1. The Mystic

    1. The Mystic

    0

    Santa Fe, NM

    Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Mystic

    3.8 (25 reviews)
    Closed 4:00 pm - 12:00 am (Next day)
    Updated 2 months ago

    Request information

    Response time

    1 hour

    Response rate

    100%

    Services - The Mystic

    Catering services

    Hotels

    The Mystic Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - The Mystic

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Trash
    Keely C.

    None of the hours were correct. It says it will charge your card on arrival or when the desk closes but we were charged an hour early. Okay, but when we tried to contact the desk there was no answer, it goes straight to voicemail without any message, just the beep. We get there in a downpour and while we have the code to the lock box there is no instructions on how to open it. The desk was locked up 15 minutes early but there was another guest pounding on the locked door with different complaints, so I stood by waiting for help. The restaurant/bar said it was open until 10, it too was already locked up at 8:45pm. It's a nice remodel of a drafty old motel but the draft is still there. There is no coffee in the room and the hours for breakfast are listed as both 7 & 8 am depending on where you're looking, and we had business to attend to. There is no microwave as advertised. The refrigerator buzzed loudly all night which was almost good white noise over the neighbors tv all night thru the paper thin walls. They had not emptied the trash basket. The beds are metal spring so they creaked every time we moved. The sink bowl takes up the entire counter. One of the products had been used Otherwise, cute.

    Back lounge
    John R.

    When my teenage son and I had to shelter from a crazy dust storm instead of camping, The Mystic was an amazing find that made a fallback plan into a trip highlight. The vision for transforming a classic motor inn into a modern Southwestern Oasis is impeccable. You still feel the vintage roots, but every surface and amenity has been updated for beauty and comfort. We stayed in room 11, but were handed a key with a rune symbol to locate it. Fun! The room has comfortable double beds with plenty of available outlets, a nice shower and a capable mini split air system. The hotel was full, but we were never bothered by noise from adjacent rooms. Parking was adequate for a full facility, and the gate/fence gave a little extra sense of security beyond a normal open hotel parking lot. The diner served a complimentary continental breakfast that was a good notch above the usual motel chain. And with all the nice servingware, it felt closer to a BnB than a hotel. I spent some extra time walking around and admiring the curated art and interior design. So much thought put into this place. The service and staff were super friendly and I enjoyed chatting with them about the place. We even receive a "neighbor" discount, as we came in from Texas. They said the owner comes in from Texas every couple of weeks to check in. Only a couple of opportunities would have made our experience even better. It took about 10 minutes to locate the front desk attendant when I arrived. Now, there was this huge wind storm happening, so I am sure they were busy battening the hatches. But maybe a way to page for service at the front desk would help. The same thing happened when we arrived at the diner for breakfast. No one around for a few minutes until I peeked into the kitchen. Just a simple ringer or maybe a camera to notify the staff that someone has arrived or needs service. From a facilities perspective, the door handle on our room was loose enough that it was tricky to lock/unlock with the key, but the deadbolt was nice and secure. Overall, The Mystic was a true highlight of our trip and I can't wait to come back and stay here with my partner.

    Hotel room closet
    Beth C.

    We enjoyed staying at the Mystic so much over the Holiday weekend! Conveniently located next to Jackolope on Cerrillos Rd, this boutique hotel is full of design inspo! We arrived early and grabbed a delicious bite at their cafe. Our server was very kind and helpful. They have a great little menu for the afternoon, and a happy hour starting at 5. The seating area in the cafe or lounge is comprised of several different spaces, plenty of space for groups and fireplaces. The room itself was sparse but had all the essentials for one night. We also enjoyed their delicious breakfast in the morning, which is included in your stay. This is an affordable option for Santa Fe and although it is quaint, I feel they have maximized their outdoor spaces well. We will be back!

