I ordered 6 different cookies and most of them were pretty good! My favourites were the pandan and the cookies and cream oreo one. Milo and classic were my least fav. However they weren't so delicious I could finish a whole cookie, I just ate a third of each flavour and then gave the rest to my family. Usually I devour cookies easily but idk, these were good but just missed the perfect cookie mark somehow - maybe they're a bit too cakey/soft, and the flavours aren't strong enough in some cookies. I prefer a chewy/crispy cookie texture and these are not that at all, so if you're picky about the texture then I wouldn't recommend these. However if you like all cookies like me but just have a preference, these are worth trying at least once. They also taste much better warmed up. Price-wise they're a bit expensive now, 6 for $18, but they're a decent size and have unique ingredients so I can't complain. Overall I'd recommend this place - the milk n oreo cookie was the best so maybe try that! read more

The Night Baker - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

The BEST cookies I've ever had. Super soft and chewy and held up really well even after a few days! The ube one is to die for, and all the flavours are not too sweet! read more

The Night Baker - Assortment of cookies - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

I hate to say it, but these definitely look better than they taste. I was really excited to try The Night Baker, but what really gets me about their cookies is the whole wheat flour (which might just be my preference) and that the inside is slightly less baked than I would prefer. I just find that the whole wheat flour just gives it an undesirable grainy texture and wheaty flavour. I'm all for cookies that are soft and chewy inside, but these were a touch raw, and I actually found them to be a lot better when I took them home and baked them for 10-15 minutes. All of that being said, they do have some really nice flavours and the staff is really nice! Might give them another try as they roll out other flavours. read more

The Night Baker - Ooh Bae, Mistachio, Classic, Campfire S'mores, Sans Rival - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

I came here randomly to pick up some cookies expecting them to be the greatest because of the reviews. We got a pack of eight cookies for around $23 and I wasn't that impressed. They weren't bad but they weren't the greatest I've ever had. Coming from a family with lots of bakers, I think my standards are pretty high with cookies so these just weren't it for me. For some of them, I couldn't tell if they were intentionally mushy or if they just weren't baked thoroughly on the inside. I will say that the cashier that checked us out was really friendly but other than that, I don't see myself coming back. read more

See all

In a city where Craig's Cookies is King, it's lovely to see another cookie contender take a stab at the throne and succeed. While I do love Craig's Cookies, the novelty has worn off and I wonder just how many chocolate chip cookies I can eat from there. The Night Baker has a range of flavours and they were all really solid. These are two bite cookies, they're quiet hefty. I tried six flavours and will rate them from my least fave to most fave: Pretzel and m n m: least fave, this was a super heavy cookie, if you like peanut butter though you'll like this. Original: simple, walnut, good but doesn't stand out. Matcha pistachio: lovely matcha flavour and smell, really nice, they clearly use real matcha in baking Strawberry jam filled: super yummy, right mix of flavours S'mores: chewy ooey and chocolatey And my favourite was the cheddar cheese with cheese filling. Reminded me of a cheddar cheese muffin from Mmmmuffins circa 1989. I love it. Would eat it every day all day. Six cookies were $15. read more

The Night Baker - Cheddar cheese, original, jam, s'mores, matcha, pretzel n mnms.... - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

These cookies are the stuff you dream about - maybe that's why they call it the Night Baker. They're soft, chewy, flavourful and rich (but not Kim K-rich - just rich enough that you can keep eating them). It's a dangerous game, but Night Baker almost always wins. Do yourself a favour & play the game, I have yet to meet someone that does not love these cookies. read more

The Night Baker - The best cookies in Toronto. - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

Walking along College on this warm and sunny Sunday, we decided to pop in for a snack. We ordered two cookies: the matcha pistachio and the chocolate with marshmallow (campfire s'mores). Both were delish! Chewy, moist, good ratio of "stuff" in each cookie. I was actually surprised with the whole pistachios in the matcha cookie! I'd definitely come back and try other flavours. I think it was $5 plus tax for 2. If you buy 6 or more, no tax. read more

