I've purchased several pistols from Suffolk Sportsman, and every experience has been outstanding. Alan is knowledgeable, professional, and truly easy to deal with. He made each transaction smooth and straightforward from start to finish, no hassles, no pressure, just great service and communication. Highly recommend Suffolk Sportsman to anyone looking for quality firearms and honest, reliable customer care. read more

Very knowledgeable owner operator. Alan the proprietor is truly a nice guy. He runs the store with his son Danny. Very helpful and patient and can steer you in the right direction if you need assistance deciding between firearms and the right accessories. Great service on shipping and transfers and handles hunting and fishing licenses. read more

Always a great experience. Very knowledgeable and great customer service. Good selection of fishing gear and ammunition. Staff is very knowledgeable and helpful. 5 stars. read more

I went to this store today not thinking I was going to walk out with the hand gun I wanted.they have a lot of hand guns in stock.they were so helpful and so nice to help me get this gun sig sauer 365x Marco .i will definitely be back there again . If u can't find what u are looking for give them a shot . Thank u guys you were great read more

I've been coming here for over a decade. Allan is a great guy and extremely knowledgeable. He takes his time and explains things to people new to firearms. The selection is great and they also carry a lot of items related to fishing and other outdoor activities. I highly recommend Suffolk Sportsman for anyone looking to purchase a firearm beginner or experienced. read more

I have been a customer for 19 years. always friendly and helpful. Very knowledgeable and will get you what you want if they don't have it. within reason of course. Charlie G. read more

Sporting goods and guns. I'll admit it, I'm getting ready for the zombie apocalypse; you see enough of it on TV and the movies, so it must be real...right? Aside from the walking dead, I came to the realization after the recent hurricane events in my area, that I am woefully unprepared in terms of self-protection and projecting a sense of "go somewhere elseness" to wood-be thieves, that I decided it is time to arm myself. I'll admit it, I think I have watched one too many "Doomsday-prepper" shows... I haven't been around or needed firearms in a long time, so venturing in to this place was a bit intimidating, but more from a cautious standpoint on my part, than anything else. The guys working here took the time to explain what my options were in my the type of rifle I was looking for and gave me plenty of info that is allowing me to do some complete research on the final design of the weapon I want. No hard sales push and totally professional, I was very pleased with the whole experience. Aside from guns and hunting items, they have a nice selection of fishing and other sportsmen related goods. Definitely worth a look if you are in the area. Parking in the rear. read more

Warning to anyone considering selling a gun via consignment with these crooks. I gave them an antique rifle to sell in 2017. I then called them every several months and they said there was no activity on the rifle. During the past few months I called every month and they said they would either get back to me or that that rifle had not been sold yet I became very suspicious and decided to pay a visit in person to get my rifle back. It was only then that they informed me that it had been sold several months ago. Even though they had my phone number and even though I made many attempts to contact them and find out the status they never told me about the sale. It is obvious that their plan was that I would just forget about it and they would keep all the money. Beware read more

John and Allan are quite helpful. My purchase was at a very competitive price. It's great to have a good local place to do business. I will be a returning customer read more

Cool place. Decent selection. Picked up a beautiful Mosin Nagant M91/30 yesterday. Not the typical high-pressure, bad attitude place you'd expect from a gun shop. read more

The people at Suffolk Sportsman are friendly and knowledgeable. All of the shooter/ hunter guys I know go there. If there's an item that they don't have, they will order it if you ask. They also don't try to push higher priced items than what you need. I went in looking for an "affordable" shotgun, (which is a very relative term with firearms). The only question that they had was what I was looking to use it for. He showed me a very good one for about $100 cheaper than I thought it would be. Most places I've been to will tell you that they have one for $250 that's not too great, but have a better one for $400. I highly recommend. read more

Over priced ammo when reliable sources are online. Also every phone call I make over there I get a very irritable and condescending response. Although I am all for supporting local business this one does a poor job at trying to maintain new customers by being competitive with other businesses online and across the island. read more

Suffolk Sportsman is the best sporting goods store on Long Island! Owners Alan and John are extremely professional, very knowledgable and very helpful in finding the best fit for each person. I also appreciate that whenever I go in there, someone always helps me out and they aren't pushy. This is a great store, has great parking and a staple in the Smithtown community. I would highly recommend this store to all my peers. read more

I bought a Remington 700 sps tactical from Suffolk Sportsman in 2014. I was not aware of the xmp trigger recall at the time. The following week I saw a online article about it and I went to Remington's web site and entered my rifles serial # in and the only thing that came up on the screen was "this number has been entered into the system already, check back at a later date for more info". So I then called Suffolk Sportsman up and inquired about my rifle. I was told by ALLEN that the trigger recall was taken care of already by Remington before he sold me the rifle. Ok. So I put my rifle into my gun safe and it sat there until now when I am ready to start my build on it. Doing some more research on the Remington 700 and the trigger recall I saw that the way you can tell if your rifle has been retrofitted with the new trigger was by a punch mark on the bolt release. Low and behold my trigger does not have a punch mark. I called Remington directly and they inform me my trigger indeed needs to be retrofitted and they will be sending me out a box so I can ship my rifle to them for the retrofit. The issue I have with Suffolk Soortsman is that they KNOWINGLY SOLD ME A RIFLE THAT HAD A DEFECTIVE TRIGGER AND THEN LIED TO ME OVER THE PHONE THAT THE RETROFIT WAS DONE ON IT. Thank God I never even loaded the weapon and nobody got hurt or worse. So I hope everybody reads this review so you can see for yourselves what kind of people you will be dealing with at the Suffolk Sportsman. Stay clear of this place. read more