My husband and I actually stumbled onto Tomacelli's completely by accident while cutting across the west side of Sioux Falls on our way toward downtown. And honestly, those accidental discoveries sometimes wind up becoming your favorite places. We were absolutely famished that afternoon and wanted something different from our usual stops when we noticed this little pizza place sitting quietly inside a fairly non-descript strip mall. At first glance, you might not expect much. Then you walk inside. The atmosphere immediately drew us in. Warm, casual, inviting, and filled with the kind of local neighborhood energy that makes you feel comfortable almost instantly. It had personality. Not manufactured "corporate chain pretending to be cozy" personality either. Real personality. Thankfully, the food completely lived up to the vibe. We ordered a large specialty pizza loaded with all the trimmings along with a smaller pepperoni pizza because my husband and I have fully embraced the philosophy that ordering "too much pizza" is not actually a real problem. It is simply future happiness. And because we apparently cannot order pizza without wings, we added a small wing order as well. The pizzas were absolutely fantastic. The crust had wonderful texture and flavor, the toppings were generous, the cheese was gloriously hot and melty, and everything arrived piping hot exactly the way pizza should. Even the smaller pepperoni pizza impressed us. Sometimes simple pizzas reveal the quality of a place better than overloaded specialty combinations do, and Tomacelli's absolutely delivered on both. Now the only small critique we had involved the wings. My husband and I personally tend to prefer traditional deep-fried buffalo wings over baked-style wings. That is simply our preference. However, even with that bias, the wings here were still flavorful and enjoyable enough that we really did not mind very much once we started eating them. And honestly, the biggest compliment we can give this place is simple: We kept coming back. Even though we live on the east side of Sioux Falls now, we still happily make the drive across town because local gems like this are worth supporting. More importantly, the consistency has remained excellent every time we have visited. That matters. Any restaurant can accidentally have one great night. The places that keep earning loyalty are the ones that continue getting it right over and over again. read more

It was my last day in SD. Saw the falls and wanted some pizza. Found Tomacelli's on my map, let's go. Has a nice divey feel with the graffiti all over, Already lovin' it.! See the 80s video games, and my comfort level increases. I get to the counter and ask the guy "what's the signature item on the menu?" He offers a couple of things. One the recommended items was the Tomacelli Special. Lots of pepperoni, lots of cheese, sausage and ranch dressing as the sauce. Order and get some quarters to play Galaga. I get the pizza and it has tons of pepperoni, the crust has a nice color and cheesy. Grab a slice has some tasty pepperoni oil on there. That pizza is delicious. I didn't even miss the pizza sauce. Also got some cheesecake. Good stuff- solid dessert. I definite revisit and recommend. read more

Tomacelli's Pizza & Pasta - Tomacelli Special- - Pizza Near Me - Sioux Falls, South Dakota

See all

Went to pick up a pizza that I had ordered. Pizza was ready. The clerk was coughing and wiping his runny nose on his shirt. Also no hair covering. I told him to keep the pizza and walked out! read more

Good Dough! For not too much money! Save it for the Casino!!! Don't forget to sing the place, they'll even hand you the marker! Whole pie with Chad A. and he even got his money back in the back! Hint hint! The cheese is right, the toppings are a'plenty and they have the right amount of sauce! Even the drinks are appropriate! The conversations got intermingled and new friends made! It was hot and served with a cheeky smile! She was cute! I'll be back soon! They didn't forget to ask us about the big game either! read more

Excellent lunch of 2 made to order pizzas with delicious toppings and an exceptional perfect crispy crust. Great service, pies came quickly. Don't let ambiance of restaurant made you miss this restaurant. read more

Had a late lunch. Salad and medium pizza shared with a friend. Both were fresh and flavorful. Service was above and beyond

Amazing pizza and amazing service. I highly recommend to come and eat here. Not a long wait for the food.

Amazing service is awesome, food is delicious, definitely a if you know you know place. so worth it, employees super nice!!

When we drove up I must say I was not impressed!! But, the food was good and the serving size was enough for my wife and I to take home and have a second meal the next day! I ordered the spaghetti with Italian sausage and it was not bad at all. My wife ordered the Cajun fettuccini Alfredo with chicken and in my opinion it is definitely a do over!! We both have been eating on these two dishes now two and we will still be eating again!! read more

Tomacelli's Pizza & Pasta - Spaghetti with sausage and Cajun Chicken Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Sioux Falls, South Dakota

Great service and pizza! If you're thinking about a salad, just go ahead and do it. It was fantastic.! read more

See all

Awesome local pizza establishment with a huge variety of specialty pizzas and great crust with some char! There website is a bit outdated and even though it doesn't mention it they do deliver. read more

