Best place in Tallahassee to find made from scratch cakes - my favorite is a Red velvet cake that I order special with white wedding cake icing. It lasts no time when served during our family get togethers. read more

#1 of 100 review December challenge. Local favorite in Tallahassee. Young staff on Saturday was so sweet and helpful. Came by for some pastries and bagels. They even had our favorite cannoli. It was cold today and had my parents with us so didn't eat on the outside area but on a warmer day would. Worth a look! read more

See all

Whether it's a morning sesame bagel or a famous smile cookie in the afternoon, Tasty Pastry is perfect for all of your daily bakery needs. A decades long family favorite, Tasty Pastry is a charming local bakery that has served as our birthday cake, office breakfast (think bread sliced bagels), last minute hostess gift, weeknight prepared meal, "go to" bakery. Service is always prompt and with s great big smile. After moving away for 8 years, we are back in town and I'd be lying if I didn't say that Tasty Pastry bagels and veggie cream cheese were a factor in our decision. read more

Tasty Pastry Bakery - Get there at 6:45 fit fresh bagels! - Bakeries Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

This bakery which was established back in 1963 is located in a cute area off of Market Street. It's kind of hidden so look for the American flag. When you walk in there is so many bakery options. It took me a second to really decide what I truly wanted. I must say the jumbo cupcakes look amazing. They offer cookies, muffins, donuts, eclairs, and cupcakes of course. I tried the blueberry muffin, and it was moist and delicious. It was definitely one of the best blueberry muffins I have ever had. I can't wait to try the coconut cupcake later! The staff is friendly and ready to help you when you walk in. They also have a lot of outdoor seating to hang out and enjoy your baked goodies. The name of this bakery is fitting....Tasty Pastry Bakery! Enjoy! read more

Tasty Pastry Bakery - Jumbo cupcakes and more... - Bakeries Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

I love Tasty Pastry! I don't have the time or energy to make baked goods at home so I enjoy going there to get a tasty treat. I've been craving cinnamon rolls for a month and tried them at many places but was left wanting. The cinnamon roll I got at Tasty Pastry yesterday morning was everything I've been wanting--warm, fluffy, perfect amount of icing. They offer them with or without raisins. I got them with raisins. I started eating my roll before remembering to take a picture. Oops! They're that good!! read more

Tasty Pastry Bakery - Cinnamon Roll, slightly eaten - Bakeries Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Everything at Tasty Pastry is just Heavenly. Depending on my mood, I grab a Jumbo Cupcake, brownie, or an apple turnover. I really like all the options as there is something for everyone. You won't be disappointed with this large selection of sweets and breads. read more

Tasty Pastry Bakery - a variety of baked goods - Bakeries Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

They did an amazing job on my daughters bday cake! I brought them a picture of what I was hoping for & they were able to replicate it exactly! I will absolutely be back. read more

Tasty Pastry Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

I went to Tasty Pastry for some of the delectable casseroles and perfect M&M cookies and was helped by Keira. Keira was so sweet and knew what she was talking about. I really like how the store was set up and even got a loaf of bread to take home! 10/10 recommend!!! read more

Despite having pictured cakes that they've created on their website, they will only allow you to select from a numbered list of cakes when placing a custom order. Even if it's been custom made before with a listing on their website you can show them; such as a pregnancy belly cake, they will not create another because it's not a "numbered" cake. Not sure if this is because they're relying on straight-out-of-school bakers or lack of care to try and make a sell. Save time and frustration by going to Publix, at least they're consistent. read more

Id say this is probably the best regular bakery in town for the money. Rows after rows of inventive delicious baked goods all for prices that won't burn a hole in your wallet. Honestly is better in some ways vs the more traditional French bakery in town, but makes different treats. Well worth visiting! read more

