We got cookies here a couple of years ago and remembered liking them, but this batch seemed smaller than before and they were very dry. Maybe they will be better with some ice cream? It also looked like my vegan chocolate chip had an m&m in it, so I was a little worried about cross contamination with a non-vegan batter but at least I guess it wasn't an allergen? I don't think we'll be back. read more

Simply amazing... the cookies are to die for and their cookie cakes are perfect for any event! The staff is super friendly and welcoming. Could not recommend Taylor Chip more! read more

Best. Cookies. Ever. Nothing more to say, but since Yelp won't let me post without typing more, I'll say it again. Best. cookies. Ever. Try the pumpkin, you wont regret it. read more

I am reading the rave review and wondering if I got cookies from the same place. I picked up 4 cookies; 2 snickerdoodles, 1 choc chip, and one oatmeal raisin. First, as we looked at the case, the cookies were inconsistent in their diameter and thickness. But hey, it's all about the flavor and bake right? Well, the snickerdoodles were almost raw inside, and the chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin had this off-putting and strange consistency, and almost no flavor. For $4.50 a cookie, I would have expected perfect baking, perfect flavors and perfect consistency. Disappointing and will not return. read more

Best cookies I've ever had. Easy ordering online and delivery within a week. I recommend following their instructions and warming the cookie in the oven before eating - delicious. Great option for gift giving. read more

As a big cookie guy, I've ordered lots of cookies from stores across the country that advertise online and can ship to you, and after I tried Taylor Chip I stopped ordering from anywhere else. Bar none, these are the best cookies I've had. They are on the pricier side for this market but the cookies themselves are very large. Half dozen will last you a week. It looks like they have a few locations now and I won't be surprised if they continue to expand as a business but please don't lose the quality in your cookies! It happens so often when I see businesses add many locations across a region or the entire country. Keep crushing it! read more

Having tried 6 varieties of their cookies, I have to say I am disappointed in each flavor, or lack thereof. The cookies are underbaked, overpriced and somehow ALL tasteless. The flavors are indiscernible and oddly meld into a bland, basic, floured sweetness with no depth or spice. Hard to explain, even harder to eat. read more

This was our first time here, it didn't disappoint. The display of cookies is beautiful, very clean. There was a line but staff kept you moving. We ordered a half dozen- now it is $4 a cookie- if you get a half dozen you get 10% off- full dozen 20% off. Not must but since it was our first time we opted for the half. Cookies were very soft and all had great flavor. Overall flavor of the cookies was great as well. read more

These are the best cookies made outside my own home. These cookies are under baked, just as I like them! Highly recommended!!

I received my cookies today and I am very satisfied. The delivery was fast and arrived within a fee days. I tried the stormy pebbles just because I was curious. Heated the cookies in the oven and enjoyed the delicious gooey cookie with a hint of strawberry flavor. The texture was amazing. Looking forward to trying the white chocolate macadamia tomorrow. My only con is, a couple of the cookies were broken even with all of the bubble wrap. I would contribute that to the transport handling. Otherwise, I am delightfully satisfied. read more

We live in Michigan and placed an order for a dozen of the cookies. OMG! They are wonderful! They got here here so fast too! The family loves them. Thank you guys so much!!! read more

I'm in California and ordered a dozen cookies through their website. Nibbling on my first order now. Easily placed order online. I like how I can select my own assortment of cookies for my order. It lets me try all of the various flavors that interest me. My order was well-packed for shipment (no broken cookies), and it was delivered when promised. It included information about the shelf life for when cookies are stored at room temperature, refrigerated, and frozen. Each cookie is individually wrapped & sealed. They're delicious! I'm warming mine for 30 seconds in the microwave. They come out with the perfect texture, as if they just finished baking in the oven: warm, outside cooked through, but cookie is soft and gooey. Yummy! I'll definitely order again. These will also make the perfect edible gifts. Highly recommend. read more

I ordered the s'mores, chocolate chip walnut, peanut butter and jelly and white chocolate macadamia. Everything was good and I was very pleased. The only thing about the delivery is that they should have put an ice pack inside the package because the cookies were very melted by the time I got them. The taste was delicious and I would totally order from them again. Just next time make sure there's a nice pack in it. read more

PS These people at Taylor Chip Cookie called me a crud. A CRUD??? LOL I am not surprised by all their many 1 star negative reviews. They were horrible to deal with. read more

Ordered them online when I saw a Facebook ad and I couldn't resist. They were so delicious, they came fast too. So soft and tasty. 10/10 would recommend, great surprise gift or treat for yourself. read more

Taylor Chip Cookies - S'mores Cookie - Desserts Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Delicious cookies and delightful staff! They are super friendly and helpful for all your needs!

