Gary and his staff came highly recommended. My wife's engagement ring needed to be repaired. Her ring never left our sight and the repair was completed in a matter of minutes. The ring looks as great now as it did the day I bought it for her 25 years ago! !Everyone there is very nice and knowledgeable. I will make my future jewelry purchases there ! Joe read more

My fiance and I ended up going to Gennaro to get our wedding bands since I wasn't thrilled with the place he got my engagement ring at and this place was extremely recommended on the Brides of Long Island Facebook group. I worked with Donna who assisted us with the bands, and Latisha (I think was her name) to get my ring re-sized and polished, and to fix a scuff in the finish caused by the other jeweler. All the work was done right in front of me and never left my sight. The experience was absolutely 10/10 and I definitely HIGHLY recommend them for your rings! read more

See all

I had a very disappointing experience with this business. I initially brought in two rings, one for reshaping and another for a diamond replacement and repair. The ring that was repaired was significantly over-polished, and I was given a replacement diamond that did not match the quality or grade of the existing diamonds in the ring, which was visibly noticeable. I returned to the store, where I was told the diamond grade and gold weight had not been recorded, though they acknowledged the over-polishing issue and diamond grade issue. I was then informed that a casting would be ordered so my original diamonds could be reset due to the over-polishing. However, when I returned, I was told the casting could not accommodate my diamonds because they were different sizes--meaning the stone measurements were not taken before the casting was ordered. At that point, I was told a fully custom ring would need to be made to fit my diamonds, which made me very hesitant. Eventually, the custom ring was completed, but I was not satisfied with the result. The color of the gold appeared different, and I was never informed that the original ring's weight had not been documented. I later called to confirm whether the ring was solid gold and was told it was. However, only a few months after receiving the new ring, it has significantly bent. My previous ring lasted 6-7 years without any structural issues, so this level of bending so quickly is very concerning. Overall, what started as a repair issue turned into an ongoing problem with communication, quality, and craftsmanship. I am very disappointed with the final result and the overall experience. read more

My engagement ring and wedding band had to be resized, Irene, Kay, German, & Sergei all had a part in it. I heard about this place on the TV said that your diamond never leaves your site well if that's not the truth I don't know what is. From the minute I got there I was with my rings everyone was so nice and explained what was going on the whole time. Prices are high, but the job was great. Thank you everyone. Mare read more

Amazing experience getting me and my sister's tennis bracelets resized and extra clasp added. We came all the way from the North shore and it was definitely worth the drive! Cindy was super friendly and attentive and the jeweler Ben was very meticulous. We were able to watch as our bracelets were resized, which gave us peace of mind. Overall great experience and look forward to coming back! read more

Amazing customer service from Cindy and Ivette, gorgeous jewelry. I had a small repair that they were able to manage on the spot.

My engagement ring broke and I had it fixed at Gennaro Jewelers. The associate who helped me was Courtney and she could have been nicer or more helpful. My ring never left my sight and the professionals who fixed it were masters at their trade. I will alway go back to get all my jewelry fixed there. Thank you. read more

Very honest, trustworthy and pristine work. Friendly, helpful and professional. I would recommend Gennaro Jewelers to anyone that need professional and experienced service. read more

A wonderful experience! I knew that my husband and I were in good hands the moment we walked in the jewelry store. Eric greeted us, and made the entire experience of replacing my worn out wedding ring very pleasant and educational. I recommend (without reservation) Gennaro Jewelers to anyone looking to purchase jewelry. Thank you so much! read more

Always a pleasure! Courtney is the best! Got my ring resized and a little something for myself in an hour.

Honestly best on Long Island, Integrity and quality service ..... Will return for all my jewelry needs! read more

Went to have my husband's antique watch evaluated for fixing. While we were waiting Courtney offered to clean our wedding rings for free while Laura collected the necesssry paperwork for the watch repair. Great atmosphere!! Wonderful service! read more

They are extremely cautious of jewelry. Once purchased or getting items to be fixed. They are always diligent and have the item in plain view and if they move around the store they raise the item over their heads. The place is usually very busy but they have staff to accommodate. Prices are very reasonable and I loved Erin who assisted me both times I went there. A strong recommendation from me. read more

See all

Great service! Knowledgeable and extremely helpful staff. Your jewelry gets treat with the utmost care and it NEVER leaves your site. I went to get a ring resized. They explained everything to me, let me watch the process from start to finish, my ring was resized and back on my finger within an hour. You are aware of the whole process from start to finish and that was so reassuring to me. I will recommend anyone to Gennaro Jewelers. read more

Diana at Gennaro Jewelers was an absolute pleasure from the first moment my husband and I met her. She was very knowledgeable, professional and explained the entire process for having my engagement ring reset with a new wedding band. We learned so much ! Only wish we went to this jeweler years ago! Would highly recommend Diana at Gennaro! In fact , all of the employees were exceptional, pleasant and professional. read more

Casey was awesome....helped me with ring sizing and the purchase of new jewelry. Very patient and friendly!

