Stromboli surprised me. I don't like mixing marinara with cheesesteak flavor, but the meat/cheese just popped out of the taste pool, and I could see everything else was just to set up the main stars! Thoughtfully done for sure! Now, the "foodie" squad is probably after the dying lame trend of burnt wood-fired gimmicky nonsense (literally the toxic waste firemen wear suits to protect against). What happened was shrinkflation sold smaller inferior pizzas by unskilled cooks burning it black and told trendmongers it was chic to eat. Ha ha ha! I eat real people pizza and Swarthmore Pizza makes exactly that! Old school classic American pizza like the 80s made! I will never be a follower and I don't have an ego to make me feel pressure to eat char-burnt "food" and say the emperor has clothes! Thanks for making regular-azz good pizza, Swarthmore Pizza! read more

Swarthmore Pizza - Swarthmore Pizza -- CRAZY DELICIOUS white buffalo chicken pizza!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Swarthmore, Pennsylvania

See all

Great pizza, especially when you eat in the restaurant. One of the best cheesesteaks in Delco IMHO!

Food is swimming in oil.,pizza cheese wasn't melted. Only fresh thing was salad. Felt like I was in the dining room of a retirement home.

Pathetic excuse for a cheesesteak. Absolutely weak. I would rather eat hamburger helper on white bread. I mean seriously, it doesn't even look appetizing. The cook should be fired and the restaurant should be sold. Just give up, you provide no type of satisfaction for anybody. I feel sorry for anybody else that has had to go through this type of disappointment. I could have thrown this sandwich against the all, rubbed it on my carpet, and had my dog slobber on it. And then, only then, MAYBE it would look more appetizing. Pathetic. Sad. The pizza is pretty decent though. read more

Swarthmore Pizza - You call this a cheesesteak? - Pizza Near Me - Swarthmore, Pennsylvania

Great pizza and service. We have been to a few pizza places in the area and this one is best.

Cute little pizzeria in town. Friendly and personable staff. We ordered a meat lovers, wings, and fried mushrooms. They do something magical to the crust of their pizzas, so delicious! Toppings piled high as well. Wings and fried mushrooms were also yummy! Highly recommend read more

Swarthmore Pizza - Meat lovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Swarthmore, Pennsylvania

See all

Great food especially the pizza and great staff. Been coming here for years and I adore this place. Keep up the great everything!!!!

Ordered lunch special: fried flounder sandwich. It wasn't flounder but a fried fish cake -- perfectly square and about a 1/4" thick. Smaller than a McDonald's fish sandwich. My friend got a burger, which also was thin and dwarfed by the bun. Pizza and cold sandwiches are good but I'd suggest staying away from anything else. read more

Swarthmore Pizza, Swarthmore PA. I was feeling nostalgic so I went to Swarthmore Pizza. Ironically when we lived in Swarthmore we never went to Swarthmore Pizza. The reviews on google maps weren't great and I saw they had Cheesesteak egg rolls on their lunch menu. I asked if they still could make them and they said, yes. That was the high point of my visit to Swarthmore Pizza. read more

See all

We order there pizza most of the time but tonight my husband had a craving for spaghetti and meatballs And I wanted eggplant parmigiana. They were both horrible. The eggplant had zillions of seeds and the gravy was so thick it didn't pour it clumped on top of our meals. The salads were half a bowl full and wilted lettuce. Nothing looked fresh. we took a few bites and threw them both in the trash read more

Perfect Pizza every time. Delicious, Fresh, and Great tasting! Dine in area is really nice and Staff is friendly. Can't say enough good things about this place. read more

I rarely write negative reviews but sometimes it's unavoidable and hopefully it inspires improvement Parking spaces are very limited but establishment is well attended. There was a long line when I was there so I placed my order to go. I was really enthusiastic about trying it. Since I was the city of brotherly love I chose the Philly cheesesteak. What a disappointment! Essentially ground beef sprinkled on a regular slice. Not worthy of name in my opinion. Service is good. Hopefully, the other dishes are better. read more

See all

Everything is frozen there is nothing that is cooked freshly there is no brick oven pizza because the brick oven does not work we're not recommend eating here at all nothing is homemade nothing read more

This place is amazing! My brother just moved near there, my mom and I stopped in to eat, the staff was sooo awesome, the food was amazing!!! Today we ordered delivery from there, the delivery guy was soo sweet, and the food was beyond great!!! I hope you guys like delivering to the Crum Lynne condos, because I don't see us not ordering from there anytime soon. Thank you so much!!!! A++++++++++++++ read more

