Great food, Garlic knots were the hit for everyone. Ordered twice in a week. Found my new go to Pizza Place.

The staff was patient with me my first time here, as I tried to figure out exactly what I wanted to order. They offer pizza by the slice, and you can see which are available as soon as you walk in. I tried the Margherita and Spicy Pig slices, along with a 3 piece garlic knots. Both slices were delicious and still nice and warm when I got them back to my hotel. The location is a little small. It is a good vibe though, and seemed to be a little busy when I walked in. Good slices, friendly staff, good vibes. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Spicy Pig, Margherita, Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

Wow, NYC got transformed to a Pacific City. Walk in and see the fresh pie, thin crust of course. Never mind the ambiance it doesn't matter when it comes to taste. I can't tell you which one to get. But I will guarantee one thing. You will buy another slice. They do the XL diameter and serve it by the slice. It crust is re- toasted at high temp for a minute. I'm going to guess the guy is from NYC. This due to the sauce. Tangy, slightly sweet, thick, smooth, evenly placed but all the way to the edge! Go! Do it! Can you tell I'm hyped about this place in a little strip mall? read more

Uptown Pizza & Bagel is hands down the BEST in town!!! From the moment you walk in, Vanessa makes you feel so welcome--she's the sweetest and truly sets the tone for such a great experience. The jalapeño bagel is my absolute favorite (perfect little kick ), and the white pie is SO good... but honestly, you can't go wrong with anything on the menu. And don't even get me started on the cheesecake--OMG it's a must!! If you haven't been yet, you're seriously missing out! read more

Oh my word I wish we lived near here! This for sure will be our go to when in the area. This and the Peruvian place in the same plaza. The pizza really is like the pizza i enjoyed for years in time square. Much respect!!!! And the ranch. Delish!!!!! Clean place too. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Trust!!! It tastes DELICIOUS!!!!!!!!! May not look great but it is the best!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

People hyping as the closest to an authentic NY pizza place and I guess I have to agree! They do have one,if not the tastiest pizza in town. My son who loves pizza loved it more than his usual pizza spots. Highly recommended! read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Doing a double slice pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

See all

I ordered the special that includes two pizza slices and a drink. All of the pizza looked delicious but since I was with my daughter, we decided to keep it simple and go with cheese and pepperoni pizza. My daughter loved the cheese pizza. As soon as we walked in, we were greeted right away. The restaurant was very clean and they got our slices out quickly. Before leaving, I also ordered two bagels to go, and I'm really glad I did. The bagels were delicious. We will definitely be back again! read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Pepperoni Pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

See all

I've never really been a fan of NY style pizza, but that all changed this weekend when we stopped in for this pizza. I was blown away on how flavorful the sauce was, how fresh the ingredients were, and the crust... Dammmm!!!!! That crust was so good. It was light, and when you got to the end it was crispy. Each slice was such a great size and the toppings come perfectly distributed. We ordered a pepperoni, a supreme, and 1 slice of Margarita (which was my favorite.). When we come back to Temecula, this will be our go to now. The staff are also so amazing. They're all so friendly and had some good tunes playing. You can see the reaction of other customers who are eating there. They love this pizza, and the love the atmosphere there. It's what imagine a local NY pizza parlor would be like. Thanks for a great dinner and making us feel welcomed! read more

See all

I've been to so many differ pizza places and this place does it RIGHT! They have a deal with two slices and a drink for only 12 bucks and their slice selection is amazing so many different pies to choose from and they all look delicious. The service was fast and friendly too, I only visited for a break during work hours but I'll definitely be coming back any time I'm in the area ! read more

Wings so good (if you like them crispy ask ahead of time)! Pizza crunchy and soft all at once don't know how else to explain (sausage on the meats lovers is so tasty)! Bagels delish! The garlic knots are a must have! All very delicious! Staff is friendly, such a nice atmosphere. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

Stopped in for a lunch date with some of my girls and the staff was super friendly and quickly got our slices warmed up seating was open. Inside was clean. read more

See all

Why is it I never knew Times Square existed until just a few days ago? I was tasked to pick up bagels for a small group of us. Times Square came up as being the closest place to me and with high ratings. I walked in, picked from their display case and my task of bagel picker upper was completed. Very good freshly baked bagels! The next morning we enjoyed our bagels topped cream cheese and paired with a cup of coffee. Tip: if you need more than a few bagels, call ahead and preorder to make sure they have enough for you. read more

Very good quality food. Perfect ratio On the pizza. I love the classic little seasoned croutons on the ceasar salad. Salad dressing very tasty. Cheesecake very good as well. Probably ordered from NY which is the move to make. Very friendly staff and great atmosphere counter service pizza place. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Cheesecake - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

See all

Been here many times, pizza and bagels are fine. Added a cookie to my bagels cause why not, but checked what one was in bag in aluminum foil because I had thought there were two types while still at the register, but turns out it was burnt or regular. I asked her if I could switch it out and she said no cause I touched it (aluminum foil) but is right since you can't take food in. Solution if I wanted a non-burnt cookie was to purchase another one which I did. Picture attached. You can tell what a burnt cookie is. I thought it was double chocolate or something. Basic food service and customer service if someone spends over $25 don't pass something burnt off and then say basically, "you touched no take backs". Won't be back, not big deal, just principle of it all. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Both regular choco chip cookie.... One obviously burnt. - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

Super authentic nyc shop pizza is good and bagels are great as well . Just a little flop but good undercarriage. 7.8/10 one bite score

Thin pizza,crispy bbq wings. Such a good combination. Love this place. The Caesar salad is also good read more

See all

First time and it was I went in for lunch I wanted a pizza and saw this place sold by the slice. I will be coming back. Staff was super nice and place sure nice as well. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Lunch special! - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