We came in today and had the absolute privilege of working with Cindy. My husband needed a new wedding band due to his being lost and while we were there we worked on finding a beautiful pair of stud earrings for me. Cindy treated us like family which really made her stand out. We will for sure be back to see Cindy in the future for all of our needs. read more

Gennaro Jewelers - The beautiful new band - Jewelry Near Me - Bellmore, New York

This is a jewelry store like no other. Prices are phenomenal. Associates are friendly and more importantly, very knowledgeable. They offer services while you wait with staff who can replace watch batteries to actual stone setting replacement or repair. They are also first responder friendly. If you need anything from an engagement ring to a watch or beautiful first responder pieces too. Go to Genaro Jewelers. read more

I bought my fiancées engagement ring at Gennaro's and Angela and the team were amazing. The process was extremely detailed and well thought out and the knowledge Angela has gives you a great sense of confidence in your purchase. It truly does feel like a life long relationship when buying jewelry here and I understand why my grandparents and aunts and uncles continue using Gennaro's. 10/10 would recommend! read more

Always a positive experience. Helpful, honest salespeople. They stand by their products.

We ordered an NYPD medallion and necklace for my son for Christmas with his badge number. Came out awesome. Staff was friendly quality of purchase was excellent. I would certainly recommend GENNARO JEWELERS. read more

I had my 58-year-old engagement ring repaired today at Gennaro jewelers. I received extraordinary service from Adriana and Gary. My ring never left my sight while it was being repaired. The cost was very reasonable for the amazing job that the jewelers did. My ring looks new. It was cleaned and polished. Thank you again Adriana and Gary for your excellent service. read more

Tina was super sweet and helpful when I came to get my rings resized. She made sure they were polished, fit perfectly, and all for a fair price. read more

Shopping for an engagement ring isn't the easiest but the team over at Gennaro has made the experience so easy and amazing. They really focused on the small details and made the dream ring i wanted for my future wife come to life! Special thanks to Angela, Adrianna and Armando. read more

Amazing, incredible, everything you need in a jeweler! A friend had recommended Gennaro when I needed to get a piece of jewelry appraised. I went on a chilly Saturday morning and was let in by security and noticed how crowded it was! It's not a huge space by any means but they somehow make it work. I was immediately greeted by Laisha who was AMAZING! She quickly found a spot at the counter for us and put my jewelry on a color-coded hook so I would always see it while it was being cleaned. YOUR JEWELRY NEVER LEAVES YOUR SIGHT HERE! I cannot stress that enough. I have anxiety and that alone made me feel so much better. After cleaning my piece, Laisha explained the process. They put the jewelry on a microscope that then shows it around the shop on TVs so we can see the number of the stone and that becomes your ID number. Such a cool process to see a number you normally would never see all magnified. After that it is brought to the appraiser's station while your jeweler holds it up above their head and you follow them (again it never leaves your sight). The appraiser was great and fast. She jotted down her notes, took photos, and printed everything up for insurance purposes. After that I was back with Laisha who gave us some goodies and allowed me to add an item to my wishlist. Yes, they have a wishlist and yes, you should use it. After paying and chatting it was back into the chilly air and on my way home with my appraisal in hand. Such a wonderful experience. Also my piece has never looked this shiny before. Impressive. read more

We are from Bronx/Yonkers and were looking for a reliable place where to have my wife diamond ring enlarge , and we couldn't find a better place, this is the place to go if you have any jewelry repairs or if you are looking to purchase , as I saw the large variety of jewelry they stock. The staff was very professional , beyond our expectations, Erin the young lady who took care us, we were very impressed with her professionalism and help through the whole process, then German and Kay the care and workmanship absolutely amazing . Thank you so much for everything and God bless you ! We hope to come back soon and refer anybody who needs your services. read more

Earlier this month, Cindy helped me and my soon-to-be fiancé find the perfect setting for an engagement ring with a preexisting stone we had. She was very attentive, answered all our questions, and walked us through the process with ease! I highly recommend going to Gennaro for all your jewelry needs! read more

Gennaro Jewelers - Engagement Ring - Jewelry Near Me - Bellmore, New York

Thank you to Cindy and Nathan for doing a great job helping me and my family! They were quick, professional and friendly.

