We eat here pretty often, but mostly when we could eat outdoors. It's too loud indoors. It's called "The Second Half" on Main, but it's no Second Half. There is very little in my mind that seems to be in common (although I admit I had only gone to the old place a handful of times). The bar is too small for the number of people that want to be there. That said, when we can get there and get a seat they have great wine selections. We usually get the specials. Portions are large enough to share. Desserts are from Mara's. read more

I live out of state and went here with my parents who go often. My dad can't walk very well and as I witnessed Stephanie and other staff being so concerned and helpful and joking with him, I felt such relief and joy that this place takes care of both of them. The food was great too - mini crab cakes and linguine with white clam sauce. Thank you! read more

Owners Dennis and Diane Gentile are usually at Second Half on Main, overseeing what is a great restaurant. 5 stars all the way. Their Angus Burger is to die for. French Onion soup is superb. The staff is superb, most of the staff has been there awhile. Great sports bar and bar table area and dining room is not crowded. As you leave check out the sign over the door... "I've seen fire and I've seen rain"... Jim Croce and Dennis Gentile. Ask Dennis the story behind the sign. Outdoor seating and kid friendly. read more

The food here is really good. I got the burger and a beer. Beer is pretty cheap here as well! The burger was a standard one and the fries were super crunchy and yummy! The only thing that gave this 4 stars was that my burger took FOREVER to come. However, the waiter was really nice and took my beer off the tab to compensate for the wait. Overall, a good restaurant! read more

I got a chicken sandwich and it was pretty good, but this dude didn't give us what we asked for. He came by our table two times over the course of our meal. We got these crappy styrofoam plates that when I was done eating, that shit blew away in the wind making a whole scene in front of everyone. L. read more

I decided to give this place a try, very good food, homey and welcoming atmosphere....nothing to complain about. Really good place to do take out from. You need to try their MARYLAND CRAB CAKES, they are to die for. Definitely coming back soon. #SweepstakesEntry read more

The bar tender is super nice..... Just flew in from California.... The place is open until midnight.... But no food.... Anyways, a good small quaint to go to late night. read more

I'm huge fan of this place! Whenever my boyfriend & I can't think of a new place to try, this is one of our fall back restaurants. I prefer sitting outdoors because it does feel a little cramped inside. Someone else mentioned the bar area is too small for the amount of people who want to be there and that is completely accurate. In the winter months when there is a wait, people are all crowded around the bar area and practically standing over others who are dining- not the most ideal situation. As mentioned in other reviews, the service can be hit or miss too. The last time we went I told the waitress I was starving and would like some bread. She acknowledged my request and then didn't bring the bread until our entrees were ready. Later when she noticed I hadn't eaten the bread she said "oh, you didn't like the bread?!" No...I just didn't need it once my entree came! On the other hand, I've also had good service there. I can only speak to the deliciousness of two items on their menu since I always order the same thing- the spicy garden salad is soooo good!!!! It's the perfect combination of ingredients topped off with their mouth watering basil vinaigrette. Also, their sweet potato fries are scrumptious! I am, however, biased since I find all fries to be absolutely irresistible so make what you will of my review on their fries...haha. I will definitely be back again...and again...and again!! read more

Went there for lunch and both doors did not pull open or did the latch worked. It appeared closed. Upon leaving the parking lot, came across a kitchen worker. He was kind to let us walk through the kitchen. The bartender upon seeing us walking from the kitchen.... let's just say his tone of voice was rude and sarcastic. The waitress had to show us that door was working upon pulling it very very hard. We just left without sitting down. I would recommend because of the poor handling of customer service. Just plain rude. read more

Really neat place. Pet friendly dining is available on the (front) sidewalk area. Staff is most accommodating and each server has their owner unique customer friendly personality. The menu offers a refined cross section of items. A good place to just chill out in a nice town. read more

Even though the menu is not expansive, everything is usually very good. They have excellent steaks, burgers, salads and crab cakes. In the summer, it's a great spot to sit outside and enjoy the atmosphere of Denville. When you want something easy and relatively inexpensive on a night where you just don't feel like cooking, this is the place to go. They don't take reservations, but if you call ahead they'll put you on the waiting list during busy times so you don't have to wait too long. read more

