We went there on Sunday night. The place was empty and the hostess was at the podium on the phone for a few minutes. When she got off of the phone she said she'd be right back amd disappeared. We waited for another five minutes, got annoyed and left. Hoping this was an off night not sure we'll try again. I used to love this place. read more

Had my Birthday Happy Hour here on Friday and everything from The service to the food was amazing ! We LOVE all of the staff ! Highly recommend! read more

This is not our first visit to Argyle. We stopped in on a Monday night and were promptly seated. We ordered the Monday $10 burger and a quesadilla. Our food was very tasty and came with a wonderful presentation. The food tasted very good and was of proper temperature Etc. The desert selection is very nice also. We chose the red velvet cake which was delicious. So all in all the food is a five star worthy visit. Where it all falls to SxxT is Margo the waitress. I might have to call the board of labor and have them investigate whether she is suffering forced labor. She was the most cold, impersonal waitress possible. No introduction, no interaction, just the facts. Maybe her entire family abandoned her recently and she is devastated but she is not my candidate for waitress of the year. In 2023 I guess some people do not value a personal touch and some friendly interaction. Hey, maybe even a smile? For this she was tipped appropriately. If we go back hopefully Margo will have found a career more fitting her personality, or lack thereof. read more

Went there last with my fiancé and it was unbelievable! We started off with bacon wrapped scallops, delicious. Then we proceeded to have the Burrata salad, the surf and turf pasta & spicy tuna rice cakes. The service was great. And the ambiance was very romantic in the back. Everything was 5 stars! Highly recommend read more

So, after a bit of a letdown at The Brixton, (rude hostess) we stumbled upon The Argyle for a quick bite before seeing a show. And let me tell you, we were pleasantly surprised! The vibe was lively with a nautical theme that drew in a good crowd but not so crowded we felt crammed in. Our waiter was great, understanding our time constraint and getting our orders in quick. We went with mostly appetizers and they were all delicious! We had the Brie Stuffed Pretzel, Crispy Calamari, Black Angus Sliders, and nachos. And the cocktails were spot on! So much so that we had to order another before paying the check. Overall, we had a really enjoyable experience at The Argyle and would definitely go back next time we're in Babylon. read more

The argyle has been a staple in Babylon for decades but it needed a serious menu change the past few years. Thankfully the new ownership has done just that. I've frequented the new Argyle several times in the past five months and it's always a crowd pleaser. During drinks with work friends, we had several happy hour apps including beef Wellington bites, delicious! Calamari cooked to perfection and the crab cakes never disappoint. For dinner, I've had The lobster bisque, though a belly bomber, it's amazing and worth being stuffed. We tried the Chilean sea bass which I usually do not prefer but they cooked it perfect with lobster risotto that had BIG chunks of lobster! We went back 2 nights later for it. That good! The rib eye with added compound butter was another fave dish. I met a client for lunch there last Friday and had the steak sandwich which was fire!!! Def be back for that. And being the brunch lover I am, I had to go back and try their crabcake eggs Benny which has no bread thankfully (save this calories where you can!) and the Steak and eggs which both I would go back for again! Lastly what to make mention of the bartenders that are always there with a smile on their face. We usually sit at the bar and eat, so it's nice they always make you feel welcome and make extremely tasty cocktails. It's really great the new owners reinvented the place so we have another great local restaurant to frequent. Thank you Argyle! read more

We have been here a few times since they reopened for dinner or drinks. My wife usually gets the cauliflower steak or burrata salad while I get the filet, skirt steak or burger. Thus far, we have not been disappointed. When not sitting at a table, we enjoy sitting at the bar interacting with the bartenders. The drinks are fabulous. From the Babylon Express to a bourbon mule, you can't go wrong. read more