I had a quick get together with a couple of friends and they decided to get a couple of pizzas delivered from Swarthmore Pizza. First, they ordered around 10 pies. Most of the pies they got were plain, but they also ordered a few pies with other toppings including pepperoni and mushrooms. I decided to have a slice of the mushroom pizza. When pulling a slice of pizza out of the box, I was delighted by how easily it broke off. However, I was quickly disappointed after seeing how greasy the pizza was. Further, I felt as if the flavor of the pizza was nothing spectacular either. The cheese and sauce was fine, but nothing popped out. Also, the pizza was fairly doughy and the crust was a bit dry and bland. I did like how tasty and fresh the mushrooms were. Altogether, Swarthmore Pizza serves a solid pizza, but nothing truly stands out about it. read more

Swarthmore Pizza is one of my favorite places to dine in and take out in Delco. Throughout the pandemic they have been doing all they could do to keep the community safe. Including, donating to hospitals and healthcare workers . I was dining in Friday night and overheard a woman complaining about employees not wearing their masks. I only saw one employee with his mask below his nose for a minute and that's because he was unfogging his glasses! Let's try to be kind to the small businesses that our trying their hardest to stay afloat and feed our community. Instead of knocking them down, let's continue to build them up. Also, their white pizza is to die for. Along with their Sicilian! read more

I picked up takeout today and saw three employees not wearing their masks properly while making food. Two had them below their noses and one was wearing it over their nose or mouth. He was making the pizza. I told the cashier and she (1) said they fall down. I said that's not what's happening in those three instances and pointed to them. (2) told the one guy with his whole face out to pull it up and he groused. She had to ask multiple times and he argued with her or cursed me. He still didn't pull it up all the way. I told her I'm calling the health dept. Starting tomorrow there is no indoor dining in PA. Isn't that ironic? My sister is a nurse in a COVID ward. There are no beds left. She sees people DIE EVERY DAY. The people at Swarthmore Pizza are part of my community. I don't want people who are my neighbors and community members to die. Do better. Also that was the WORST chicken cheesesteak I've ever eaten. It was like shredded chicken jerky, totally dry and crunchy. read more

We ate outside under the tent and had a fabulous meal with sal as our entertainment!! The bruschetta was the BEST I have ever had!!! And this was the 1st time having the brick oven margarita pizza, DELICIOUS!!! read more

Consistent. Reliable. Fast. Tremendous service and attention to detail. A lot of options in Delaware county but for the reasons mentioned swathmore should be you go to option for take out. Good healthy and hardy options depending on your mood read more

Love this place! Wonderful food! Sandwiches, pasta, and pizza. Service is impeccable and they also have great beers and cocktails! 10/10!

Order from Swarthmore pizza once again trying my luck..Baked Ziti 13.95 with a salad...okay 13.95 nice I thought does it come with bread no!! It coast for hoagie roll 4" 4 dollars ..okay..so I ordered one Greek salad which is 9.95..well it cost me 27.50..where ever that number came from IDK..So picked up they forget the salad I was already home..I'm not going back at least I've the Greek salad..good enough..got home the baked ziti t was in the smallest container from looks like a microwave heated it up.. Never again thanks!!! read more

Stopped in here a few weeks ago and had an excellent sandwich so decided to buy some pizza for friday night dinner.Must say the pizza was terrible. The upside down pizza was very salty and the sauce had a can taste. The vegetarian pizza is not good Or at least what I think a vegetarian pizza is this pizza Was very salty and had some onions and green peppers thrown on top. People were very friendly ,But otherwise I suggest sticking to the sandwiches read more

I don't understand how these guys received so many stars? The pizza part of it was not even good. Under cooked is more like it, plus they say they are brick oven, but I didn't notice it. I love brick oven pizza, I know what brick oven pizza tastes like and should taste like. They are far from it,I'm sorry, but I am not trying to be "That Guy". I have to call it like it is, and I really don't like giving a bad review, especially if it deals with pizza. I love pizza! What set me off about it is a few thing, we'll do the Pros/Cons Cons: - You don't display your pizza, this being your main seller I think you should display it. - Topping were cold when I had asked for a sweet sausage, it looked and tasted funny. - Under cooked pizza where you can still see the dough not fully baked. - Bland flavor to it, your sauce that you use tastes like day old ragu, it didn't have that impact where it hits you on the sides of your mouth. (We all know that feeling) - Calling it brick oven. Pros: - You sell beer and wine, with some good, to decent selections - Your waitress assisted an elderly couple to their car. - You maintain the space used, plus you have outside seating. I know it's my opinion , and maybe I got you guys on a bad day (Friday), but I wasn't impressed. I'd try it again though, maybe this will change , maybe I just got you guys on an off day. read more

Wonderful people. Good but not my favorite pizza crust. Nice family place. Love to take my kids.

