Happened upon this when in the area with a friend and we had to stop in and check it out! It's so cute!! Everything is made in house with the exception of the macarons. It was hard to choose, but I did a half pound of the small cookies as I really wanted to try the anise ones. I made these growing up and it was definitely a walk down memory lane for me. Had to get the pistachio croissant and also a piece of the pistachio cake. My friend got the biscoff cake and I got a piece e of the carrot cake to take home to my husband. They give you a warning about the cake lids- heed their warning as they do not stay on and you should not pick up by the lid! I tasted the biscoff and it was exactly that and so good! The pistachio cake was three smaller layers of cake with what seemed like a lighter buttercream frosting, but not too much and not too sweet either. The cake was light and flavorful. The croissant was large and more than enough to share! read more

See all

What a cute little place in Fishers! The decor is beautiful - everything you would look for in a fun, new pastry shop. My sister and I ordered a few items: - The pistachio latte was meh - tasted like milk. I would not order this again. - The biscoff cake was delightful. Fluffy and flavorful. Loved it. I will say that I hate the little containers that these cake slices come in, though. If dining in, they're impossible to navigate. My cake literally kept falling onto the table. I had to hold it with my hands like a caveman. - The Dubai chocolate was fabulous, and it was well-priced. I'd go back just for this! The service was pretty darn slow, but I expect that this will improve over time. Overall, I really enjoyed this place, and I'll definitely be back. It seemed like they were sold out of a lot of items by 11am on a Saturday, so I'll plan to get there earlier next time. read more

This place is so pretty! Love the decor. The display case showed off all the pastries beautifully . I was very excited to try the Mango Mousse because I love mango. The dessert itself was colorful on the outside and had a delicious, creamy mango filling on the inside. It was a 10/10 dessert. I had also ordered a pistachio iced Latte. The latte basically tasted like milk. It had little flavor. Definitely not my favorite Latte. If you would like to try a place that is like Cake Bake but with a slightly cheaper price tag, I would highly recommend checking out the Cake Pantry. read more

See all

A cute boutique bakeshop in Fishers. They offer decorated cakes, fresh pastries, sandwiches, and coffee in a charming space with a few cozy tables for seating inside and outside. I tried the caramel almond Danish and a caramel iced latte, and both were good. The Danish had the perfect balance of flavors, somewhere between a sticky bun and a Liege waffle. The iced latte was smooth, creamy, and had just the right amount of caramel without being overly sweet. Together, they made the perfect afternoon treat. Whether you're catching up with friends over coffee or looking for a cozy spot for a mid-afternoon date, or taking your family out for an afternoon treat this is a great place to visit. read more

See all

What a cute shop! I wasn't expecting all the pretty decor. It was very empty when I went in on a Wednesday at 11am, but that wasn't bad since I was able to have a quiet convo with my friend. There isn't a ton of drink options to choose from - just a few coffees and some canned drinks. There are quite a few dessert options left and I tried the fruit tart which was really good! The fruit was fresh and the custard was tasty. I will be back! read more

The Cake Pantry - Fruit tart - Bakeries Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Cake pantry is located in a good area in Fishers where you can walk to it easily - street parking fills up, but there are garages nearby. I tried the strawberry cake - delicious, tasted like strawberry shortcake! I also tried a slice of Biscoff cake - this fell short for me. Biscoff is a delicious, but strong flavor and the white cake and whipped icing paired with it are just too delicate. Lastly, I tried the apple mousse - super cool looking, and it tasted like apple pie! Overall, really good, moist cake with some inventive mousse treats I haven't seen elsewhere - worth checking out. read more

See all

I really wanted to like this place, and keep in mind that I visited only 2 weeks after their grand opening, so there's every chance that they will eventually improve, but I was disappointed by my visit. First off, I stopped by a few minutes after they opened and though there was a couple inside, the doors were still locked from the outside. The couple waiting next to me outside gave up and left. When I was eventually let in, I looked at the handful of sweets on display, and they just looked lonely. Only a few slices of cake and some of the fruit shaped mousse desserts, which did not look as appealing as I've seen them elsewhere. The service was lacking as one employee was busy putting in a bunch of croissants to bake and the other one seemed to be off disappearing to Narnia or doing whatever behind the scenes work in the backroom. The sweets I did buy were pricy, but nothing special. When done right, the fruit mousse desserts can be worth a $10 price tag, but these were small and just ok. The slice of cake was also fine, but not something I would get again. read more

The Cake Pantry - Raspberry mousse dessert - Bakeries Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

