I got to Yelp in Castle Rock today. And it was for this cute cake shop in the heart of Castle Rock downtown. And it's none other than the Cake Company. I had a side hustle job assignment in the very neighborhood mid-afternoon. And I simply didn't want to go there, work, leave and get home; I wanted to discover a business I have never been to. I hence googled bakeries and this cake shop came up. According to a little research, this shop opened its doors in January of 2021 by two sisters who are Colorado natives. This element added more excitement to my quick visit I made today. The Cake Company is adorable. From the exterior signage to the interior decors, everything that decorates the whole space matches the theme of the store. Mostly pink and off-white, they not only sell beautifully crafted cupcakes, pies, rice crispies, cinnamon rolls, to name a few, they also sell some gifts such as wine glasses, t-shirts, journal books, tote bags, mug cups, I mean you name it!! I was at awe standing in front of the showcase that displays all sorts of sweets. When one of the ladies upfront greeted me with a very peppy welcoming tone, she kindly said to take my time. I thus allowed myself to be indecisive for several minutes to take my time (LOL!!) Whereas the pies and cheesecakes to the right looked amazing, they also appeared a bit too big and decadent. Since I only needed one good piece of some delicious something, I opted for a cupcake as they aren't as big as the other sweets. Upon asking the same lady which ones are the most popular, she said it was either Berry Tilly or Better Than Sex. My instinct told me to go with the latter: Better Than Sex. The different lady transacted my purchase. She carefully put my cupcake in a single cupcake box. Just so you know, their boxes are tilt-free so your sweet stuff won't tilt inside it (unless you violently shake the box!) The cupcakes are $6 each. And yet, if you buy 6 or more, each price is reduced to $5.50 up to 11. If you buy 12 or more, each price is reduced to $5.00. 20% discount will be added if you purchase 3 dozens. The shop does sell gluten free ones and yet any of the discounts I mentioned don't appear to apply to them. After the purchase, I looked to the left to discover a little entry way to the store next door. It's Lost Coffee. The customers are free to go in and out between the two shops. This means that you can take your cupcake to the next store and have some coffee or tea to pair with it. This is another store that has this symbiotic relationship with their next-door neighbor business. I always find the concept so intriguing. Businesses help each other. As soon as I got back to my car, I immediately opened the box and started to dig in. And wow....I know this is such an ordinary statement but I will say it: this is/was by far the best cupcake I've ever had. It was perfectly moist in the sponge part with the perfect sweetness. After one bite, it was simply impossible for me to stop eating it although I wanted to save some for later. The cupcake thus disappeared so quickly in a matter of 2-3 minutes. Their cupcakes are phenomenal. There is no way you'll buy cupcakes from other places once you have experienced theirs. I am already pondering as to when I should go back. Discovering great businesses bring me joy; this is why I can never stop Yelping. read more

See all

I adore this place! So cute, great location in Castle Rock downtown, the friendliest staff, and out-of-this-world desserts that really hit the spot when you have a sweet tooth! We are creatures of habit and love grabbing a slice of PB pie. Just thinking about it has my mouth watering! Their pies are whipped and light but still so rich and delicious! If you're a PB lover, I highly recommend. They also have other flavors and a large cupcake variety, as well as some cute local goods to browse while you wait. 10/10 would recommend for a sweet treat in Castle Rock! read more

See all

Their cakes are beautiful and scrumptious! I needed a last minute birthday cake and they had a few available off the shelf. Perfect and delicious. They wrote on the cake while I waited. Cute shop too. Wonderful business in downtown Castle Rock. read more

The Cake Company - Bakeries Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

Pretty specific, but literally the best banana crème pie I've ever had. Love the dark chocolate with the banana layer. It's sweet but not as sweet as you think. Coconut crème pie was good but not as good at the banana one. Staff was helpful too. They recommended the banana crème pie and thankful they did read more

The Cake Company - Banana crème pie - Bakeries Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

See all

I got this as a birthday gift and it really made my day extra special. The cupcakes are all sooooo good. I've never had good cupcakes for a long time. I like the texture, the sweetness is just right, the frosting- delish! Now have my new fave!!!! read more

