Had an extremely pleasant dining experience, highly recommend the western omelette!! Make sure to…read moretry the house made seasoning salt on the PILE of yummy hash browns that come with it! Great service, exceptional food, thank you

Great spot not far off I70. Small town diner atmosphere. Great breakfast and friendly service.read more

Amish Country at its best!…read more This is a gem of a restaurant. We found this place thanks to the great reviews on Yelp. We were not familiar with Baltic, Ohio, yet we were so happy we found this place. The staff was so friendly and welcoming, it felt like we were eating in someone's home. Christian, the manager, could have not done anything more to accommodate us. He really went out of his way to enhance our experience. Our waitress, Arlene, had told us she had been there for several years and you could really tell this by her ability to help us through the menu. She wanted to make sure we were completely satisfied. The menu was one like I had never seen before. Everything from a large breakfast selection to Wagyu and Prime steaks. I had the best Ruben sandwich I had ever eaten ( that is saying a lot). We also shared the Wagyu filet with hand cut fries and sweet potato fries. The steak was sautéed with fresh mushrooms and onions. The steak was seasoned to absolute perfection. You have to try this. I have posted pictures of the menu. Don't forget a side order of homemade mac & cheese. Their prices are extremely reasonable considering the quality of the food and the impeccable service. The decor is perfect. Simple yet very pretty. They even have a nice area (living room style) that we hung out in until our table was ready. This Amish restaurant is the "best of the best". I will be back in this area next year and will be sure to make this my go to restaurant. Bravo to the staff and chef, well done.

Frankly, I didn't hate or love it. I just don't see a reason to make a trip there other than a…read morelack of competition. Food = Jalapeño popper dip was good. Pork chop was cooked alright, but definitely needed a sauce to add some flavor as it was bland. Coconut mango rice was sad (my wife is filipino so she knows a bit about rice, mangoes, and coconut). I had the reuben and it was alright. I don't understand why all the steaks and fish are "market price" on the menu. This is not a fancier restaurant that serves wagyu, why can you not figure out how to price half of your meats? Service = Good with no problems. Restaurant = Stylish, Spacious, and Clean.

The food was amazing; service superb and we got to meet and talk with the owners. It's a small…read morelocally owned place with that welcoming feeling

We had a great lunch at the Mill Street Diner on New Year's Eve. Not much was open in Amish Country…read morethat day so we felt lucky that they were open. They were steadily busy, but the staff was friendly and upbeat. It is in an old building that made you feel you had stepped back in time. Comfortable booths and high ceilings. Very homey feel. The food was hot and flavorful and not very expensive. We'll be back when we are in Sugarcreek again!

The food tasted good; however, we arrived at 7pm on a Friday evening and weren't served our 2 meals…read moreuntil 7:50 pm (and the restaurant wasn't particularly busy). Apparently the server and the cooks didn't communicate well and she explained that she had to place the order twice. My Reuben sandwich on rye was piled high with corned beef, a slice of Swiss cheese and sauerkraut and came out hot. On the other hand, the French fries also came out hot but were soggy in the middle. The other meal, a hamburger served with sweet bourbon sauce, also was tasty although my table mate ordered sauce on the side and instead the sauce had been spread on the bun. Our service began with oil-dipping sauce and 4 diagonally-sliced pieces of plain white bread. It lacked creativity yet snacking on it helped to pass the time while we waited for our meals to arrive.

This was a nice little place. The host and servers were very attentive. The food was good and…read morereasonable pricing. We had ribs and fish and chips. The ribs tender and the sauce was very tasty. Unfortunately I forgot to take pics before I started chowing down

Had no idea what to expect as I walked into this little cafe. There were several signs and even…read morevehicles advertising their cupcakes. It was cute inside with some fun decor that you had to walk around and enjoy. We were here as a group having a catered lunch so again no idea what to expect. Their coffee specials looked good. We had four wrap options and two salad options to choose from. They also put out a tray of four different desserts. I chose the ham and Swiss wrap and the Italian. Both of them were surprisingly tasty. I never order wraps so I was happy to enjoy them. I had the pear salad with a balsamic dressing that was good. The desserts on the other hand were ok at best. For a place with so much hype around cupcakes I was surprised they weren't on the tray. Instead we had a choice between lemon bars, a strawberry shortcake, s'mores bar or buckeye bar. I tried both the strawberry shortcake which seemed to be a bit too dry and didn't have enough strawberry flavor and the lemon bar which my friend enjoyed but I thought was ok. Just didn't have enough lemon flavor or the lemon gooeyness that I'm used to. The staff was friendly and attentive.