They are lucky someone hasn't died at their negligence!! So the week before Christmas, my 93 year old grandmother went to Tasty Pastry to get a quiche for the holidays. She has a condition called Alpha-Gal, which makes her highly allergic to beef, pork, and lamb product. As we went in, she explained her health issues and was told to get the spinach and tomato one. She looked it over and asked again if there were any meat products used whatsoever in the quiche or even may have been in contact with them. The cashier assured her that these were completely vegetarian. When she took it home and are the first bite, she noticed a strange texture but assumed it was an additive or something like that. Within a short time, she had an extreme reaction and was violently throwing up and shaking. She didn't want to eat any more of the quiche after vomiting it up all day, so she gave it to my aunt. My aunt quickly called my grandmother and explained to her that the quiche had minced (basically pulverize) ham in it and to take her allergy protocol. She and I have both called the store and were told we would hear back from the owners about making sure this doesn't happen again. This may seem small or petty to some, but those with food allergies know this is literally life and death (especially to a 93 year old. Here is the label of it if anyone else has these issues. I expected better from this store. read more

My wife woke up with a craving for bagels so we tried Tasty Pastries. Mistake! Everything in the place looked fantastic but when we got to the eating part the product was old and stale, not just the bagels but I had a donut and a five dollar cupcake! RIDICULOUS!!!!! We wont be back. The service was just ok nothing special, you would think that you would at least get a smile during the fleecing!!!! OVERRATED!! read more

The Cookie Monster was delicious and cute! Thank you to the gal that boxed up 3 dozen cookies for me.

This bakery is always on our go to list when in town. Long time classic bakery that has provided traditional bday cakes, breakfast danish, breads, casseroles galore over the years. Family owned and operated...it can be busy on weekends and around holiday times, plan accordingly. The Market Square area is evolving; however, this bakery is reliable, genuine, and delicious, of course! Another additional must support local establishment for Tally. read more

Tasty Pastry Bakery - Jumbo cupcake oh my! - Bakeries Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

The lightest fluffiest most full of fruit blueberry muffins, cranberry muffins wonderful they did great pastries have some wonderful things. Tasty pastry. We love the blueberry muffins the most, but it's true Bakery use real sugar and probably makes some wonderful croissants anyway it's fun to go there. it's clean and there's a couple other stores that are close by that you would enjoy going to , give it a try I promise you'll like it some part of it. You'll probably be a part that you don't like exactly but it outweighs the good outweighs the bad go for. read more

I had previously given this bakery a not-so-good review due to the very rude treatment I was exposed to a while back. But, in picking up a cake that my husband ordered for me daughter - who LOVES this place - I had a very pleasant experience. I wasn't ignored when I walked in, I was spoken to in a nice manner, and the person at the cash register was extremely pleasant. We were all quite satisfied with the outcome of the cake decorations; my daughter loved the cake! read more

I've never tried this place, but I figured since they'd been open over 50 years, their products must be good, but I was wrong, the cake I ordered was great! I ordered a 5 layer chocolate ganache cake for my son's graduation over the phone. I explained what I wanted, just a simple "Congratulations" with my son's name on it, and maybe 2 small graduation decorations. My son has an unusual name, and I was thrilled that the decorator called me to confirm the spelling of his name. The people who work there could not have been nicer, and each person who sews you makes sure to ask if you've been helped, and everyone there had a smile on their face. The cake was not only beautiful, it tasted amazing!!! They have earned a new, very happy customer. read more

Tasty Pastry Bakery - Graduation cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

This place has Great freshly baked cinnamon rolls--a real hidden gem. Also bought garlic bread

Craving CARBS! I walked into a line of happy people waiting to get great service. After a moment, it was my turn. I ordered sour dough bread, three cheese croissants, three plain croissants, three chocolate croissants, and chocolate dipped Oreos. The pleasant server gladly put my order together into boxes. The total for everything came to $28. When I opened, the wonderful smell of croissants filled the air. The cheese croissants were insane. Like always, I will be back. Maybe I will order a cake next time. read more

