I lived in a one-bedroom here for two years (2007-2009). I rented from a private owner (this building is all condos). Overall, it was a good experience. For the price, this is not a huge apartment, and over two years it started to feel more cramped! But they are nice units, and you are paying partly for the location and the views (which are incredible!). The exact quality of the apartment depends on the owner, of course. I had several friends in the building who also rented one-bedrooms, and they had much newer appliances and prettier decor. Not that my unit was a problem, it just wasn't quite as fancy for the high price we were paying.
Maintenance was wonderfully reliable. Every time we had even the smallest issue, maintenance came within a few short hours.
I am subtracting stars for the doormen. I don't want to generalize, because several of them were nice. However, most of the doormen were incredibly rude. The minute you had the tiniest issue (for example, buying a couch for your apartment), they give you tons of attitude and make things exceedingly complicated.
Management was also consistently rude. They always acted like we were burdening them if we had the smallest issue.
Moving in day was an absolute nightmare. We reserved the freight elevator (for a very brief 3-hour window, seriously?). When we arrived at our assigned time, someone was blocking the entrance! The doormen were of no help in this situation. When we were then unable to move in all of our furniture in the shortened time, the doorman shouted at me. Literally, he shouted at me in front of absolutely everyone in the lobby. I actually cried in front of strangers. I NEVER cry in public, ever. Except when dealing with the doormen of The New York! Moving out day was equally stressful and horrible. Unless you can afford an entire team of professionals to move all your things in about 2 hours, you will have problems moving into this building.
So although the majority of my two years here were quite nice, the incredible stress of living under the watch of these doormen was a totally unnecessary burden. If I am paying THAT much to live in a building, I want to be treated nicely! read more