What an amazing selection of great cakes! I've had the signature chocolate cake and also the lemon…read morechiffon as a cupcake, and I'm ordering another specialty one in a couple weeks (still can't decide on a flavor). The cupcakes are super moist, and all the flavors really seem to complement each other. I wasn't a fan of raspberry filling before now, but Jackie's filling is made with real crushed berries, not like the syrupy stuff at the grocery store. I'm interested to try the carrot cake and cheesecake in the future- will add to the review after I've had those. Really wonderful all around, from the customer service to the cakes themselves. These calories are worth it!!!

Best cakes and cupcakes EVER!! My favorite is the lemon chiffon, but the Sweetheart Chocolate is…read moreamazing, too. They look gorgeous, taste even better!

I called 3 bakeries to try and get a cake delivered to an out of town co worker where we are in…read moreLouisville and mama to be is in Colorado. No one delivered! Then I called Nichole and got her voicemail and did not leave a message. She called me back and that right there made me know she was the right person to make the cake, get the card, sign all our names, get the gift card, and deliver to make the new mamas long distance baby shower a success! Kudos to you Nichole and Thank you again!!! You are the epitome of what high end customer service should be!!! Thank you!!!

Prompt delivery, friendly staff, beautiful cake Recommend…read moregiving them your business!

Really good food service atmosphere if recommend highly ,....... Will go back again would recommend…read morefor birthday parties and special occasions

The Cupcake Cruiser was located at the Odell's Brewery while I was on a brewery tour with some…read morefriends of mine. Probably a very good place to go and sell cupcakes on a Saturday. I bought the Vanilla loves Chocolate cupcake. It was pretty good. Of course I haven't ever met a cupcake that I didn't like. My friends got the Oreo cupcake and seemed to like it. Single regular sized cupcakes are about $2.75 each. The best way to catch the cupcake cruiser is if you go to their website, www.gocupcakecruiser.com. There are a list of prices if you want a bunch of cupcakes, their menu options, catering options and contact info. That is probably the best way to catch the cupcake cruiser because under the 'news' heading you will see where the cupcake cruiser will be located. You can always email them as well too on their website if you need extra pointers as to where they will be located. They keep moving! They are not at one location constantly.

Amazing small bakery with the nicest people you'll ever meet!…read more I've stopped by numerous times to pick up a slice of cake, maybe a single serve cheese cake, cookies or macarons. Everything does not disappoint. Special ordered a cake. It was not only lovely, but super delicious. This is my go-to bakery!

The best cakes and cupcakes in town. Everything is absolutely DELICIOUS, and everyone there is very…read morekind! Normally I make all cakes in this family and I love it. However in April of 2022, for my son's birthday I just didn't have the time and looked for a real local bakery. I found Brenda's and we purchased a tres leches crunch cake and cupcakes. They both received RAVE reviews by all of us! For my daughter's birthday she asked to go back so we did! We've been back 3 times now and every single time, everything we get is AMAZING and delicious. Everyone there is so nice, and she even cut fresh strawberries for the top of the cake and put a little Happy Birthday thing on it for my daughter. They take great care to make sure your cake will survive the trip home too. We'll be back and I'm definitely recommending this place to everyone I know!

Most of the cookies here are a bit too dense & soft for my personal tastes (almost a cookie dough…read morevibe at times), but the atmosphere is so friendly and there are so many fun options! We did the buy 6 get 2 free deal, and out of what I sampled, my favorites were the Oreo Crunch & the Brookie. The citrus flavor in the Orange Doodle (not 100% sure I'm getting the names right) was also really nice, despite the aforementioned overall base texture that just isn't my personal fav, and I also enjoyed the salted caramel bites in another (Cowgirl something?). They're all also very rich so I can only sample a few bites at a time.

Love love love Mary's Mountain Cookies! Every time I come to this location, the staff are so…read morefriendly, helpful, and available (and also very patient as I take forever to decide). There's so many delicious cookies to choose from, you can't go wrong! My personal favorite is the frosted Oreo cookie, so yummy!