Our experience with Gennaro Jewelers was wonderful! I would rate them with ten stars, if I could. I needed to have my engagement ring repaired. Adriana, Laura, Michelle, and Jared dropped what they were doing to help. There were a lot of people in the store; they were extremely busy and went above and beyond to help. The problem was solved! Bhin and Hector, the technicians who measured and set the stone, were fabulous. Their attention to detail, accuracy, and craftsmanship is outstanding. The care and attention we were shown by all who work there was impeccable. My husband and I highly recommend this jewelry store. Look no further. Go to Gennaro's!! read more

We absolutely love Gennaro Jewelers! Angela took her time explaining everything we needed to know about diamonds for my engagement ring. She assured us that If they didn't have what we wanted, their jewelers could make it! She treated us like family! Highly recommend read more

They are the best in bellmore village always does great work fixing and has beautiful jewelry ! They have been in business for as long as I'm alive and while I'm in Bellmore , I would go nowhere but Genaro read more

My fiancé bought my engagement ring online and I didn't want to have to ship my ring out for a few weeks to get it resized. After a year of engagement and doing a lot of research, I finally decided on Gennaro to get my ring resized. Beverly helped me initially with sizing my finger. I went from a size 7 to a size 5. She walked me through pricing and after confirming I was comfortable with the cost (~$225), she went ahead to clean my ring. I was also taken downstairs to the gemologist who did the resizing work. I was told step by step on what he was doing. After resizing it, he allowed me to try it on. I wanted it a bit looser and he complied and then it fit perfectly! They also spot check each other so another gemologist tightened the prongs and inspected my ring. They also confirm that it's still your ring before and after the process by identifying a characteristic or an ID on the ring. I felt very pleased with their service and I loved that I could get my ring back on my finger within 45 minutes versus 3-4 weeks at other retailers. I also decided to buy my wedding band there and that was a smooth process as well. I recommend coming to Gennaro around 10am on Saturday to miss the morning rush of people. They are always busy! I will come back here for my jewelry needs! read more

Although the store was crowded we were serviced w/in 5 minutes of entering. We worked a/ an amazing person, Cindy Delorantis, who explained and took us through all of their procedures for an appraisal. She was efficient, articulate, poised (in the midst of a late Saturday afternoon crowd) and highly instructional /informational. We followed Cindy through the different areas in the store to clarify what the steps being taken were. They say that they do the appraisal's while you wait and watch ~ and Yes! They actually do that! ~ We watched the jewelry being cleaned, put under a camera and put up on a TV screen to show what it visually looked like and then we walked w/ Cindy over to the actual appraiser. He (Jared Baglietto) took his time w/each step and Cindy continued to check back w/ him and explain to us, while we watched. When he was done, Cindy took the piece back and had us check on the TV screen again as she showed it on the camera, and she cleaned it and then she explained all of their pricing procedures. The entire 'process' was professional, smooth and Cindy made it reassuring and pleasant. I have had appraisal's elsewhere but this will be my first thought for going for/ or to any jewelry establishment for any purchase,service and attention~ based on the quality and and attention of the staff I encountered. read more

I recently had a custom ring made here and it was the best decision ever. When my dad passed away he left me a ring that was way too big for me to wear. For years I wanted a replica made so I can carry a piece of him with me. After meeting with Angela I knew that it would be possible to have the ring I always wanted made. Other places over the years would give vague estimates and also lied about the stone (the original ring is black onyx and one jeweler said it was coral). She helped so much and you could see she actually cared about helping me ring the best option for what I was looking for. Instead of making a mold of the ring, we went with taking separate pieces and making them into a new ring and carve out the feather design on the sides to look as close to the original ring as possible. When the ring was done and I finally got to wear the ring it not only looked like my dad's ring, but it was also a bit of my style as well. I love this ring and can't thank Angela and everyone else who helped with bringing this dream come to life. read more

I needed some repairs (and what turned out was a reset job) on an engagement ring that was a family ring and a lot of sentimental value. The team at Gennaro (especially Anthony, who walked me through the whole process so nicely) were so thoughtful and caring, and really took the time to help me understand everything that would happen, all while I waited there. My ring looks incredible, and I couldn't be happier with the service I received. read more

Angela helped my fiance create the most stunning ring. I can't believe I get to wear it forever! He said they were incredibly kind and easy to work with. looking forward to working with them again! read more

My old store Love that place and the owner too bought some nice items there. Gennaro a real gentleman and quality items... read more

great service and beautiful jewelry. We've been going for years now. We had Harris help us who was very patient and knowledgeable.

I had the BEST experience with Sean at gennaro jewelers! He helped me create a custom piece and was there with me from start to finish! The final ring was more beautiful then my wildest dreams. I will be back and I'm sending all my friends :) read more

Just received the custom made NMSP pendant that Gennaro did for my wife. It is absolutely gorgeous and my sweetie LOVES it. Laura walked me through the custom process and was VERY patient with my many requests. A great product from great jewelers! Don't hesitate to let them do the magic for you!! B read more