Greasy thin crust that is a local favorite in the twin city area. When visiting I try to hit this spot more for old time's sake, not so much because it is the best pizza in town. Prices aren't bad, and make sure you're going the correct direction on the one way street, even if you've had a few beers. read more

Some of my friends told me about this place. There aren't many great pizza places (or anything food related) in Bloomington. I didn't think their pizza was anything special. But the waitress that served my food was kind of a psychopath. She wouldn't leave alone and let me eat my food in peace. She came over to my table every two minutes and asked ton of questions on my personal life. It was very unpleasant and the food doesn't give a reason to take me back. read more

We like to order Michaelios from Tobins. Yum. Good pizza. And we like the family meal deal with two pizzas and 4 drinks.

Horrible customer service (has been going downhill for a while but now not worth ordering from). Called and ordered pizza, was told check was fine as long as not from "wood forest bank" (same line they've used for years...no idea why the owner doesn't like wood forest, but not my place to question since they are upfront about it). Have paid by check from First State Bank Bloomington dozens of times. Check refused when delivery came. Called to complain and was brushed off. Will be giving Grady's all my business from now on. Better Pizza and WAY better sides/non-pizza items. Only ordered from Tobin's because Grady's is so popular the wait can be a little longer. Have ordered from Tobin's many times during my life, as my parents before me, now I will not return. read more

Thin crust is yummy and crunchy. I am a fan of this place, it is old and ugly inside but it is what makes it cool! They put the perfect amount of cheese on. read more

Loved the pizza (I'm from the Chicago area - I miss good pizza) until a friend who served there informed me of the incredibly unsanitary kitchen (from the looks of the place, I believe it!). Have not been back since! read more

good pizza, but is it really the best in Blom/Normal area? Came here at night with a friend and there was zero other customers present. The dining room looks like a scene from a mobster's movie, as if the restaurant was a front for the Italian mob. But in reality, this place is just really old fashioned and had lots of history to it where you can find pictures and illustrations dating back to the 1970s. We were quickly seated by the waitress in a booth. We ordered the garlic bread and a large Hawaiian pizza. The garlic bread has much to rave about. it was crispy and just seasoned just perfectly. The pizza left a bit to be desired though. It was kind of soggy and the greasy cheese just slipped off the crust. that is a deal breaker for me :( but our waitress was very nice and refilled our drinks promptly. read more

We ordered Tobin's for a trivia night with around 100 people. It was delivered hot, fresh and on time and was well-received by all of our guests! Tons of compliments! read more

Waaaaaaaay back in the day this was my pizza of choice while attending Illinois State. I had the chance to stop in this week and not a damn thing has changed. Pizza was great, mgmt. came by to check on you, and the same old photos adorn the walls ( I gotta believe there's one of me in there somewhere) I thought perhaps nostalgia colored my memories, but the food was as good as I remembered. Recommended. read more

Best pizza I've ever eaten. If they would drop their horrid spaghetti and sandwiches and just focus on the pizza and service then it could go to the next level. I've been eating there for 40 some years and have worked there for many as well. The quality dropped a bit when the new owners took over but still the best around. Highly recommend the Momma Theresas pan pizza. read more

Tried to grab a pizza the other night and the staff was terrible, got my number wrong twice and saying they tried to deliver the pizza but no one answered. The manager tried to make it seem like it was my fault their employee got the number wrong and after I waited and 2+ hours calling multiple times. Will not not be ordering here again. read more

Love their fried chicken! We have not ate at the restaurant. It's mostly delivery that we order. But it's fairly timed and we like the food. It's weird that they ask or make u wait depending on what pizza place you want to order.. but still good. read more

The food and atmosphere deserves 5 stars but is was a little pricey for pizza. My wife and I definitely recommend coming here. You'll be glad you did. read more

We love Tobin's pizza!! Most nights, standing room only but Moe does his best to get you seated!! Our recent trip was excellent. Christmas break for the college kids so we were seated right away or just got lucky!! We always have the deluxe pizza and a Hawaiian when we go. Never disappointed, lots of toppings, cheese and a good thin crust. The cheese bread, salad and chicken dinner are yummy also!! If you are in Bloom8ngton-Normal, IL, you've got to give Tobin's a try!! Moes's the nicest guy you will meet. Watch out for falling spiders!! Moe's a prankster!!! read more

Best pizza ever! I live in Nashville where Marco's is sort of like Tobin's but when I come here I have to have the real thing that tastes exactly like it did when I was in high school 40 years ago. The buck stretcher (free small with a large) is still a great deal too. read more