Came here to The Argyle Grill for dinner with some friends . As you enter the restaurant there is a nice size bar to the left , where there were many patrons enjoying themselves .To the right are some smaller tables and towards the rear are larger tables set apart with a large mural on the wall . We arrived around 6 PM and were immediately seated , no wait ! The dining area was clean and neat . Service was great , we took our time ordering , the server didn't rush us , he was polite and friendly . Everything we ordered was delicious. We began with ordering some bottled water and a glass of wine and than shared the Kung Pao Shrimp and Calamari appetizer. Although the pieces of the calamari were a bit chewy , hence the 4 stars, it was still tasty, just spicy enough coated in Hoisin sauce with soba noodles and snow peas . Delicious ! My main entree was Chicken Cardinal with red mash potatoes and sautéed spinach . Quite a hearty portion, enough for two ! The chicken was tender, layered with prosciutto , pepper jack cheese and red roasted peppers . The combination of the flavors worked well together ! The mashed potatoes were a basic mash well prepared and nicely seasoned with a simple sautéed spinach . My friends both enjoyed their entrees as well . One ordering the Mediterranean Salad the other the Grilled Greek Chicken. All in all a very nice enjoyable and comfortable evening out. read more

See all

I've been to The Argyle twice for dinner since re opening with new ownership. The food and drinks were amazing each time. Some of our groups favorites were the beef wellington bites, the lobster pasta, the spicy stuffed rigatoni, the thai calamari, and the burrata salad. The watermelon martini and dirty martini were both great as well. Will be returning. read more

Well this was certainly better than a few years ago. They have a nice brunch menu on Sunday's but it is expensive. The blood orange mimosas were flavorless. The avocado toast was really good except, the multigrain bread was like killer daves thin sliced and it was over toasted. I probably would not have served it that way at home let alone in a restaurant. But the spicy goat cheese spread made up for it. Don't cut corners Argyle. People don't mind spending money for fresh delicious food. Perhaps find a nice bakery for your multigrain bread. Overall we had a nice meal and i would go back for another try. read more

Tried the new brunch since my last visit was a great dinner. The food was excellent again and it wasn't hectic like most brunch spots can be. Service was quick and pleasant. I would recommend one of the poached egg dishes and the Bloody Mary was just right. It's a nice relaxing dining experience at a reasonable price. I'll be back again to try other dishes for sure. read more

We went to the argyle for dinner on a Saturday night it was amazing ! We walked in and first impression was great hostess was so sweet and accommodating we didn't have a reservation and we got sat quickly just enough to grab a drink at the bar . The bartender Jay was awesome ! Our server Holly was so sweet and recommended all the best . Hands down to the chef food was spot on . short rib was amazing and the ribeye cooked to perfection . We will be back ! Thanks for a great date night . read more

If you are looking for steak house ambiance without the prices of Insignia & other restaurants, the Argyle is exactly what you're looking for. Lily Flanagans Restaurant Group did a great job re vamping the place. The menu and its pairings are excellent. From the staff, to the head chef, to management, the team at the Argyle will truly provide you with a great experience. Perfect spot for a date night. read more

Came twice since new ownership & wow! Once for a date night, we had Holly as a server. Service was phenomenal and the food was top notch. Highly recommend the Wellington bites, the tuna rice cakes & you need to finish with dessert and espresso martini! Really can't recommend enough. read more

Tried the Argyle for brunch yesterday, I ordered the chicken and waffles and it was amazing. Our waitress Jennifer was great and very attentive. It was our first time there and we were very impressed with the service and food. Will definitely be back! read more

been here a few times since it changed owners. Food is very good and all the new people are friendly. will good back for sure

The service was awesome and the drinks were strong. Highly recommend the stuffed clams

-super delicious food -yummy desserts -Good/ big size portions -friendly staff Only down side it was super hot (& it wasn't even that hot outside!) Definitely want to come back & get different meals!! read more

See all

Had lunch yesterday. The waiter started by complaining about a big party coming in to us. He did not bring water to the table and did not ask if we wanted water. We ordered soup, the soup was warm, not hot. This seems to be a reoccurring problem. We ordered drinks. The busser brought the soup. The busser then brought out the entrees and looked at us because he had not cleared away the first course from our table. I did not expect to have to bus my own table. The waiter did not come back. We had the fish and grilled chicken quesadilla. It was just ok. I finally had to ask another waiter for our check. When our waiter finally did come back he asked if we wanted another drink. We said no as our meal was finished. So the food is mediocre and so is the service. read more