The Cake Company - Bakeries Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

I am so impressed by this bakery! Everything was fresh and beautifully presented, and the service was very friendly. We tried several different items and really enjoyed each one so much that we forgot to take photos. -NY cheesecake cupcake: this was a vanilla cupcake with a strawberry cheesecake mousse filling, topped with a cheesecake mousse and a cherry pie filling. The texture of the mousse was perfect, too heavy or thick. The flavors worked very well together and it was not too sweet. The graham cracker crust at the bottom of the cupcake was a fun touch as well. -Sprinkle cake scraps: they had a couple cake flavors sold as a container of scraps covered with a layer of frosting. I thought this was a great way to reduce food waste, and you got a lot of cake for the price ($6, same as a cupcake). The cake was very moist, and the white chocolate mousse was delicious. -Banana cream pie slice: this was a delicious variation of a traditional banana cream pie! It had a graham cracker crust, a layer of banana mixed with dark chocolate ganache, topped with a vanilla pastry cream and whipped cream. The different textures of each layer worked perfectly together. Between the slight grit and saltiness from the crust and the addition of chocolate to the banana layer, this dessert was very well-balanced and difficult to put down. Overall, I was so impressed by the quality and presentation of everything! We will definitely return to try more cake flavors and some of their other desserts (the fresh cinnamon rolls sounded amazing). Worth a visit for sure! read more

Although I didn't personally set foot in The Cake Company, I was brought three delicious cupcakes from here and I was very impressed (even though I'm not a sweets person). I tried the chocolate covered strawberry, the pumpkin spice and the tiramisu. My favorite was the pumpkin spice! Very apt the upcoming fall, beautifully crafted and delicious! read more

See all

I came here once before, but didn't get a chance to take pictures. And I still forgot to take pictures of my cupcakes, but the customer service was great. I went after getting my coffee from next-door, which is super convenient and very cute little walk-through area. The gluten-free cupcakes are delicious and you can't even tell the difference between the full gluten and not gluten-free versions! They are not crumbly or dry. They're very moist, fluffy and flavorful. I love coming here for a treat yourself or girls day. And taking a stroll in the rest of area. I definitely recommend everyone coming here at least once it's very cute and I will be coming back! read more

See all

The cupcakes here are decent with good texture, decent sweetness, though the prices lean boutique. I really appreciated the staff's commitment to inclusivity. One of the special needs women in the back came out to say hello while we were browsing. She had a really confident energy, which is amazing to see in a support program like this. It's great when local businesses provide opportunities for everyone to shine, even those who might not typically have front-of-house roles. That kind of courage to put people forward, regardless of their disability, speaks volumes. I'll probably stop by again if I'm in the area, just to support that kind of bold staffing approach and keep the mission going. read more

The Cake Company - Bakeries Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

Amazing cakes! When we're in downtown we usually have a coffee next door and grab a couple of their top notch cupcakes however the best cake is their Key Lime Pie. Probably the best one I've had. This is a masterpiece, no less. If you're a Key Lime fan like me go there and try it as soon as you can. The staff is always very friendly and they have a few tables outside. The coffee shop next door is recommended too. read more

The Cake Company - The best Key Lime Pie! - Bakeries Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

See all

TCC is quietly one of the best dessert shops in the Denver metro area. If you're in the south burbs looking for something to bring to a dinner when you're tasked with handling desserts, you can't go wrong here. It can be tough to find a place that has more than cupcakes that you can pick up without ordering in advance. Here, you can find beautiful cakes to go with your cupcakes that can save a special occasion when you forgot to order ahead. Best of all, everything tastes amazing, and the staff is super nice too. Big, big fan of TCC. read more

The Cake Company - Cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

See all

Really yummy desserts, this place is a gem, super glad I gave it a shot. Would love to see some additional flavors and options added, this is going to become a go to for us. Begging for some more dairy, free options, as well. read more

I passed by this place while attending a walking tour of downtown Castle Rock. After the tour ended I decided to stop by and check them out. I've always loved gourmet cakes and cupcakes. They have a marvelous display of cupcakes! I ended up ordering, Better Than Sex, Pumpkin Spice, Irish Cream, and Chocolate Dipped Strawberry. Cupcakes tasted phenomenal! Cake was moist and not dried out at all. I do not like when stores sell dried out cake or cupcakes. It just ruins it for me. All the cupcake flavors blended well. I offered one to a friend of mine who really enjoyed it! He was impressed too. The staff member who took my order was barely paying attention as I ordered and paid. I recommend better attentiveness to patrons. Notwithstanding this observation I will definitely return here. I'm so glad they're a little pricey because I would be ordering cupcakes every week or weekend! Keep up the good work! As another reviewer wrote, this place can be "dangerous for your waistline." Agreed! Also, place is clean and no public restrooms, of course. Also, there is no place to sit down and enjoy your cupcakes so it's to go only. I had the Irish Cream cupcake with my coffee this morning and it was delicious! Great combo! Some of the cupcakes are advertised as "boozy" which I think is cute and thoughtful of them to label appropriately. I ordered two "boozy" cupcakes and they weren't that strong. Just the right amount of touch to them. If you're a Castle Rock resident or passing through, check them out sometime! I don't feel you will be disappointed at all! Plan on "paying for what you get." read more