    MUST READ: This happened on Saturday, May 24th around 7pm. Upon entering, the décor and aesthetic was beautiful! We sat down in the sofa area in the middle of the restaurant and ordered some drinks. 1. Our two drinks took about 30 minutes to come out, which is a while considering there weren't many people even at the restaurant, and they did not taste good at all. 2. We ordered one plain Mystic Burger - came with the toppings and wasn't plain. 3. one regular Mystic Burger (pepper jack listed on the menu) - came with cheddar and a hair melted into it 4. one Buffalo Bleu Grilled Chicken Sandwich - blue cheese is in the name of the item, on ingredient list, and comes on a potato bun...and they gave it to us with cheddar & NO blue cheese & on sliced sourdough, not a potato bun. 5. We asked for the regular burger with the hair to be switched out with a Buffalo Sandwich instead - this sandwich was brought out with pepper jack cheese versus cheddar like on the first chicken sandwich & again...no blue cheese. We asked for a side of blue cheese since neither sandwich came with it...and they brought us some which did not make sense as to why they didn't add it to the sandwich since they clearly have some in stock. 6. Lastly, as we were finishing our food, I found a cap nut at the bottom of the bowl of French fries I had been eating out the whole time. I am glad I saw it and that this order did not end up going to a child who might have swallowed this. I wish I has taken a picture of the actual item, but I was too shocked and just sat there with my jaw on the floor. (I attached what it looked like off of google images) I had never been through something like this at a restaurant nor any business I have been a customer at. The waitress hardly came to check on us and when we brought all of this to her attention, she didn't seem to care one bit. I feel like I am still in shock over this whole ordeal we went through.

    Beautiful spacious cafe
    Sam S.

    Mystical for sure! Who knew this gem existed??? Was a bit difficult to find, no fancy exterior. Gated park which is a plus. My room was very clean, apparently a recent refurbishment. Only caveat: ROOMS ARE TINY!! no closets or full view mirror. The restaurant had fresh delicious food. This place is a definitely amazing!!

    Breakfast tacos
    Bex R.

    The Mystic Santa Fe is a picturesque gem, beautifully resurrected from the historic Silver Saddle Motel. Its delightful rooms, adorned with charming décor and comfy beds, offer a serene retreat. The customer service is superb, adding a touch of warmth to the stay. The restaurant's delectable cuisine is a delight, and Juno's mixology skills at the bar are truly enchanting. A real treat is their late-night opening on weekends, perfect for unwinding after exploring Santa Fe. Waking up to a snowy day, the breakfast was a culinary marvel--especially the remarkable Cottage Cheese Comeback Kid dish. A return visit is eagerly anticipated!

    Incredible churros!
    Lyn B.

    I loved everything about The Mystic! The food, service, and design! My friend and I went there for lunch yesterday and it was outstanding! I was blown away by the interior design and the attention to detail from the silverware, art, food presentation, and the delicious food. Great job, Mystic! I can't wait to bring my hubby here!

    Recipe for my flatbread!

    See all

    4 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 month ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1
    Photo of John R.
    16
    14
    14

    1 year ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 2
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Lee J.
    0
    20
    0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Bex R.
    64
    59
    116

    3 years ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 1
    Love this 3
    Oh no 1
    Photo of Lyn B.
    13
    17
    6

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Amanda T.

    Amanda T.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of A G.
    0
    14
    6

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Matt M.

    Matt M.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Mike M.
    28
    37
    0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Amanda T.

    Amanda T.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    The restaurant servers are less than friendly and welcoming at the High Desert restaurant! They are the reason this place hasn't caught on.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - The Mystic

    Review Highlights - The Mystic

    I also met the owners and they are super helpful and down to earth, they clearly put their heart into everything and care so much about people having a good experience here.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Inn of the Governors - 2 bed room

    Inn of the Governors

    (220 reviews)

    $$

    I've only stayed here once - but I'm gonna go out on a limb and give it a 5…read more Because when I've stayed in Santa Fe in the past, it's usually abt 3 blocks away, still definitely walkable, certainly very nice, but not as central as this. And they didn't hv any 2 bed rooms available. So I found this place And in that week between Christmas and New Year's we still wanted to catch the Christmas lights and farolitos And if you too are about location, location, location This was perfect If you've ever had to drive to Santa Fe, you know that parking can be a bear -- and it was, with a lot of the main streets blocked off in anticipation of NYE celebrations. The hotel is actually quite a large, sprawling complex, much deeper that what might be assumed when pulling in. We got there mid-afternoon so could park rt in front of our first floor room. I hadn't even thought about that but my creaky knees were happy and quite relieved to only hv to haul my wee bag up 7 steps or so. Check in was easy, if a bit crowded, as a lot of regulars like to show up a bit early too. The doorman was a very polite young man and everyone made us feel welcome. The older gentleman at the counter was a font of information And made sure we knew abt the Happy Hour Short and sweet Whatever you do: try the biscochitos! (The official NM state cookie, fyi - for a reason - when done right, and these definitely are!) Everything was very clean Even with all the Christmas decorations and greenery out There's an excellent restaurant on site And when they say there's "a bit of a kick", and shd you be a wuss like me, order the spicy on the side. Staff was very considerate abt this. And breakfast is pretty good too! And it was so easy to walk to everything, stuff I usually don't get to see bc I'm usually on the other side of town. All in all, a lovely stay