I preface this review with this - I am a pizza snob. I think NY Style is the best and DiFara in Brooklyn is Mecca. I temper my expectations here in Delco. You just aren't going to get great pizza in Delco. New London, Gaetanos and Renatos each do a decent job in the "Its Not NYC BUT It Is Delco" category. Thought it was time to give Swarthmore Pizza a try. Ordered a side salad to start. Lettuce didn't look fresh. Couple pieces of green pepper and Tomato. Nothing special as far as dressing. They offer traditional or brick oven pizza choices. Got margarita pie from brick oven. Small in size.Crust was not crispy. Cheese ok. Sauce ok. Not very distinctive taste. Disappointed. Two ice cold imported beers from fridge reasonably priced. Service was good. You can do better elsewhere. read more

Swarthmore Pizza - Side salad - meh - Pizza Near Me - Swarthmore, Pennsylvania

See all

Terrible, placed an order for delivery, they told me 30 minutes......... hour and 1/2 later they arrive. Best part the driver doesn't have any change forcing me to tip more than what was deserved. I even had to call to find out we're my food was. Food was cold and the sandwich was made wrong. They really didn't do a single thing right! Avoid this place read more

This was the most disappointing experience I have had in a long time. My roommate and I placed a fairly large order this evening and EVERYTHING was incorrect. One cheesesteak had the wrong cheese, another didn't have any cheese at all. We asked for "Texas fries" with the ranch on the side, the ranch was on the fries... We also ordered a calzone that was supposed to come with marinara but they forgot that as well. Oh and the caesar salad....that contained pieces of lettuce bigger than my face, no exaggeration. Haha oh and we tipped before we checked our order. Needless to say we won't be ordering from you guys anymore! -p.s. I didn't want to give this place any stars but yelp makes you select at least one in order to post a review. read more

Swarthmore Pizza - see. - Pizza Near Me - Swarthmore, Pennsylvania

just had the best dinner at Swarthmore Pizza. we started off with one of the appetizer specials, shrimp and scallops wrapped in bacon and it was incredible then for dinner, my husband got the homemade veal Parmesan with a side of linguine and I had the homemade lobster ravioli both entrées were absolutely delicious, and the portions were huge !!!! I also treated myself to one of the specialty cocktails, which was a lime margarita, and it was so good. The atmosphere was awesome ..They had live music, and the service was great I highly recommend this hidden gem, and we will definitely be going back !!!!! read more

This is our go-to pizza place. We love the upside down pizza. Their wings and Greek salad are delicious, too! And they're always friendly...from ordering over the phone to the delivery person. read more

Our weekend go to! All the pasta dishes are great along with the Chicken Parm! The Pasta Chicken salad is a favorite too!

Great food and friendly service. I Definitely recommend the Swarthmore delight pizza!

Swathmore Pizza is the best pizza in Delaware County hands down. The ownership and staff is extremely friendly. Service is constantly top-notch and I have yet to have anything but a great experience. I will be coming back! read more

Thank you for being open during the Covid-19 crisis The pizza , cheesesteak were awesome. The curbside service was flawless. We miss sitting inside & we will be back again ! read more

Swarthmore pizza is by far one of the best places in delco to grab a bite to eat. The staff is super friendly and has made sure over the past few months to ensure the safety of their customers by social distancing, wearing masks etc. Their Sicilian pizza and white pizzas are awesome. Definitely try it out if you haven't yet! read more

I ordered bacon cheeseburgers on two separate occasions and they forgot the bacon both times. I called to complain and the girl on the phone didn't seem to have the time of day to even let me finish my complaint. She cut me off in mid sentence more than once and was kind of like, "Oh well". I'm new to the area and I ordered from them fairly often, however, they lost my business - not so much because of the mistakes, but because of the girls' attitude when I called. After reading many other complaints from their customers, it seems that they just don't care about their unhappy customers. They never responded to my e-mail complaint - not even to apologize. There are too many other options to go to than this place that has marginal cooking skills and zero customer service skills. I have had much better experiences with the 320 Market Cafe. Do yourself a favor and kick Swarthmore Pizza to the curb, after all, that's what they do to their customer's that have complaints. read more