Great spot! Amazing service and super friendly. Great appetizers as well. Came with local friends and will be back next time I'm in the area! read more

One and Done! St. Patrick's Day 2022, 1:30pm, not busy at all, drinks took a very long time, we ordered shrimp tacos and asked multiple times if they are Gluten Free and safe to eat!? Waiter revised the menu with the cook supposedly and gave us options- stated "Shrimp Tacos are safe". They came out and my girlfriend who has celiacs disease took one bite and said they're too good to be GF. I looked and knew immediately they were flour taco shells.... Waiter apologized for mix up, said GLUTEN FREE was even on the ticket- so either ignorance or laziness played a huge role here. They didn't even take it off of our bill! Hahahah SMH Not impressed with the food or drinks. Decor was nice though...!? read more

The food is delicious - have had several different meals - each was great! I love their soup -clam chowder.

Meh, the dinner was forgettable, Penne aka Vodka and my wife's Shrimp and Grits did not have much if any flavor. Hers was supposed to be blackened but was not, and mine had very little sauce and I was unable to discern the vodka sauce from regular tomato sauce. The drinks were good and strong and the waiter was attentive and did a good job overall. Noise level was way above average. read more

Went to the Argyle Sat night (1/22). We went for dinner, the food was excellent, the service very good. We sat in the bar room vs the back room (that was what was available). The downside: Reservations would be nice, or an accessible wait list via the web. Get with the program... The noise level due to the ungodly decibels being pumped in from their music was mind numbing. Let's disregard that the music was crap (but you may like it). It add NOTHING, but noise. The bar is loud enough, now you have people SHOUTING at each other to be heard. That increases the noise. Walked to the back room on my wait to the rest rooms. The same lousy music, same volume. Again no value add, but at least quieter (no bar crowd). Guys... wise up. Music is to add not dimmish a patrons visit. read more

I haven't been in here in since the pandemic started. I had the watermelon martini $17. Made by Valerie Which was outstanding. I Had the ahi tuna,$17 which were 4 slices the size of Domino's in a Ginger sauce ok. Small portion for the price .what happened? I order the calamari. Extra crispy and overdone pieces. Nothing like a Calamari chew. They have a new chef which I picked up right away. Get with the program. Our waiter was very nice. read more

Chose the Argyle grill after other restaurants had a longer wait. It was definitely not a bad choice. We were seated after a short wait. They provided complimentary bread, which was good paired with the olive oil on the table. I chose the steak salad for a change and it was really good. Everyone enjoyed their meals and had no complaints. Parking is tough on Main Street but there is parking in the back of the restaurant read more

The Argyle - Steak salad - New American Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

Came here with my boyfriend. It was the only place on the Babylon village strip they didn't require a 30-40 minute wait. Service was quick and the interior is nice. Kind of loud in the restaurant portion but it's a tavern so that makes sense. Our short ribs tacos were beyond dry, no flavor and I didn't even finish the one I was eating. The chicken wings were okay, very very meaty which isn't really my type of wing. Their Brie stuffed pretzels was hands down the best part of this dinner. So good and the jam they served it with? Amazing. Unfortunately, I won't be back. Very expensive bland food. read more

They don't answer their phone. Called on a Thursday at 6:30 to place a take out order. So frustrating.

Argyle is a classic/well known pub in the Babylon area. I've been there a few times and you can get a good meal, but the atmosphere can be a bit too rowdy at the bar depending on how late you come for dinner. The place is big and pretty inside. We came for the steak special on a Wednesday night before thanksgiving. The food was good. Steak cooked as asked and came with an app and dessert for a great price. The salmon had a mustard sauce which felt a little overpowering but was still a good meal and cooked well. I probably wouldn't get it again. The drinks are delicious here - a bit pricey for the cocktails, but worth it. They make a mean chocolate martini. The biggest con was the wait for water and how loud the music was during dinner hours. You could barely have a conversation, which made it frustrating to talk to each other at the table. I could understand after 8-9PM, but we were there at 6:30, so they need to consider improving that. Overall food was good but not over the moon. Our waiter was also amazing, just a bit busy. I'd come back, but sit at a table farther away from the speakers. I'd also recommend coming to the bar just for drinks. read more

