We had the Fajita Chicken and Beef Combo for two. It was fantastic! Honestly, I think it was…read moreenough for 3-4. We each also had a margaritas. One of the best we have ever had and NOT short on the liquor. The place is very clean and the servers were friendly and top notch. It was 25 minutes from across the Ohio River where we were staying in Madison. But, it was a beautiful drive and WELL worth it!

I highly recommend the bacon wrapped shrimp. Unbelievable…read more The place is extremely nice inside. Like you don't expect this quality of interior finish. It's very pretty. The staff is very attentive and extremely friendly. Service was amazingly quick. Every restaurant has refried beans, I don't know what they do different but it's unprecedented.

Mi Viejo is one of those places where you walk in thinking, "Let's just hope they have queso," and…read morewalk out thinking, "Well that was actually... pretty decent!" Food: The steak fajitas and Chimichanga Mexicana were both perfectly fine -- not life-changing, not flavorless. Just solid, no-frills Mexican food that does the job. The meat was seasoned well, which honestly makes up for a lot. Salsa: Now the salsa... I don't know what that was, but it tasted like it came from a can that lost a bet. Thin, flavorless, and a little sad -- like it wanted to be pico de gallo but ran out of ambition. Guacamole: I'm 90% sure it was squeezed from a tube and shaped like a sad little worm on the plate. It didn't taste bad exactly, but it definitely didn't taste like avocado either. It looked like it needed a hug and a better life. Beer: Major shoutout to the beer -- served in ice-cold mugs and at the perfect temperature. You'd be surprised how many places mess that up. Mi Viejo nailed it. I may not remember the salsa, but I'll remember that frosty mug like an old friend. Service: Fast, friendly, and no nonsense. Exactly what you want when you're just trying to eat your weight in chips. Ambiance: Cool vibe -- kind of a bourbon bar/sports bar hybrid. Lots of TVs with football on, dim lighting, and music at that perfect "I can still hear myself think" volume. Also, one cracked window, which was slightly concerning but added a little mystery to the place. (Like, what did happen there? A salsa revolt?) Value: Great bang for your buck. You won't need a loan to eat here, which is rare and beautiful these days. Final Thoughts: Is it the best Mexican food I've ever had? No. Is it the best Mexican food within a 30-mile radius of a Dollar General? Probably. Worth a stop if you're in town -- just skip the salsa, lower your guac expectations, and definitely get a beer.

We always have excellent food and exceptional service! I've never had a meal here less than stellar.read more

Recently moved to Madison and started visiting local restaurants. Diego's is the BEST Mexican food…read morein the area, we both Love it! Always fast, always delicious and great service too!

Attended a funeral in Madison and decided to get something to eat before driving back home to…read moreJeffersonville. We elected to try Diego's after checking the Yelp reviews . . . we should have driven on home. We were seated promptly - and our server was very nice, but he was handling the front of the house on his own - which meant service after being seated was poor at best. Once our food arrived - our server disappeared - never checked that everything was okay - never offered refill on drinks - nothing. I ordered a burrito with chicken and it literally had three small pieces of chicken, a boat load of onions and peppers - plus enough of the liquid it was cooked in to fill the plate! Needless to say, the flour tortilla was gummy from the liquid and inedible. The others in our group said their food was "just okay". Once someone came out from the back we got our check and left. My best advice - if you see Diego's - keep driving.

Delicious traditional Mexican tacos. Well priced and well sized, you will do well coming here to…read moreeat. Very nice staff as well. A true hidden gem !

Best authentic Mexican food within a 100 mile radius. The food is what shines here. If you know,…read moreyou know. I'll be stopping back often to get my lunch & horchata!

I read through the reviews and almost all of the negative reviews dealt with service. I've been…read morehere a handful of time and never had bad service. Last time they did get my drink order wrong, but other than that I have no complaints about the service. Food is your typical 'authentic' Mexican restaurant... so its good. But to date I haven't had anything unique or overly outstanding to warrant 5 stars. A bonus is you get salsa and dip as opposed to most places where you only get salsa. I can't tell you want the dip was, other than maybe a thin bean type dip... really good either way!

Quick friendly service and food was hot and delicious.There was an extensive menu and authentic…read morecuisine.

I hate doing this for places that I've never had a problem with before but today was completely…read moredifferent, The service was terrible. The fact that me and my fiancé asked for just queso on our food and end up with the red sauce a the queso. Our dinner was completely ruined, like I said we've never had a problem with the place before till tonight, so I'm never going back. And when asked for a replacement we were told we had to pay the messed up food and the replacement food.

Loved the vibe and decor. We chose this spot over others in town as we were visiting because of the…read morecheery exterior. The inside had even more flair. The staff were friendly but did seem a little out of sorts. It seemed like they were maybe cleaning up from hosting a large party or event so maybe we just didn't visit on a regular day.The food was good, I would maybe just order something other than the taco salad next time. I ordered chicken and got steak but just decided to roll with it. However, the veggies were fresh and the steak was flavorful.

Stopped here for lunch, the food and service were great! They bring out two salsa's, one is…read moreslightly more spicy, both have good taste! Ordered the queso, it's good, but on the more viscous side in case you don't like runny queso. I had the Arroz Con Pollo. It had really great flavor, the grilled chicken was phenomenal, and the lunch order was a generous portion. Definitely keeping this place on my radar for any time I'm passing through the area!

Well-seasoned food, fresh ingredients, highly recommend the chicken ranchero, huge proportions…read more Hubby and I could have shared an entree and still left full!

Some of the best, authentic Mexican I've had in the greater louisville/southern Indiana area. The…read morespace is clean, the service is fast and friendly, and the prices were great too! Give them a try!

The soft drinks were watered down All in our party got the…read morechicken. The waiter lied and said the grilled chicken would be fresh cooked. They used chicken that was piled high under a heat lamp. The chicken was heated on the grilled after being dried out from being under the heat lamp all day. Chicken was so tough , you could not even chew it. The baked potatoes had been there all day. Inside the potato was all brown from being there so long. This was a horrible experience and a total waste of money. Do not recommend this place.