The Night Baker - Yummy cookies!! - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

Never had a chance to physically drop by the store and was surprised to see it on ubereats. Ordered the box of 6(milk and Oreos, campfire s'mores, mistachio, ooh bae, piñata colada, pb &b). Cookies are definitely different from your usual retail boxes cookies as these were relatively dense and cake like texture. Personally I like my cookies to have more of a crunch texture rather than a sponge. Loved the gooey texture. read more

The Night Baker - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

I've been on a cookie craze lately and I was recommended this place by a friend. I loved their Ube and milk n oreos cookies the most, but all the other flavours were also amazing. The cookies were nice and soft. read more

The Night Baker - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

I don't usually have much of a sweet tooth but this cookie shop had such good reviews that I had to pay them a visit to see what the hypes all about! I like how they have variety from their permanent flavours and experiement with seasonal cookies often. We tried the ube and easter cookies. The ube (purple) is supposed to be their best seller, and I can see why. The cookie was soft, and the filling inside wasn't too sweet. But I actually liked the easter cookie (green) better, there was oozy melted chocolate and a few pieces of crunchy wafer in the filling. What i like about these is that they aren't too sweet, theres a good amount of salt to even out the sweetness. However, I do prefer thinner cookies that aren't so doughy but they were still good. If you like sweets, I would definitely recommend a visit! read more

The Night Baker - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

Folks, I really wanted to like this place. In fact, I had such high expectations when ordering the cookies. Unfortunately, I was very disappointed. I ordered a cookie box with the following cookies included: - The classic: the best of them all. Dark chocolate and salt never fail to disappoint. A bit on the drier side but quite tasty - Ooh Bae: alright, it was a unique flavor and not too sweet - PB & B: I'm usually a sucker for anything peanut butter but this lacked the richness of peanut butter made from scratch and felt more like a Reese's cookie - Milk and Oreos: this was the biggest disappointment, very basic - Nutty pumpkin: I quite liked this one, on the softer side since it has a pumpkin spice cream cheese filling I'd still come back for the classic, but it definitely fell short of expectations. read more

Best cookies I have ever ordered. Each cookie is distinct, delicious and true to its description. This will be my go-to moving forward. Thank-you, Night Baker! read more

I ordered the half dozen cookies on ubereats and these are the BEST cookies I have ever eaten in my entire life. I find that most cookies are way too sweet and I don't feel good after eating one. With these cookies its the perfect distribution of where the dough is delicious and soft and the middle filling is sweet but its not the entire cookie so the sweetness balance is perfect! My favourite is the Ube cookies those are so so great. Definitely will be repurchasing and giving some to my friends and family~ read more

A prefect fresh baked cookies for the cold weather its yummy with hot chocolate milk and warm up cookies to enjoy at home all comfy . The cookies are 3.00$ and a whole pack of 12 is 31$ it's worth the trip if you love cookies and give some to Santa read more

The Night Baker - Yummy fresh sweet big cookies worth the trip 12 cookies for 31$ and one I think it was around 3$ - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

I wanted to send my mother a special treat for her birthday (COVID-19 has sadly kept us from seeing each other) and after searching several dessert shops in Toronto, I came across The Night Baker. The flavours intrigued me straight away and I knew my mom would get a kick out of them. I placed an order on their website and even though it's currently an uncertain time for deliveries, my mother was super excited when the door bell rang during our FaceTime call at the scheduled time. The delivery was a no-contact drop off, which I appreciated. I asked my mother what was her favourite but in all honestly, she couldn't choose! She loved them all. I also put a quick note when ordering that it was for my mother's birthday and they put a little birthday sticker on the front of the package. How sweet! :) I can't wait to visit the shop in person soon enough! read more