I was very dissapointed in our visit to tobins. We sat down and it was pretty empty even at dinner time. Our waitress could hardly be bothered with us. The pizza menu is over complicated. We ordered wings, the garlic bread and a deep dish 14" pizza. Our waitress brought our drinks out and then we didn't even see her again until the deep dish came out about 30 or 40 mins later. No wings or bread ever came out. She laughs and says, so they threw your ticket in the bowl and the wings and bread was never started. They will be out in 10 mins. They finally come out and we are done with our pizza. We were not offered so much as an apology. Then she brings the bill...grand total of $56 and some change. We were charges $12 for drinks alone. Seriously, I could have ran across the street to Kroger and bought my family of 5 drinks for $6 or $7. Anyways. Pizza was good, nothing like it was when I was a kid. Bread and wings were ok. Would have been nice to have had them as appetizers like we should have. Pitiful service. I think I'll take my business elsewhere from now on. Edit* Owner pretended to care said she was going to look into it and never heard back read more

Best pizza in town! Dine in or carry out it is always good. Like dining in because of the family atmosphere and small layout. Staff is always nice and on top of their game. Hardest part sometime is finding a parking spot. read more

I've carried out pizza here a few times and don't think it's anything special. I was recently given a gift card so I decided to try it again and ordered a two topping (vegetables) pizza. When I started eating the pizza, I found little bits of ham on several slices. I'm a vegetarian so this really was not okay with me. The ham wasn't spread out throughout the entire pizza, only a small area which tells me the ingredients were contaminated/mixed in. Since it was only part of the pizza and I used a gift card, I decided I didn't want to spend my time driving back but I definitely won't be returning. If you order a pizza without meat, it should come without meat (especially ham)! read more

My favorite pizza in the country!! Order Momma Teresa's pizza. It's the BEST pan pizza I've ever had. When my sister was visiting, we got some Tobin's for the rest of the family. She doesn't like pizza, but after everyone exclaimed how good it was, she tried and now she always asks me to bring some from Illinois to Iowa when we visit :) Normally, pizza sauce gives her heartburn, but Momma Teresa's has cheese with tomatoes on top--no sauce :) Tobin's is popular, so if you dine-in, you may be waiting 10-15 minutes for a table. Also, because the Momma Teresa's is pan pizza, it takes longer to make--but it's well worth it! To curb your appetite, try their yummy Super Salad Bowl. It can also be quite noisy, so if you want a quieter night, do carryout instead. We have ordered delivery a few times and found the pizza to be a bit soggy. It's much better to do carryout than delivery. We always order the Momma Teresa 15", and even during busy times the pickup time is only 30 minutes. The pizza does well as leftovers :) The 15" has 8 GIANT pieces, so you can get at least 4-6 meals from it. I used to eat Micheleo's once a week because they had a great lunch special on slices. After they went out of business, Tobin's bought their recipes, so if you're craving Micheleo's you can still enjoy it! The only downside is that we are vegetarians and four times have had pepperoni or ham on our pizza instead of pineapple (They use shorthand, I think it's P for pepperoni and PA for pineapple, and one guy taking the phone order even refused to write out pineapple when I asked :( We order a weird combo of onions and pineapple, so sometimes they think it's Hawaiian and put the ham on. So then when that happens we have to wait for them to remake the pizza.. not good when you're hungry. We've also found random bits of sausage and ham on our pizza, probably just drops down from other pizzas? It would be great if they could put the vegetarian pizzas on the top rack or do something to prevent those. Not a big deal, but for us it's a little sad that the animals died and someone who wants to eat ham or pepperoni is missing out because we just throw it away. Let's end on a more upbeat note. Try Tobin's Momma Teresa pizza! It's the best pizza I've ever had :) read more

My family has been going to Tobin's ever sense I was young--the workers recognize my family whenever we dine at the restaurant, which is always a welcoming. Waiting in the long lines on the weekend to have some of Tobin's pizza and garlic bread is definitely worth the wait! (Tobin's is never accepting credit and debit cards!) read more

Awesome food and great service. Feels like you're part of the family. Don't forget to sign up for your birthday cookie.

On the last night of a road trip and we didn't feel like going anywhere for dinner, just too tired. I checked on Yelp to see what good pizza was in the area. Tobin's had a lot of good reviews and they had thin crust which was just what we needed after a long day of travel. It took a whole to get here, but it was worth the wait. The packaging was something we had never seen before and we were intrigued. The pizza was pretty hot still and very yummy. The sauce was good and we were not overwhelmed by too much cheese. I wish we had a Tobin's at home! read more

Tobin's is good. I like the really casual family atmosphere and it's nice to have good pizza that delivers. The prices are typical of local pizza joints that I am used to. Plus they have RC in the soda fountain and really you can't beat that. read more

I have been going to Tobins my entire life of 33 years. Best Pizza in Illinois! Service is always top notch. Great job Moe and crew!