3 stars. Gorgeous bakery! If you're looking for a pretty place to host a small gathering, Fishers now has a beautiful option. First, this is a scratch bakery. Everything is made in-house, and some ingredients are even imported from Europe to maintain the highest quality standards. Second, everything in the display case is an absolute work of art. I spent several minutes simply admiring how beautiful and appetizing everything looked. The chef is even creating those viral mousse-filled desserts and hand-airbrushing them! The level of talent and attention to detail is impressive. The macarons are picture-perfectly pastel. The laminated dough on the croissants is gorgeously glossy. We tried the Biscoff cake and a few shortbread cookies. The cookies were rich, buttery, and clearly made with high-quality European butter. I do wish they had been a bit sweeter. They reminded me more of a biscotti or a southern tea cake than traditional shortbread. They would pair beautifully with coffee, but they weren't quite what I expected. The Biscoff cake, however, was surprisingly true to its flavor profile. Sometimes cookie butter desserts make you search for that signature flavor, but not this one. The Biscoff shines through immediately and tap dances across your taste buds. If you're a cookie butter fan like I am, you'll love it. I was a little disappointed by the white cake itself. It provided excellent structure, but the flavor was lacking. Honestly, it was almost completely neutral. That may have been intentional, though, because it allowed the Biscoff flavor to remain the star of the show. The texture was dense and sturdy, with a flavor profile that reminded me a bit of angel food cake. The cake is finished with a light, whipped cream frosting that is absolutely perfect for this dessert. It complements the richness of the Biscoff beautifully without overwhelming it. And it's served in a cake container that has the fork built in! So cute! I love the attention to detail. For those wondering, Taylor's has nothing to worry about. The offerings here are completely different, and this bakery serves a different niche. There's plenty of room in Fishers for both. They also offer hot beverages, coffee, lattes and the likes. Unfortunately, they don't have a cookie butter latte or chai tea which are my go-tos. So, I'll wait till winter to sample the drink menu. Service was good. The young lady working was knowledgeable, friendly, and did a great job answering our questions. I believe the chef was there, but he never stepped out to greet guests. It's your grand opening... come say hello! Tell us about your creations, your journey, and what inspired you to choose Fishers as your new home. We want to hear your story! Welcome to the Fishers! I'm looking forward to working my way through the case one sweet treat at a time. read more

See all

This place is CUTE. Such a fun place for cake or coffee. They do play loud music but all trendy stuff. Tons of free street parking. They have a selection of sandwiches, coffee, croissants, cookies, cakes and a few other pastries! I ordered the strawberry cake & iced vanilla latte and they were very friendly to answer additional questions and help me with suggestions, will return read more

See all

Went back again to Cake Pantry and this time I tried the coffee mousse. First off gelatin is vegetarian which was very helpful to know. Second the mousse was airy light and just the right consistency. I loved the smoothness of texture in every bite. There was a thin encasing of chocolate which added mini bites of crunchy goodness. Service was great, chef baker was readily accessible for gelatin question. Happy customer! read more

See all

Overall the pastries are so cute. The service was nice and the space is gorgeous but I would not eat these again. So cute though!

The pastries were pretty but not good. Service was good and the ambiance was very pretty. read more

The Cake Pantry - Bakeries Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Ordered 1/2 pound cookies, all of a shortbread type variety. Perfect for coffee or tea. Buttery and delicious, my favorite was the one with anise seeds, not as butter-rich but perfect sweetness and taste. We arrived in the afternoon. It appeared that the pastry cases had been sold out. There were maybe only one or two of different types of croissants left in the fridge. On the other side of cakes by the slice same situation, only two or three slices left. Maybe it was the time of day that we came but looked kind of sparse which probably a good thing that means they sold out right? Cutely decorated inside. Overall I would like to come back to try other items and especially curious about their coffees. read more

Today I finally stopped by to congratulate the owner on his beautiful Cake Pantry business. I was familiar with his sweet but not too sweet baked goods and fine pastries as well as his excellent buttery flaky croissants . I was not disappointed. Also, was able to taste some new flavors like anise cookies they were delish. As well as the chocolate cookies. My daughter is having a birthday in August and I plan to order it from the Cake Pantry. It's a great location and worth a taste my friends read more

I got the lemon mousse and I have no idea what was in the middle but it was jet black and leafy? They don't tell you what is inside any of the desserts and when you ask staff they don't know ether. read more

The Cake Pantry - Lemon dessert - Bakeries Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Lovely environment, helpful staff. Delicious Biscoff Cake with just the right amount of icing. The cake was moist but not too sweet, the icing was just enough to not over power the cake. The choices are numerous, fine cookies to croissants to cakes and mousses! read more

Excited to see this new bakery open at the corner of North St and Maple in downtown Fishers. This business was located in Al Basha, but now he has his own space. The cakes are delicious. The biscotti cake is very good. The pistachio cake is unique in that it's savory and sweet (maybe goat cheese in the icing?) My wife really likes it. I will definitely try the croissants. I bought a raspberry dessert to try after dinner. The bakery is beautiful. Very friendly ownership. I hope they are around for years. read more

See all

Finally, a good croissant!! inside is very cute and staff was super friendly. Will be coming back again!

Easily the BEST fruit tart I have ever had. Perfectly crisp shell, a lovely layer of dark chocolate, perfectly sweet pastry cream, topped with fresh fruit. Their cookies are also outstanding. To top it off, the service was great, and the atmosphere was so chill and comfortable. Definitely a Fishers gem. read more