The food was prepared in a very convenient way for the Togo order I asked for additional protein (shrimp) and veggie (broccoli) options they had on their menu. There is a order window inside and to note restaurant is attached to a local bar lounge. read more

Tomacelli's Pizza & Pasta - Chicken Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Sioux Falls, South Dakota

Sorry, hate to be a downer here, but I'm amazed at how this place got the high marks that it did! We got a cheese/sausage pizza, very standard, and were left very underwhelmed. There was very little flavor that set it apart- no spices, bland, and a little doughy. It was just...there. Hopefully we just caught them on an off night. We had heard all about this being the best pizza in town, so they'd for sure deserve another try. read more

Tomacelli's Pizza & Pasta - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Sioux Falls, South Dakota

I really enjoy this place on holidays and weekends--Service is the best at those times. Food is always great and reasonably priced

Tried the Crab Rangoon pizza they had as a special during the pizza battle...my favorite pizza from the battle by far!! The flavors were spot on, and it was such a fun and unique idea! I would order it again if they ever decide to bring it back! read more

Delivery order was very good. Thai wings were tasty, with a little heat and tender. The garden salad was huge and very fresh. Jambalaya pasta was inspired and delicious. And the service was great, polite and friendly. The driver called enroute to confirm my room number at hotel - giving me the option to meet him elsewhere on the property if I preferred. Nice end to a long day of driving. read more

Very simple. Best pizza in Sioux Falls. We order extra sauce and well done. Friendly staff and real pizza made in real ovens. Yum!

Delicious pizza always! Delivery is simple and always correct. I recommend this place if you are looking for a good pie!

Very nice people, service was very friendly and homey! SUPER CHEESY! Every bite out of any of the pizzas was mouthwatering stretchy cheese! Definitely would recommend the chicken Alfredo deep dish, very flavorful and filling. The atmosphere was very unique, I, personally, loved it! I will definitely come back! read more

See all

Driven by Tomacelli's our whole life & finally decided to try it backed upon all the positive reviews. Will definitely be back. Pizza & service were both great! read more

Wow!!!!! This pizza is so good! We ordered take out, we got the Tomacelli's special pizza, it was absolutely delicious. Service was friendly and efficient. 10/10 read more

Best pizza in town hands down service is great and fast and very friendly can't stop eating there pizza 5 out of 5 all day thanks guys u rock read more

I hesitate to recommend, but that's because I'm selfish and I kinda want to keep the things I cherish the most all to my self. That's how I feel about Tomacelli's. It is head and shoulders above the rest of the pizza places in town and I'd go as far to say that it's one of the best restaurants in Sioux Falls. I usually order an extra large Big Nick. It's a great value and I can three meals out of one of these bad boys. My wife gets a medium pizza and we're set. We order delivery and we're down close to Tea, no worries, our order comes hot and delicious, and everyone from the person on the phone taking my order to the driver delivering my food are professional, knowledgeable, courteous, and friendly. We love it! About the Big Nick, it's a grown up flavored hearty pizza pie generously topped with black olives, green bell peppers, onions, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, sausage, tomatoes, cheese, and sauce. All of the ingredients are high quality and fresh. I didn't use to enjoy black olives, but the Big Nick converted me. I enthusiastically recommend Tomacelli's !!! You will not be disappointed. read more

Tomacelli's Pizza & Pasta - Medium Big Nick no onions - Pizza Near Me - Sioux Falls, South Dakota

See all

We are traveling through and decided to stop here for dinner. Walking in the front door, we almost turned around and went somewhere else. There is "graffiti " all over the door. I really questioned what we were getting into. Inside the restaurant, you realize the graffiti is purposeful. There is graffiti all over the walls, ceiling, seats, and booths. Other than that, the walls were decorated tastefully with restaurant cartoony pictures and it is clean. The menu is large with salads, pizza, and pasta. My husband and I opted for pasta. He had the Lasagna and I had the chicken pesto pasta. They both came with garlic toast. My pesto was very good. Sometimes I have had pesto pasta and there is just not enough of the pesto. There was no fear here. It was mixed with diced tomatoes and sliced mushrooms on fettuccine noodles. My husband's lasagna was approximately 5" square. He is very picky and said he really liked it. The prices are awesome as well. If we had a chance to eat here again in the future, I wouldn't have a problem with it. read more

See all

this pizza was so good if u go to Sioux falls you gotta try this, their service is also amazing, they are completely understandable of all your needs, the place also be getting good vibes here too. read more

Very good food and nice staff. Unique and original decor. Had the Chicken Alfredo Cajun and it was perfect.

Absolutely amazing pizza! Service has always been great, the pizza too! We love their gluten free crust! Highly recommend!!

