Pizza was gross. Plus when I called in the order I said no green peppers as I'm allergic. She read the order back to me with that info. Lo and behold, it had green peppers. Not easy to pick out they were under the cheese. The sauce had no flavors, meat the same. It got tossed. read more

Loved our stop at The Old Icehouse Pizzeria! Excellent pizza, the service was top notch, and it was a beautiful day so our group sat out on the rooftop patio and the staff even came upstairs multiple times to check on us and refresh drinks. We will definitely be back. Thanks!! read more

Service is excellent, people that work there are friendly. Pizza is fantastic have eaten here many times always good.

Pizza is incredible and some of the best ever. Love the pizza every time and have had about everything on the menu. Love the people and atmosphere!! read more

When we first walked in we were greeted by two young girls (who looked to be the only ones there), and ordered a CBR pizza and cheese bread. We went upstairs to grab a table by the window, there aren't many seating options downstairs. The food took probably twenty minutes, which is about average. We were the only table though. The pizza was tasty but the crust was pretty dry. Honestly the cheese bread was better in our opinion, and you can add toppings to it. We will come back for some more cheese bread for sure, but probably will skip on the pizza. It was that good. read more

The Old Ice House Pizzeria - Cheese bread - Pizza Near Me - Hope, Idaho

See all

Pizza awful Service five star Salad delicious You need to wait a very long time to eat Pizza like cardboard Enough said read more

My wife and I are staying nearby so we stopped in here for lunch. We split a 12" sausage, pepperoni, and mushroom pizza that was fantastic! Our beers were cold local crafts that we both enjoyed. We were cheerfully greeted upon arriving at this quaint little stop in the road next to Hope City Hall. Order at the counter then find your seat at the bar, on the front porch, the upstairs dining room, front deck facing the lake, or the back patio that was enclosed by mountain walls. They'll bring your food to you pretty quickly. We met some locals who stopped in as it is one of their favorites. So, you should try it too! read more

The Old Ice House Pizzeria - You have a great view of the lake if you sit outside upstairs. - Pizza Near Me - Hope, Idaho

Pizza and salad and beers all very good. View is epic. Service is friendly. It's a great place to enjoy a sunset and a tasty pizza with cold beer and a healthy delicious salad. read more

We stayed in Hope over the holidays and resort staff recommended we try Old Ice House Pizzeria. The reviews were good so we decided to try it. The pizzeria is cozy and has a great view of the lake. We ordered the peninsula pizza. The pizza tasted average; the chicken was a little tough/dry and crust looked fluffy but was hard. Reasonable prices. We didn't order the cheesy bread but saw someone else get it and it looked pretty good. They also offer breakfast. read more

The Old Ice House Pizzeria - Peninsula pizza with olives - Pizza Near Me - Hope, Idaho

Love coming here after watching the Salmon spawn in Trestle Creek. The beers are cold and a few of them on tap are local. We like to sit upstairs and enjoy the view of Lake Pend Oreille. The Greek Salads were tasty and plenty of goodness on the plate. The pizza was a little less desirable. We ordered the Scotchman's Supreme - the sausage was minuscule, but the rest of the items in it were tasty. However, the crust lacked flavor, was very soggy in the middle and slightly burned on the edge in a few places. Service was good, but when it came time to check out, the young lady taking our payments seemed a little blasé and we all had to ask for boxes even though we brought the pizzas down to the counter when it came time to pay. read more

See all

The pizza is solid, with fresh ingredients, well priced. The view is beautiful! If you're looking for a relaxing spot, friendly service for a pizza, drink and view. Give it try! read more

Not super consistent with their pizzas. They skimp on meat a good bit. Sometimes the pizza is very dry. Other times it's cooked just right, you never know what you're going to get. I recently ordered one pizza on the phone, she said 35-45 mins wait. We showed up in 45 mins and they hadn't even started our pizza yet and we had to wait 20 more mins for our food. It's fun to go there once in a while, but overall I feel it's overpriced. read more