I maybe it's just me everyone loves tasty pastry but I have never had anything from there that has knocked my socks off. I prefer the cake shop read more

Very good bakery. Devenney and Abby very good workers. They were very nice and very good. read more

Tasty Pastry Bakery - Free sticker - Bakeries Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Oh so delicious!! Customized two-tier baby shower cake, and the cake was absolutely delicious! The real test is how the cake holds up the next day...and SUCCESS!! We forgot to put the cake into an air-tight container after the shower, and the leftover cake was left in the original cardboard box overnight. The cake was equally delicious even 24 hours later. We never got around to storing the cake correctly, but it stayed in the original cardboard box for 4 days...and the cake was still moist! The actual cake (vanilla cake with vanilla frosting) was delicious! The cake was not sweet, and the frosting was sweet enough to compliment the cake. NOTE: This was "winter" time in Florida...so I'm sure the humidity would impact how soft the cake stays! read more

This cake was GREAT! Fresh white cake filled with strawberry jam decorated in pinks for a baby shower I hosted. The customer service was incredible. Tasty Pastry took the time to speak with me which made me feel they had a vested interest in my baby shower cake. My inquiries were met with polite friendly suggestions on their decorating skills, color schemes as well as their artistic vision for my cake. Price point was perfect. Each time I went into Tasty Pastry their bakery products were fresh and delicious. I purchased cinnamon buns, fruit danish, cheese danish, muffins apple fritters and individual cake servings. I was happy with everything I purchased. This was a WIN WIN! read more

Tasty Pastry Bakery - Half Sheet Baby Shower Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Great service tasty treats! The peanut butter cookies were some of the best I've had.

I didn't enjoy any of these delights, due to gluten intolerance, but family enjoyed them. The reports were the cannoli was delicious and the "M"cookies: molasses, macadamia nut and macaroon were marvelous! Tasty Pasty was busy on this mid-December day and the cases were filled with holiday pastries, decorated cookies, & breads and even fresh fruitcake! read more

Tasty Pastry Bakery - Outside - Bakeries Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

After another bakery couldn't make our order, I called Tasty Pastry. They agreed to prepare it and alleviated my main concern that it would be done on time. I was so happy with the beautiful round, 10", double layer decorated coconut cake. After serving it at the birthday party, everyone raved about the delicious moist cake. It truly was a beautiful cake. I say was because in less than two days, it was gobbled up! Thank you, Tasty Pastry Bakery! read more

Tasty Pastry Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Pastries and quiche are outstanding! Best Bakery in Tallahassee! I definitely recommend!

Love that this bakery is still around. I have loved them since I was a kid...and now I'm a middle aged lady. :) I recently ordered a birthday cake for my sister. On their menu, I selected carrot cake, the design and all the details. Paid, everything was great....but, apparently they didn't have carrot cake and all I got was vanilla. Boohoooooo..... so, would be great if they never ran out of what we wanted to order. Having said that though, the gal I was working with was awesome and their products are just so delicious. read more

I we were so disappointed with the cannolis. They seemed like they were sitting there a long time. The taste wasn't awful but the shells were soft. No crunch! The overall appearance of the store is kind of dingy. We won't be back there. read more

The best bakery on Tallahassee's northside by far. Always pleasant and their cakes snd cookies are to die for.

Have found their pastries to be outstanding... Also, like that they sponsor Lucky Goat coffee. read more

I can't keep track of how many bakeries I've been to in my lifetime & I've been to Tasty Pastry more than once. In my opinion this place isn't bad but it's not great either. The service is good & they have a good variety of pastries but the taste is average. Maybe I need to try one of their made to order cakes since that's what a lot of the good reviews seem to be referring to. If you decide to order a cake from Tasty Pastry & you wouldn't mind sharing, please let me know so I can try some & give the bakery a more precise review. read more