    In reference to the staff specifically. All very helpful and polite…read more Becky with the sherry & tea hour so fun and informative. Mix the dry and sweet -it's great. Richard helped with car & check in. Perfect location. Walked everywhere! Shower water pressure a plus. Superb breakfast & beautiful flowers.

    Drury Plaza Hotel in Santa Fe - Spacious bathroom

    Drury Plaza Hotel in Santa Fe

    (219 reviews)

    $$

    I should preface this review by saying that we would never book this type of hotel for ourselves…read more That said, this was booked for us by a family member we were traveling with, so we tried to have an open mind. The valets offered a warm welcome that set the tone for our entire stay and the front desk check in was friendly and efficient. In fact, every single staff member we came into contact with was an absolute delight. From the manager who we encountered each afternoon and always took the time to engage with us, to the awesome lady with the funky makeup who served the complimentary afternoon drinks. Everyone we came into contact with was lovely, even the lady bussing tables was a delight. Our room on the 2nd floor was ok, it was very long and narrow and despite having plenty of sq ft, the layout made it feel small. The bathroom was decent and the linens, towels and amenities were a good quality. Each day at 5.30pm the hotel offers complimentary drinks and snacks. We checked it out once; the cocktails, although served with a big smile, were cheap and sugary (as expected). The food (pasta and baked potatoes with fixings, hot dogs and popcorn), wasn't to our taste but many of the guests with children appeared to be making a full dinner out of them, so that is definitely a great feature for families on a budget. The location is really good, no more than a 7 min stroll from everything in the historic center of Santa Fe. I would recommend this hotel for family road trips and business travelers on a tight budget. The staff make this hotel a place you should consider if you're ever coming to Santa Fe.

    This hotel provides better service than many "upscale" hotels who are supposed to have all the…read more"proper" training. I have been coming to Santa Fe for more than 35 years, always staying at our family home. When that home was sold two years ago, this became the first time my husband and I needed to find a hotel for one of our visits. Because Santa Fe feels like a second home to us--and because we were returning to celebrate our tenth wedding anniversary--I did a tremendous amount of research before booking. We chose the Drury Plaza Hotel because we wanted to be within easy walking distance of the historic Plaza while still receiving genuine value. The included breakfast and evening Happy Hour were major deciding factors. Happy Hour includes drinks and enough substantial food that it can easily serve as dinner after a full day of sightseeing, adding meaningful value to the stay. The location could not have been better. Each morning, I walked to the Plaza before my husband woke up, and we could hear the bells from the Cathedral Basilica of St. Francis of Assisi. We also took several day trips to nearby areas, and the Drury was an ideal home base for everything we wanted to explore. We stayed for 4 nights and 5 days. The rooftop pool and Jacuzzi were another highlight. We enjoyed beautiful Santa Fe sunsets from the rooftop and returned later to soak in the Jacuzzi and gaze at the stars. Those quiet moments became some of our favorite memories from the trip. A pro tip for future guests: on the second floor, at the end of the hallway, there is a lovely "secret garden" lawn area with tables and chairs. Relatively few guests seem to know about it, but you can take your Happy Hour food and drinks outside and enjoy a peaceful setting away from the activity of the main hotel spaces. It was an unexpectedly blissful little retreat. As the former CEO of a destination event-planning business, I also paid attention to the hotel's conference rooms and event facilities. Any company or organization hosting a corporate meeting, retreat, or special event would likely find this property especially appealing. The combination of location, guest amenities, gathering spaces, and walkability makes it a strong option for groups wanting both convenience and an authentic Santa Fe experience. The hotel itself is lovely, welcoming, and exceptionally well positioned, but here is what other reviews may not fully capture: the staff is everything. They are the true difference-makers. We were told that employees are hired, in part, because they genuinely enjoy people, and that quality is evident in every interaction. The front desk staff looked up, made eye contact, and greeted us whenever we passed rather than remaining focused solely on their computer screens. The valet team warmly welcomed us each time we returned. Angela was especially warm and welcoming during Happy Hour. Jo made us feel genuinely special, while Josephine stood out for her calm, gracious leadership and her ability to remember and acknowledge us whenever we returned to the hotel. Marco and Angel were also superstars at the rooftop bar. The hotel proactively asks whether guests are celebrating anything, and the team actually pays attention to the response. We did not request anything special, yet we received a complimentary suite upgrade for our anniversary, along with a bottle of wine and a card signed by members of the staff. Those thoughtful touches meant a great deal to us. We also experienced a power outage during our stay, and that unexpected moment revealed just how well prepared the team was. Staff members were positioned at critical points throughout the building, calmly guiding guests, opening doors, and providing assistance. Service culture and training often reveal themselves most clearly when something does not go according to plan, and this team rose beautifully to the occasion. The Drury Plaza Hotel gave us the location, amenities, value, and atmosphere we were seeking, but the people are what made our anniversary stay truly memorable. After more than three decades of visiting Santa Fe, we are grateful to have found a hotel that now feels like part of our connection to the city. We will absolutely return.

