My daughter had outgrown her Cape Cod bracelet, so we stopped in to purchase a larger one. Wendy was extremely helpful and patient with assisting us in finding the perfect fit. read more

The owner was very polite and helpful. He went out of his way to ensure I was comfortable and not feeling pressured into a big financial decision like other jewelers often do. Also extremely high quality jewelry that you can trust. read more

DO NOT BUY ANYTHING FROM THIS STORE EVER!!! HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE AND CONDESCENDING RUDE ATTITUDE BY WENDY SWEENEY AND THE OWNER. My sister was a 30-year customer of this store and spent hundreds of dollars over the years on jewelry. She recently bought an $85 silver bracelet from this store and the clasp was faulty. She tried to return it but they have a no return policy, which she was not aware of. She called the store several times and was told that the owner Steven Brander would call her back. He never did. She drove down there and the store employee Wendy Sweeney was hostile, rude and condescending, arguing with her and telling her why did she buy something that she knew was faulty!!! Then she left and came back to talk to the owner and he was just as rude and condescending and the employee Wendy Sweeney lied and told the owner she called her a bitch, which she did not! She said she recognized her condescending bitchy attitude. You know, it's not difficult to have good customer service and say something like "We have a no returns policy. I know you are disappointed but let me help you find something else." Instead, even the owner refused to help her and demanded she apologize to rude and condescending WENDY SWEENEY. ONCE THEY HAVE YOUR MONEY, THEY DON'T WANT TO TALK TO YOU! DON'T SPEND YOUR MONEY HERE EVER!!! read more

We recently visited The Silver Unicorn on our recent trip to the Cape. I was amazed with the amount of beautiful jewelry and I found the staff to be most helpful and friendly. I purchased a beautiful bracelet and will definitely return on our next visit to Yarmouth. It is worth the visit. read more

Bought "Cape Cod" bracelet here but it is not stamped 925 for sterling. The gold ball is pale, like 10k, not right color for 14k. Wondering if it's a rip off. Also no receipt was given. read more

I recently had a great shopping experience at The Silver Unicorn! I came in looking for estate jewelry (which they don't carry - they sell only new pieces), but decided to stay and shop around anyway. I'd been in the market for a new 18" solid gold chain for a pendant I have, but I didn't want to spend an arm and a leg! The prices here are pretty reasonable :) A couple of the sales staff helped me during my visit and both were incredibly kind and patient while I made my decision. They took out all of the gold chains and let me look at them, as well as priced a few out for me. They price their gold chains by weight. I ended up getting an 18" solid gold mini figaro chain for about $90. I've had it now for about a month and I've been wearing it 24/7. It's holding up beautifully :) read more

Love coming here every time my bf and I are on the Cape always get great customer service and hospitality see you again soon :) Hannah and the manager ( sorry forgot name ) were great! :) read more

We popped in today looking for Cape Cod jewelry. Wendy and Hannah were wonderfully helpful and accommodating. The jewelry was beautiful and much more reasonably priced than other places we've looked. read more

This is the only place I will go for my Cape Cod jewelry! Quality, prices and service are amazing. you will not regret shopping here!

This place was the best jewelry shopping experience I have ever had. The staff and owner were so helpful and understanding of our several purchases and a few of our exchanges. They are very accommodating and wanting you to have the best experience. read more

I love the Silver Unicorn! The staff are so helpful and kind! They also gift wrapped our jewelry too!

I stopped by recently in search of wedding rings and had a great shopping experience. I was greeted by warm smiles from the staff, and the owner Steve introduced himself to me. The woman behind the counter who helped me was very attentive, knowledgeable and patient with my many questions. My fiancé and I will be back- this will be our "go to" jewelry store- the selection of jewelry is amazing. Thank you Silver Unicorn!!! read more

There is so much jewelry to choose from!! The prices are discounted and the salespeople were friendly and helpful. I will definitely be back! read more

I get all of jewelry from here, the staff is so kind and are always able to find exactly what I'm looking for! The prices are great, and I know my jewelry is in great care when I bring them to be cleaned! I will never go anywhere else read more

Always friendly. Always willing to work with you. Always good prices! We will visit the Silver Unicorn every time we visit the cape!

