Wow! The tastiest Pork Chop I have eaten in a LONG time. Great service and the Potato Skins app was…read morereally good. They do give you a LOT of food and a to go box is in a lot of folks hands going out the door. I highly recommend this place for lunch or dinner but come hungry!

Food was great, fast service during a busy lunch period on a Tuesday. was a business lunch and we…read moretook a chance Atmosphere very plain, bar area was fine. Suggest little more of a theme of some type needed

If you want a locals place for beer, this is your spot. If you're looking for a great service and…read morefood place, maybe look elsewhere. Came on a Thursday evening for dinner at the recommendation of the hotel. Upon arriving, it is immediately recognized to be a dive bar. I was all for it. Two of us were quickly seated at a booth. We ordered a couple beers, jack daniels bbq wings, and the Thursday surf and turf dinner meal. The dinner meal came with a soup, salad, or veggie and a potato (for which they had almost 10 options from baked, mashed, and various fries). The wings were a great size but lacked in enough sauce that they almost tasted plain. The steak was ordered medium and came out rare (we were fine with it too). The steak was completely unseasoned, just cooked meat. We ordered Cajun seasoning on the shrimp and pretty sure they, too, were plain with no flavor. The mashed potatoes and gravy were good. Service was just OK as well.

1 week ago Service was terrible. Food took forever to come…read moreout. Asked server how much longer; she said "I don't know" and didn't offer to check. Crispy chicken was overcooked and mostly breading. Had to go to the bar to pay the bill as no server came with check.

I had the fish tacos with a side salad…read more The salad was fairly basic- carrot strips, tomato slices quarters, a mix of salad greens. Nothing fancy but it was a generous portion. I'm a salad fan so- no complaints from me. You could change to mac n cheese or something else but I needed some veggies. The fish tacos- pretty fabulous. The fish (cod) had a tempura-type batter on it. They weren't greasy at all. Cabbage on top, a light sauce. I like spicy so the server brought me some hot sauce. As for the atmosphere- neighborhood restaurant, very clean, well-stocked bar, friendly environment. It wasn't too busy when I was there and I've seen it mess with service in other restaurants, but I got my order in and the food was out pretty quickly. All in all, totally worth it! I'd eat there again.

The outside of this building makes it look like a dive. Inside is a cool bar and back patio. Can't…read morebelieve it's not more popular. As a local the outside was discouraging. Now it's our favorite. American with a fusion. Amazing tempura fish tacos with slaw last time. Today we had a pulled pork with grilled pineapple over rice with an Asian leaning any red blooded American would love. Great Mac and cheese with Chinese Gen Tsaos chicken on it or orange chicken. Great pairings. So refreshing to not have things from the deep frier all the time. Best appetizers are the pierogies with bacon and sour cream. Heads up cash is cheaper. Card clearly stated costs 3% more. They have an ATM in their dining area. It's not overpriced. Most meals are the same as Hometown restaurant across the street. They have a whole other side of dining you don't see when you walk in. Would be great for a large gathering. I

What an absolutely perfect experience from the delicious Friday fish to our server, Eric (who also…read moreturns out is the owner!) to the music and atmosphere on the deck. We will definitely be back.

After enjoying the fish fry for a number of years last Friday night meal was a huge disappointment…read more The fish was pre-breaded then frozen from a supplier. The appearance was unappetizing and the taste marginal. A shame as the fish fries used to be outstanding.

My favorite wings in the Olean area…read more You have the most hospitable bar tending staff imaginable. Any issues with food get resolved promptly. A large variety of sauces to choose from and a great menu. Definitely my recommendation to anyone looking for an inexpensive fun night in Olean.

Wow! I thought the half way inn was the best wings in the area until I had wings at the 3rd base!…read moreOur minds are blown! It's more of a cozy friendly dive bar without a nice view like halfway inn, but the halfway in wings, fries, and staff don't hold a candle to 3rd base! The wait staff and management at 3rd base are what make it a Cheers type vibe. Don't sleep on it or be fooled by the unassuming outside. The place is dated, but very clean, fast, super welcoming, exceptional at what they do, a well oiled machine, and delicious! My mouth is watering and I can smell the wings and Cajun fries vividly in my memory while I write this. I'm kicking myself for driving by without trying them for forever. I'm addicted now!

Food was excellent. Service was excellent. It's not fancy but you can dress up or dress down and…read morestill feel comfortable. I got the surf and turf and it was a bit too peppery for me. She said they could adjust that for us, which I would request next time. And I'd love to have a return visit.

The portions of food are tiny, i got the 22oz ribeye which dosnt tell you the price probably bc its…read more50$ which for a 22oz ribeye in a nice restaurant isn't terrible except the ribeye they gave me was definitely less than a pound. Me and my date were able to eat our whole meal and not even be full, very disappointing for 100$ meal with a 20$ tip

The Scarlet Vetter says......this restaurant is great! It boasts a wide selection of enticing…read moreitems. From high end steaks to everyday burgers and then my favorite..... breakfast served all day. It is very spacious, so it was easy to get a seat even on a busy Saturday morning. Complete with a cozy fireplace, it is clean, well appointed and has an inviting atmosphere. The sound levels can be a bit much, and since it's a family place, you will occasionally be dealing with a screeching/screaming child. But overall, a very nice dining experience. Coffee and water came quickly with a complimentary bread and muffin basket. I ordered a special style eggs benedict with a croissant and melted Swiss cheese under an herbal hollandaise sauce, (instead of an english muffin) and my husband ordered a wonderful homemade turkey barley soup and the hot turkey sandwich entree. The food was very very good. It is worth every minute of the forty minute drive from our house!

It's, "fine dining for Portville". Not exactly a white-tablecloth sort of experience, it's a safe…read morechoice for families of all ages. The menu means towards middle-American classics: turkey sandwiches, meatloaf, pork chops, etc. The twist? There's a maple-syrup theme snuck in wherever it can go. The glaze on the baby carrots, on the pork chops, on the chicken breast? Yes! Maple! The service is skilled and efficient, the people-watching unparalleled, and the portions are enormous for the listed price. Figure two meals for the listed price, and it seems a better deal! Limited wine and beer list; gift shop on premises for maple syrup and jams as souvenirs.

Walking in it is a Bar. Now after you get past the bar there is a lot of seating. It is very…read morewelcoming once you get by the bar. The waitress was the friendliest person I have seen in this area in a long time. The food was amazing. I got the pull my finger chicken and pulled pork sandwich. It was huge and a lot more than I could eat at one sitting. I also got the buffalo chicken dip and may have filled up a little before I got my sandwich. We will be back here again even if it's out of the way. Great food with great service is hard to find these days.

I have made many bad decisions in my life at 11 o'clock at night, but this was absolutely not one…read moreof them. Coming into town late on a business trip, there aren't many options for food. Yelp helped me find Randy's just down the road from my hotel and I went for it. I had a great steak dinner, a cold beer, amazing, friendly service, and nonstop local flavor entertainment as patrons came and went. If this place was a reality TV show, I would be watching it. Give Randy's a try you won't regret it. The food is amazing and the people and the place are legendary.