Consistently great food and friendly service make this the best spot around. Large portions (food & drink!) and a great atmosphere. Without question Denville's go-to restaurant for over 20 years. read more

Fast service and good food! Parking around back was a little tricky as we missed the first turn, but figured it out eventually. Cute little place to stop while on a road trip. read more

The Second Half On Main - Burgundy burger and eggplant wrap. Loved them both, but especially the wrap! - American Near Me - Denville, New Jersey

Great local American Bar/ Food we like the atmosphere here, chill vibe , we like the wings! Great and crispy! :) Bartender and service were both nice and accommodating we will definitely be back!! read more

I went last night to watch the Giants game and we had a great dinner.Great wings and great burgers. If only the Giants scored a touchdown.

This place is great! Good atmosphere. The bar staff are excellent. I have not eaten here, just been for drinks. But it is very friendly, and a lot of fun. The bar area can get crowded, but everyone is friendly enough. Had fun here on St. Patrick's Day too, with bagpipers and Irish music. I definitely recommend this place if you want to go out for a few drinks. The food looks/smells great. But, I haven't eaten here yet. read more

Amazing service! Alex was very attentive, personable, sweet, and accommodating. Best service I've ever had!

I so want to love this neighborhood bar and restaurant but they consistently under deliver. My second visit in less than a week. Today at least the beer was cold. The medium well burger, more rare in my book. Service always slow, and if the beer is cold I would have had one or two more. Please don't forget what I order and ask if I want another drink...just sayin ' read more

We waited for a hour yesterday we got cold clams casino My wife got the wrong meal it was restaurant week not going back

I really enjoyed this place. It has a nice, friendly, atmosphere; pleasant and attentive waitresses; good food, good beer and shaded outdoor seating. I had the walnut salad with blackened chicken. Good, simple, healthy and clean. Just what I wanted. read more

This is a good, casual spot where you can get a quick drink and warm meal. The food in general is more so on the comfort food side, but it is consistently very good. We always try new things here and are pretty satisfied. I really like their appetizer menu, but burgers, pastas, salads all offer decent choices. The only thing that could better is quicker service (but the staff is super friendly!) read more

The Second Half On Main - Patty melt! - American Near Me - Denville, New Jersey

See all

An awesome restaurant on West Main in Denville. I had their pear salad which was stuffed(and I mean stuffed) with chicken, fruits, nuts, and cheese. And the mango dressing was one of the most memorable dressings I've ever had. Our server, Courtney, was an absolute doll from beginning to end. She was so polite and hospitable. The portions are huge, and there is good value. I can't wait to eat here again. read more

Great spot on the main drag in Denville. Great menu selection for both lunch and dinner. Great for either burgers or well executed entrees. Run by locals, so friendly environment. Great food at a very reasonable price. I wish it was closer. read more

Just went to Second Half with my wife for our Saturday nite date. It was excellent is everyway. The service was prompt, informed, polite and graciuos. Lots of drinks and funky beers at the bar. Several page menu with lots of selections. Basically and American menu with some creative twists. I had the Avocado and Mango salad special with grilled chicken on top. My wife had chicken francese. Both meals came out promptly, were hot and delicious. The food quality was superb. If you want a local bar/restaurant where you feel comfortable no matter how you are dressed, this is the spot. Also, the other guests were as diverse as it gets from old couples to young girls out for the night, to families with kids. Everyone seemed welcome. Try it. You will be back. We will. read more

Great place for a relaxing drink and plate of food. Alex, Courtney, Tommy, Cody, Jack, and Luke make every guest feel super welcome. The daily specials are usually pretty solid. The pours are as generous as Dennis and Diane are as owners. Great place to be to unwind after work. read more

Update: things improved as the Entrees arrived. Food was hot and tasty. The pace of service and attention to our needs quickly improved. We were told the host never told the wait staff we had been seated and never assigned a server. I don't know how the back works, but our server was sweet and the food was good. We will return as it's a nice spot. Nice people and good food. read more