    Rosewood Inn of the Anasazi - Lovely room

    Rosewood Inn of the Anasazi

    (147 reviews)

    $$$

    The Rosewood Inn of the Anasazi was the perfect spot for our stay in Santa Fe. We appreciate that…read moreit was walking distance to so much the downtown area had to offer. There were also no details spared from the cookies and chocolate with a handwritten note when we checked in to the Velcro strap added to my charging cable when the room was cleaned. I would stay here again in a heartbeat!

    We ended up stopping here twice during our trip while exploring Santa Fe, and it quickly became our…read morego-to spot to unwind. The bar itself is super cute with a cozy, inviting seating area that makes you want to linger a little longer than planned. The decor leans warm and stylish without trying too hard--perfect for slipping in, grabbing a cocktail, and giving your feet a much-needed break from walking around town. The staff were genuinely friendly and welcoming. Service leaned a little on the slower side, but the warmth and attentiveness more than made up for it. It felt relaxed, not rushed--very much in tune with the whole Santa Fe vibe. Also, a random but deserved shoutout: the downstairs bathrooms are exceptional. Clean, spacious, and surprisingly elevated for a bar stop. Great spot for cocktails, light bites, and a breather in between exploring. Honestly, it left such a good impression that I'd absolutely consider staying at the hotel next time. If you're in the area and need a cozy reset, this place is 100% worth the stop.

    Inn of the Turquoise Bear

    Inn of the Turquoise Bear

    (58 reviews)

    A Fine Experience…read more.... - Overall: 5 - Location: 5 - Exterior: 4 - Interior: 4 - Ambiance: 5 - Witter Byner Room: 5 - Witter Byner Bathroom: 4 - Breakfast: 5 - Amenities: 5 - Hosts: 5 - Housekeeping: 5 - Parking: 4 - Value: 5 For the first stop on our driving tour of the Southwest US, we stayed in Santa Fe for 5 nights. But where? Reviewers touted the Inn Of The Turquoise Bear.....and they were right. Pros: - Location: Central. Just south of the downtown area and a 15 minute walk to Canyon Road. - Exterior: A sprawling property in a residential neighborhood. Several smaller buildings seem to have been added over the (many) years to the main building seen on most photos of the property. - Interior: Like going back 100 years. Things were fixed, of course...especially in public spaces...but you might feel as if you're in a living museum. - Our Room (Witter Byner): Large and rambling. More than enough room for 2 people plus a balcony overlooking the front of the property. Very comfortable. I could live there for a month if we didn't mind going up and down 15 stairs to the main floor. One interesting aspect: The bathroom. It was very nice and fully equipped, but separate from our room and down 5 stairs. That wasn't a problem during the day, but a few nights were an adventure - Breakfast: Unreal. Everything was homemade with great taste. The buffet portion had sliced fruit, granola, juices, pastries and yogurt. The hosts and kitchen staff had 3-5 entrees available each day. I rarely tried those since I filled up on the buffet, but my wife ate one every day and only had good things to say. Service at the community table was gracious and unhurried with lots of interesting conversation. - Amenities: A 1-2 hour Happy Hour every day starting at 430 or 5 PM. Fresh cookies, fruit, tea and jug water were available all day (coffee from 630-10 AM). Umbrellas. Plenty of smiles. - Hosts: Everyone was very friendly, helpful, informative and even charming. Special thanks to Aileen (sp?). - Housekeeping: Effective, efficient and unobtrusive. - Parking: Sufficient. The large courtyard in front of the of the property provided enough room for cars in the 11 room B&B. - Price and Value: Reasonable. It's not cheap, but as in most cases you get what you pay for. We'd heartily recommend the Inn Of The Turquoise Bear, but make reservations well in advance.

