Cool place. We go there for St. Patrick's. But will probably go there more often. Good food, good beer, good vibe. Service is friendly and prompt. Really like this place. read more

Great hole in the wall with good finger food and great drinks. Came for book club hosted by Brooklyn Public Library--Books and Brews. Great group of book lovers. I will definitely return! read more

See all

I'll keep this short but honest. Absolute worst burger I have ever had in my 44 years of life!!! I order the blue cheese burger with tater tots. The meat is a frozen patty and they used blue cheese dressing rather than the actual blue cheese crumble. The tater tots are hard as a rock. It's almost impossible to ruin a tater tot in the whole tater tot existence. I can't believe somebody actually works in a kitchen and produce this disaster of meal. Don't ever try this place! read more

The Gather Inn Again - Where's the Blue cheese crumble, it's not there because it's dressing! - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Very small local bar. It has a family like atmosphere kinda like Cheers. Everyone knows your name. I don't know if that's a good thing sometimes. Either way we were treated well as we were with some locals. read more

The Gather Inn Again - The entrance - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We decided to order from this restaurant because of the great reviews. But I was sadly disappointed. The food arrived warm. I ordered the chicken BBQ nachos (sorry folks, don't like sour cream). The avocado was not a bright green, but ok, it was the evening & avocado does not like to be left out. The BBQ chicken was very good. BUT...I was halfway through my meal when I found a used diabetic test strip and lancet in my food. I was mortified! That is just disgusting. It is also a health and safety issue. My son immediately called The Gather Inn Again, had to leave his name and number. The owner did get back to him today. Unfortunately the owner #jaimedenardomicucci (Instragram name) was extremely rude. We also call Uber, though we know they only deliver and they were floored that such a thing even happened! And P.S. Uber called us back today to see how things were and inquired about any health issues. A shout out to Uber for being kind and considerate throughout this ordeal. Unlike the owner. Thank you Uber. I posted the same picture here on Instragram and the owners response was totally unacceptable. I was going to copy & paste her response, but then I thought better of it and screen shot her accusations and my response. She accused me of photoshopping the pic. And basically that I was lying. Why in the name of all the G-ds & G-ddesses would I make up such a thing? I never ordered from you before. And it is not like I was a "Karen" and b*tched about a piece of hair in my food. This is appalling! This is a health and safety issue. This is not something that happens all the time. Hair in the food -- yes. Used test strips & needles -- a hard NO!!! I was so sick about this all night. I went to the doctor's today and he was very angry that a restaurant would just disregard something like this. He immediately tested me for HIV (highly unlikely but better safe then sorry) and Hepatitis A, B & C (highly likely). I have to wait 6 weeks to see if any symptoms start to appear. So while she is accusing me of lying, I have wait 6 weeks to see if I am sick with something. So to sum up this drama.... A). I will NEVER order from this place again B). The owner is rude and totally disrespectable toward their customers C). Clearly they do not give a crap about their business read more

The Gather Inn Again - BBQ Chicken Nachos w/ used diabetic test strip and lancet (needle) - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Came here on a Yelp recommendation in the Gerritsen Beach area and decided to come for brunch. Unfortunately we came on a Sat and they weren't serving brunch... BUT we were in luck! The bartender/waiter asked the chef if we would be able to order something from the brunch menu so we were able to get omelets and tater tots! OMGOSH those tater tots were amazing! and a HUGE portion! for $2! Best deal ever. I got a spinach mushroom omelet and the bf got a mushroom cheese omelet also very reasonably priced! Would definitely come back for brunch! read more

The Gather Inn Again - The bar - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I had my son's birthday party at The Gather Inn Again & everything was perfect. The staff is friendly & the food is always good. It's always my go to when I order in. read more

Amazing food and service!!! Ask Kaitlyn about the new home made dip. It's delicious!

Ordered through Uber eats and am absolutely disgusted. The "French dip sandwich" is boiled roast beef that I wouldn't even give to a dog to eat. The sliders came with cheese when they specifically ask if we would like to add cheese since they are not normally supposed to come with it. The onion rings look like they were cooked so many times they are almost black and taste like pure oil. The wings are dried out and burnt like chicken jerky and were bare wings instead of the buffalo wings we thought we were getting. read more

The Gather Inn Again - a roast beef sandwich - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The Gather Inn again has been my place to go with my family for many years now! Food is always amazing, the owner is always there to make sure everything is perfect! Anytime I go into Brooklyn New York it's one of my first stops. Neighborhood place with top of the line service and great people. read more

Went to the Gather Inn yesterday for lunch with a friend. The food was amazing. Fresh, and delicious. Had the bbq chicken cauliflower nachos and loaded tater tots. Staff was friendly. Very attentive and company was great. I would absolutely recommend going in. Getting some food. A few drinks and just have fun. It was a good time read more

