I've been on an Irish Pub kick for the last week and Thatcher's is a classic…read more Hubby of course had a Guinness. He likes it here because they have the full size pint glasses where many other restaurants have switched to the smaller size. I got a Stella on draft because I'm not a fan of the stouts and lagers. Hubby got a cup of the hearty beef barley soup then enjoyed his corned beef sandwich with seasoned fries. Very big portion that he is going to have for lunch tomorrow. I went with the chicken curry. It's my daughter's go to favorite for this place and I know she will be happy to have some of my leftovers since the portion is so huge. Hubby liked dipping his fries in the sauce (as did I). Such a joyful meal! I highly recommend it! He got a coffee and we split a piece of cheesecake. It was a large plate for a small piece. It may not have been too small, but perhaps some Whipped cream or a smaller plate to appease the eye. The service is fantastic! We sat and had menus right away, whenever we finished a drink or food. They cleared items right away and were very attentive. There were TVs over the bar with various games and it looks like this was the place for World Cup soccer. The bar area is very lively and a fun place to hang out. But there are also multiple rooms where you can have a quieter meal or even outdoor dining when the weather permits. If you haven't been here, do stop by when you are in the Denville area. You will love it!

Huge menu Nice staff…read moreGood for groups Bar and dining room area Lunch specials Nice staff Street parking

We kept hearing for good wings go to Knotty Pine in Wharton…read more So we did.... Definitely a hole in the wall but Definitely a gem! The pub is small and the bartenders are friendly. The food is basic typical American menu. Standard popular beers on draft. We Definitely ordered the wings and tried the KKP (which is regular buffalo) and Motor oil The motor oil wings ended up being very good lol We then shared Ribeye cheese sandwich ;Onions & peppers come w/ the ribeye sandwich but I wanted Onions & he wanted peppers, we asked for it on the side & we put what we wanted on our halves Marriage is all about compromising We were so full. The food tasted very good and everything had great flavor! We definitely will be back we enjoyed it very much. If you are in the wharton area give it go and pop on in for some Motor Oil wings!!!

Wasn't a planned stop. Needed some food while traveling and this place was close and had a strong…read moreyelp rating. Arrived and ordered 12 wings since they stayed in the menu they were voted best in New Jersey, onion rings, and a couple pints. Went with 1/2 salt and vinegar and 1/2 motor oil which was a seeet Asian chili sauce. Holy wow these wings were the best I've ever had! The onion rings also may have been some of the best I've ever had. Yeah it's bar food but it's bar food on another level! If we ever find our way back to this part of the country we will definitely be back. Highly recommended!

Since 1979, the Quiet Man has served amazing meals, provided comfort food, a place to feel at home…read moreand joyous music and entertainment. They will be closing next Saturday. If you haven't been, I'm sorry. If have, rejoice and know the chef, Skip, who happens to be my brother-in-law will enjoy his retirement after a chaotic, non-stop last month. I stopped in for lunch today with my good friend and struggled with what my last meal should be. I opted for the Chicken pot pie and corn fritter. It was light, flaky and delicious. The corn fritter came with maple syrup and brought me great joy. My friend went with the pork Milanese which was huge! It came with mashed potatoes and veggies. She definitely will be having a second meal from that pork cutlet. She also ordered a Reuben to take home for her hubby. Sorry, no photos of the sandwich. The service is always top notch and the drinks free flowing. Stop in if you can. But know the wait will be lengthy but worth it.

Authenticity Cozy Irish Pub with soft lighting and warm friendly staff. Smaller establishment but…read morenot too tight. There may be a wait on busier days; but not too bad and worth it. Nice bar, and good selection for wines and beer. Parking is street parking mostly and they have couple of parking spots to the side of the restaurant. Genuine hospitality that welcomes you like they've known you forever. You are going to ask why you haven't been here many times before after you visit. Everything is of quality and fresh. The menu is concentrated offering a nice balance of traditional items and Irish dishes. The Potato and Leek Soup is made very well with such a clean smooth broth and plenty of potato and leek present in the soup. Try the Cajun Chicken and Sausage gumbo was a nice option offering Big pieces of Chicken and Andouille Sausage. Nice kick but not overwhelming. Clams or Mussels appetizers are on point and worth sharing with the table. The Corned Beef and Cabbage dish was amazing and definitely NOT bland! Lean Corned Beef and fresh hand cut veggies make this a must have! The NY Strip, is tender, cooked perfectly and recommend having the whiskey sauce over the top! For $38.95 it is a bargain! Highly recommended as it literally checks every box for me. Will definitely return!

