Glad we tried this place! We had a big order for a party we hosted -plain cheese, pepperoni and white. I know it was a bit bold trying a new place for a party without trying ourselves first but we took a chance based on reviews and glad we did! All pies were a hit and even better we were able to use their daily specials pricing too. My husband picked up the pies and the shop was clean and the service crew was friendly. Being new to the area we love to try to placed especially based on recommendations and glad we can add New Haven into our mix. If the take out was this good, I am eager to try dine in. We definitely recommend the white pizza- perfect amount of cheese and garlic. read more

Let me start by saying the staff are some of the coolest nicest people ever. The food is pretty good! I wouldn't go here for a healthy choice. But definitely an affordable choice. They also have 6 packs to go which is nice if you live in town I would be remissed if I didn't add: this is NOT New Haven style pizza lol still yummy though! read more

New Haven Pizza - Plain Pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

The pizza here is very good! The Cesar salad was a bit odd as it was mostly all cheese. It's a bit of a wait when you order and they always seem to have a lot of orders (which is a good thing). Also, there isn't designated parking, so you need to plan for that. read more

See all

Walking by and decided to stop in when we saw the New Haven Pizza sign. We met Bree at the counter who was friendly and welcoming. We ordered a large cheese pizza and two bottled waters. The pizza came out hot and the crust crunchy. Reminded me of Seasons Pizza. Not like New Haven, but it was fresh and we liked the cheese. The place was clean with booths and table seating, and the staff were friendly. Cute little spot to grab a quick meal. read more

New Haven Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

See all

Great pizza with a nice crust and plenty of cheese. I had onions and green peppers and they were sliced thin so they cooked a bit on the pizza. I don't like when the veggies are too raw. read more

Stopped here because of the name. New Haven is famous for great pizza. They should rename it "Not New Haven Pizza" Inside is typical pizza parlor , no other patrons was first red flag. Staff was nice. We ordered a large plain pizza and an order of fries. To be honest, the French fries were extremely good. Should have stopped there. The pizza came out in a timely manner, visually looked good. No cheese pull hinted to a low quality mozzarella cheese or mix. After first bite, reminded me of frozen pizza. Maybe a blend of Parmesan and a little mozzarella I feel was used. Not good. Sauce was bland also. I will come back for fries but seek pizza somewhere else. read more

Stopped here for my hour break during jury duty. Quick block around the corner from the justice center. Ordered a personal size pizza and Dr Pepper for $10. In and out quick. It was hot with fresh ingredients. Crust maybe not the best, but there was nothing wrong with it. Great service and easy. read more

New Haven Pizza - Personal pizza with pepperoni and sausage. - Pizza Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

Another AWESOME visit to New Haven Pizza in West Chester I've been going there since the 70s. Family owned and operated Service is always over the top Young lady working the register and is so friendly and nice. Breath of fresh air to be greeted so nice in world where people are so miserable My daughter and I love the pizza special with 2 salads and 2 drinks for 16 bucks They have a cheese steak special with a salad and drink for 13 bucks Awesome person pizza with salad and drink for 8 bucks All specials are enough to share read more

See all

Amazing staff. The Greek Salad is amazing!!! Any dinner platter is great! Family owned read more

Stromboli was amazing last night! I had to come back. Topping: jalapeño, ricotta cheese, pepperoni, and sausage. Crunchy and delicious highly recommended read more

New Haven Pizza - Just chips, waiting for my order. Excited - Pizza Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

Very average food. The ordering process is antiquated -- by phone only. Also, a credit card surcharge?

The food is amazing and surely one the better pizzas I've had. The location is great as well. The service is also excellent. Ambience is down to earth which I like that kind of setup. read more

Normally I don't leave bad reviews, unless something is really bad. My reasons for this review are unusual: bad pizza combined with misleading marketing claiming great pizza. First, let me say these things: The service here is great. Nothing wrong with that. And I did not try anything on the menu except the pizza. Their cheesesteaks could possibly be superb. I have no idea. But I love pizza. I've been to New Haven. I've had Sally's Apizza. I've had Frank Pepe's. This was not that. I grew up in the South Philadelphia (the Italian section). And I've specifically gone to NYC to try the various Ray's. I know my pizza. So my first big complaint is that they named this place New Haven Pizza, but there is not a serious attempt to make New Haven style pizza. And after receiving the pizza and realizing it was not New Haven style, I looked at the kitchen. They don't have a coal-fired or wood-fired oven. Standard US commercial gas-fired pizza ovens. Fine for NY or Philly style, but not New Haven or Napoli style. Is that unforgivable? Yes. I know a local pizzeria that wanted to make Napoli style pizza, and they built a wood-fired oven. And they didn't even call themselves Napoli Pizza. My second complaint is that even though they're not making New Haven style pizza at a place called New Haven pizza, they're making not-so-good pizza. The crust is the biggest issue. It's not a crunchy, chewing Philly / NY crust. It's not a bubbly burnt crispy New Haven crust. It's not a chewy and sometimes soggy in the middle Napoli pizza (not my favorite). Sigh. If they hadn't named their place New Haven Pizza I would never have written this review. read more