Everything was delicious! We were very happy with our service and Food! Diane at the door is a delight! The happy hour options are great! The only complaint I would have is my steak was medium well instead of medium, other than that everything was perfect. Would recommend to family and friends! read more

As a Denville resident, I used to look forward to stopping by here from time to time. Not anymore... My wife and I stopped by yesterday afternoon for a beer and a quick bite. Not so fast... The bartender, an older woman with dark hair, was TOTALLY fixated on some regulars at the end of the bar. She was so involved with them she didn't even notice we came in and sat down. We waited and waited and waited... She still never noticed us while she talked and carried on with her friends, passing us a few times while doing so. This went on for over 10 minutes before we walked out, which she also didn't notice. BTW, the same exact same thing happened to us last month so I thought I'd let everyone know not to waste their time here unless you're a regular perhaps? Also, we noticed the place was dirty and unkempt. The floors by the bar was filthy and the men's bathroom was disgusting. Also, for some reason there was one of those cheap apple-cinnamon scented candles burning behind the bar, perhaps trying to cover up the stench of this dirty restaurant? I doubt this place will make it through the winter... Good Luck read more

This restaurant is so nice and the bartendar and the staff are awesome..i and my family came in for lunch..i wanted something not on the menu and guess what they made it for me.....awesome, awesome customer service and the bartendar is an awesome guy with redddish blonde hair..makes the best drinks...i highly recommend this place...and the Irish kiss drink....lol....yesss!!!! read more

5 of us came here last night for dinner. They didn't have any open tables in the front but they were EXTREMELY accommodating and had set up some bar top tables at the back of the building outside. Sadly, just as we began to order it started to torrential down pour. Due to covid we could not go inside. The entire staff came to our rescue and carried bar tables and chairs to a covered part at the back of the building. Not only were they beyond helpful they also treated everyone a round of drinks due to the unfortunate circumstances. To top it all off, once we received our food it was all TREMENDOUS! They have taken your typical "bar food" and doctored then up as unique delicious dishes. We couldn't have had a better first time dining experience post covid! Special shoutout to Dan and Janet! read more

Ate here and had a French dip sandwich and it was really bad- very tough meat, inedible. I wouldn't got back based on that experience, although I have heard that the burgers are good. read more

It took a very long time for our server to come and acknowledge that we were there. It was a very long wait to get a drink and a 40 minute wait to get our burgers. The burgers are terrible. Asked for water which we never got. Had to search myself to find ketchup, forks and napkins. First and last time here. Just moved to town, heard that it was not that great, but decided to try anyway. Bad idea, stay away. read more

Came in for dinner and drinks tonight and had a great time. Our server Nick was attentive and fun. Enjoyed the food (portobello burger) and drink, the new berry buzz! read more

Ordered the catfish today. Excellent meal and the 60 second Dogfish IPA was a perfect combo to this spicy dish!

owner brought us soup on the house...it was german onion soup and very tasty, it was also 9 degrees outside! we went with friends for lunch, table of five, very slow and the only table in the restaurant. We had Grilled Steak Sandwich, BLT, 2 Portofino Wraps, and a Burger. All were very good! read more

I really love this place. I work right down the street so i come here regularly. Everyone is super friendly, and their food is great. Their burgers are definitely top 5 all time i have ever had. The bartender Luke is a great person. He makes this great drink the velvet hammer. I highly recommend it. read more

Decent food, friendly service, and great outdoor seating in the summer. Unique American style menu that can be hard to find elsewhere. Seasonal specials can be fun. read more

Quaint and small, but excellent and friendly service, lovely atmosphere and delicious food. Prices are fair, convenient parking on street or in rear lot makes it easy to pop in and out of. read more

Only been here twice, the first time was a decent lunch but the second time I got put in a back corner and felt like they kept forgetting about me and the food was not worth the price. read more

Great food, service is often pretty good. Love their apps and a handful of their entrees-- it's one of those places where you have to decide upon a few different entrees because they are good. Two star were docked for mainly one reason: they charge you extra to refill a soda (+full price)! That is very unacceptable, especially with their prices. That alone keeps me from going there-- for a place to be petty enough to do that. I haven't been here in at least a month, so someone can correct me if I am wrong and I'll adjust, but I doubt it. read more