Tasty Pastry Bakery - (Clockwise) red velvet cupcake, carrot cupcake, coconut danish, chocolate croissant & a cheese danish. - Bakeries Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Favorite Bakery in Tallahassee!! There's definitely a reason that most coffee shops in Tallahassee sell their pastries, they're just so good. I have never really liked muffins until I tried their banana chocolate chip muffin, I became obsessed and can eat it any time of the day. I have never had a bad customer service experience here, every time I go in they're always super busy but get me in and very quickly (which I like). The only downfall is that they don't do special requests (emailed them once to see if they could take the nuts out of the banana bread they sell and they said no). read more

I frequently but a bakery treat from here because the location is convenient. I knocked off a star because nothing's stands out. And another because everything always tastes like it was made the day before. read more

See all

Outstanding! Contacted Tasty Pastry because they had delivery available. Wanted cupcakes delivered to FSU to surprise someone for their birthday. They said the gourmet cupcakes and brownies we sent were incredible! Tasty Pastry was very thorough on getting the directions correct to ensure the delivery would reach the correct building and were very clear on when the delivery would be made. Thanks for making her birthday special! read more

Some great items and some not so great. Amazing key lime pie cheesecake and cheesecake w nuts and chocolate chips. Almond horns are good. Chocolate cupcake w chocolate mouse is moist and good frosting. Poor quality: quiches, cheese danish, chocolate eclair, magic 7 layer bars. Muffins are moist but waaay too much sugar on top. Red velvet cupcake: decent cupcake but cream cheese frosting has very little cream cheese in it so has mediocre flavor. read more

What a wonderful find...couldn't be happier with this place (well unless it was free lol). Ordering was easy, they were pleasant and accommodating, delivered on time and even were kind enough to wait when my daughter wasn't at first available to receive them...and she said they were delicious. Will definitely use them again and definitely want to try out the restaurant next time we visit our daughter in Tally. read more

Tasty Pastry Bakery - Beautiful gourmet cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

I ordered the King Cake from here to celebrate Carnival. I ordered it a day before and it was ready on time. My only concern is that when I walked in, I saw a table that had a bunch of King Cakes on it, all packaged the same. I thought that maybe these were made specifically for walk-in orders, and that mine (because I pre-ordered it) would be different (aka fresher, different packaging, etc). When it was my turn to get to the counter I told them that I was picking up a King Cake I ordered yesterday, so the woman walks to the back and hands me the exact same box that was on the table in the front. I thanked her and paid for it, but it made me think that these King Cakes are not as fresh as I would have liked, or even not made in-store (especially for ordering from a bakery instead of picking it up at the grocery store, for example). The King Cake itself, sadly, was just very typically. Nothing to write home to; it's a huge, dry cinnamon roll with green/purple/yellow colored icing. This particular experience will not deter me from shopping here, however, as they had many wonderful looking treats on display that I am sure taste wonderful. read more

Favorite bakery in town! A great selection and equally great prices! Have had the Cookie Monster, cannoli, and s'mores cupcake. All delicious, especially the cupcake! Friendly staff and great outdoor seating. Very wide selection of donuts, muffins, pastries, cupcakes, brownies, cookies, and more! read more

Tasty Pastry Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

I was in the area for a meeting a decided to take a stroll down the plaza. I found this quaint little bakery that was nestled in the middle of the plaza. Nice shaded sitting area out front as well as a pleasant home feel. The bakery has a large array of breads, cakes, cookies, pastries and much more. I decided to order two cookies. The macadamia nut and oatmeal raisin. I decided to try the Macadamia first. I didn't like it. It was hard and didn't seem fresh. After the initial bite I decided to try the oatmeal. Let's just say the cookie was so soft and delectable. Absolutely DIVINE and made UP for the taste of the other. I kept looking in my bag to see if there were any morsels or oatmeal raisin cookie left. No, just the hard macadamia was left behind. I will definitely go back to see what else they have to offer. Definitely, not my last time going here. Overall 4 stars. read more