Solid 5 stars. I…read moretend to eat at alot of the large specialty cookie establisments and this is now at the top of the list. Every cookie we tried at Mary's Mountain Cookies was just as good or better than any other place I've been. These aren't your super-thick, pudgy, crumble-style cookies -- they're closer to a normal thickness, but about six inches in diameter. The selection is really good. It's not just your standard chocolate chip and sugar cookies -- they had all sorts of combinations, including cookie sandwiches with filling. In fact, we enjoyed them so much the first day that we went back the next day for more. They also have day-old cookies on discount, cookies in the freezer, and it looks like they do birthday cookies as well. Peanut butter dipped in dark chocolate -- fine. My wife really liked it -- it's one of her favorite cookies. I thought the peanut butter taste could've been a little stronger. The cookie was moist and not bland, it just could've been a touch better. Turtle cookie -- one of my top 20 cookies of all time. This is actually why I went back the next day -- to get another one. It hit every mark: the right amount of sweetness, the right amount of crunch, the right amount of gooeyness. One of those cookies where you go, "yep, that is a good cookie" -- and it leaves you wanting more. It's right on the main strip, so parking might be iffy if you're in Old Town Fort Collins -- but if you're walking around that area and looking for a sweet treat, 100% recommend this place. Would recommend, and would return.

**MY EXPERIENCE:**…read more Dive into Mary's Mountain Cookies, where every step feels like a delightful escape! The oversized, imaginative cookies are a visual and taste sensation, each flavor bursting with personality. Picture this: a cheeky bicycle hanging on the wall, embodying Fort Collins' quirky spirit. From the moment you walk in, you're swept up in a wave of nostalgia and flavor. Our first visit was nothing short of magical, and even miles away, those cookies remain etched in memory. If you're in town, this is where you need to be! **HISTORY & CONTEXT:** Mary's Mountain Cookies has been a cornerstone of Fort Collins, delighting locals and visitors alike with its creative flair and unmatched quality. It's more than just a cookie shop--it's an experience, a slice of local culture wrapped in buttery perfection. Whether you're a die-hard cookie fan or seeking a distinctive Colorado adventure, Mary's stands as a must-see treasure. I will be back!

We paid over $200 to Make Your Cake Bakery for a 12" diameter yellow cake and a 4" diameter yellow…read moregluten free cake. Was not worth the money. Both cakes were very dry. The larger cake was for an engagement announcement & the small one was for our gluten free friends & family. The icing was blue and white marbled on the large cake, and white and CSU colors on the small cake. The icing did taste good and was worth 1 star. However, the baker did not put the couple's names on the engagement cake. There was 1" lettering saying congratuations along the top but nothing else on the top. The mini cake had the words I requested, for my son's graduation. The baker also had the cakes ready on time...sort of. That was worth the other star. I suggest you save $200 and order your cakes from the Walmart bakery. They can't do any worse.

My daughter's beach themed cake turned out perfectly and she even offers local delivery! Made our…read morebusy day so much easier and the cake is exactly what we wanted. Wonderful quality, friendly, and reliable. So glad we chose Make Your Cake for my daughter's special day.

Shannon made an outstanding custom cake for my daughter's surprise baby shower with about a week's…read morenotice. I sent her several Instagram photos ranging from simple-but-elegant to multi-faceted tiered confections. We went over flavorings and fillings, but the actual elements were up to her discretion. She made me an unheard of price... so generous that I began to get nervous... I was particular afraid that it would be too flat since I didn't want to pay up for two tiers, but as you can see, it was plenty tall. I only needed to serve 20 adults, and this 10" cake provided so much leftover. I loved the consistency of the chocolate cake, and it was very moist. Shannon really went the extra mile to make it special, so I highly recommend her service.

I have never seen cookies and a cake look so horrible! I don't know how she's still in business! I…read morejust want to warn people so they don't have to go through what I did with her service. I was embarrassed to have her products on my cake and cookie table!