Tobin's is by far one of the best pizza joints in town. They perfectly combine cheese, sauce, and seasoning. They have friendly staff and the crispiest pizza around. If you have never tried it, I highly recommend it. read more

I've had Chicago stuffed pizza in Chi-town that was superb but if you're looking for the best thin crust pizza look no further than Tobin's. Perfect texture and flavor and that's just the crust. Combined with the toppings there's an explosion of great taste in your mouth. The chicken and spaghetti is seasoned very well. Staff is very courteous and helpful. Antoinette is great! read more

Always amazing. The restaurant has this cozy family theme that's truly appealing. The chicken is great as well if you are looking for something besides pizza! :) read more

I cannot believe this place will not allow you to order cheese with your salad without spending 3.00 for a super salad with stuff you don't want on it......horrible service, greedy practices, don't recommend ever going there read more

Good pizza. Proud to day this is made right here in blo-no. Lived here all my life and always remember going to Tobbins weird entrance for carry out and the smell of pizza ( and grease) cooking. The only thing stopping me from going to 5 is the price is high. read more

I would not recommend dining in. Here's a play by play of our night on 8/30/2016 and reasons for rating -Ticket times are unacceptable! -Waitress provided average service; but accurate wait time would've been nice. -atmosphere where we sat was freezing and cooled food almost faster than we could eat it (we where by the take out window area in a booth) - overall decor is cheap and dingy (plastic flannel-backed table cloths, plastic fake grapes laced in indoor lattice, red and green scratched up picture frames that look dirty and glass is noticing not clean and held up with cheap plastic tacky tabs, etc. 7:19- we arrive 7:20- we where seated 7:21- orders where taken, 3 pasta dishes and 1 pizza. 7:50- (30 minutes!!!-acceptable wait time is 15-20 minute ticket times) Only 3 pasta dishes arrived. Waitress said pizza would be only another 6 minutes. 8:05- (15 minutes elapse) pizza arrives. 2/3 people who ordered pasta are done when pizza arrived for 4th person. 8:13- we get our bill and cash is on the table at 8:14 8:17- waitress comes back with bill (not a bad wait time for bill) read more

Greasy, bland sauced pizza topped with government grade cheese served out of a building that resembles my backyard wood shed.

Who doesn't love Tobin's? C'mon now. Have you been inside that place? No? OK go home, think about your mistakes, then go to Tobin's. It's glorious. read more

No way do they replicate the original Micheleo's Pizza! When they were open, they were the best pizza in town. Mo Davis may have bought the name, but he doesn't buy the original ingredients, and the sauce doesn't even taste the same.... read more

I really enjoy Tobin's pizza...we get it delivered on occassion...my husband also enjoys their fried chicken. A great local place on Main Street that is easy to find! read more

It seems to be a consensus: Tobin's is perhaps the best pizza in Bloomington-Normal (that's actually saying something, given the number of places that serve up pies here in town). The Mama Theresa's is indeed phenomenal, but you can't go wrong with a "regular" thin crust pizza, either. They have barbecue sauce (or something like it) on all the tables, and I douse each slice with it before eating it. It's not that the plain pizza leaves something to be desired, it's just that it's even better with the sauce! The prices are definitely reasonable, and there are some other tasty menu items if you're not feeling like pizza. But this is the kind of pizza you can eat even when you don't really feel like eating pizza. They don't accept credit cards, which is kind of absurd, so make sure to have cash or check on hand. read more

Their meat-lovers is the best in town. The decor is very old school, but the pizza is great. Small parking lot so be prepared for some creative parking skills or a slight walk on the weekends. Go for the family buck stretcher if you can and put your name in the birthday list to get a free 10" pizza around your birthday each year. They don't forget! read more

I love Tobin's pizza. I always stick to my favorite toppings of theirs: sausage, pepperoni & mushroom. I love the fresh mushrooms. My parents used to order from here all the time when I was little. It's always been really good. Their garlic bread is great if you dine in. I also like the BBQ thats on each table. One thing to note is they do not have a hot box or anything if you place an order for pickup. The pizza can get cold if you're late or they're quicker than expected. read more

Ordered the spaghetti and chicken takeout special tonight, the customer service when I arrived was fantastic and the food was just as good. We plan on making this special our Tuesday night tradition going forward! read more

Great Pizza! I love the ham and onion and must have BBQ sauce with it!

I lobe tobins...reminds me of a pizza joint my family would go to on the south side of chicago. Wish they had better consistency or quality control, but overall very happy read more