See all

We have been here a handful of times. It truly is amazing. The desserts are the best we have had in many many years. Cheesecake, cupcakes, and other items are simply amazing. Well done serving a high quality product. Can't wait to come back this weekend after dinner downtown. Can't say enough good things about the flavors and quality. read more

The best pastries anywhere. I eat a lot of cakes and they never disappoint when it comes to their cake - but the peanut butter pie is hands down the best thing they sell. Absolutely incredible. The staff is nice, and the place is cute and always pristinely clean! read more

The Cake Company - Peanut butter pie - Bakeries Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

See all

First photo is the cake THEY said they would make for my son's birthday, the second photo is the cake I received. The cake looks nothing like the photo THEY sent me. I had my cake delivered, since my son is special needs and I couldn't go pick it up in person. This business is extremely unprofessional, when I emailed my disappointment in the cake they just said "Sorry, we understand if you don't work with us again" wth? No credit/ no refund/ they offered no compensation. My special needs child cried all weekend for his cake, and his birthday was ruined. They put no effort into making his cake, just a plain cake with cake toppers, and then had the audacity to charge $150 for it. I could of purchased a $20 cake from Walmart and put cake toppers on it. Terrible customer service! Thanks for ruining a special needs boy birthday party! . I disputed the charge with my bank, and they disputed it back..... Horrible waste of time! read more

The Cake Company - Photo of the cake they promised - Bakeries Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

See all

Found this place by accident after grabbing a coffee at Lost Coffee shop. With fresh pies and crazy good cupcakes, even though I'm not a sweet tooth, it's worth the experience. From Tiramisu to the 'Hostess cupcake' I had as a kid, there's plenty to choose from. Staff is great and can give you great advice on which cupcake to choose. Store is small and quaint, perfect for a shop like this. read more

The Cake Company - Tiramisu cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

See all

This place is seriously dangerous for your waistline! Honestly, one of the best cupcake I have ever had. I tried a German chocolate cake one but they have tons of traditional as well as unique options. Its in downtown Castle rock so plenty of parking near the shop (they have a parking lot as well as street parking). I am sad that a pastry store that was there before closed down but glad that another small business opened up instead. There is a great coffee shop right next to it as well. read more

See all

Hands down the best cupcake I've ever had! Moist cake, cream center, cookie bottom, perfect not too sweet frosting and just beautiful read more

The Cake Company - Pumpkin cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

See all

Soo good, always get these cupcakes for our birthdays. The tiramisu and better than sex are my favs! Always consistent and yummy.

How can you work here and not eat all day?!?!?! Oh My GOODNESS! This place is FULL of YUMMY GOODNESS so beautifully displayed....and bonus....they have SAMPLES AND Gluten-free products. Not just 1 gluten free choice but about 6! This is amazing! The store is so beautifully decorated for the holidays and it just smells as fantastic as it looks. Unfortunately, due to my allergies- I could not try anything myself....but it was somewhere I would like to bring my husband for him to try something! read more

See all

Beautiful and tall custom birthday cake. Everyone who saw the cake was impressed with how beautiful it was and how great a gluten-free cake could be. read more

just not for me I guess. Cupcake prep and flavors are not anything that I am wowed by. Some of the flavor names are a little trashy. Icing to cake ratio is not balanced. Same for the cakes and other desserts. They are the only cupcake bakery in CR so I try really hard to like their products but I am not a fan. read more

Beautiful and delicious cake and cupcakes for our large event. Great service and communication too! Thank you Lauren! read more

The Cake Company - Bakeries Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

Best cupcakes I've had. They're light, not too sweet and delicious. Customer service is top notch. I'll be returning for a sweet treat or celebration. read more

The Cake Company is an awesome treat in Downtown Castle Rock. We were greeted up front by a friendly associate who came out from the production Bakery in the back and helped us make our difficult gourmet cupcake selections out of their amazing display case. In addition to top notch cupcakes, they also specialize in custom cake orders to fit any occasion. We got a NY Cheesecake, a Chocolate, and two Berry Tilly. Each of them were incredible and didn't last long once we got back home. All were extremely fresh and made with incredibly high quality ingredients. They made a lasting impression on the whole family and we are sure to be back soon! read more