I have only been here once for a bagel lox; it was okay. Wayyyy too much cream cheese and the salmon was not as fresh as I'm accustomed to on the east coast; especially NEW YORK! Came today to try the pizza. The "big girl" (I'm fluffy too so I can say this) had several opportunities to tell me that they had a 2 slice special with drink for $10.99. She NEVER ONCE offered. Then she made sure when she delivered the semi-warm slices to my table that I phad to PAY before I could take a bite. Good thing as when I bit into the cold, chewy dough and the tasteless toppings I was saddened. :( Sadder still was hearing the folk that walked in to order and was told about the 2-slice/drink special. Here I am eating 2 miserable slices, no drink for $12.94!! Remember Bongioirno's (sp?j of Temecula? They are now UPPER EAST SLICE. Now that's GENUINE, AUTHENTJC NY pizza‼. The owners are originally from Catskills, New York. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - NY BAGEL LOX - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

Food great, fresh and lots of toppings per selection. Great price and the staff is friendly. Ordered the 18 pizza with 3 toppings and was not disappointed. read more

Times Square pizza is so fire!! It was my first time here and everyone was so nice and welcoming.. especially Alyssa she's so sweet!

EVERYTHING! You're instantly greeted when entering by everyone working! I love that I can pick from a variety of different slices! And honestly can't wait to come back for a bagel and salad and the turkey club! read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

This was my first time here. The staff was really friendly. We ordered the lunch special which included to large pizza slices of your choice and a drink for $10.99. Inside they had table seating for small groups. read more

We went yesterday to try Temeculas Best Pizza.... Absolutely terrible is an understatement. Nothing wrong with the employees, the pizza itself had to be the most tasteless thing I've eaten in years. I had to look up if this was the only pizza place that entered this competition because that's what it seems like. If this recieved first place I can't imagine the other places in the area. Again nothing wrong with the cleanliness or employees that was all fine, the pizza itself is just definitely worth not even looking in this direction when you're hungry. Try little Cesar's instead you'll save money plus better tasting by miles. 1 star only because employees were nice. 0 stars otherwise read more

$12 dollars for two slices or $8 a Alice this place use to be two slices for $8 such a joke don't waste your money lol

It was our first time eating a tomato pie at this pizza joint. Being from New Jersey, Im really picky about the pies I eat. This place makes a good one and we'll be eating a pie again soon. Great job, guys and gal. read more

First time here from LA and I will be stopping by every time I come visit my family in Temecula. Glad to discover Times Square pizza & Bagels. Pizza and wings are very good! One of the best I've ever had ( and I l've eaten a lot pizza and wings with beer while watching sports). Great and fast service. Cashier (forgot her name) was very helpful and nice. We will definitely try out the bagels as well next time. read more

See all

No flavor whatsoever. Wouldn't be returning to this location. After two slices, I still felt extremely hungry. All stars deducted. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

See all

Wow what a lucky find. I was headed home from my daughters wedding In Fallbrook and pulled off the freeway and came across this location. Probably one of the best bagels I've ever had. Service was great fast and quick and I just wish they had one of these in Arizona where I live. read more

The food was amazing the fresh bagels were very good 10/10. The vibe here was chill, and if you like ranch, they make the best ranch. Everyone was very friendly. Definitely coming back soon! read more

Is the flavor in the building with us?? NY style my arse. Do they own a salt shaker?? This was the most bland flavorless pizza ever. Just nasty.. no way this is how pizza tastes in NY. As a Chicagoan, I give this a thumbs down! Never again! Eeeyuck! read more

The food at this restaurant was amazing. The service was good. Also the ambience was really crowded but I know that is a good sign for this place because everything was great. read more

LOVE this place! The Pizza is so good!! The veggies and pizza toppings taste fresh - and all the flavors combine so well. And the staff is super nice friendly and helpful. Highly recommend, this is my new favorite pizza spot. read more

Awesome place!! Fast and good prices. They have such an assortment of pizzas and I wanted sun-dried tomatoes and artichokes on a pizza that wasn't supposed to have it and they offered to put it on for me and it just is such a refreshing change of pace from the large and very structured pizza chains. read more

Times Square pizza never fails to make a delicious pizza. Every bite is so yummy and flavorable. Not many pizza places I can honestly say tastes as good as their pizzas read more

I love their pizza and service is always good! We have gone many times and continue to stop in when we are craving that thin old fashioned type of slices. Tried the calzone and wasn't too impressed but I'll stick to the large pepperoni and a cold pop! Yum, try a pie but eat it there so you get the hot & fresh experience. read more

Great pizza !! Fast service, never had to wait longer than 3 minutes when doing dine-in. Small but cute indoor seating. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - NY BBQ Chicken Pizza, NY Margherita Pizza, NY Buffalo Chicken Pizza & NY Sausage and Mushroom Melt Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

Really good place. Crispy crust pizza. "NY Style, thin and crispy". A little greasy, but to be expected with the style. Restaurant was clean and organized. Service was fast. Sale by the slice. I had the lunch special, 2 slices and a soda for 10 bucks! Can't beat it in SoCal. Would come again. read more

Abby and Kimberly are amazing! Great customer service, and even better pizza! Can't beat the 2 slices and a drink deal. read more

Times Square Pizza & Bagels - 2 big ahh slices and a drink. $9.99! - Pizza Near Me - Temecula, California

The Best Pizza around is this place. The service is great and you can buy by the slice. Excellent. You can't go wrong at Time Square Pizza. read more

The bagel sandwiches were really good! Massive portions so it really feels like a good bang for your buck. They really packed the bagels. The employees were really really nice as well. We showed up a few minutes early for our pick up but the staff were super friendly and tried apologizing for our order not being ready. Even though it was clearly on me for showing up early. Overall really good experience read more