My wife went into the store to purchase a piece of keepsake jewelry for my son. Somehow the owner decided to upsell my wife and do a cash deal in the tune of 1600 for 13 gram Figaro 14k chain. If you do the math the chain is sells for best 400.00 pure around the tune of $700.00 for something that my son didn't even want. The following day we went to return to get the cash returned to us and all that was offered was a store credit. Note we buy jewelry each year for the past 15 years from them. Buyer beware... read more

I went there to get a chain for my locket/urn. The family that owns and operates were incredibly warm, and kind. I was shown a silver chain that is so durable they have one on display holding up a brick! It was also priced fairly, and surprisingly affordable. It was very important to me that it be durable. I carried my son for 9 months, and will carry him in my heart forever. With the help of the wonderful people at the silver unicorn I will carry him on my kneck for the rest of my life as well. We can not thank you enough. read more

This is my go-to for 14k gold or sterling silver jewelry. The quality is excellent and the prices are less expensive than other jewelry stores in the area. The owner is also super nice and helped me select my bracelet based on what I was looking for. Super happy with this purchase (and the way my other pieces have held up over the years). read more

If I could give this jewelry store 0 stars I would. I stopped in 2 weeks back and bought a beautiful ring. I wore it a few times and after about a week the ring completely cracked and was unwearable. I went back in today with a receipt (to prove I bought it not too long ago) and the older man who "helped me" (who I think is the owner or manager) was extremely rude and inconsiderate of my money and experience. He told me it was not his problem the ring broke. I explained to him that it was an $80 ring and should not have broke the way it did. I asked to have it exchanged instead of refunded, so that I could just have a new, not-broken ring. He laughed and said he wouldn't help me at all because it was not his problem. I furiously walked out of the store and will absolutely not be returning. My recommendation is, save your money and go to a jewelry store that doesn't sell you up charged poorly made jewelry. read more

DO NOT SHOP HERE. TOURIST TRAP! This place was horrible the woman who sold me my poor quality cape cod bracelet was impatient with my questions about the product. I went back in to try and return it less than 12 hours later because the bracelet was scratched and had faded color and she buffed it out. But 10 minutes later it looked exactly the same if not worse. The woman called me a "pain in the neck" , twice, to my face. Terrible customer service. I went in to speak with the owner who was not impressed with my dilemma and said he would try and do something to help. Haven't heard from him since. read more

VERY VERY rude man that works there or owns the place, extremely passive aggressive. A shame because they seem to have nice jewelry but the man was completely disgraceful... read more

We visit every time we visit the Cape, we never leave without a gift the remind us of our wonderful holiday. Thank you for helping us keep our memories alive. read more

***ALERT*** DON'T Buy ANYTHING from Silver Unicorn on Route 28 in yarmouth, They Sell Silver PLATED JUNK METAL! My grandmother bought me a gift back in 09 and today I went to a place that buys SILVER and they tested it and it came back fake. That's over 200 dollars that my grandmother spend on that Silver plated junk! read more

Although the buying experience was pleasant, the return policy (which, admittedly, is posted behind the counter on a piece of paper) is non-existent. No cash refunds? To have such a strict policy in place, one would expect to be verbally informed of it as well as in print on the receipt. Neither of which was the case. Too bad. BEWARE!!! Make sure you love what you buy or be willing to take store credit. read more

This shop has been in business for over 35 years, no easy feat on Cape Cod. While I did find what I was looking for, a specific gift for someone, I found the endless cases of jewelry to be kind of overwhelming, way overloaded and oddly lacking of interesting pieces for a jewelry store with so much inventory. The staff was very nice and the prices very fair. It's a great place to buy a jewelry gift. Maybe not so much for someone who is looking for more unique artisan pieces. read more