The Night Baker - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

See all

Great tasting cookies, but a little too sweet and dense for me. The fillings pair perfectly with the cookie, and I really enjoyed the texture. I bought the 6 pack and was only able to finish 1 1/2 cookies because of how rich they were. This is definitely more of a once in a while treat then an everyday thing. Will be back in the future for when I'm craving something sweet! read more

The Night Baker - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

Damn these are the best cookies I have ever tasted. The mistachio is a must order. Price wise it's not too expensive and love how soft and chewy the cookies are. My new fave cookie place. read more

Yuck! I bought 3 cookies. They had absolutely NO TASTE TO THEM. They tasted raw and gave me a belly ache! I would have been happier with a Bag of Oreo Cookies! Yuck. Seriously save your money. read more

All cookies I've tried have been delicious. Top one would have to be the cookie butter one. Wish this place was open later for those late night cookie cravings. read more

As someone who enjoys a fresh, moist and decadent cookie, I was looking forward to The Night Baker which I had been told produced some of the best cookies in the city. In what was a most difficult choice to make (try choosing only two cookies from the wide array of flavors presented to you), I went with the Beggo (Nutella filling) and the Campfire Smores (at 2.75 each plus tax). These were fresh, warm, full of flavor and decadent, and the moment I finished my last bite, I was already debating on going back in and getting a couple more (but alas, I'm trying to eat well and barely managed to stop myself from going in and walking out with a box of 6). I stopped myself on that day but am already looking forward to my next visit. A must try for any lover of cookies! read more

See all

The cookies are beautifully crafted and I love all the unique flavours! Don't get me wrong the cookies were delicious but $16.50 for 6 cookies is quite expensive!! read more

Amazing. They just happened to be a few minutes walk from where I was having dinner at that night. They're so warm and fresh. I'm definitely coming back here to order more. read more

The Night Baker - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

The Night Baker - Toronto. Delicious cookies. I loved the Oreo one, carrot cake, Red Velvet, Sans Rival and Peppermink crinkly . I also tried the Ube (purple jam), matcha, s'mores, Easter eggs, and cheesecake one. read more

See all

I was very excited to try out the cookies here, but I left disappointed. I got one of each flavor that was available that day (the classic, campfire smores, mistachio, red wedding, quezo royale). In my opinion, the cookies here are too doughy and heavy. The minute you lift a cookie up with your hands, you are left with buttery and oily fingers. Out of the flavors that I tried, my favorites were the smores and red wedding. I was very excited to try the mistachio, but the flavors did not blend well and it was very bland. In my opinion, there are better options in Toronto to get good desserts. read more

Was happy to see the Night Baker at the christmas market in the scotia plaza! Been following the cookies of night baker over instagram for the longest time and was excited to try when we got the chance. When we were at the xmas market, they only had 4 flavours remaining: Smores, chocolate chip (dark chocolate), pistachio matcha and gingerbread nutella. First off, the price of the cookies were a tad big steep.. 2.75$ for one or 15$ for 6. Since we wanted to try a couple, we opted for the 15$ for 6. The cookie itself was not very big, but thick. The chocolate chip one was very grainy and did not enjoy it very much. The first thing my husband said was if the cookie was gluten free lol!!! It had a crumbely texture and just was not my cup of tea... The smores one was not very sweet and was not filled with marshmellows as i wish it would... the gingerbread nutella one was delicious. Had a good amount of ginger taste and had a good amount of nutella! FInally, the pistachio matcha was such a disappointment!! That was one that i was really looking forward too... did not have pistachio OR matcha flavour to the cookie.. it was very subtle... the only thing i could taste was the white chocolate which was not what i wanted. My coworker also bought half a dozen and did not enjoy the cookies as well.. she even asked if these were considered " healthy" cookies lol!!! Overall, for the price we're paying i expect to have a more higher quality cookie but was truly disappointed with what we got. Don't think i will be returning again. read more