The Gather Inn Again - Loaded Tots - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Felt compelled to give another visit to this new Gerritsen Beach staple. Again, the place does not fail to deliver on the neighborly atmosphere, service and quality. The menu is still a homage to the local crowd and gets fleshed out with down-to-earth specials like a $10 Meatloaf over Mashed w/Mushroom Gravy or a $9 Shepard's pie. Add to that, the $2 cans of Bud and you've got a magical night of local skulduggery all ready for you at The Gather Inn Again. read more

The Gather Inn Again - Husky Burger with perfectly done Tots. That's pub eats! - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Another delicious meal for dinner tonight. Daughter home from college and it's a must have for her. Loaded Keto Nachos out of this world. Caesar wrap so fresh. Breakfast Burger is one of a kind. Topped it off with a slice of New York cheesecake to complete. I would add a photo but it's all gone read more

The Gather Inn Again is simply rather amazing. The menu items were really good and the prices are really reasonable. Absolutely yummy and healthy. And employees were really kind and helpful. Overall it was a wonderful experience. read more

Ordered here a few times. Most of the time it was good but a few times it was horrible . A hit or miss. The blue cheese for the wings were runny watery. The fries were ice cold and greasy. Certain things were somewhat forgivable/tolerable if you like a place enough. But THE WORST thing was when I bit into a big SCREW embedded in my quesadilla. This is unforgivable and there is no excuse for something like this so dangerous to happen. I bit right down on this SCREW and my tooth crunched ; I was in so much pain. Thank god it wasn't worse. When I called the establishment the person apologized and I got refunded but they didn't sound at all as apologetic as I think they should have been . For this experience I will NEVER eat from here again and don't recommend anyone risking it due to dangerous inconsistencies. read more

Great local bar the kind you can hardly find any more. The food is top notch, last time I was there tried the chicken wings, potato croquettes. Local DJs, sports on the big screens and ice cold beer. Tonight they have spaten Octoberfest on tap which is a excellent seasonal addition. Plenty of outdoor seating facing the ball fields across the street. The interior is enormous and even pre covid it offered social distance on some nights. read more

Best burgers around. Taco salad is amazing. The prices are great. Staff is always friendly. We are repeat customers for sure

$14 for burger with a frozen patty and burnt fries is ridiculous. I've not had a burger this bad since I was in public school. Salad was not fresh and barely had any chicken on it, disappointing considering that's a $3 add on. Perhaps this place should change its name to The Gather Inn Never Again. read more

Just ordered in from grub hub. This was my 2nd order experience with them. The first time I got a soup and wings. The soup was so oily and wings were mostly fried shell and extremely greasy. Months later I figured let me give them another try with other items. I'm disgusted. The chilli cheese was $6.50 and container was barely half full. In addition to that there was puddles of oil that seeped through the container. I was impossible to have a spoonful without a mouthful of oil. It was so insanely spicy you couldn't taste anything, and there was no indication in description it was spicy. It gets worse.. I ordered veggie wrap and I am appalled. The description says house veggies. Granted that could be any variety. The sad part is this sorry excuse for a wrap had NOTHING but onions and green peppers. Not a piece of broccoli, cauliflower, zucchini, nothing. Who on earth would ever order a wrap with raw green peppers and onions? They have some nerve to charge $9.50 for that. The tater tots on the side are the only decent thing I was able to eat. And they are mushy and flavorless, zero seasoning. Safe to say I'm done with this place. read more

See all

Best place in Brooklyn! Staff is very welcoming! Food is always on point, we eat here 3 times a week

Love this place! Food is great, never disappointed, go here every time I'm back in Brooklyn. The spicy BBQ sauce on their wings is the best and the Irish nachos can't be beat. read more

The food is delicious and the prices are right. There is always a neighborhood event like brunch with Santa or Halloween Dinner for the family. It's a great neighborhood place. read more

Everything you could want, great people, great food, great service...old school Brooklyn at it's best!

Not wasting my breath on this place. Steer clear!!! Also, not a hospitable crowd. Seems like if you are not from around there, then you're not wanted there. Food is not worth having (considering the prices)...lots of frozen product and you will know when you take a bite. read more

Great place, food, drinks, friendly, clean music. Relaxation

The other reviews made this sound like it was gonna be an amazing place. We found it on a whim after playing some mini golf. I came here on a Sunday afternoon and it was basically a sports bar with food. The Burger was okay, didn't taste homemade tasted frozen. The best part was the tater tots! Service was great though! read more

Great local pub. Has a nice family atmosphere where it seems everybody knows everybody. The staff is friendly and very helpful as well. Food is great and i give a clap to any establishment that lets you choose between fries and TATER TOTS!!!! State of the art jukebox as well with thousands of music choices from multiple genres. pool table available as well. Its kind of in the middle of nowhere, but definitely a gem. read more

This place is a hidden treasure. The staff is friendly and warm. The owner is hospitable. The bar food is excellent, I love the buttersteak on garlic bread. read more

The Gather Inn Again - New American Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Good food and exceptional customer service! I ordered online and they were out of one of the items I wanted. After several unsuccessful attempts to reach me by phone the delivery person knocked on my door to find out what I wanted in place of the missing item. Will definitely order from them again in the future! read more

