Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Good Wolf

    4.2 (55 reviews)
    Closed 5:00 pm - 12:00 am (Next day)
    Updated 2 weeks ago

    The Good Wolf Photos

    THE GOOD WOLF ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - The Good Wolf

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Charred Boulevardier
    Mark T.

    One thing was missing: top down lighting; otherwise a fantastic experience! I'm a big fan of Little Bad Wolf next door, and finally made it a point to stop in and visit the neighbor. It's not flashy, it is less busy, and if you don't know... sneeze and you'll miss it. The vibe is dark and moody, with notes of brown and dark blue. The art also fits the overall atmosphere well. I question, however, the large TV screen that seemingly only shows their name. It's not intrusive, just a bit weird. However, it was so dark that seeing the menu was more challenging than it needed to be. I can light it up with my phone, though I do (and did) so at the risk of being 'that guy'. Top-down lighting folks, I see the lamps up there, too! I ordered: - Oysters (4 as-is, 4 with mignonette on the side) - Duck Gnocchi - Sticky Toffee Pudding The oysters were medium-sized and excellent quality! They were delightfully briny and without a hint of cartilage or sand. The first order came with mignonette, and while enjoyable, being a bit of a purist, I put on a second order with mignonette on the side. Sure enough, I found myself adding it of my own accord. All the more evidence the kitchen knows what it's doing! Further proof? The Duck Gnocchi - the gnocchi themselves were soft and pillowy, more so than I've experienced up to this point. The duck in the dish was tender and soft as can be. The veggies (mirepoix) were sliced and cooked perfectly, adding texture, freshness and bulk (fiber?) without overpowering anything. To top it all off, breadcrumbs for a little crunch, and a mild sauce that tied everything together in perfect harmony. For the most important course, dessert, we have the Sticky Toffee pudding. A well cooked, well sauced helping of pudding, topped with a large scoop of ice cream that slowly melted, transforming the flavor as you go. For drinks, I ordered the Charred Boulevardier and the Burnout. The Boulevardier was rich, sweet and savory, in contrast the Burnout was brighter and fresher, and still boozy. While neither drink was a smack to the face with alcohol, after getting up, I could feel the effects. In terms of their service, it was polite and attentive, and all items came out fast! The prices are okay, though if you love oysters, keep in mind they will set you back $4/each! Final verdict: There is nothing at The Good Wolf that I wouldn't happily order again. It is hard to choose a standout when everything was of a high caliber. I look forward to working my way through their menu, and continuing to feed the good wolf (props is you know the story of the Two Wolves).

    Chicken and Peppers - Lemon Herbed Jus and Fries
    Christopher V.

    I've been a patron of the Little Bad Wolf ecosystem (Gretel, Wolf & Co., the coffee, butcher, and grocer) since the beginning, and I really want The Good Wolf to succeed. The ingredients and concepts are clearly high quality, but unfortunately, the execution of several dishes during my last visit resulted in a mixed and ultimately disappointing meal. The Hits and Misses: Duck Gnocchi: The base flavor was wonderfully comforting, but the entire dish was heavily over-seasoned to the point of being too salty. Shrimp: High-quality shrimp, but they were dry and significantly overcooked. They would benefit greatly from being served with a simple garlic herb butter. Crab Cabbage Salad: The char on the cabbage was a pleasant touch, and the amount of crab for the price was fair. However, the dish was unbalanced; there was too much raw red onion, which completely overwhelmed the sweet, delicate flavor of the crab. Chicken and Peppers: The chicken was moist and of excellent quality, which I appreciated. Yet, it lacked basic seasoning and really needed salt. It was served with an extremely generous--to the point of being wasteful--portion of fries. The cocktails were the highlight of the night, perfectly balanced and well-made. The service was also a bit strange. I also overheard two other tables expressing frustration with their service timing and attentiveness. The potential here is huge, but until the kitchen tightens up on seasoning consistency and preparation timing, it's hard to justify a higher rating. 3.2 stars

    Piano and jazz mocktail
    Paul C.

    I came to The Good Wolf on a Friday night and I was surprised it wasn't busier! All the service staff were super friendly and helpful. The restaurant was very well decorated and felt sophisticated. I do wish they had a stricter dress code for the staff because some people's attire seemed too casual / not aligned to the restaurant's ambience in my opinion. I tried the following: -Piano and Jazz NA cocktail: it was good, a little too tart, but not bad for a NA option (4/5) -Cheese curds they were just okay (3/5) -Burger was phenomenal and had a nice spice to it (5/5) but unfortunately the fries were room temperature and definitely the low light of the meal (2/5) A solid four stars- I'd be happy to go back but I probably won't become a regular. The burger is definitely worth trying and if they clean up some details / make some easy adjustments to the food quality it could definitely become a 5-star stop.

