Locally owned and operated! Great selection and good food. There pies sell out fast. They are so good. Love their peanut butter pie!! read more

This gets five stars! We were traveling through this area on motorcycles. Popped in and were pleasantly treated with a great meal experience! Super cool vibe, food was great, I highly recommend Tally-Ho Restaurant! read more

Tally-Ho is a small hometown diner that we visited on our Vacation in the end of August 2025. It is about 20 mins. from the Baseball Hall of Fame. We went on a Friday night and the place was crowded for the Friday fish fry. This cozy old fashioned diner reminded me of my Grandparents. They would have loved this place! The food was amazing for a diner. The wait staff was so friendly. Prices are reasonable. It honestly was a trip back in time to my childhood. We really enjoyed it very much, as places like this don't exist anymore where we live. I suggest you stop by if you're in the area. The nostalgia family friendly atmosphere was very nice in this fast food world. I would like to again Thank the anonymous lady who paid for my family of 4s dinner that night. It was very kind and a wonderful surprise. Tip: Try the homemade pies before they sell out! read more

What a great dinner spot. I had a Ruben and it came more like a pastrami with cheese. No dressing, no sauerkraut, on rye. But I liked it. My wife's burger was delish and a mountain of fries. I should have had fish n chips or the fried chicken dinner. Both looked great. We are next door at the village inn. This was so good we'll be back for breakfast. The motel is across the lot. Very affordable. 1/3 of what dinner was last night. $$. read more

See all

A friendly wait staff, but I was served one of the worst burgers ever. Gray and tasteless. Couldn't finish it. Won't be going back.

Good atmosphere, lots on the menu. Really enjoyed the Friday night fish fry. For a small town restaurant it's pretty good.

This restaurant has been a family favorite for my entire life. Heather runs a great business here. Food is always good, whether it's breakfast or lunch.. always good! This is a kid friendly place, they even will give your kids a crayon box and coloring book to keep them entertained while you eat. This is a gem in Richfield Springs! read more

The restaurant was closed. Unable to eat there. So we walked down the street to Cassidy Diner for breakfast. Nothing special just good breakfast. Coffee was good so I was happy. Tried Tally Ho next day still closed. Must only b open on weekends. read more

A great place to eat. Food was delicious and the staff was extremely friendly. I highly recommend this place to enjoy a meal.

Great food for cheap! Huge serving sizes and great service. The ambience proved to me that It was a family restaurant.

Great is right! The fish sandwich and cole slaw was delicious. However! The raspberry pie was Thee best ever!! An apology from the owner that because of her daughter's graduation party on the following day, she had not made cream pies Thursday night. The word has been passed, worth a visit for the real home made pies!!!! read more

Surprisingly good, fresh food for a diner. Passing through town. Great meal. Nice people.

Visited on Saturday the 7th, shortly before closing- but had great friendly service and excellent food- the hot pork sandwich and onion rings were fine Grandma should be complimented on the lemon meringue pie. read more

Tally-Ho Restaurant - Hot pork sandwich and onion rings from the Tally Ho. - American Near Me - Richfield Springs, New York

See all

The best breakfast I have ever had. Fresh home cooked meals, pies, sides, and milkshakes. I had the corned beef hash with 2 farm fresh eggs over easy with home fries and rye toast along with fresh squeezed orange juice, and a side of delicious crispy yummy bacon. It was so good. I drive 5 hours to get there so we make a weekend trip around this place! They serve breakfast and lunch. I have been going here for over 30 years, and they have always been consistent with delicious home cooked meals. I love going here and you will too. Did I mention the prices, oh incredible prices, inexpensive not cheap but definitely inexpensive. So worth it!!! Try the steak or burgers I highly recommend everything and the big huge onion rings. And end it with a big piece of home made pie. Delicious!!! read more

Tally-Ho Restaurant - Front of Tally-Ho restaurant. - American Near Me - Richfield Springs, New York

See all

Great little spot in Richfield Springs! Stopped for breakfast on the way from Cooperstown to Niagara. Friendly service and good food with huge portions. Our breakfast was excellent! read more

What a great place. Nice location,off street parking. Friendly staff. Had a great haddock sandwich and excellent cole slaw. But for dessert had the best piece of raspberry pie I ever ate. Wonderful crust and at least 3 inch deep raspberry pie filling. All the pies are homemade, delicious read more

I just used the Tally-Ho restaurant for a work related catering event and Heather and the staff were awesome! We ordered a large breakfast spread of different breakfast sandwiches, pancakes, and French toast and all of the food was excellent. The food was ready for pickup (and fresh) right on time! The team loved the spread and would definitely recommend to anyone in the area. If we ever go back up there, then we will be sure to return to Tally-Ho. Thanks so much again! read more

What a great place to go have breakfast in Richfield Springs, NY! Everyone was so friendly and the food was great! You couldn't ask for anything more from a place like this. I recommend this place without a doubt if you are in the area. read more

Ok diner food, I had the Fish reuben,, as unusual as it sounds, it was pretty good. I was underwhelmed by the strawberry rhubarb pie though, seemed like the filling was just cornstarched juice, no annoying fruit parts.. but the crust was good.. I 'd eat there again. read more

I just got back home from my bucket list travel to Richfieldsprings ny. I lived with the owners Doug&Sue Tabor back in 1957 thru 1960.I started working in the restaurant then at 13 years of age.It has been 57 years since i left and in returning my first stop was the Tally Ho.I brought my 46 year old son who put up with my tales of the area and the restaurant his whole life and i must tell you the staff and the food are as wonderful today as in 1957-1960.Heather and staff helped bring back the history of the Tally Ho and Richfieldsprings and now my son has fallen in love with the memories.You will not find a better place to eat within 50 miles. I live on the eastern sea coast and have never had a fish fry as delicious as that at Tally Ho. In closing i wish to thank Heather and her staff for maintaining the Tally Ho tradition. God bless all. R.E.Wilson read more

We stumbled across the Tally-Ho on our way to a music festival and enjoyed it so much that we stopped again on the way home too. It then became our yearly tradition on our way to moe.down. Both the dinner and breakfasts were great and the staff was very pleasant and attentive. The thing that really got us coming back was the pie though. We always get pie after our meal and a few pies to take with us. Every one we tried was great but if I had to pick a favorite it would be the strawberry rhubarb. read more

Good food, huge portions, closes early, hard to get stroller in and out, felt like server as ignoring us with only 3 other tables occupied. We had to ask for menus, and flag her down after a long wait, to order. Food came quick, but we had to wait ages to pay. read more

Heather and the staff at the Tally-Ho are hardworking and this restaurant is a mainstay in the community. It's where the community locals meet and catch up on the area news and people. Check out the specials! It's an affordable place to eat and the Friday night fish fry is an area favorite. The back room of the restaurant serves as a meeting place for the local Rotary and many groups use that as their place for gatherings. Heather caters local functions. Plenty of parking and the vintage car shows through the summer on Monday nights are a fun small town happening. read more

My wife and I come here to eat every 2 weeks. We live on Long Island and have a summer home nearby. The food is excellent and the friendly service can't be beat. We both look forward to stopping in for breakfast or lunch, Highly recommended. read more

Food was so so, the bathroom was to small dirty and not easy for a wheelchair, the waitress carried our drinks over in her armpit, they had children running around, the manager was being nasty and for the price I was not satisfied. read more