Sick of all this trendy self-serve yogurt and topping nonsense? Check out Yummylicious for frozen yogurt and ice cream served the old fashioned way! The salted caramel pretzel and birthday cake frozen yogurt flavors are both delicious. I'm not into chocolate frozen yogurt anyway, but my family said it wasn't very good, hence 1 star docked. FYI: get your ice cream only. No seating. read more

See all

My husband liked his ice cream, but my frozen yogurt tasted "off," and I did not feel well later that night. My fault, I shouldn't have eaten it! Of course, can't be certain my not feeling well was from the frozen yogurt - could be from anything, but it's certainly possible. At any rate, tasted bad, so I wouldn't return. read more

Yummylicious is a awesome ice cream store in Downtown sag Harbor. They offer speciality ice cream, sorbet or yogurt. Try out a few samples. The mango and the cotton candy flavors are amazing. read more

Yummylicious! - ROSARIO S. CASSATA AT YUMMYLICIOUS IC CREAM STORE IN DOWNTOWN SAG HARBOR LONG ISLAND, NEW YORK. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Walking through this beautiful neighborhood, admiring the boats, the atmosphere, the shops, we needed to get the kids ice cream to bribe them into cooperating. This shop has no seating but on a beautiful day, you just take it to go or sit outside on a bench. No bathroom either so bring hand sanitizer before you let the kids eat. On this day, they had usual flavors one of which was cotton candy ice cream. It tasted exactly how you'd imagine cotton candy ice cream to taste. Very expensive but what do you expect. read more

Ice cream is decent, basic you can get this anywhere. Too expensive for what it is, go to big olafs over here.

Not bad ice cream but very mundane flavors. I enjoy the homemade places more. Not just for the ice cream but the atmosphere itself. I wasn't disappointed by it, but I probably wouldn't come back for more. read more

Yummylicious! - a man in a face mask holding a cup of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

STAY AWAY! RUDE RUDE AND INSECTS IN THE ICE CREAM! Having come here in the past I recommended it to my family to try while enjoying an afternoon in Sag Harbour. After taking a few bites I noticed that there was an insect in my ice cream! FROZEN AND DEAD INSIDE! UNSANITARY! After bringing it to the employees attention she shrugged and threw it out. I asked if I could get another flavor and a refund and she told me I can either get one or the other. I'm sorry but I'm willing to give you another chance after finding a BUG in my ice cream and that's the rude response I get? The employee went to speak to the "person in charge" and they were whispering in a corner. The employee PAOLA is terrible, rude and unprofessional! I will NEVER come back and I am contacting the health department to see what other unsanitary issues are present at this establishment! DISGUSTING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Very friendly staff, great ambiance, good portions, fun place for kids, great location in town.

they are so rude. they gave me a attitude when i asked for a drink they said "oh we actaully dont have it" in a rude way. it was a white girl. not cool never coming back to this shitty place read more

very yummy boba, the only boba i've been able to find near east hampton! but lots of ice inside, if you wanna enjoy more of the drink ask for less ice. the shop is super cute inside, masks must be worn, boba cost about $7. read more

Yummylicious! - black tea boba for about $7! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Main problem lies either with ownership or training. Teenagers working for the summer is a great thing. These kids were among the rudest and (I'm sorry, but) dumbest I've encountered. Couldn't care less about their customers. There's better ice cream on the pier, or frozen yogurt up the road. read more

Bought boba tea the other day and it was so gross. The tapioca pearls were rock hard, I wasted my money- don't waste yours. It went straight into the trash. A teenage girl helped me and she was quite rude as well. read more

Edible but barely. They serve Hershey ice cream. Frozen yogurt is icy. I would not recommend this place. read more

Not bad yogurt - tried for the first time. I'm sure ice cream would be much better but was trying to save calories. Overall - nice service, exceptionally clean read more

I was in the neighborhood and walked past this shop. Despite selling fro-yo and ice cream, I was more in the mood for ice cream. The place had quite a few customers, so I was surprised at how quickly I was served. I got cookie doughlicious and play dough on a cone. I wouldn't recommend the play dough tho, tastes a bit too much like vanilla. But I enjoyed everything else about the place :^) read more

Yummylicious! - Just two ice cream lovers enjoying their time out east on LI. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