    Steak tartare
    Caleb H.

    The service was excellent and the restaurant decor made an evening with friends feel just the right amount of elevated and laid back. The happy hour menu had great options and then when we ordered for dinner everything came out perfect. Maybe the best burger in Chicago?? Will have to go back and try again.

    Lemon Curd and Toffee Pudding

    Enjoyed everything. Ambiance is cozy and welcoming. Staff was exceptional and friendly, made a perfect dirty martini and espresso martini. We had the cheese curds which is a must do in any midwest bar but it's a tad elevated here with two dipping sauces and in tempura batter. We split the carbonara which was made perfectly- every bite I savored. He had the good burger which was great but a little overcooked. I had the artichoke parm - everything about it was awesome. Bread I have to say was the best part. We split both desserts and we were both full but managed to eat most of the dessert. Would recommend this now that we've tried both The Good Wolf and The Little Bad Wolf, both were great but I like the Good Wolf better for the menu and cozy atmosphere and the super friendly staff.

    Helen H.

    This place is a fancier sister to the Bad Wolf. Perfect for a romantic date night! I visited twice, and the lighting can get pretty dark depending on where you're seated. They don't take reservations, but I haven't had any issues being seated right away during the weekdays. Highly recommend the cottage fries. I love the thinly sliced potatoes with prosciutto complemented with the softest shaved manchego. It's a good size as well. The sticky toffee was amazing. It came out warm and the combination with ice cream was excellent. Gnocchi and duck was salty to me, and the dish was small for the price. The gnocchi itself was so soft and yummy though. There was fish dish that is no longer on the menu that was delicious and well seasoned. My friend enjoyed her carbonara as well. The carbonara is supposed to be one of the larger dishes so I would like to try that the next time I visit. The drinks here were great. I would visit the bar just for their cocktails. The service has been consistent both times. I can't wait to get the cottage fries again!

    Double Decker Sandwhich
    Jake H.

    didn't think a step up from Little Bad Wolf was possible, but they achieved it. Incredible food and awesome staff with a classy bar and bartender to boot. A perfect date spot. Cheese curds were unique, all the sauces were great in different ways and the breading really was great. The Carbonara and double decker both were phenomenal, with both being so different from each other but nailing the flavors. My wife had named this and one of the best Espresso martinis in the city. Love The Good Wolf and everything chef Kohli is doing.

    Gnocchi and duck
    Alexander B.

    I'm obsessed with this new place in our neighborhood, I really loved the gnocchi and duck and the toffee pudding was a blast Service was also great, if you like fancy vibes you're going to love the ambiance because lights and art are awesome, perfect for a date night!

    Monkfish, beef Wellington, cottage fries, cheese curds, sticky toffee, lemon dessert
    Yesenia M.

    If you've ever gone to Little Bad Wolf (which if you haven't then that's also recommended!), then Good Wolf is a must-visit. As the sister restaurant, it brings the same inviting atmosphere but elevates the dining experience with more refined flavors and creative dishes. The monkfish is a standout -- perfectly cooked and bursting with flavor. Don't skip the lemon dessert either, it's a delightful, refreshing finish to the meal. The service, drinks, and food were all top-notch, and the ambiance makes it a great choice for a date night or a casual get-together with friends. I'll definitely be returning! Highly recommend for anyone looking for a unique yet approachable fine dining experience. Can't wait to check it out again next time I'm in town!

    Reservation cancellation email

    See all

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of G S.
    0
    35
    0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Erin O.
    69
    21
    0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 5
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Eric M.
    109
    12
    3

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of M G.
    0
    5
    0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - The Good Wolf

    You might also consider

    Larry's

    Larry's

    4.3(66 reviews)
    1.2 miUptown
    $$

    Love the vibes and energy here always. They also have super fun trivia on Wednesdays and it's…read morealways a blast!

    Not sure how I missed this joint but so glad I found it. Larry's is a small cocktail bar in the…read moreLawrence House, which was built in 1830 and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Because it is located in the lobby of the apartment building, it is not something you see from the street. The bar itself is very small, but there are multiple seating options outside of the actual bar. You are permitted to take your drink to the lobby or to the outside patio area. Both are nice and allow for a pleasant drinking experience, but folks that live in the building sit there as well, on laptops or reading. The vibe of the bar is super chill, with this crazy red hue that I love. I am not a big cocktail person per se, but if you are into them like The Queen is, then you are in for a treat. There are also non-alcoholic selections for wines, beers and cocktails for those that require that. In addition they also have bubbles, so that is a win for me. In addition to great cocktails and bubbles, they also do "Summer Movie Nights" on the patio. You can bring a blanket, grab a drink and enjoy. Larry's does not serve food, but you can order something to eat from The Uptown Deli (which has good sandwiches). There is street parking on Sheridan and it is about two blocks from the Lawrence Street El stop (once it opens again). Now that I am aware of its existence, I will be back to chill and have bubbles, and maybe catch a movie.

