Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Butter Pecan Cafe

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    Closed 10:00 am - 4:00 pm

    Order The Butter Pecan Cafe Takeout or Delivery

    The Butter Pecan Cafe Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - The Butter Pecan Cafe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - The Butter Pecan Cafe

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 1,031 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Bakers of Buffington

    Bakers of Buffington

    3.7(95 reviews)
    6.5 mi
    $$

    Baker's of Buffinton made the cake for our daughter's wedding celebration. It was magnificent!…read more They absolutely brought our vision to life and it was delicious too. Thank you!!!!

    Gotta say, I've had wildly mixed experiences with BoB over the years. From snotty counter help to…read morecakes not designed as discussed. This last experience, well, it takes the cake. I was gifted a birthday cake and the first piece ticked a lot of positive boxes, but left something in my mouth. Literally. It was almost the consistency of shredded coconut and I dismissed it as such because I didn't order the cake so wasn't sure what the person who had ordered it had asked for. The second piece, same thing - only this time I noticed I couldn't really bite through whatever the mystery shavings were. I've been baking for over 40 years and as I considered what "whatever" it was could've been, it wasn't the right consistency for coconut. I managed to pull a bit of it off my tongue and the only thing I could liken it to in my years of baking was when I accidentally shredded part of a rubber spatula and it ended up in the cake. I was able to track it down to the frosting. Specifically the blue. I scraped all the blue frosting off and tried a small piece and no more mystery matter. I plopped all the blue frosting that was left, which was mostly a set of frosting balloons, in the sink drain. I first ran hot water over it and this was what was left.The attached image shows what is left - after having used the sink for FOUR DAYS. It still hasn't broken down. If it were butter and powdered sugar it would've been gone long ago. I don't know what that was/is, but I don't see myself eating another one of their cakes anytime soon.

    Photos
    Bakers of Buffington
    Bakers of Buffington
    Bakers of Buffington

    See all

    Lancaster Cupcake - Cupcake Split - Build Your Own Flavors - cranberry orange with vanilla ice cream and chocolate shavings

    Lancaster Cupcake

    4.8(9 reviews)
    38.5 mi

    Geeat cupcakes! The staff at the Lebanon location are always genuine and kind. We love going to…read morethis location! Awesome special flavors that symbolizes summer right now. The location has some homage to Lebanon and it is great for serving up a great party atmosphere! We got Caramel Millionaire, Peanut Butter Oreo and Vanilla Party for our daughter! All 3 were a hit and delicious! $42 dollars for a dozen cupcakes is what holds this back from a 5 star! Love their product, but wow that can add up they are a delicious cupcake though!

    Lancaster Cupcake in Lebanon is my dangerous little weekly habit, and honestly? Zero regrets. Their…read morecupcakes are hands-down the most flavorful, soft, decadent little masterpieces I've ever tasted. I have never had a bad flavor here. Not once. My year-round ride-or-die is the Strawberry Champagne... dreamy, sweet, a little bougie, and absolutely addictive. But the current seasonal obsession (pictured) is the Cranberry Orange and I am not kidding... it is obsession-level good. I'm already plotting to buy a dozen to freeze so Future Me can still thrive when the seasonal menu changes. The whole atmosphere? Gorgeous. Classy. Bright. Feels like you walked into the Pinterest board of a person who actually has their life together. And if you haven't tried a Cupcake Split, stop reading this and go fix your life. It's the perfect half-cupcake, half-soft-serve combo with fun toppings that make you feel like a kid again. This one is Cranberry Orange with vanilla soft serve and chocolate shavings, and I need it framed on my wall. Friendly staff, stunning space, ridiculous desserts... Yeah. You'll probably catch me in here at least once a week. Don't judge me -- judge the cupcakes for being irresistible.

    Photos
    Lancaster Cupcake - Is there anything cuter than a Cupcake Split - Build Your Own with gorgeous decor!?

    Is there anything cuter than a Cupcake Split - Build Your Own with gorgeous decor!?

    Lancaster Cupcake - Class area and seating

    Class area and seating

    Lancaster Cupcake

    See all

    Flavor Cupcakery

    Flavor Cupcakery

    3.9(184 reviews)
    42.7 mi
    $$

    Last year, I received a birthday delivery from Flavor, but the delivery arrived looking like it had…read morebeen dropped and the cupcakes were a bit of a mess. (Not sure who the delivery service was. Flavor replaced the order without *too much* of an issue.) In November, I stopped in to get something for a friend's birthday, and bought a 4-pack for them. Staff were super friendly & answered my questions easily. Feed back on the cupcakes was thumbs up all around. There were about a dozen flavor options (I think), & they all sounded good. Ended up selecting the Snickerdoodle, Cookies n Cream, & 2 of the chocolate-peanut butter because the recipient is a big fan of pb cups. I no longer work in that area but I will likely be back soon for another special occasion. I get noticed for their specials and they're so tempting. Yummmm!

    I highly do not recommend them. I ordered a cheesecake and called every single day to get some kind…read moreof status update on it and they do not answer their phones. When I went in frustrated to talk about this, an employee named Brooke smugly looked at me and rolled her eyes while I expressed frustration at not being able to get a hold of them. She shook her head and had a huge attitude with me as I explained that I just wanted an update on my cheesecake. The customer service was horrible if they can't even update regular customers on a simple cheesecake I can't imagine how nerve-racking it would be to hire these people to do a catered event like a wedding or a birthday. The front employee Brooke was smug, snide, and extremely disrespectful enough that I will never go back again after that being my very first experience there.

    Photos
    Flavor Cupcakery
    Flavor Cupcakery
    Flavor Cupcakery

    See all

    The Butter Pecan Cafe - bakeries - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...