The Night Baker - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

Mistachio and OOh-Bae Cookies (Love the gooey, chewy texture but a bit too sweet for me) -- Photos of these thick and gooey cookies from The Night Baker keep popping up in my suggested posts and finally had a chance to try them! I got the Mistachio, a matcha cookie with whole pistachios and white chocolate chips, and the Ooh-Bae, a ube cheesecake cookie with a ube jam centre. These cookies are probably the most gooey and chewiest cookies I've tried (and who doesn't love that! ), but they were a bit too sweet for me. Out of the two, I prefer the Ooh-Bae because the matcha and pistachio flavour didn't come through as well as ube. If you have a major sweet tooth and love cookie dough I think you would love these! read more

The Night Baker - Ooh-Bae and Mistachio Cookies - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

Just walking by the neighbourhood and saw this little gem's soft opening. I had the Classic (dark chocolate, walnuts &sea salt) and Ooh Bae (Ube cheesecake, ube jam filling). Both were really good, soft and chewy kind of cookies. Cookies were very balanced, not too sweet and the descriptions were spot on. This might be my new cookie drop by. Will come back to try the rest soon. read more

See all

Good cookies. Not the mouth orgasm I was hoping for, but really good. A bit pricey, but this is Toronto after all.

Very cute spot with lots of personality. The cookies are really puffy, on the cakier side, filled with a variety of stuff. I personally found it too sweet for my taste. The ube ice cream was very creamy but sadly it was half melted, so I had a soup of ube. The cookie cup was much harder and brick-like, compared to their regular cookies. If I had a choice, I'd get 1 well-frozen (not runny) scoop of the ube, and the ube cookie on the side, rather than the cup cookie. It's 2.75 each, or 2.5 each for 6 or more cookies, and no tax. They also have a rewards point system, and you get a free cookie for signing up. oh and the 2 girls working there were SUPER cheerful and energetic, so service was 10/10. I recommend this place to anyone who loves very sweet and rich cookies. read more

Cute little shop with not much selection. When I went, there were a total of 6 flavors- mistachio (matcha & pistachio), smores, chocochunk, red wedding (white choco chips & raspberry filling), peanut butter, and a cheese. I do not recommend the mistachio as that was super dry despite how good it looks/sounds. I liked the raspberry filling one the most! A box of 6 cookies is $15 CAD, so being from NYC, this was a really good price! However, the cookies were a bit disappointing at first. I tried a bite on the first day and they were super buttery and on the dry/ grainy side. I did give them another chance on day 2 and they got much softer. If you're looking for moist cookies though, this is not the place. They are still decent cookies though and last for a good amount of days. read more

Delicious cookies delivered fresh to your door, doesn't get much better than that. A bit on the pricey side, but they are quite a hefty size cookie. I usually can't even finish 2 of them in one sitting! So far my favourite flavours are the classic and the Oreo milk n' cookies. They freeze well too. read more

We were craving some cookies so the gf and I decided to swing by Night Baker to see what the craze was about. As we got their perhaps half an hour till closing, they were running low on flavours. Thank goodness they still had Matcha Pistachio because that was the #1 must try on OUR list. Loved it - Definitely taste the pistachios - the Matcha wasn't too strong but you could tell you were eating a Matcha cookie. We ordered this Quezo Royale one which seems to be a hit here on yelp, but it wasn't OUR thing. A little cheesy and had a odd after-taste to it, perhaps a bit too rich and too different for me, but can't say I loved it. Quick service and the cookies were decently priced for gourmet style. Give them a try before you decide the best cookie shop in Toronto since there seems to be so much popping up! read more

I was really excited to try these cookies because they looked so delicious but was so disappointed. I got the Ooh Bae and Mistachio when they had a pop up at the Square One Lunar New Year event. The Ooh Bae had a veeery subtle hint of ube but I really had to think about it to be able to taste it, if that makes sense. As for the Mistachio, fortunately there were actual pistachio nuts otherwise it wouldn't have tasted like anything. I couldn't taste any matcha at all! Both of the cookies mostly tasted like dough, to be honest. Cool flavours but it wasn't executed well. read more

