Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Toss Up Salad Bar Restaurant

    5.0 (1 review)
    Closed 10:30 am - 6:00 pm

    The Toss Up Salad Bar Restaurant Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like The Toss Up Salad Bar Restaurant

    Recommended Reviews - The Toss Up Salad Bar Restaurant

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Salad 186 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Sage Karma Kitchen

    Sage Karma Kitchen

    4.4
    (65 reviews)
    3.2 mi
    $$

    The food is wonderful. They said they were founded by someone with dietary restrictions with the…read moregoal of being a safe place to eat for people with a variety of restrictions and allergies. They were very great and informed about our needs (as someone at our table has a severe food allergy). We tried multiple dishes and they were all so yummy - very fresh and flavorful. The vegan/gluten free cupcakes were SOOOO good too!

    I typically like the eating establishments in downtown Willoughby. They are all nice little places…read morewith good everyday bar food. Easy to order, easy prices, good everyday food. Unfortunately, that was not my experience with "Sage Karma Kitchen". We showed up there for a quick dinner. The room was maybe 25% full. Plenty of room for seating. The hostess thought it was a great idea to sit us directly in the scorching sun rather than every other table in the room that would have been shaded... oh well. Our waitress showed up to take our order before we had a chance to even pick up the menus. We asked for just a couple minutes and she cheerfully walked away. Seemingly, never to return. I looked all around for her until I found her leaning on the bar talking to friends. We finally placed our orders, somewhat begrudgingly. My wife had a bowl that she definitely enjoyed very much. She said she would like to return to try it again. I struggled to find anything on the menu that sounded remotely interesting and finally just ordered the hummus appetizer. I fear they left the flavor in the kitchen. It certainly never arrived at my table. When we were ready to leave I had to begin the search once more for our waitress. She was nowhere to be found. I couldn't even enlist the aid of the hostess because she had found a group of her own friends to talk with. Finally, I found our waitress and was able to escape. The two stars is only because my wife enjoyed her bowl. For me... naaa! Too bad. No second chance here.

    Photos
    Our waitress is in there somewhere
    Our waitress is in there somewhere
    Good bowl
    Good bowl
    The drinks were everything!

    See all

    The drinks were everything!
    Mykonos Gyro

    Mykonos Gyro

    4.9
    (37 reviews)
    5.2 mi
    $$

    We enjoyed our visit to Mykonos Gyro ! We went for lunch on a Saturday and a couple of tables were…read morefilled, but there was plenty of seating. We were greeted right away by we think was one of the friendly owners. When you order a drink, it's in a cooler that is either a bottle or a can. My husband got the Kalamata Specialty Gyro and it was humongous!!! It was filled to the brim with Gyro meat -Kalamata olives -feta cheese, and french fries. My husband said it was DELICIOUS .! The only problem is that there was so much of it. It was way too much for him to eat. I got a regular Gyro with french fries. It was good, but I won't say that it was the best that I've ever had. We also ordered the pierogies that came with tzatziki sauce. They were very yummy.! ** We really wanted to mention the MUSIC that they play here. I guess I would call it Pop music, but in the Greek language!! They had it at the Perfect Volume level to where you could enjoy the music but you could also have a nice private conversation.!!! Fantastic!!! We really loved the music! ** The service was very good. And the food came out fast. We took some of the baklava home to eat later. My husband loved the baklava! He said it was super buttery and delicious! I guess my suggestion would be that if you order one of the specialty gyros, you should take someone with you to split it because they give you A LOT OF FOOD! So you definitely get your money's worth for a good meal ! We hope everyone tries this restaurant in Mentor

    Wanna hear a shocker? I LOVE Greek food! Okay, that's not so shocking. I studied abroad in Athens,…read moreGreece back in 2011 and lived on a diet of Gyros and souvlaki. But back then, dinner only cost me 2 euros... now Mykonos Gyro in Mentor, Ohio isn't 2 euros, but it is still very cheap! I wish a nice place like this was near my home or near my work instead of all the way out in Mentor, Ohio! But I was in the area, going to the dentist appointment, and had this joint on my want to visit list for a few months, so I picked up dinner to-go after my appointment. This is a sort of new, small, authentic Greek eatery, run by very kind and helpful Greek gentlemen. I ordered a small lamb/beef gyro meal to-go. For $7.99, it also comes with fries. It only took 5 minutes for it to be ready and after my 20 minute drive home, I opened up the takeout box and saw massive portions of food! If I was smart, I would have reheated my fries in the air fryer and not the microwave, but I am sometimes dumb and had reheated fries. I think that if they were freshly eaten right when I got them, they would have been better. However, I would have liked them seasoned. So I just used some seasonings I had at home. The gyro, for being a "small," was big, filling, and delicious! The vegetables were fresh, the gyro meat was tender and plentiful, and the pita itself was quite nice. No complaints! I will continue to try to support this small business whenever I am back in Mentor. It was so good!

    Photos
    Mykonos Gyro
    Kalamata Gyro is HUGE
    Kalamata Gyro is HUGE
    Exterior

    See all

    Exterior

    The Toss Up Salad Bar Restaurant - salad - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...