Loved this place!- It started with the 2 ladies working the cashier and tossing the pizza. They were friendly and fun at the same time. We ordered 2 pizzas, Margherita with hot honey, and a Margherita with pepperoni. Both were thin crust and delicious. Indoor or outdoor dining offered simply awesome views of Lake Pend Oreille. The service, the pizza and the ambiance were fantastic. Highly recommended. read more

This is the best pizza I've had in all of Idaho so far, seriously the best, awesome service, and a comfortable area to either eat or wait for your food. I'm definitely coming back repeatedly read more

The Old Ice House Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hope, Idaho

Great pizzas.Great lake views. You must stop over to thr TOIHP you won't be disappointed with the views or selection of pizzas. read more

The Old Ice House Pizzeria - Upstairs view of LPO - Pizza Near Me - Hope, Idaho

The view alone is worth it! But fortunately the pizza is the best around and the salads are fresh not bagged and they have deserts and games. So great place to bring visitors. We go all the time. Also dogs allowed and they have a bowl of water! Very dog friendly . We always eat outside! read more

The pizzas are hot, fresh, and delicious. Our favorite is the cheesy garlic bread. Small place and very cozy. Service was courteous, but during dinner time it can get busy so expect delays in getting your order. Still worth the wait and a fun place with great views inside and out. read more

This place has it all! Gorgeous view of Lake Pend Oreille, patio seating, and delicious Calzones!! We will likely be back tomorrow for some pizza Oh yes, and nice variety of beers on tap read more

Great little find.... best pizza in the area. What it has going for it: - pizza actually tastes like I could have been made in NYC (sauce wise) - wife says it has a cozy atmosphere - quick turn around from ordering to food on table (Sunday afternoon in Dec) - great view of lake What it has going against it: - pricing is about 20% more than what you would pay in NYC but on par for this area - no fountain soda (only cans) - crust is a little thinner than actual NYC pizza So finally found a decent pizza joint in this neck of the woods (took awhile). Hope residents should feel lucky to have this eatery in their town. Born & raised in NYC, living there for over 40 years. Closest thing you will find in this area to good NY style pizza. Would definitely come here again. read more

I highly recommend the Green Monarch pizza (yummy fresh pesto sauce) and add meat! The crust is thin and the perfect texture :) a mix of chewy and crunchy. The folks are friendly enough. The wait times, especially in summer, can be as long as an hour. Fantastic view! read more

The view of the lake is being amazing. People are really nice. Very unique. A very cool building & little town.

Great views of the lake and mountains. pizza, service and drinks are excellent. Fun art and location. read more

See all

We ordered 2 slice of pizza.. waited 40 minutes and were told it would be another 15-20 minutes. We left before we even tried the pizza, and did not get a refund. If you're going to advertise pizza by the slice... that wait time is unacceptable. read more

First time visiting! Beautiful view, cute restaurant. Clean place with kind and efficient workers. Now the important part!... the pizza was awesome! Perfect crust, not greasy.... Really good sauce to crust ratio. Will stop again the next time I'm driving through Hope! read more

This is a fun location, beautiful pizza oven, drinks with view. So it is a destination, not fast food. Nice choice of custom made styles, crisp to foldable, meaty or mediteran. read more

The pizza here is very unique in a good way. My favourite pizza place. The staff here is always courteous and helpful. The view from Ice House just can't be beat! read more

Driving through and dd ided to stop for a quick slice and hot damn was it worth it. Best pizza I've had in long time. Friendly, fast, fresh, quality service/food and the view from upstairs (where we were alone the entire time) was worth it on it's own- will definitely be coming back. read more

The Old Ice House Pizzeria - (L to R) slice of soho, penninsula, monarch and margherita. So freakin good. Also the first sticker is free for fellow sticker hounds! - Pizza Near Me - Hope, Idaho