See all

DREAM CAKE! I asked for a heart cake with the word Libra on it for my bday and they gave me exactly what I imagined but better! I highly recommend going to this little bakery shop for all special occasions and getting the cake of your dreams. It not only was picture perfect, but also taste amazing and price was pretty reasonable for a custom cake. I got the Berry cream flavor. read more

See all

This place is delicious. My now go to spot for desserts and special event cakes. I use to go to another local bakery in CR but all their cupcakes started tasting the same and prices were up . So i stopped going but luckily this little gem opened up. I was wary at first since it's hard to find a good bakery but everything I've tried has been delicious and I am not a fan of anything super sweet or icing. This is the first cupcake in years that I've eaten the icing off of. I will Continue to return until I try all of their cupcakes and pastries and then I will return for seconds ;) read more

See all

Ordered cupcakes for a business meeting and they were a hit! The assortment looked beautiful and everyone was "mmmmmmmm! These are so good!" Success! read more

Why did you increase the pie price just to make it seem like your 10% off promo is a discount?!?! Very dishonest. I bought the banana cream pie two weeks ago, so I know what the price was. read more

Absolutely yummy!! I don't like super sweet and sharing a cupcake with a friend was perfect!! We walked next door and grabbed a coffee;) read more

The Cake Company - Cute box with each cupcake ! - Bakeries Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

Don't use The Cake Company! Order two pies on December 6 to be picked up on Dec. 24 at 3:00pm. Confirmation confirmed the date and time. On the 24th we left home at 1:30pm to pick up a few things for Christmas Eve dinner and pick up the pies on our way home. We arrive at the shop at 2:45pm and they are closed. Sign in the window indicated they closed early. We get home and there is a voice mail delivered at 1:45pm that we should pick up the pies before 2:00pm because they are closing early. So, no pies for dinner. I called on Dec. 27 and was told they had called to notify us of the early closing so they did their due diligence and it was my fault for not getting the pies. GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICES. Sad, because their pies and cakes are good. Will not do business with them. RB read more

First time at this business. Nice looking but small selection of goods. I purchased a small slice of pie for nine dollars. That's all fine, but I hate bad customer service. The young woman rang me up, I didn't tip. I suppose that's why she was upset. She didn't ask if I wanted a receipt, mumbled something and walked away. I wasn't even sure my Transaction was complete. Very rude. Will never go back and will definitely not recommend to friends, family or co-workers. Thanks for making my nice day just a bit worse. People should leave an establishment happy and satisfied. read more

I should have taken a picture. I got the cookies and cream and spiced carrot cupcakes. They were probably the best cupcakes I've ever had. I generally don't like cake or cupcakes because of the dry nature of the dessert but these were fantastic!! I could have used a little more filling on the spiced carrot but still so so so good. read more

Ordered a GF PB chocolate cake for my husbands birthday and it was phenomenal!!! Can't wait to try more. read more

The Cake Company - Chuck's Peanut Butter Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado

See all

Some of the best desserts I've ever had!!! The lemon cream pie, tiramisu and chocolate peanut butter are at the top of my list, but everything I've tried has been amazing. read more

Cupcakes and Cinnamon rolls are always amazing, however Customer service is awful the past 3 times we've been in. The girl with short hair that works the cash register has been nothing but rude each time we go in, we took a friend in yesterday during the Octoberfest , my friend bought some stuff and she came out of the store and said well that lady was rude, not friendly and got annoyed when she asked for a bag. I knew exactly who is was talking about because the past 2 other times I've gone in with my mother she gave us attitude. Not pleasant and seems to rush you or get annoyed if your taking along time to decide. read more

They make very good gluten free cupcakes in a variety of delicious flavors! A bit pricey, but yummy!

If you are looking for a great desert to take home for a special occasion or just a cupcake or cinnamon bun on the run. This is the place to go. The food we enjoyed was delicious and the staff were very friendly and helpful to point out any specials or assist with our order. Located right next to the fire department and was clean and well lit. We will definitely come back read more

My daughter who is living in California bought me a half dozen assorted cupcakes for Mother's Day and had them delivered to my front door... I can't tell you which was my favorite because they all were so delicious and fresh.. I'll definitely be buying more from this bakery ... very high quality read more

The Cake Company - Assorted cupcakes!! - Bakeries Near Me - Castle Rock, Colorado