I ordered the cheesesteak and chicken quesadilla. Both were good, but the cheesesteak could use more meat and cheese and the quacamole was brown. All the flavors are great and I will order from them again. I will definitely try other things... read more

Ordered on UberEATS the food was horrible had to throw it out. Food was burnt, the soup was spilled in the bag so the soup in the dirty paper cup they provided was non existence. Wings salty and burnt. Ordered corn fritters they only gave me 4 in a big pan. Just horrible will never order from this place ever in life again. Waste of money and time. The only positive thing I can say is that the delivery guy was friendly other than that the food sucked! Avoid this place at all costs! read more

I'm absolutely disgusted!! Placed an order on seamless an HOUR later y'all cancelled my order claiming you were closed. Thanks for keeping my son hungry and now eating cereal for dinner. Plus you mess up my bank situation over a holiday week by refunding and not reversing the charge. Will NEVER Order from these irresponsible uncaring people again. read more

Reminds me of an olde Irish Pub, good mixture of spirits, imported brews, and great domestic beer on tap in a bottle or can. The food is all fresh made and off the scale burgers with a side order of fries, tots or salad. Menu is wide ranged and mouth watering delicious cooked to perfection and proudly served professionally and on time. All the barkeepers are fast, intelligent, funny, and friendly. If your looking for an ordinary local pub then this is not for you. This place is loaded with atmosphere excellent staff new menus and ice cold beer. So next time you want a cozy place to feel at home, you won't be sorry. So come out to the Gat & Let the good times roll! read more

dont order they run out of food charge you and tell you it's your fault... what a scam!

I loved this bar; this was exactly what my friend and I had been looking for when we embarked upon our Gerritsen Beach adventure. (Basically, once I read the NYTimes article, http://www.nytimes.com/2002/03/03/realestate/if-you-re-thinking-living-gerritsen-beach-secluded-peninsula-south-brooklyn.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm, I have wanted to go here-- particularly because I come from a family of first responders and spent my childhood in a little lakeside city of 5,000.) Gerritsen Beach reminds me of Indiana in the best possible way-- except that there are docks along the water in lieu of refineries! Clearly this is a place where everyone knows everyone, people are friendly, and streets are ridiculously safe. My friend Ray and I wandered in after checking out the Veteran's Wall and Marine Park. We were so pleasantly greeted by the bartender, as well as all of the patrons at the bar. The place was decked out for Halloween, too-- which always warrants an extra star in my book. There were also seals hanging on the paneled wall for each of the armed services (yet another star... so really this review is up to seven stars). Immediately the bartender (a sweet, grandfatherly figure) approached our table and asked us what we wanted. Lickety split, and two frothy beers were placed in front of us... for the price of four dollars. (Amaaaaazing.) The menu was traditional American food, again in the best way. Tater tots! ("Napoleon, give me some of your tots!") Ray and I both ended up going for the steak sandwich... which was HUGE. I can eat and eat, but this sandwich defeated me. It's a shame that it did, because the steak was sliced ever so thinly, yet wasn't dry. It was juicy and dribbled down my chin (gross, yes, but candor is essential in Yelping!), complete, of course, with melted Velveeta. There were more tater tots on my plate than I think I ate in all of my years of preschool. Anyway, the people were all so extremely nice. They were all pals, but they made sure that we felt comfortable and welcomed. This is clearly a center of socializing for Gerritsen Beach, as I saw signs on the walls for an upcoming Halloween party on November 2. Definitely a great choice. Great prices. Great people. Seven stars. AND free WiFi! read more

Love the atmosphere of this place,made me feel at home. The beef quesadilla was excellent and the service was top notch. The two girls I ate with said the cook that works Saturday is hot. read more

Came here for an engagement party and I was pleasantly surprised with this spot. They have a large bar area and also a separate private room for parties. The fried pickles, tater tots, and mozzarella sticks were great to munch on throughout the night. Our server, Danielle, was extremely nice and kept coming around to make sure everyone was okay. Also, the drinks here are very reasonably priced! read more

Thought I'd stop in for a quick afternoon indulgence but boy was I in trouble ! All I ever wanted was a classy amaretto sour - 20 min later bartender decides he is fresh out .... Then I ask for peach schnapps ... Guess agAin ! SOLD OUT ... I ended up being served toilet water and a splash of cranberry - washed it down with cheese fries and a slice - bad gas for a month - never again! read more

Let me start by this; I grew up in Gerritsen Beach. When I went to the Gather Inn growing up, it was definitely NOT this. Yay! Great food, new menu, owners who actually come to greet you is a new and much needed addition to the neighborhood. I come from NJ for the 50 cent wings and the tots. All the apps are amazing. The owner Jaime will go over and beyond to make your experience amazing. I threw my brother's surprise 40th there. The party went off perfectly because of Jaime. read more

CLASSSSSSSSSY place to come during work....u can bring ur own jello shots NO PROBLEM!!! They are good at making any drinks u want!!!! HOLLA BACK! read more