Took over a week to get them. All dried up. Stale..I write a letter and they file say a claim with Fed Ex... that's nonsense . Also said heat them up to soften ....Nonsense again.. should refund my money or resend fresh cookies...just saying read more

Honestly I am local to Lancaster and have tried these multiple times hoping my next experience is better. They taste almost raw yet dry all at the same time. Not worth the money in my opinion! read more

In the Past month or so I have ordered 3 times. Two of the deliveries were great, the third not so great. I was sent an email to give them 5 stars so I just let Taylor Chip know that a few of my cookies were melted and a few were pretty messed up crumbling and such. They contacted me. I was not going to say anything cause I don't have time to pursue a bad cookie delivery. But since Taylor Chip reached out I told them. They wanted pictures of the box the packing amd wanted to file a claim with fed ex. The box is on the bottom of my garbage can. Jenna responded since I am not willing to dig in my trash can there's nothing that can be done and had the nerve to send me their Policy. I was not asking for anything, just responding that the third delivery in a month was not the same as the other two. Not impressed with Jenna's response or customer service. 1 Star for this delivery! read more

The cookies are delicious and the customer service fantastic! I ordered a half dozen last week and was given two of the same cookie by accident. I let Taylor Chip know of the error and they remedied the situation right away :) Now I just ordered another dozen and will be closely monitoring my email for the shipping notification. Keep up the good work Taylor Chip! read more

We unfortunately didn't receive our cookies in time for Christmas. However, we've ordered these cookies before and know the quality and taste are worth the price tag. I appreciate Taylor Chip working with me on a resolution. While I am confident the cookies will still be good when they arrive, I'm a 1st time mom who is breastfeeding. With that, I'm just extra cautious about what I'm consuming right now. But, I'm sure my husband will be very excited to have half a dozen cookies to himself read more

Hello from Florida! I am in loveeeeeee with that chocolate chip cookie! I ordered a dozen and I could hardly wait. I'm so sorry I didn't take photos, they were gone wayyyy too soon. I froze all but one right away since I wasn't going to have them in one sitting. Half a cookie was a really nice serving size, to get my sweet tooth satisfied. Pro tip, if your cookie is frozen and you want it nice and hot, throw it in the air fryer for 4 mins =amazinggggg! I was surprised I didn't love the expresso chip as much as I predicted, especially since I had ordered two. I think the crunch was a little much for me& also unexpected. We'll definitely order again soon. Great customer service as well. I love response small businesses, you guys are doing great and is killing the cookie game read more

I ordered 6 cookies and few of them were very hard. I reached out to the business to explain the issue but they basically told me I was wrong and their cookies are delicious. Some of the cookies were in fact VERY GOOD! However not all 6 had the same quality as those few. When you spend $30 on 6 cookies you kind of expect them all to have the same high quality not just a few. I tried reaching out in fb messenger but they seemed to think it was impossible for them to be wrong so they blocked me from fb. Pretty unprofessional when a customer is trying to express a concern. If all 6 cookies were as good as the few I got I would give the 5 stars. Kind of sad how it was handled. UPDATE I also have the emails and the video I sent showing how hard a few cookies were. I NEVER said they all were hard in fact I say in the video how soft a few of them are. If you advertise for gooey soft cookies why would I have to warm them up to make them soft. Obviously you lack in customer service and have some ego that doesn't allow for you to except criticism. I posted my emails so you can clearly see I did not say all of them were hard. I'm also going to post a few screenshots of your replies to people who thought your cookies were undercooked, so if thats how you sell your cookies why were some of mine hard? Why would I have to warm it up? Should I post the video of how hard it was? In my video I said how soft and fresh a few of my cookies were, however a few were hard and crumbling. Twist it how you want but your lack of customer service and ego will catch up with you. read more

See all

Incredible service, I needed a birthday cookie made in a bit of a time crunch and and it was taken care of with no hesitation for me and I got exactly what I wanted. Great price for the cakes too. Other than that, you get what you pay for and the single serving cookies I've tried have also been delicious. read more

Taylor Chip Cookies - Small cookie cake - Desserts Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

These cookies are everything and more! They were delivered fast and soooo fresh! Soft and chewy ! The marshmallows in the s'mores cookie were so soft. My favorite was the salted pretzel caramel! Omg it was on another level! I would definitely order these cookies again and recommend them to everyone who loves cookies! read more

I ordered twice for my family. They are excellent cookies! My brother loved them! Thank you!

I visited a few months ago and was very disappointed with what I got. All cookies tasted like it was simply a sugar cookie with the toppings mixed in. On top of that they are very gooey, but in the way that is reminiscent of raw dough. Looked forward to trying them for weeks, and got less than stellar results. read more

Cookies are delicious!! Our favorite is the loaded PB and pumpkin spice. The others are good too, these just are extra amazing!