    Photos
    Larry's
    Larry's
    Larry's

    See all

    Sweethearts Bar - Interior/Vibe

    Sweethearts Bar

    4.2(10 reviews)
    0.3 miAndersonville, Edgewater

    This bar is so adorable! The name alone drew me in lol. We got there right when they opened at 4pm…read more The bartender was really friendly and asked us about our plans for the day. We ordered a Saturn and a Hemingway Daiquiri. Both were sweet, refreshing, and delicious! Of course we had to order the jello shots that come with a little candy heart on top. I'm already planning my next visit here to attend the Lover's Lounge event.

    If I'd just stopped in for a drink or two, we would be fine. My rating would be a three or a four,…read moreand 'have a nice day.' Alas, my catchphrase being "I eat and I know things" means ordering food is a given. That was a mistake, but not as bad as whoever made the decisions behind the Heartbreaker Burger. Let me start with the good. I started with the M&M shot, a simple yet tasty, and not face-melting combo of mescal and Montenegro. I drink spirits neat, so YMMV, but something I wouldn't mind ordering again. Next, I tried the Vieux Carre: a solidly executed classic with balanced flavors and spirit-forward without going overboard. While the bevvies are not mind-blowing, the prices are low - In the year of our Lord 2026, $12-13 for a cocktail in Chicago is almost unheard of outside of happy hour. The vibe is old-timey and retro. Loads of wood, exposed brick, and wallpaper that your great aunt probably had. There are a few game-heads on the walls, for I guess great uncle likes to hunt. There is also a piece of art on the walls that, feels almost like it can go in a museum, but not quite. Let's say this: gentlemen, I would advise against brining a date here, lest you be tempted to look a little too long. Alas, we've now arrived at the abomination that is the, perhaps aptly named, Heartbreaker burger. To start, it was wrapped in foil and tasted through and through as though it's been sitting under a heater for at least an hour. The lettuce within had time to wilt due to the heat, making it go from a positive addition, past neutral, and into negative. The patty missed the mark: In this case, Smasburger applies to the thinness, and not at all to a roasty, crispy, Maillard-y consistency. Between the thin piece of strongly favored meat, and bun a little too large and dense, all other ingredients lost their presence. Further, If felt the burger was so bready, I removed the top bun and turned it into a fork and knife affair. I'm all for burgers getting wider, rather than only so tall one can't open their jaw so far, but not like this. Hardly worth mentioning are the sides of Tater Tots and Queso. Both weren't heartbreaking, but at the same time, wholly unremarkable. Felt as though I could easily beat these with a quick stop at Aldi. I've no complaints about the service. Since I came right around opening, it was very quiet. Still, I was well-taken care of, and things came out relatively quickly. Final verdict: Sweethearts Bar makes inexpensive, solid classic cocktails in a mostly retro vibe. However, the alleged-smashburger left a bad taste in my mouth, literally and figuratively, spoiling the experience. Would return?: Probably not. There was nothing on the menu that I couldn't easily and cheaply recreate myself. Would recommend?: Also probably not. If you're looking to catch up with a group in a space without a TV, Sweethearts and its cheap drinks aren't a bad deal. For all other cases, I would not recommend.

    Photos
    Sweethearts Bar - Inside

    Inside

    Sweethearts Bar - Sidecar!

    Sidecar!

    Sweethearts Bar

    See all

    The SoFo Tap

    The SoFo Tap

    3.6(114 reviews)
    0.8 miUptown
    $

    I love this bar so much STILL…read more Gay, straight, whatever - just behave. We always end up chatting with fellow Andersonvillans when we go here. Daily specials. If you love dogs (is there a person who does not?) go here on a Saturday! It's DOG PARTY! I try to pet as many pups as I can, but truthfully, they are catching up with their dog friends. The perfect description of this place was uttered by my good friend, the legendary John B (may he RIP). It's a casual neighborhood bar that just happens to cater to a mostly gay clientele. Go here, make new friends. Pet dogs. Quaff a few.

