A bar for cakes? Can't go wrong. So many options. But don't fret because you can get a cake flight and choose three different slices! Staff was nice. Location was convenient. Cakes were delicious. read more

The Cake Bar - Chocolate cheesecake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

See all

This is probably the worst cake ever. This was my 2nd try and I'm not going for strike 3. Both visits I had 4 different flavors. Absolutely no taste. Why does the icing pull off in complete chunks? Don't waste your time or money. I'm a junk food junkie and would never consider a grocery store cake but I definitely have had better cake from Weis. read more

I love that they sell the cakes by the slice, allowing you to get multiple flavors at one time. I also appreciated that all of the cakes were not overly sweet or over sugared. Eggnog Great eggnog flavor. The whipped cream like icing is light and fluffy. The cake itself was very dry. I even put it in the microwave for a few seconds to knock the chill and it was still dry. Peanut Butter Lovers This was the whole reason I stopped. Had I just had this cake alone it would've been a 5 star review. The chocolate cake was very moist, even after sitting in my fridge for 3 days (I ate the other slices first). Nice rich chocolate in the cake. The peanut butter mousse in the middle was airy and a great ratio of peanut butter. They had the same whipped cream frosting and topped it off with this peanut butter ganache type drizzle. This cake Fed My Soul!! Hands down the best cake on the menu and totally worth the drive. Pistachio Cranberry The white cake was still dry. Good amount of pistachios and cranberries in the slice. It was just okay. Non-Food Stuff Staff were friendly. I appreciated that they have contactless payment. Ample street parking (meters) a block away. read more

The Cake Bar - Custom Cakes Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

We heard about this place from one of the breweries we stopped at. Why not have a cake flight before dinner? They had a decent variety but I would say some of the cake was more fresh than others. A nice experience overall. read more

The Cake Bar - Cake flight Boston cream, Choclate PB, Choclate decadence . - Custom Cakes Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

See all

All of their Cakes are Beautiful and taste delicious.... Lots of Goodies and it's all worth it

Amanda, Thank you for making our 40th surprise birthday party a smashing hit. Your custom cake and cupcakes were a show-stopper. ***I ordered a Highland Cow 6" cake (peanut butter mousse with chocolate icing) and sixty plus highland cow cupcakes (yellow, chocolate and pumpkin flavors) to supplement. The butter cream frosting had the perfect combination of flavor, smooth texture with just the right amount of sweet. The cake and cupcakes were fresh and moist (even after I had them in the refrigerator for an extended amount of time). The Cake Bar captured the perfect amount of frosting to cake ratio. Each treat was and simply scrumptious. The cake and cupcakes were delicately decorated and exploding with "WOW". Your skill, creativity and artistic talent are remarkable. Each cupcake and the cake were a work of art of their own. From my initial inquiry, working through a concept and to final delivery, I was given a really personalized and professional service. I couldn't be more impressed with the finished cake and cupcakes. Everyone loved them. The Cake bar is by far, comparable to none. I will sing the praises of The Cake Bar to anyone with a five star +++ rating an recommend no others. Thank you for your incredible work. Regards, Renee Tucker PA Micro Midgets AND Associate Broker, RE/MAX Town Center, The Bay Area Group read more

See all

Beautiful cakes! Easy to work with and best of all taste delicious. I can't find all the pictures of cakes and cookies they have made for us. read more

See all

Had hot chocolate after the Christmas Parade yesterday morning. It was soo good! Of course, I grabbed a slice of pumpkin cheesecake for later in the day! read more

We had the Cake Bar make our wedding cake and some extra desserts for our wedding, and we were very pleased with the results. First, the cake was delicious - we got three tiers, each with its own flavor, and each was excellent. The lemon cake is a particular standout! We also got various assorted desserts to accompany the cake, such as cookies, cupcakes, and macarons. These were also great, and our guests snapped them up, the macarons especially! Finally, we asked them to make special favors for us - cookies decorated to look like our cats. We were very pleased with the result, and they turned out just about as cute as the real thing! Amanda met with us several times to help us work out the details and was very helpful. Overall we were very pleased with both the service and desserts we received, and we'll absolutely be stopping in next time we're in the area to grab a slice or two. read more