I wasn't sure about my first cookie, a classic chocolate chip. It looked amazing and thick, definitely larger than the palm of my hand. It was still slightly warm. The texture was different than any chocolate chip cookie I had ever tried. The top of the cookie has a crust, a crispy crackly layer to bite through. Inside the cookie was also different. Not fully baked. It was grainy and sweet like eating cookie dough from a mixing bowl. It was honestly a little too sweet for me and under baked. I ate half of it in the parking lot then put the rest back in the box with the other five that I bought. Because I was traveling for hours with the box, the cookies sat till the next day. I have to admit though that I enjoyed the rest of that cookie the serving day even more than the first day. The texture has dried a bit so it felt more baked on the palate. I wanted another immediately so Brooke a sugar cookie in half and it too was delicious. My favorite so far was the oatmeal raisin which was very thick and loaded with plump, moist raisins. I will definitely consider ordering more for delivery since Taylor Chip is over for hours from my home. read more

I fell for their social media campaign, but, I assume they delete anything negative from Facebook as there is no possible way that not one person there thinks the Taylor Chip Cookies are as disgusting as I do. I ordered the dozen pick-your-own, the only positive I can say is they shipped promptly and arrived on time. otherwise, they are way overpriced, they taste raw (not underbaked, raw!), and are either too sweet or have zero sugar in them. I had one chocolate chip cookie and it was so sickeningly sweet. I tried the loaded peanut butter and couldn't get beyond the first bite... the cookie is dry and bitter and the peanut butter is dry, bitter, and gritty. I now have 10 overpriced cookies in my fridge. read more

I'm not sure why people go crazy over their cookies. I think they are bland. I ordered a cookie cake back in June and it was dry. You could tell it wasn't made that same day. The vanilla frosting on it had a weird taste and they didn't even center the message on the cake. I decided to give them another try and buy some of their regular cookies for a friends birthday. Just like the cookie cake I don't think they have good flavor or much flavor at all. I don't get what the big craze over them are. I will definitely not be spending anymore money on these cookies. read more

I originally saw Taylor Chip at fit fest at Spooky Nook but couldn't get near their table! It was so crowded! My coworkers also wouldn't stop talking about how good the cookies were. I read the about info on their site and took my husband & daughter there today to see what they had to offer! The owner was awesome in explaining the business, cookies and dough! We sampled dough and it was by far the best I've had! We bought 6 cookies and dug into them as soon as we hit the car. Now we are not gluten free by any means but the gluten free chocolate cookie with pb in the middle was the best I've ever had! So moist! We will be back for some cookie dough soon! read more

Not sure how a cookie can be "bad" but these cookies were disappointing. With Levain Bakery being the gold standard for cookies, these were closer to store packaged quality. Do NOT recommend. read more

I was really excited for these cookies, but unfortunately every time I would finish eating a cookie I would feel immediately sick afterwards. The cookies did taste undercooked and more like cookie dough. What got me hooked on wanting to purchase them was seeing the smores cookie, sadly the ones I got (smores, snickerdoodle, salted caramel preztel) were grossly over sweet. So if you are the type that do not like overly sweet sweets, tread lightly. The concept of shipping cookies is cool, however with how overly sweet/heavy you feel after eating one I don't think it is worth the price. Will most likely toss the rest of mine out, as its hard to say if I am feeling sick from the overly sweetness, or the cookies itself. Otherwise I would have shared the rest of my friends kids. read more

I ordered these cookies and wanted to love them, but after trying two on separate occasions, I got sick from the cookie not being cooked enough. Don't recommend. read more

The worst cookies ever! The second time we've been gifted these, and they are terrible. Nothing is labeled, they are only half cooked, and because they were delivered they look like mush. Don't waste your money! I hate to do it, but I will inform the buyer/sender this time! read more

I ordered on a Wednesday. They shipped on Monday and got here 2 days later. So impressed They are pricey but definitely worth it if you love a chewy cookie. They're sweet and delicious hopefully they end up nation wide! read more

Taylor Chip Cookies - half dozen assorted cookies from Taylor Chip Cookie Co - Desserts Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Taylor Chip cookies are legit as good as the videos they have on their social media show. They're really soft and gooey in the middle, like they were just freshly baked. These cookies have amazing flavor. Get the s'mores! They are hands down, my fav. read more

Just recieved my delivery of cookies! Although I live close to Lancaster, I figured I'd get some shipped to me so I could try them. Absolutely amazing!! I will definitely be making the trip to the shop for my next purchase! read more

The mac nut and oatmeal raisin cookies are the best we have ever had. The cookies are so big my sister and I split one. Will definitely order again. Thank you! read more