It can be a bit slow, but it is a small building with so many potential employees. I will say that the delicious food most definitely makes up for it. The staff have always been friendly. It is outside seating only, but I think that adds to nice spot. I would very much recommend trying here! read more

Family owned and operated for more than a decade. Cooking up some of the best food you're gonna find in the area. Not fast but fresh! Better to call ahead to reduce your wait time. They are almost always busy and on a hot day when there are games , the line can get really long. But it's worth the wait. Homemade food right out your mamas kitchen, definitely worth the wait. The tenderloins they make fresh in-house. The pizzas are made fresh every order and can get creative. The Broasted chicken , it's moist on the inside and extra delicious crunch on the outside. They have a secret recipe on the Cooney Dog. I love the handmade burgers. They put all the traditional trimmings on it, and don't forget the fries. They have awesome curly fries also, you can add cheese on the side or on top! They have so many flavors and creative ice creams , my kids absolutely love it! The outside area has seating in the shade, in the sun if you like and also covered seating if it's raining or you just want to rest under the covered area. They have a bike rake and are right across from the Marathon Station, if you need to fuel up your vehicle. You have to stop to see them if you pass through the area. read more

See all

Excellent service from Casey and excellent food and prices most of all the food is very fresh and delicious...

Guy is so nice and everything is great for a low price! We always come here from California. Ordering ahead (call the number and place an order) is definitely recommended than driving up!) As always, we'll be coming back! read more

The Tasty Freeze - Building image - Comfort Food Near Me - Montezuma, Indiana

We came after a day kayaking. The banana split was good as was the brownie delight. It was a short wait and the service was good. They had lots of tables for eating and it was great small town stop. read more

See all

Very poor quality of food and service was worse than the food but most of all way over priced

Worst food and service ever.The young man in the drive thru said it's a thirty minute wait and it was being fifty minutes and our food was burnt and tasteless also Way over prices then we talked to the manager she said she could not do anything about it even when I said there's a roach in the bag but food administration will take care of it lol If you are wanting great food during cover bridge or any other time tray the Mexican restaurant in montazuma read more

We love their food. Especially their broasted chicken, the tenderloins and their shakes.

So many options for soft serve and shakes. Fries were hot and crispy. Such a good find!

Dont go here and get food and the milk shakes if you wanna wait like an hour for a small order thats for one person seriously 5 people got there food before me and I ordered before they did and then the girl did not even give me napkins for my greasy ass burger workers are rude here now I know why I don't hardly ever come here its not worth the little drive to Montezuma read more

Always had good clean service there. Sodas, food and ice-cream. Eat at tables in your car or to go. read more

i ate lunch at tasty freeze. I had a hamburger and fries. The fries were hot and salty and delicious. the hamburger came out with fry sauce that I couldn't eat because I'm dairy free. They willingly took it back and made me a new one. Great customer service. read more

Had the double bacon cheeseburger with fried mushrooms and a peanut butter ice cream cone. FANTASTIC. Be prepared for a MASSIVE ice cream cone. Will definitely eat here anytime I'm near. read more

We usually love it here, however this time we ordered a peanutbutter and butterfinger milkshakes. There was barely any pb in the one and the other tasted like a root beer float. I took it back and she said that was how it was made. This would have been nice to know before ordering. Also we ordered loaded ffs. We were thinking cheese and bacon this is usually standard. It came with black and green olives and green peppers on it! Yuck! This also would have been nice to know before ordering, this trip was kindof awful. Side note : the staff was friendly. read more

The Tasty Freeze is a wonderful little hometown stop. They serve just about every kind of ice cream creation you could imagine. Our favorites are the flurries, which are like DQ's Blizzards. In addition to their great ice cream, they also serve lunch/dinner - chicken, sandwiches, fries, onion rings, tenderloin, etc. Their motto - "not fast, just fresh" - can be true especially during summer/baseball season but it's worth the wait. Portion sizes are excellent - you definitely get your money's worth. Order at the counter and then use the outdoor seating or you can take it to go. They also have a drive-thru for those rolling through or on their way home. read more