I almost forgot to add this place to my Memorial Day reviews in Southampton and Sag Harbor areas we went recently. This is a very cute and lovable place to be, very colorful. The yogurt tastes like real ice-cream, but it's yogurt. Not a lot of chairs, just mainly good for in and out. But sitting here on a high chair is good for cooling off in a hot summer day. Not a lot of seats around. Maybe 5-6? Looking out the window, you see Main Street and people, that's all. They make the place look super cute. I could see it from far and I wanted to go here. Hubby got combination with some sprinkle, unfortunately too late to snap his yogurt's photo, this fella couldn't wait, that's my husband! LOL. But I tried the yogurt he ordered for himself, it was as good as my yogurt. I had vanilla with no sprinkle. I wish I could have some but I'm not crazy about sprinkle on any ice-cream or yogurt. Tourists to this town should come in and try this place. Have a bite to share or something. Nice and cool inside. Very clean too. Happy kids all around sitting and enjoying their ice-creams. Two low chairs for the kids to sit. A few thumbs up if I have more than 2 hands! read more

See all

Mango Bubble Tea is phenomenal. Took about 5-7 minutes for her to make it, but it was delicious

Great place. Awesome location, ice cream was delicious, had place to sit down and enjoy. The girls behind the counter were very pleasant. Highly recommend. Will be back for sure. read more

After being pointed to Yummylicious! by some lovely Irish tourists, my friends and I eagerly threw open the door to enjoy a frozen treat. We were greeted by two teenage girls who appeared to be counting down the seconds until they could close their fine establishment. After much deliberation, we landed on some 10$ chocolate milkshakes, which were about as costly as you'd expect given the usual Sag Harbor rates, and about as tasty given the town is known for seafood. The most saddening part of our visit, however, was when Time to BeReal flashed on our screens as we paid. We were understandably thrilled as we posed for selfies and smiles, however across the counter we were met with blank stares that drained our enthusiasm faster than the news crew arrived at the beach to cover another shark sighting. Food was fine, however the deduction in stars come from the lack of enthusiasm over social medias newest craze. read more

I used to love this place... but I'm quite troubled by the fact that they are handing out samples and encouraging people to remove their masks inside to try different flavors. I can't understand how that is even legal, given the local mask ordinance. The owner obviously doesn't care about the safety of his patrons or employees. read more

This place is pretty tasty. Great service. Decent prices for yogurt in the Hamptons. I'd go back.

When living in Sag Harbor, I didn't know if I'd ever find bubble tea... then one day... someone tells me yummylicious sells bubble tea! I come almost everyday for a bubble tea since I am a bubble tea enthusiast... Yummylicious also has great ice cream! Honestly everything here is great. The ice cream is Hershey's ice cream, and is delicious. I like the cookies and cream. There is also seating by a big window where you can look at the main street of Sag Harbor. Also, when you walk in yummylicious the design of the place is fabulous and smells great when you walk in. There are lights that change color every second. The people here are great too. If you get yummylicious card at the cash register, you can get 9 ice creams/drinks and then get a 10th one for free. I'm a regular, so I've already gotten two things for free. I'd definitely recommend coming here for some tasty refreshing ice cream. read more

The best ice-cream ever. I had the cappuccino crunch on a sugar cone. It was perfect on a hot day like today. Also have yogurt, milk shake and bubble tea. Super cute place. Good service. Pleasant staff served to perfection. read more

Sadly the first time my family and I went there we got food poisoning. The ice cream also tasted quite odd.

Only reason I go here is because they advertise "Bubble tea" and every time I go inside its never ready -and it's always past 12PM! Went two days in a row where this happened, asked the girl to speak to a manager and she said she comes in later. Not how you run a business read more

Worst fozen yogurt I have ever had! Waist if money, and waist of space. Terrible service, and terrible taste.

The salted caramel pretzel frozen yoghurt is truly yummylicious! Unlike other salted caramel ice creams that are too sweet, this one is perfectly balanced, and you can taste the pretzel. read more

This place is fantastic! Friendly staff, delicious ice cream/froyo, and the lights are soooo cool! I'm not a big fan of bubble tea, but if I was, I'm sure I'd love what they have to offer too! Overall, this is my favorite place in Sag Harbor if I need to satisfy my sweet tooth, and I have a good feeling it'll be here for a long time. 10/10 would recommend! read more