    Stayed here for three nights on our Santa Fe visit. It was formerly the home of Witter Brynner a…read morefamous poet and scholar in the early 1930's and 40's. Many of his literary friends visited here and the guest rooms are named for them. There is assigned park parking as well as it's a premium in town. The breakfasts were excellent and the staff was very accommodating. The location is convenient to the downtown Plaza and restaurants. A beautiful property.

    Casa Culinaria - The Gourmet Inn - The Colorado Room

    Casa Culinaria - The Gourmet Inn

    (66 reviews)

    $$

    If you're seeking a warm, relaxing boutique experience in Santa Fe, this is not it…read more Our suite, the aptly named "Territorial," was beautifully styled but functionally absurd. The bed sits just inches from the toilet door, so unless you're unusually close with your travel companion, pack earplugs and a blindfold. Dust was caked into the corners, a dead bug was in the ripple of the vintage rug, and we were greeted by a dried booger on the bathroom door (seriously). The door frame lets light in, the floors creaked like a haunted house, and the entire layout felt like it was designed by someone who's never actually had to sleep there. There were no privacy blinds, only wooden shutters, and the artwork provided enough clutter to fill the room just in case you forgot your own luggage. Breakfast was the big show! Most of what we were served was delicious. For an extra $45 per person, you'll be given whatever the kitchen feels like making that morning... no choices, no allergy considerations, and not even a glass of water. Instead, you're handed an herbal infusion and expected to sip with gratitude while waiting 90 minutes for your dessert tart. But our group's disappointment simply must have meant we didn't understand the "magic" of the experience. In the end, Casa Culinaria is the kind of place that confuses ambiance with hospitality and is more interested in curating an image than creating a welcoming stay. If you're searching in Santa Fe for a splintering rocking chair, garden corners appropriate for Instagram, or even paying $340/night to be treated like an inconvenience... this is the winner! Anyone interested in actual hospitality should keep searching.

    We had an amazing stay at the Casa Culinaria Inn. What made our stay even more wonderful was our…read morethree course gourmet brunch. Carolina has created a carefully crafted menu with food that makes you feel good! Manuel took wonderful care of us. This is perfect if you are looking for a quaint breakfast spot.

    Hilton Santa Fe Historic Plaza

    Hilton Santa Fe Historic Plaza

    (283 reviews)

    $$

    This used to be our go-to hotel whenever we visited Santa Fe. After 15+ years of family trips and…read morestays here, we'll unfortunately be looking elsewhere. The biggest issue is security. During our most recent stay, our vehicle was one of at least three that were broken into with many very large/heavy items stolen overnight while parked in the hotel's paid parking lot. The lack of security measures, whether cameras, patrols, or staff presence, was disappointing and left us feeling unsupported after the incident. What was even more frustrating was management's response. When the answer to multiple vehicle break-ins is as we were told by the GM - there's nothing we can do and that cameras don't deter theft or help identify thieves - it's time for us to stay somewhere else. We understand that crime can happen anywhere, but guests paying for parking should reasonably expect the property to take security seriously and make an effort to protect them. What makes this especially difficult is that we've always loved this property. The hotel has a historic charm, a great location that makes it easy to explore Santa Fe on foot, and while the rooms aren't luxury accommodations, they always felt comfortable and familiar - like a home away from home. Through the years, the staff has consistently been friendly and welcoming. That's what makes this review so disappointing to write. What was once a 5-star experience for our family has dropped to about a 3-star experience because we no longer feel confident that our vehicle and belongings are safe while staying here.

    Fairly nice property located in the historic district…read more Room was large and tastefully appointed but had an odd sliding door for the bathroom which affords little privacy. Sadly our room was above the trash compactor and the 5AM pick up was not welcome. Bar and restaurant were both surprisingly good. The breakfast portions are enormous and we couldn't finish. Drinks were reasonably priced and quite good. Staff were all super friendly.

    The Mystic - venues - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...