We stopped by to get ice cream with the grandkids... At least that was our excuse. The ice cream was great. I got a Boston shake which was made perfectly. The kids got an assortment of items which they all devoured. It takes a little time to get your order but it's worth it. read more

The Tasty Freeze - Another satisfied customwr - Comfort Food Near Me - Montezuma, Indiana

Its fairly good variety sheds no light on service. If you want ice cream its great, If your after food you will be waived on to a parking lot. This is where they will "waive" to you that your food is ready. Frozen "made to order fries" and a hot dog that seems questionable at best. The coney sauce was great, not quite worth the half hour wait because the server is shy about waiving to people read more

We love this place. Their shakes are amazing. We love LOVE LOVE their chili !! We love all their food

A Tuesday evening, we now have been officially waiting AN HOUR for our food. Three hamburgers and chicken tenders. I think they make food for the drive through first. Maybe 4 other people here. Everyone else is getting ice cream. Now it's been 64 minutes. This is nuts. read more

Great home town place to eat, I personally wasn't the biggest fan of the ice cream. The food was defiantly worth going back for sometime.

Food was ok, but had to wait over two hours to get it. When asking what items came on various entrees/sandwiches, the lady didn't know.

Absolutely love the staff. Love the food and the ice cream!! Favorite food? It's a hard choice between the cheeseburger and the breaded tenderloin. Favorite ice cream? Cow pie flurry. You can't go wrong eating here. read more

my sandwhich fell apart almost instantly, took over a hour to get my food,barley warm honestly if you were to go here just stick with shakes

Not many choices in town, in fact there are no choices in town. We have at here MANY times. Food is pretty fair for a little ice cream shop. Service is always a problem. While staff is friendly it's always busy and wait times are forever!!! read more

The place was recommended to me by friends when I was visiting. I finally made the trip to Montezuma. Boy, I don't regret it. This place is surreal. Amazing food and ice cream selection and great service despite the crowd waiting. I tried the best breaded tenderloin I've ever had and the flurries are to die for. This place should be on diners and dives. It's one of those old timer places you don't want to see change one bit. read more

Good ice cream but they are well beyond slow. Waited for over 20 minutes for a burger. Also there are hundreds of sweat bees that will not leave you alone. read more

We love their the broasted chicken it is worth every penny. THEY ARE ALL SO FRIENDLY and the eating area is so clean.. I would have to say try it once and you will be hooked.. read more

Growing up in Montezuma, I ate at The Tasty Freeze pretty often, it was nice but nothing like it is now. I have recently driven to Montezuma from east of Bellmore (about a 20 mile drive) just for one of The Tasty Freeze's Breaded Tenderloins. Those things are HUGE and delicious. They are big enough for 4 sandwiches. Well worth the $8.50 price. I would definitely recommend The Tasty Freeze !!! read more

Super clean place, fresh food! The menu is amazing soooo many options! We had the tenderloin- wow, delicious . My daughter loved the chicken fries & their mini tacos. My son tried the double burger- and a brownie delight! Everything was perfect! We sat outside and enjoyed the nice picnic table. Definitely worth a stop if anywhere near this area. read more

The food is good,but don't go there if you want to be treated with repsect. They hung up on me mid sentence on the phone. When I called back they was rude to me. When I got there to pick my food up. They told me it would be 20 min more because they thought I may have been calling to cancel my order. Whatever. So they bring me my food about 3 min later. Right? So they lied about that. I asked who took my order on the phone, apparently they had no idea who took it. They forgot my fried. Then was going to charge me for the fries they forgot, and make me wait 20 more minutes for fries while my food got cold. No I didnt wait. I have been coming to the tasty freeze for years, the service is always horrible. They couldn't even tell me the correct cook times, nor was the staff appropriately trained as the lady said so herself. So don't waste your time. Go down to the restaurant, they are super friendly and a lot cheaper read more

The food reminds me of when I was a child and the original owners of the Tasty Freeze had it. The Sloppy Joes still taste like they did 30 years ago, which I have to say is delicious. The menu has a lot to choose from, including shakes and cones as well as sandwiches. My only complaint is it's a bit pricey for the area. But if you're driving through Montezuma, it's worth a stop to check it out. read more