See all

We stopped here for dessert after dinner. Destination dessert in Hanover is now one of my new favorite things. We ordered two slices-- white chocolate pumpkin cheesecake and Grandma's Fudge, which is a yellow cake with chocolate frosting. The service was fast and delightful, even though it was verging on their last hour open. Both tasted wonderful-- great textures, good frosting to cake ratio, and the cheesecake was topped with these sugared pecans which just made each bite. Truthfully, my favorite part of the experience was the frosted mug of milk to wash it all down. They were happy to give us a box for leftovers. It's a cozy little space where you can eat at the bar or at a variety of tables. They're family friendly and offer some gluten free options as well. The Cake Bar is definitely a new downtown gem, and I can't wait to try something different next time. We will be back! read more

The Cake Bar - White chocolate pumpkin cheesecake and Grandma's Fudge (yellow cake with chocolate frosting.) - Custom Cakes Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

See all

The staff seemed to be bothered when i showed up. Almost like they didn't want anyone there, the cake was beautiful but nothing more then sheet cake with basic icing and shaved almonds. Coffee was nice and way to lax ambiance read more

Last week I ordered a fruit tart cake with a quick and very informational response from their Facebook messenger. They said a week notice and the cake was done the day I needed it and they even allowed me to pick it up that day even though they were closed and I thought that was so kind of them. When picking up the cake she was very nice. Definitely recommend the cake bar! The cake was so beautiful and delicious! #supportlocalbusinesses read more

The Cake Bar - Custom Cakes Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

Refused to sell me a cake whole while there were 10 cakes in the case. Instead, they sold me an $18 bland, burnt, and dry red velvet cake. I was willing to pay $36 for a whole specialty cake but they refused, unless I was willing to have them slice it before I left. Huh???? I wish them the best but I won't be supporting this business again. Sad that a small business in Hanover isn't interested in a happy cystoner read more

Cakes were good. Unfortunately we got there an it on the late side so they had a fairly limited selection.

I was so excited about this place because I am new to the area and love cake. The prices per slices were a little more than I anticipated, however, I purchased two different slices; Grandmas Chocolate Fudge cake some lemon poppy cake. They both did NOT taste good. The grandmas chocolate fudge icing was gritty and the cake was nothing to write home about. The other cake just was off-putting for some reason, the last was off. I do not like to waste food, or waste money, however I threw both of them out. I guess I am lucky, I won't have temptation near by, saving my waist and my bank account. But yea overall, I would not recommend, sorry. read more

I had the Peanut Butter Lover's and the Raspberry Delight. Both fabulous! It's nice having cake from someone who knows the classics and not just box mix with powdered sugar and crisco on it. read more

See all

Gluten free options. No sugar substitute options . Coffee was good ! Cupcakes were great !

Love the taste of their cakes, but also true artists. The cakes are so beautiful and they can copy a photo to a tee. Everyone raved about the cake at my daughters baby shower. read more

Brilliant! Great addition to the local business scene. The coffee is tasty. I've have the white chocolate iced mocha, definitely a must try. even a simple iced latte is great. The cake display is eye catching for sure. I decided to try the key-lime cake slice for my first visit. It was delicious. I can't wait to try the other flavors! read more

I have ordered several cakes from them and they are always perfection! The flavors are wonderful, always moist and flavorful. (My favorite is the chocolate peanut butter! ). The decorating is always just what I wanted. Quick to reply to my emails. Love doing business with them and am sure to order more cakes in the future! read more

Ordered the most amazing chocolate cake with Pb frosting! The cake was moist and just the right balance of sweetness. Amanda is super accommodating. It was a pleasure doing business with them and look forward to trying other cakes in the future! read more

Went to the handover dutch festival and thought I'd try the " Cake Bar"I had a piece of the Grandmas Chocolate Fudge cake and my husband had the Raspberry Delight. Don't waste your time on this cake. Mine was dry and the icing was gritty I had a bite of my husbands it was the same. The cakes are expensive and if this is what you get I would rather have a box cake anytime because it's 100 times better. I was really looking forward to this because I've seen their Facebook page and the cakes look beautiful, but this was such a disappointment read more

I visited the cake bar last Friday evening I got 2 slices of cake one was the raspberry and the other was the Carrot cake. The raspberry cake seemed stale and the icing was really quite hard and tasteless. The carrot cake the cake part was good but it wasn't the right icing for the carrot cake also did not like that icing. Also fields a little pricey for a slice of cake and the location isn't very big. One positive thing was the people behind the counter are really very nice as well as the customers. read more