We have three months to complete the 2026 Tri-State Stamping Tour with American Legion Post 289 in…read moreWest Milford, NJ. 158 places across NJ, NY, and PA to visit to support the Veterans and those who support them and get our books stamped! This is stop 23/158. This is quite a nice place. Nice bar area. Good number of places to sit and eat.

Stopped in today while doing the 2026 Tri-State Stamping Tour with American Legion Post 289 in…read moreWest Milford, NJ. 158 places across NJ, NY, and PA to support the Veterans and those who support them. This is number 23.

Sorry to say, we had zero star service from one of our previously preferred local joints…read more My wife and I sat down at the bar on Saturday night and were completely ignored by the bartender. There was no welcome, and he seemed to go out of his way to not make eye concast. We sat down next to the taps, so there is no way he could have missed seeing us enter. After 5 minutes of being ignored, watching him serve other clients, futz with bills and tabs with his back to us, get ice from right in front of us, but not look up, we got up an walked out. I'll update Yelpers in a year or so as to whether their service has improved...one year is about the next time I will set foot in the place. Until then, you can find us at the Landmark in Livingston, where we are always greeted and appreciated.

typical bar food - crazy prices - atleast the beer was good - cash only - small bar - good waitressread more

Great place. I met a guy named Moke who apparently lives on one of the stools. He had his knee…read morereplaced so I bought him 10 drinks to be a nice guy.

Stopped in after a 7 mile hike for a nice cold beer. Cash only and no food. Great beer prices -…read moremost beers were $4 and the special was $7 pitchers of Miller Lite. We enjoyed a pitcher and the outdoor area. The set up is great. We came during the day so it wasn't super crowded but I can see this place being really fun at night. The only pitfall of the outside area is that smoking is allowed.

Enjoyed a nice lunch here on a quiet week day. We both started with a cup of the potato leek soup…read more- yum! We then shared the shrimp/sausage app which was plenty for 2 people. The app was good with chunks of garlic - good for bread dipping! My wine was good & the price for draft beer was very reasonable. Bartender was helpful & friendly. Would definitely go back when we are in the area!

paul made a dismal January 2 winter's visit a time full of hygge as we say in Denmark. I'd left…read moreanother Irish eatery-drinkery in town because the teen-ish greeter sat me in the middle of a room at a two person near picnic table and she could care less. Not Paul. He warmly welcomed this weary traveler on frosty foot by inviting me to sit wherever I'd like. He then attended to me by walking the football field (or pitch) length of the bar to take and bring my orders with nary a complaint or grimace. And the shepard's pie was the best I've ever had in my life INCLUDING IN IRELAND (coming close the edging out one I had in Kilkenny!) The French Onion soup had a veritable salad of liquid cheese solidified into gullet-cramming ecstasy with the soup itself reminding me of my first such onion soup in Montmartre at Mere Catherine in Paris as a tot - an eatery that is there to this day. And don't tell my new trainer at the gym I INHALED THE SAVORY CHEESE CAKE WITH A GIANT TWO DOLLOPS OF WHIPPED CREAM! And though I'd just told my gastroenterologist in town I don't drink - and Hand to God I don't, I asked which of the Blessed Bushmills they had and Paul recited the trilogy of Regular and Black and Honey! So what's like sure to be my one Bushmills of 2026 glazed and soothed by Arctic Throat with the delicacy of the world's oldest drilled whisky - years ago I visited the distillery in Northern Ireland where it's said while the whisky cures in casks, that which evaporates is the Angel's Share. So this true Irish jewel - not far from the Green where men and women were hung for crimes but now just hang out in warmer times, is here with its doors and arms often. If St. Paul's for soul salvage, this Paul was for good spirits' salvage. THANK YOU!

Once again, Panther has great food, exceptional service, and perfect cocktails…read more I got the Steak Sandwich, which I loved, and a Paper Plane, which can often be overly boozy but this version was delightful. We also tried the daily appetizer special, Turkey Empanadas, and they were insanely good. It's always lively, friendly and cozy inside. They've mastered the modern pub scene.

Stopped in for lunch on Black Friday while visiting family in the area. The place was pretty busy…read moreand we sat in the bar area. Service was terribly slow the duration of the time. There was 1 bartender and 1 server covering the area. It took forever to have our order taken and to get to water and or food. I wasn't impressed with my meal either. I had the aged cheddar grilled cheese. There was barely any cheese on the sandwich - it was 95% apple slices and fig jam. They didn't even bother to take the sticker off the apple. I would not recommend this dish. My husband enjoyed his french onion soup; his Reuben was average. My family member enjoyed their steak sandwich. Maybe they had their holiday crew working given it was Thanksgiving weekend and that's why our experience wasn't that great. If I was here again, I'd want to sit in the main area in the back and order something different.