See all

Once again, divine pizza from Ice House! Hopefully Hawaiian on a cauliflower gluten-free crust. And oh yeah, then there's the view. Definitely worth any drive to get here. read more

If you ever find yourself driving through Northern Idaho on a pretty day do not miss the chance to stop at this little gem for a cold beer and some pizza. The pizza can be ordered by the slice and is made to order. They half bake a cheese pizza and put the rest of the toppings on and finish cooking once you order. The result is a hot, fresh, pizza with a wonderfully crispy crust and fresh ingredients. The original pizza is cooked with marinara sauce on it but they can add pesto or barbeque or whatever you want. They also have calzones, salads and full pizzas. Save some room for the huckleberry ice cream though, you can't come through this area without trying at least 3 huckleberry flavored items! The view is outstanding. On a clear day you can see for miles on Lake Pend Oreille and enjoy the wooded mountains. There's even an eagles nest in a nearby tree, hopefully they'll be in on your visit. Quaint, low key, and a perfect place to rest your feet, definitely don't keep driving past this little gem on your way to wherever! read more

The Old Ice House Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Hope, Idaho

See all

Idaho friendly, with a awesome view of the lake and great pizza . Take the beautiful drive to Hope Idaho and stop in a get some delicious pizza read more

The Old Ice House Pizzeria - Pizza with a view - Pizza Near Me - Hope, Idaho

Awesome employees, amazing pizza, and the view is unreal. The Hope-full Hawaiian pizza is delicious.

Everything is made fresh here and the lady working here was bragging about where they get their pepporoni from and how it's not greasy. I am a huge fan of Pizza Hut, and this place wasn't better than PH in my opinion but the staff and service was far beyond. And the location is stellar! I could see loving to hang out here with friends. It's very homey, inviting and has a nice view. Upstairs theres a couch and games, and a porch. A great find in a small town. More happening during the summer of course but fresh made everything (cookies, pastries, etc). read more

See all

Bomb pizza., the chicken bacon ranch is fricking awesome. And the view is pretty special too! read more

The Old Ice House Pizzeria - Pizza, beer, views... - Pizza Near Me - Hope, Idaho

Amazing pizza. Love their sauce. Great friendly service. They even have Gluten Free Pizza, crust made in house!!! read more

The Old Ice House Pizzeria - Live music - Pizza Near Me - Hope, Idaho

This is one of those places you go to and enjoy a perfect summer night with a view of the lake, cold beverages, the quirky atmosphere and you never, ever forget it. The pies are huge. They try to source as much local and organic as possible, including using local wheat from Shepard's Grain in Eastern Wa which is local and tastes great. I often find myself fantasizing about my return and what I'm going to try next. Don't go if you are in a hurry or aren't prepared to relax. Each pie is hand crafted, and it takes awhile. Eat a cookie first if you're starving. No one will tell your mom. It's only open in the summer. Be sure you check the website before making the trek. Also, Bear (the owner) also sells his garden greens off the front steps, so go to stock up. FYI, cash only. read more

The Old Ice House Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Hope, Idaho

See all

we had the meat lovers pizza and it was delicious! It was thin with a nice crust. The large fed 5 adults. Their brownies look good also. read more

The Old Ice House Pizzeria - beautiful view at sunset on Sep 13 - Pizza Near Me - Hope, Idaho

Great food! Very surprised to be just passing by and find this place. Love the atmosphere too, although if you're Covid conscience might want to think about bringing your own PPE read more

I've eaten here may times. On a sunny day the view is incredible. The pizza is always good. Their house dressing for salad is good. Salad greens are always fresh. Service has always been great. read more

Went on a Sunday evening (maybe an hour before closing) and it was super busy so had to wait a long time for our order (one small pizza and one medium pizza). Sat outside and enjoyed the view while we waited. Ordered the Thai chicken and ultra light pizza, I recommend the ultra light since the pesto is amazing. read more

Great menu (including GF options), friendly staff, and stunning view. The cauliflower crust Thai pizza was one of the best I've had. Loved it!!! read more