Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Sweet Tooth

    4.4 (5 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 8:00 pm

    The Sweet Tooth Photos

    You might also consider

    More like The Sweet Tooth

    Recommended Reviews - The Sweet Tooth

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    this place closed early and refused me service. why are we closing before our hours on the sign say???

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Matthew G.
    496
    122
    57

    9 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of V W.
    0
    6
    0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    This place has the best ice cream ever and a huge selection of candy. I definitely recommend it!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - The Sweet Tooth

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt 2,272 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Counter

    The Counter

    4.0
    (6 reviews)
    3.3 mi

    I was excited about this new local ice cream shop downtown. Finally, a charming spot worth…read moresupporting instead of another trip to the corporate chains. What a disappointment it turned out to be..I doubt this place will last the summer. The concept is cute, but the execution is a sloppy, strangely toxic little operation run by a high-strung pick me owner and her rotating crew of indifferent young workers. I waited more than twenty minutes for two simple orders, only for them to come out half-wrong: incorrect flavors, missing toppings, and sloppy scoops thrown together carelessly. When I gently pointed out the flavor mistake, the owner's response wasn't to fix it but to get immediately defensive and nasty. Zero grace, zero accountability. just brittle attitude instead of basic service. I didn't say another word and just left. I ended up throwing out the order that was wrong because of allergies. There was a gross atmosphere among the staff. You could almost hear the echo of high school hallways. A favored circle lounged around exchanging smirks, whispered barbs about customers, and idle gossip, while the few conscientious ones scrambled to pick up the slack. The owner's selective blindness was obvious. It created a clear undercurrent of favoritism, pettiness, and low key bullying that made the whole place feel cliquey and mean spirited. A business that prioritizes goofing off to fit in with teens, over consistent quality and basic courtesy isn't built to last. Between the long waits, constant errors, and thoroughly unpleasant energy, I won't be returning. and I wouldn't recommend it to anyone. For the few kids hustling, I hope you find a better gig. You deserve respect. If you value professionalism, competence, and a warm welcome, take your money elsewhere. For all its aspirations, this spot is a disaster and not worth the wait.

    I've tried this cute ice cream spot when it was located across the street & fell in love with it…read more So many choices. Great new location too. We got the affogato with pistachio ice cream & the pretzel sundae. So good. The staff is friendly & helpful with their large menu. I've had their ice cream sandwiches with chocolate chip cookies. Amazing. Street parking is easy in cute downtown Highland.

    Photos
    Building
    Building
    Pistachio affogato & pretzel sundae
    Pistachio affogato & pretzel sundae
    Pistachio Almond Affogato with Signature Carmel Salted Pretzel Sundae

    See all

    Pistachio Almond Affogato with Signature Carmel Salted Pretzel Sundae
    Jodi's Italian Ice Factory

    Jodi's Italian Ice Factory

    4.4
    (196 reviews)
    1.3 mi
    $

    Yummy Italian Ice, steaks & hoagies. I travel to get my Italian ice fix & they never disappoint. It…read morecould be updated a bit & spruced up especially with the money they're making because they stay packed. I enjoy them year round their food is awesome!!!!

    UPDATE: NO ONE FROM THE ESTABLISHMENT HS REACHED OUT TO ME AT ALL!!!. I t appears that they elect…read morewho they want to respond to, regarding the reviews 1/5/26: I bought the 6 inch pastrami only and 9 inch create your own hoagie. This first in person order that I placed, both sandwiches appeared to be the same exact size. 1/11/26: I placed an online order. This order was correct, but the sandwiches were not made at time of scheduled pick-up, SO my relative had to wait for the order that was placed online ahead with a scheduled pick-up time chosen, for them to make the sandwiches. The were three 12-inch subs that were correct. The wait time for a scheduled online order was the issue. 1/30/2026: I asked for manager on duty. The name that I heard the employee say in the background of the call, was "Corey/Cory/Cori". I was on hold for a total of 15 mins after the female employee put me hold twice without telling me that I was on hold. She just put the phone down both times and she can be heard in the background taking orders. When she was not taking orders, she was trying to get someone (this Corey person, who must have been the manager on duty that day) to come to the phone. He never came to the phone and I just hung up. Not being able to speak to the person on duty regarding the incorrect order for 1/5/2026 I placed an in person was on 2/2/26: I spoke to a woman with red hair, who I thought was 1 of the owners. I told her about my 1/5/26 purchase. At 1st: She tried to say that maybe I was charged for two 6 inch sandwiches and I though that I had a 9 inch. I told her that I still had my 1/5/26 receipt and was in fact charged for one 6 inch and one 9 inch sandwich. She said that she would give me a "credit" that could be used on my next visit. I placd an order afterwartds. One of the pastrami only sandwich did have mayo even thug I asked for it. Both of the create your own sandwiches did NOt have any cheese on them even though I asked for pepper jack cheese. Also 1 of the create sandwiches was not suppose to have lettuce, tomato or onion on it and the other one had everything minus the cheese. 4/11/2026: I purchased an order for four 10 inch sandwich: 2 pastrami only and 2 with pastrami, salami and turkey. The pastrami was not edible at all. It tasted like a net on a ham. I was also given an extra 9 inch sandwich, which was the credit give to me from the red hair. The young lady at register tried to assist me, while I was explaining to her that someome named Corey/Cory refused to come to the phone to asisst on 1/30/26. She said she was going to get "Corey/Cory". This Corey person comes ot looking confused. Then I tried explaining to him what took place and he quickly talked over me, looked in system to see the credit for another sandwich he says that the coupin is only good for 30 days. I told him that it was never explained to me that the credit was only good for 30 days plus I do NOT live in Indiana, I am coming from Illinois when I do patronize the business. Corey then asks for a yooung female, who is caucasian to assist him, but she actually helped me and he went back towards to back. I have not had any luck getting ahold of anyone at the restaurant to take corrective action. None of my family members were able to eat the sandwiches due to the bad pastrami and we tossed all of them in the trash, My bank is waiting for me to see if I can get any kind of resolve before we dispute the full April 11, 2026 transaction amount. Attached is a picture of what the pastrami looked like. I can be reached at 773-562-2354. My name is Michelle.

    Photos
    Jodi's Italian Ice Factory
    Medium strawberry and creamy coconut
    Medium strawberry and creamy coconut
    Outside of Jodi's in my 1979 Cadillac coupe Deville

    See all

    Outside of Jodi's in my 1979 Cadillac coupe Deville

    The Sweet Tooth - icecream - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...