MELT Sandwich on multi grain bread was delicious. Turkey Reuben was very good. Homemade chicken…read morenoodle soup was disappointing. 1-it wasn't hot - only warm 2-"noodle" isn't the word for what we were served. Huge undercooked goo ball would be WSY MORE accurate. AT THE VERY LEAST it should be called Chicken DUMPLING Soup. We would return for the sandwiches & skip the soup next time.

No one waited on us and couldn't even take a drink order and after 20 minutes of waiting we had to…read morego! They did try to make it right by offering me free coffee and said, we can't take your order yet as there are 3 before you. So we would have had to stay there 30 minutes before an order could be taken !! I was shocked !!There wasn't even a waiting line..so I believe they are just short staffed Or short on cooks! Normally it's a good place with good food, but they've just gotten too busy. So if you're in a hurry or don't have two Hours to Have breakfast......check out Bob Evan's street. They are always good

Back for breakfast again. Great little place eggs, HB and hash (needs to fresh not canned) loved…read morethe Biscuits and Gravy.

Came in on a Tuesday afternoon for lunch. Sign says wait to be seated, after which they tell you…read moreto sit wherever you want. Ordered off the special board, a buffalo chicken wrap. Had an option for soup (chicken noodle) or fries. Server said their fries were really good so I went that route. Food came out incredibly fast. The wrap was stuffed and really, really good. Not overly hot, but clearly Franks red sauce. I was very happy with it. The fries, however, were battered. Not a fan, though they were hot as Hades, which almost pushed this to a 5 star review, but at the end of the day, they were still battered. Fresh cut would have been sooo much better. Needless to say, the place appears to be more of a breakfast joint than lunch (they are open 7a-2p). Will make it a point to try breakfast next time I go across the street for a haircut.

Comfort food! This…read moreplace is only open for breakfast and lunch so it took me awhile to try. We went on a Friday afternoon and had to wait a few minutes for seating. The menu had lots of options plus they had a specials board. We decided to order a breakfast pizza and French dip. Bother were good and filling. Sandwiches also come with your choice of fries or soup. They had a kids menu with great prices as well.

Their honest hard workers makes honest hard living they have some great donuts their staff friendly…read moregreat for community's

Great service and food. Best donuts in town, hands down!! One of the last places to get a good deal…read moreon good food. Highly recommend

Food is delicious and service is great. Love the outdoor seating and ambiance! Staff very attentive…read moreand the establishment very clean

Delighted to find this place while on a business trip. I wanted a great cup of coffee and some…read morebreakfast to fuel my day. This was the place. Ordered a cappuccino and avocado toast. Quick service as well and the locals seem to love this place. They had something on the menu for everyone.

This was a pleasant experience and we will be back. This entire county is a dream for middle-aged…read morewomen, but this is a place to get a reasonable meal as a guy not trying to lose their mind looking at quilts, etc. Food = Fish sandwich and noodle soup were both good at a fair price. They run out of pies throughout the day because they're not serving old pie here, but they're good and lots to choose from. Service = Very friendly. Sometimes a guy has questions, like "Why is there a log of cheese with my soup?" (even though it's awesome). But they answer in a friendly way. Restaurant = This place is busy, you will likely wait. Lots of seats, because apparently I'm not the only one that plans on going back after visiting. Clean and quick.

Lovely spot for lunch in Amish country! Be prepared to wait if you go on a weekend...luckily there…read moreare a couple of shops nearby though where you can browse while you wait to be texted that your table is ready. They close at 3pm, took our names at 2pm, and said it would be a 45 minute wait (which it was) but we didn't feel rushed once we were seated even though it was close to closing time. Our server was extremely friendly and great! Foodwise, we ordered the veggie quiche with a side of the house tomato basil soup and the bistro burger (bacon added) with a side of their soup of the day, cheesy potato. They have a variety of specialty coffee drinks but I chose to order the lightly sweetened peach tea for something different. My husband really enjoyed his burger and said it was well seasoned. He enjoyed the potato soup also and only wished they had fries to enjoy with the burger. My tomato basil soup was tasty! The quiche needed seasoning...I had to add salt and pepper and hot sauce and it could have done without all the extra cheese sprinkled on top. It came with a slice of blueberry bread though which was nice! The peach tea was refreshing as a change but I'd go with coffee next time. All in all we'd eat there again for sure and would try one of their delectable-looking pastries next time too. Thank you for a nice lunch, Rebecca's Bistro!