Love these guys. Super helpful staff, great selection and prices. Bought my girlfriend one of those classic Cape Cod bracelets here, which she loves. Had another one in mind, but they seemed to know her better than I did. Would definitely go back next time I'm on the Cape. read more

I needed a necklace repaired - very delicate chain, and my baby grabbed it of my neck, so it ripped where it attaches to the charm. I've had it repaired on the other side, so I knew the repair is not costly- between $10 And $14 I was quoted the last time at few places on Main street. And that's where I had it repaired last time - I should have just gone back, but I was passing by the Silver Unicorn that day, and stopped there because it was convenient.... Lady that took my necklace said "it should not cost much," I shared with her my past experience with pricing, and I left it there. 2 weeks later I was still waiting for a call from them, so I figured I should check on it! I was told that they tried to call me "multiple times and it was always busy!" I decided it's not worth it for me to even argue with the lady, because it was plain stupid to indulge in such obvious lie... there's no busy signal on my cell phone, I don't have a house phone , if they called they could have left a message, right...?! Anyway, I was happy to have my necklace back, so the very next day I went there - only to be surprised with a $25 bill!!!!! I asked the lady, what material did they use to be so expensive??? She replied, "sterling silver"... well, the only problem is that my necklace is 14k white gold! Then, she was trying to backpedal, very unsuccessfully, after confirming what I was saying is true...ughhh the headache this whole encounter gave me! I asked her straight out - Do YOU think this is anywhere near reasonable?? She just blinked my way for a minute...she couldn't prove to me what material was used to repair it, yet was "100% certain" it was 14k white gold... all I know is that the receipt said "sterling silver"!!!!..... I told her for $25 I could buy a whole necklace from sterling silver.... And then she had THE NERVE to talk back in a mocking voice, saying "well, not in 14k gold you won't!!" I don't write bad reviews usually, things happen... but she would just not quit it. Asking me if I wanted my necklace back (?!?) and after I paid and was walking away, she ,again mockingly said "have a GREAT day"... I just lifted my arms in disbelief and left... Stay away, go to Main Street in Hyannis - cheaper, great quality, better CUSTOMER SERVICE, speedy and courteous- nothing like what I experienced at the Silver Unicorn! read more

Huge selection of jewelry! They have everythng from $10 rings to wedding bands. We went here twice in one day - the first time the woman was kind of cold but when we returned to purchase something she was friendly. I tried on probably 20 rings and didn't feel rushed. Seems like good quality and not overpriced, there's a tiny heart pendant for free with purchase (coupon in one of the guidebooks). They had exactly what I was looking for and a ton of sizes and styles. I'll be back next year for something else! read more

Bought my wedding ring here -- not only were they incredibly helpful, but honest, patient, transparent and inexpensive. Will come back!

Great store! Patty D was awesome. She is so knowledgeable and helpful. My new favorite store!!!

Just had an amazing buying experience with Patti. My wife was interested in a silver Cape Cod bracelet for her birthday. Patti anticipated our needs and made us feel very special! She even cleaned a couple of pieces of jewelry that we didn't even buy there. Great experience - thank you to Patti and Silver Unicorn! I will send others back to this great shop? read more

Never give this people to repair your watch.they crab my $2000 Versace and my Bulova as well very unprofessional and dishonest.

One summer I bought several silver gifts here and when Christmastime came, I went to get my gifts, and most of them were tarnished to the extent that I couldn't give them. Next summer, when we went back, I brought those items into the shop and explained what had happened. The sales associate said they hadn't been packaged properly, that she could take the items in the back and polish them and that they would be fine then. However, when we returned home, they weren't fine, and again, was unable to use them as gifts, as they had tarnished too much to give to anyone. In fact, I still have them. Now, when we are on the Cape, I no longer visit or shop at The Silver Unicorn. read more