Good foods, good service Prices are reasonable and the available seating is convenient. read more

If you are looking for just something plain and tasteless , then go to this place. The pizza was equivalent to something you get a school cafeteria. The cheese was like melted plastic that cooled down fast and had no elasticity. Frozen pizza beats this. I also had the chicken parm sub and it was horrible. I shared the large pie with 4 other people and all had the same reaction. I am giving this place 2 stars because we didn't have to wait long and the staff was friendly. read more

New Haven Pizza - Half cheese and pineapple: large pie - Pizza Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

I just had the rudest experience with the older gentleman, who may be the owner. I came in asking him for a slice or a personal pan. He helped everyone else around me when I was there first, and then when he finally came to me, he didn't greet me. He didn't ask what I needed. He just looked at me and then when I stated what I needed to order, he was just started saying "yeah yeah yeah" and dismissive of what I wanted so then I canceled my order. As an African-American female, I felt disrespected, especially because I was there before other customers that he assisted before me. I have been coming there for years and I usually come every Friday and will be greeted with a smile by the younger gentleman who usually works in the front, but this experience makes me not want to come there ever again. read more

If you like Greek style pizza, this is best spot in WC for it. Pies are a little small but they're consistently delicious every time. And they make a really great cheesesteak too! read more

The service is quick and the food is fresh and made to order. While I was surprised by the price point, I thought it was appropriate for the area. Will definitely be back. read more

New Haven Pizza - Very good cheese steaks and fries. - Pizza Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

Stopped in for a personal pan pizza last week, it was so freaking good. Mushroom, black olives and spinach. Def getting it again.

The menu board said the cheesesteaks are made with 7 ounces of sirloin. That sounded small and since we were in West Chester I went with the small plate mentality and got the special steak. I am glad I did. I knew I was in for a treat when I saw all of that glorious melted cheese. It was like a cheese lava flow carving a valley out of a Conshohocken perfectly baked bread Nirvana. It was very tasty, fried onions, peppers, mushrooms and a little bit of pizza sauce. The meat did not get lost in the extras. Everyone played nicely together. I like my cheese mixed in or on the bottom like a cheesy garlic bread. I still do BUT I loved the amount of cheese and the melt of the cheese. $9.50 for the cheesesteak. Considering it was West Chester and it was tasty I don't hate the $9.50. The family next to us told us we had to go back and try The Gyro pizza.. Overall very good experience. Nice clean little place. Possibly a different experience when the West Chester students are back. read more

See all

Great pizza. The sauce and crust were amazing. The place is not fancy. But great for takeout.

Family business, huge menu, consistently solid. Don and his crew are great! I always leave happy. Pro tips: Order the pizza "well done", it'll come out with a little crisp! Also, try their upside down/reverse pizza with provolone! read more

Walked in for a take out order. They were super nice! (Had a beer while we waited.) Pizza was SO good. Like. So good! Zero leftovers. I will def be back again!!!! read more

What can I say....everything on the menu is delicious!!! I'm never disappointed!!! Mrs. Bottos's soups and coleslaw are delicious!!! Thank you Mr. & Mrs. Bottos and Don for all you do. read more

The pizza here is top notch. It always seemed to me that my pizza was made with fresh ingredients with the right proportions. I'm more of a crust person and I loved their crust which is medium in size and toasted right. At this point, one of the very few best pizza places in downtown West Chester. Love their personal size pizza which curbs the craving. read more

I had to grab a quick meal for an impromptu meeting with my CPA and she suggested New Haven. I'd forgotten about this little gem, and had to walk an extra block to find their new location. The young man behind the counter was very helpful and super friendly. He chatted with me the whole time I waited and helped me pick out a beer to go with my meal. It's nice to find a place that sells singles. The food came fast and all the bags were clearly marked. It was all placed in a low box so it was easy to carry (especially nice since I was walking). My Stromboli's was the best that I think I've ever had. The crust was amazing, not at all like a folded pizza you get at most places. read more

Your typical pizza spot. I got the buffalo chicken pizza. It got the job done but there wasn't a lot of flavor. The menu is huge so maybe I got the wrong thing. read more