See all

I mean, eh. I really would have given this place a 1, but the service was very good so I'll be nice and give it a 2. First off, albeit the service was good, the food seemed to take a million years to come out. And I was hungry enough to gnaw my arm off. Where's the complimentary carbs? Where's my bread?!? Blah. And then FINALLY my sandwich came. See photos for reference. The chicken sandwich was just O.K. The pesto sauce, blech. Not good at all. Super watery, no flavor. Disappointing. The best part of the meal was that I was smart enough to get a glass of wine - and that was good. My friend Rachel picked it out and I can't remember what the name of it was - only that a half bottle cost $21, which left us with a little more than a glass per person. $21 is a lot for a half bottle - but when the glasses are $10 each, you might as well. The bill, with tax and tip, was $60.00 Which to me seems a little insane to spend for lunch. And a sup-par lunch at that. I mean, for dropping that kind of cash I think that there should be bread or something on the table to nosh on. And the sandwich should have been delicious. I've had better at a deli. Oh well. I highly doubt that I would go back, unless it was for drinks. The bar area seemed cool, and Babylon is a cool town - however with all the competition in the area there are better places to go. read more

The Argyle - Chicken sandwich with pesto, tomato and mozzarella. - New American Near Me - Babylon, New York

Very impressed with the food and service here. Extremely friendly and helpful staff and the food was very good. They had a prix fix menu - $35 for a salad, main course, and a dessert and all of it was delicious. Would definitely go back!! read more

The skirt steak was hands down the BEST skirt steak I have EVER had. The picture doesn't even do it justice. It's so huge that they had to stack the steak underneath it! Bonus points: they serve steak fries!!!!! I feel like it's so hard to find a restaurant with steak fries for whatever reason. They were delicious! The manager came over and asked us if our food was good, which was appreciated. We will absolutely be back. read more

The Argyle - New American Near Me - Babylon, New York

Beautiful place- clean and spacious. Menu looks great. However, we were seated and then completely ignored. Tables around us were served and serviced, yet it was as if we weren't even there. No apologies, no acknowledgment, nothing. After 20 minutes we gave up and left. read more

Great food - love their salads and mashed potatoes. Nice ambiance and very attentive service.

Standard bar with a great martini selection. I had the watermelon martini which was strong yet not overpriced. Pretty crowded on a Saturday night but was still able to snag a seat at the bar. Cool spot if you're in the area. read more

The Argyle - New American Near Me - Babylon, New York

I was impressed with the food. Seemed like a nice establishment. Service was ok, wish they took more unnecessary glasses, dirty plates, bread plate away from the small 2 top table we had. Food came out promptly on a Thursday night, with a half filled bar / restaurant. Plenty of people walking around town to make for an acceptable night out. Plenty of municipal parking in rear, do not park in green stalls (employee parking, & lot is patrolled until 6pm). read more

See all

AlwAys excellent restaurant service. Experienced Waite staff always accommodating, knowledgeable attentive without hovering & friendly. Food not cheap but a Good value for your money. read more

Ok.... this is a go to for me!! Food is ALWAYS amazing, beautiful environment, great servers! I find myself ordering to take home a little too often haha! Great place. Definitely one of my local favorites read more

See all

I've been coming to this place for 20+ years and I used to love it. But evidently, new ownership took over. Last week, I came in with a few family members and I ordered their "Argyle's grilled marinated skirt steak." I was horrified what was served. The portion was, at best, 25% the size of the old steak. A couple years ago, it was at least 3 inches wide and 18 inches long. The steak served was 1.5 inches wide and 6 inches long. When I complained to the hostess, she said, "Okay, I'll take care of it." I never saw her again. Somebody in charge is stingy and trying to ger rich by being CHEAP! read more

Sadly Some of the food and drink selections were not available and my sons food came out burned everything else was just OK. Definitely disappointed compared to The previous times we have eaten here. read more