Do yourself a favor and do not waste your time or money at this place. There is no shortage of…read moretrophy shops that can handle basic engraving and treat customers with a shred of professionalism--this is not one of them. I've used Trophies By Jay before, but this experience was so bad it permanently ended any future business. I dropped off two fantasy championship trophies for plaque engraving, which should be one of the simplest, most routine jobs imaginable. After an entire week of complete silence, I called for an update and was told, word for word, "Fantasy trophies are not the priority right now. I'll get to them when I can." No timeline. No apology. Just blatant dismissal. I gave it more time and called again four business days later, only to receive the exact same response. When I pressed for an ETA, I was told there was none and that he maybe could get to it by the end of the following week--nearly three weeks after drop-off for basic engraving. At that point, it was clear my order was never going to be treated with even minimal importance. Rather than taking responsibility or communicating like a professional, the owner became openly hostile and combative on the phone, telling me to come pick up the trophies so he "didn't have to deal with" me asking for updates. When I arrived to retrieve them and calmly stated I would be leaving a review, he had a full meltdown--stormed into the back room, started yelling, and ordered me out of the store like a child throwing a tantrum. Yes, the physical work is passable--but that is completely overshadowed by the astonishing level of arrogance, disrespect, and contempt shown toward paying customers. The owner clearly does not value people's time, does not understand customer service, and should not be running a business that requires any interaction with the public. If you value professionalism, communication, or even basic human decency, take your business anywhere else. This was hands down one of the worst customer service experiences I've ever had, and I will never return. I strongly recommend others avoid this place entirely.

Needed a last minute trophy, Jay had it ready in an hour. He asked how much I wanted to spend and I…read moresaid around $50. He had the trophy ready for pickup an hour after I reached out, and only charged me $35. Nice guy great business highly recommend

This shop is perfect. Plenty to choose from and a wonderful staff to help you. This shop is very…read morecentrally located on Jericho Turnpike on the East side of Mineola with plenty of street parking. (no parking lot.). I've used this shop for many years producing trophies, plaques and other various wall hangings for the different organizations to which I belong. Their selection is plentiful and they produce the engraved finished product very timely. They know their inventory well and can properly guide you once you tell them what you're looking for. Their pricing is extremely favorable for all the specialized services they offer. KUDOs to the team at Mineola Trophy

Perfect job. Placed shield and lettering was just great. Amazing display of different plaques and…read moretrophies in the store. They do amazing work.

Amazing place and very friendly staff. Got a wallet engraved and it came out amazing!!!read more

I used to love coming to this shop, but Chris doesn't work there anymore (he has his own shop…read moreExcelsior) and the Hicksville Pro shop was bought by someone who doesn't know anything about bowling. Seems to me like they're missing the "pro". I wouldn't risk taking my equipment there. Not sure about the trophy side of the business, I just know everyone working there is new.

(1) Kind and Helpful Staff! (2) Quality Work (3) Reasonable Prices - Overall was very happy and…read morepleased with these guys. They work quick and did a wonderful job for my group. We will be back again. Owner is "Onsite" - Everyone is very helpful and they have a nice variety & selection of items to chose from. They were able to engrave my plaque in Hebrew - which was really awesome. They didn't make it into a whole big deal. Highly recommend! You will be very pleased with the quality of work from Crown Trophy - The New Hyde Park location ;-) - That is! :-)

Quick and very reliable. I'm far out east in Suffolk and venture to Ron + Claudia for each…read moretournament I run. Thanks always.

I had an absolutely amazing experience here. The same afternoon as my cousin's retirement party, I…read morerealized I needed a custom engraved gift. I called, hoping for a miracle, and the woman who answered Michelle was incredibly kind and helpful. She reassured me there were options. When I arrived, she had already set aside a few beautiful options and walked me through them. The plaque I chose turned out absolutely perfect. Brian did the engraving quickly and flawlessly. As a retired officer himself, he understood how meaningful this gift was, and it showed in his work. The engraving was beautiful, and the quality exceeded my expectations. The pricing was extremely reasonable, especially for custom work done so quickly. My cousin loved it, and I couldn't be happier!!!! I'm so grateful for their kindness and professionalism. I will definitely be recommending them and returning in the future.

Brain was great, I needed a wine glass engraved for my daughter, I called him the day before the…read moreevent, and he said he would try his best, his professionalism and prompt reply was greatly appreciated. the wine glass was a hit and the price was very reasonable. Highly recommend this business for your engraving needs. Thanks brain

I wish I found this place sooner. I got a trophy and a hat made here and they do great work. Very…read morefast service. The owners are very friendly and helpful. The prices are very reasonable, I expected to spend more. I will definitely be coming back and recommending this place to every one.

I needed to buy an engraved joke gift for my son, and hoped to have it created immediately. I…read morecalled Absolutely Trophies. Not only was Corey accommodating, but he did a fabulous job. We had my son 's personalized Fantasy Football Champion trophy in under an hour. It was perfect. My son totally loved it. Thank you, Corey, for making our day. I would recommend Absolutely Trophies to anyone seeking any type of engraved commemoration. Corey is absolutely fantastic!

Came to get a champagne bottle engraved.... Rendering was sent the same night I dropped off the…read morebottle and I was able to approve it and pick it up the next morning. Turnaround was great especially since I was last minute. Thanks guys!

Outstanding service. Marc was great. Fulfilled a large order on a few days notice with no fuss…read more Highly recommend.

The staff was awesome! Dj answered all my concerns over the phone and the item look so much better…read morein person. What can I say. Very good work here.