I really loved their cookies! I like cookies that still taste a bit like cookie dough, and Night Baker does their cookies this way. My hubby and I got 6 to share (for $15, it was a pretty good price), and my favourite ones were definitely the Ooh Bae and Mistachio. I thought both flavours were really unique and yummy, while still giving me that cookie dough taste that I love. Just thinking about the cookies as I write this review makes me want to go back to Night Baker right now! read more

The Night Baker - Mistachio, Ooh Bae, Campfire Smores, Milk and Oreo, Classic - Food Delivery Services Near Me - Toronto, Ontario

Couldn't recommend this place enough. The ube (purple yam) cookie is the bomb! Anyone reading this, just go and indulge yourself!

I have been purchasing the Night Baker Cookies since before they even had a storefront location; when they would set up a table outside local markets. It's been at least two years. Since opening their store on College, I faithfully order a box of cookies once a week; I am not exaggerating. That is how good they are. Coming from someone whose very weakness is cookies, trust me, these are THE BEST out there. I have searched and tried what I'm certain is every known cookie shop, and there is simply no comparison. These are freshly baked, always. They have the perfect consistency, texture, and chewiness; these cookies are thick, filled with filling, and rich. Their flavours are unique and always a well-balanced taste that simply melts in your mouth. Not to mention, their prices are more than reasonable and they have a wonderful rewards system. I love that they maintain their classic flavours while also rotating new innovations every few weeks; the Night Baker's creations are a treat my family looks forward to! To list a few of our favourite cookies: classics -- oh bae, oreo, smores & rotating -- blueberry, birthday cake, nutella, pineapple coconut, mango, key lime pie, raspberry (royal wedding), ferrero rocher, almond (sans rival & pink lady), carrot cake, munchies. I am most certainly missing many, but I assure you, they're all wonderful. For those of you reading this review and considering whether to try the Night Baker, think no more. You will be absolutely, without a doubt, blown away. THE NIGHT BAKER MAKES THE MOST FLAVOURFUL, DELECTABLE, PERFECT COOKIES IN THE WORLD!!! Oh and lastly, the owners of and staff at the Night Baker are so sweet and humble! read more

Bought a few cookies from the Night Baker at the Design Nook last year, and they were awesome! Generous portions with pretty neat flavours. Tried them all, but I'm definitely in love with the Caffeine Fix and the Campfire Smores. They were delicious (MORE delicious with a cup of coffee!). ;-) High-quality, gourmet-level cookies from two budding bakers! Two cookie-covered thumbs way up! read more

My god their cookies are delicious! I tried The Night Baker for the first time yesterday through ubereats. Ordered their box of 6 cookies: the classic, mistachio, OG s'mores and milk-and-oreos. My favourite was the milk-and-oreos and the others were delicious too! Their cookies are chewy, gooey and soft - absolutely perfect cookies! They arrived freshly baked and warm. With a cup of coffee, these cookies will hit the soul! Will definitely be ordering again! read more

Pro: - delicious cookies that are moderately priced - always warm and gooey - can be kept for a few days and still taste delicious - lots of varieties of flavors to satisfy different taste buds - cookie rewards program to earn free cookies - flavors always change with season - clean store front Con: - none to report Overall, well priced cookies & great quality flavors. My favorite are THE CLASSIC & MISTACHIO read more

The cookies are excellent and the portion sizes are big, which is great for cookie lovers out there! My personal favourite is the Campfire S'mores because it's bursting with marshmallow and chocolatey goodness. The two key ingredients really compliment each other. The Caffeine Fix is a must try too! I really love the butterscotch. I'm not a big coffee fan but this cookie is marvelous and the added espresso is a nice touch. Mouthwatering. I'm just impressed on how huge the cookies are and yet still be well priced. read more