We were staying overnight and decided to get pizza/pasta delivered. Very disappointing. First, the pizzas: Seafood Supreme- described as shrimp and crab with green onions. I requested no onions, but I swear they put extra instead. But most importantly, it is NOT CRAB. It is imitation crab (aka fish). So disgusting. Do not advertise crab if you aren't using crab. The second pizza (Cheese) would have been okay is it weren't for the raw dough. We also ordered spaghetti, and fettuccine Alfredo. Both were very bland. The only redeeming part of the meal was the garlic bread....but only because it was obviously the frozen garlic bread that you can buy at the grocery store (so they couldn't really mess that up). Should have just ordered Domino's. read more

This is a pizza place in a mall. The interior is coated in graffiti. It is a little gritty not in a cool way but in a slightly dingy way. The pizza though stands on its own. This is one of my favorite take out places. Make sure to call in advance as the wait can be over 1 hr on weekends. read more

I am truly disappointed, order from them today 1/19/23 for picked up was told 30 minutes when I got there the guy ignored me for about five minutes (yes he knew I was there he looked right at me) he gave me the wrong order and when I corrected him he was rude about it because I already paid. he was like will I guess you get five dollars off. when I got home the food tasted like it been setting out for awhile ( I don't even live five minutes away) At one point in time they were the best pizza in town but in the last few years they have gone down hill. Not only there pizza has gone down hill the one on 12 street has become very dumpy. I am truly sad because it was at one point awesome pizza and a nice little pizza place . just really disappointed and sad how a great pizza place has become one the the worse places for pizza now . It like the owners don't care anymore. read more

Don't know how you can have a meat and veggie pizza without any taste but that's what I got. I like to try local restaurants when I travel but I will try another pizza joint next time, sorry. read more

From 2009-2011, Our group of friends are here every Thursday. We had many great memories share in this restaurant. After being away for a decade, Active Duty Navy, I returned to find this restaurant in great condition with familiar faces behind the counter. The pizza is better than I remember. I can't recommend this place enough! read more

I am in Sioux Falls for a few days, and the hotel recommended Tomacelli's for delivery. Actually, the hotel also said I should try Marco's because the front desk employee used to work at Marco's and "never got sick." So, I called Tomacelli's. There wasn't an option to order via ecommerce, sadly, because the person taking my order was in a very noisy environment which resulted in errors on my order. He also had a persistent cough which made me seriously second guess if I should order anything from there. My pizza and salad made it to me within about 45 minutes and the quality was great. I wanted a pepperoni and jalapeno pizza, but instead I got a pepperoni and black olive pizza. Pros: quick delivery, tasty pizza Cons: screwed up the toppings, order-taker had some serious upper respiratory issues or he was toking up while at work read more

Ordered a pizza to my hotel, paid for it and the guy left. Opened the box and it looked like it had been dropped. All the toppings were on the cardboard box and crust was on the other side of the box. I called TOMACELLIS back and I said you can have your pizza back, just bring my money back. His response, "We don't give money back." I said I'm at a hotel and don't live anywhere near Sioux Falls. There response was tough luck. Great business model. Nice attitude. read more

We've eaten several different pizzas and they all were good, but it's never like Omg this is awesome. Just good but not out of this world so I gave it a above average rating. read more

Very nice thin crust pizza real mozzarella fresh Ingredients piping hot ooeygooey delicious pies

Just no. Creepy, very dirty and basically your average Midwest-gas-station quality pizza with a bizarre twist. When a restaurant looks like an old bar bathroom, has almost no service, less than good pizza, and terrible drinks, it just doesn't merit the astonishingly favorable reviews that this place has, which truly is baffling... read more

This place was the best pizza joint for many years but like a lot of great places it has fell in to just ok pizza. They use the correct deck pizza oven but there cooks fail to cook them. Crust is never fully cooked we even called and ask when we ordered to cook it a little longer and still flimsy crust I can't stand. So I took the time to call and ask for manager to relay to him our experience. Let's say the person on the phone sounded way young and got super defensive saying that he just got there so wasn't his mistake. Never said it was just wanted to help bring this place back to great! Please someone in Sioux Falls bring us a good N.Y. pizza!! You will be rewarded read more

Tomacelli's Pizza & Pasta - a hand holding a piece of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sioux Falls, South Dakota

This place is outstanding!! The delivery service was fast too...unlike what others said. Our pizza & bread sticks got to us hot and delicious with cold cokes on the side. Exactly what we needed after riding 12 hours today. Thank you for doing a GREAT job when I was too tired to do it... read more

Omg. Wonderful ! was told by tower camp ground that was really good pizza..Best pizza and lots more. Over the top Only thing I would do. Advertise my business. No one driving delivery car without sign of business and have workers wear hats tees You name on everything... read more