    Popped in here on a Monday night and there was a small crowd here, but I just have to say, I love…read morethe modern feel of this place. Feels very clean! Their SPECIALS are to die for. I swear there is nowhere else in the Chicago area (at least that I've found) where you'll find daily specials that affordable. On a Monday night they had several specials, but we opted for the 'Big Ass Long Islands' which were huge and only $5 each. Considering inflation in 2022 as well as post pandemic pricing, this place and its daily specials reminds me of dive bar pricing from like 2015. You can literally munch of some free popcorn that cooks itself in the corner and change the music on the juke box as well. They also have a decent sized patio for those warmer days/nights! I'd love to come back here on a weekend and feel the vibe. I also must note that whoever the bartender was that took care of us as soon as we walked in, was very friendly and hospitable! I'll be back!

    Photos
    The SoFo Tap
    The SoFo Tap
    The SoFo Tap

    See all

    Nobody's Darling - Wine Down Wednesday! $20 Bottles of Wine & $7 Glasses of Wine

    Nobody's Darling

    4.6(93 reviews)
    0.3 miAndersonville, Edgewater
    $$
    Women-owned & operated
    Minority-owned & operated

    In honor of Women's History Month I would like to update my review of Nobody's Darling to state…read morethat the lovely owners of this fine establishment are still doing their thing. Nobody's Darling is not just to have a chat and cocktail, they offer quite a few events for folks to attend. Below are a few examples of the swinging times you can have there. In 2026 I am so happy that they are still in business and thriving. The vibe is still cool, the menu for the cocktails is still exciting and the crowd is eclectic. Wine Down Wednesday Unwind midweek with Happy Hour 5-7pm $7 glasses of wine $20 bottles Thursday: Pitch Your Peeps Help your friend find love (or vibes). Pitch them to the room - all relationship styles welcome. Feel Good Fridayz w/ DJ All The Way Kay Start the weekend right! Happy Hour 5-7pm DJ Kay live 8-11pm Sunday Karaoke All Day Happy Hour starting at 2pm Karaoke 5pm-8pm Sip.Sing. Repeat. Empanadas by De Luna Empanada 7pm-10pm DJ Gloria on the decks Cocktails flowing all night Friday, March 20 DJ Set 8-11PM

    Great drinks and no douchy "bro" energy to be found anywhere. I love this bar. The staff is so…read morefriendly and the vibe of the entire experience was very appealing. It's thought of as a gay bar and clearly that's a lot of the clientele, but all are welcome. Cocktails are delicious and run about $15 each. Pretty standard pricing. They have a good selection of n/a drinks and a menu for lower alcohol cocktails as well. Great neighborhood bar

    Photos
    Nobody's Darling - Lipstick Lover!

    Lipstick Lover!

    Nobody's Darling - Kahlo Margarita

    Kahlo Margarita

    Nobody's Darling

    See all

    Chicago Magic Lounge - Performance Bar, AKA David's Bar. Open Mon - Sat at 5:00 P.M. and Sunday afternoon.

    Chicago Magic Lounge

    4.6(465 reviews)
    0.6 miAndersonville, Ravenswood, Uptown
    $

    Didn't get to try the food but had a cocktail and it was delicious. Can I remember the name of it…read morenope lol but I would have it again. Service is great very attentive even if you sit in the second floor. I love the close up magic performances during cocktail hour. I would say if you are on the first floor especially in the front row you get more magicians performing. So that is definitely one thing I would change when I go next time. I will buy tickets for the first floor preferably in the front. I enjoy the performance it was great and entertaining it definitely flew by but afterwards you can go back to the main bar and see the show. Overall it it's very entertaining and a magical spot worth exploring

    Came by for a 4PM showing on a Sunday evening…read more Two of us ordered: french drop $15 maplewood son of juice $8 truffle fries $9 shrimp cocktail $24 ~$75 a tix Food was surprisingly decent, shrimp was quite good. You only need to arrive by 4. If you arrive earlier, you just sit at the bar -not supposed to film magic inside, tableside for an hour prior, was less impressed there since a few of them messed up / did the same trick as the group next to us John Carney was our headliner and he did a good job keeping the audience engaged, overall fun experience!

    Photos
    Chicago Magic Lounge - Live theater seven-nights-a-week.

    Live theater seven-nights-a-week.

    Chicago Magic Lounge - Looking for date night ideas? Look no further than Chicago Magic Lounge. We offer a unique experience you are not soon to forget.

    Looking for date night ideas? Look no further than Chicago Magic Lounge. We offer a unique experience you are not soon to forget.

    Chicago Magic Lounge - Upgrade to the "654 Club" to close your night out with more Close-Up Magic.

    See all

    Upgrade to the "654 Club" to close your night out with more Close-Up Magic.

    The Good Wolf - newamerican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...