Authentic. East coast to the max. Great cheesesteaks and pizza. Serves beer. Added bonus. Reasonable prices. read more

Today, we had pick of "House Special" Pizza. The Pizza was very low on sausage, ground beef and mushrooms (the main ingredients). We did not ask for peperoni, instead replace with some jalapeno pepper. The toppings were very sloppy. The pick-up box did not even have the usual wax paper underlining. When you cut, you get cardboard scarp stuck with he Pizza bottom. The pizza was tasty, yet made very sloppy !! read more

I love New Haven Pizza! Everything I've ordered from them has been delicious. The prices are great, the staff is always friendly, plus they sell beer! Dine in or take out, New Haven Pizza is the place to go. I highly recommend their cheesesteaks, Italian grinders, and meatball grinders. read more

See all

pizza was cooked perfectly and was delicious, would recommend. friendly service and the place was cool to sit in

Grew up in the Philly area and these are hands down the best cheesesteaks I've ever tasted. Quality meat, phenomenal toasted bread, onions, peppers and mushrooms. The old man who runs the place is the nicest person you could meet. Don't bother with their pizza, cheesesteaks are the prime attraction. If you're in West Chester this place is a must for a great Philly Cheesesteak. read more

The pizza is decent, but not my favorite. I think there are plenty of better places around West Chester for pizza or sandwiches such as Lorenzo's, Benny's, or Saucy's. The pizza is pretty greasy, the atmosphere isn't the best, and the workers don't speak much to you as if they are nervous or something. That being said, a few of their items on the menu are pretty good. So if you want to try something new and have tried a lot of places around and just want something different, you can always try this place. read more

I have been coming here since I was a child. Same familiar faces and the pizza is awesome. It's Greek style, but it's delicious and they have been consistent for years. Great Stromboli's and you can pick up some alcohol beverages to go if you must. I currently live in Philly, but every time I visit home (West Chester) I make it my business to stop here! read more

No, I don't like their pizza, but I'm a pizza snob, so make of that statement what you will. I have, however, been patronizing this establishment for nearly 20 years and I am absolutely impressed with their consistency over the years. This used to be a the place we bought our 6 packs, 40s, and hoagies in my college days. Now, I stop by for the occasional turkey hoagie, chicken parm sandwich, or cheese fries. Everything is just as I remember it in 1995. Only the location has changed, just a block from where it once stood in my memories. The selection and prices on take out beer are solid. Their sandwiches and food, in general, are always top notch. read more

This is my go-to pizza spot in West Chester. The crust is killer and it's always ready in "10 minutes". Kid friendly in the restaurant.

I confess, I have never been to New Haven CT and tried the legendary pie there. But based on what I've read, it's good stuff. Hence, in search of the elusive worthy pie in West Chester, I was excited to learn about a pizza joint billing itself as "New Haven" Pizza. Surely these guys knew something about a quality pie. Well, let's begin with the positives. The place is cozy, friendly, welcoming. Just a hole-in-the-wall kind of place, but it fits perfectly in the downtown area of this college town. They have cold beer for takeout. The pizza is really cheap, and the staff is friendly. So much to like! Alas, the pie is truly forgettable. As usual, ordinary pie has an unremarkable crust. This crust reminds me of frozen pizza, with its pale yellow hue and the consistency of supermarket "Italian" bread. This place serves it cores customers really well -- broke college kids needing a cheap bellyful of pizza and beer. I salute them for that. As for the pizza, four out of ten. Honestly, I think I'd prefer Pizza Hut. I am Pizza Quixote! read more

Their pizza is delicious, always fresh ingredients. They're always on point, fast service. Can't vouch for other food on the menu but it's quite extensive. One day I'll try something else but their pizza has, is and always be a West Chester staple/favorite! read more

What a ripoff! Their menu is not up-to-date. You are baited-and-switched and gouged until you bleed. Avoid this place as if it would give you the plague! read more

New Haven has been my take-out haven since I moved to WC. Actually, I didn't start going there until I moved around the corner - it depresses me a bit. I missed out on this place for almost two years. Everything I have ever ordered has been delicious. Mega fries, chicken cheese steak, salad with grilled chicken, chicken tenders, seasoned (amazingly) fries, and delicious - oh - so - delicious pizza. I must admit, before finding out I was allergic to milk (no more pizza :-( for me) I would eat a peperoni pizza once a week from New Haven. The crust is not thin - I'd say it's halfway between deep dish and thin crust. To me, that is perfection. In addition they have take-out beer and wine-coolers. The prices are comparable to other take-out locations and they have a great selection - not just the standard selection of common/popular beer. I'd love to eat here every day. Seriously. read more