Brother's Pizza in Warren is a solid choice when you're craving something good, simple, and…read morebudget-friendly. It has that same familiar charm as a classic, old timey pizza place--nothing fancy, nothing over the top, just good pizza at a good price. What Brother's does well is consistency. The pizza is reliably tasty, satisfying, and exactly what you expect from a classic local budget spot. It's the kind of place you can count on for a quick pickup, a family pizza night that won't break the bank, or an easy meal when you want something where the service is dependable and quick. It isn't aiming to compete with gourmet or specialty pizzerias, but it doesn't need to. Brother's stays in its lane and does it well. For affordability, flavor, and that nostalgic local-pizza feel, it earns a solid four stars in my book.

I'm from California and I look forward to coming here every time I visit my family. Great Italian…read morefood and great prices. 10/10

Yes yes YES! This is…read morequite literally the best pizza I have had in my entire life. Who knew it would take this long to finally find that. So cool that they are opening up TWO new locations in Boardman & Kinsman to spread the pizza goodness!! The Detroit Hot Honey Roni is my favorite. This was my first time having Detroit style pizza and it makes me feel like I don't have to travel to truly experience it. The baked cheesy goodness of a crust is phenomenal. Flavors? Out of this world. Cupping pepperoni is simply the best, their sauce doesn't give me heartburn and considering I try to stay away from red sauce that says a lot! OHHHH but their basil is always so fresh and flavorful. I think I could eat a bowl of it! The Detroit Chicken Bacon Ranch is also delicious. Best CBR pizza and I've had a lot of em. No words! The Detroit 8 Mile, same thing. Raving about it! I was thoroughly pleased that you literally get slices of garlic clove on top. The hot peppers ain't too hot & it's just GOOD! Period. Penna Alla Vodka with a fresh baked roll... my Lord! This was on a separate visit, but figured I would include it in this review. (I have been there 3 times within a month, oops) Pasta came out piping hot, flavors were immaculate; sausage, sauce, cheese, basil, OH MY! Just try it. I cannot wait to continually support this business and try new things with each visit!

I saw we are getting a Red Plum in Boardman , curiosity got the better of Me. I decided to go to…read morethe Warren location rather then wait til our location opens Nov 1st. Restaurant is Beautiful, staff very friendly and tons of parking. One of my dearest friends went with me. They have a great stocked bar and nice outdoor seating for those that prefer that. We started with the Oven Baked Meatballs, plentiful with a nice amount of fresh ricotta, it also came with a huge roll with fresh garlic and spices on it. The Meatballs were delicious. We tried the Plum Salad...the flavors were amazing the Feta was soft and creamy and the dressing was unlike any I have ever had. Best Salad. Small size enough to share. We tried a few Pizzas...took 90% home. First up New York White ...I added Ricotta to it. It was cooked to perfection and full of flavor. Second up was Detroit style The Butcher...My friend said it was really yummy, with a great amount of Sausage Meatballs and Bacon. This is the Ultimate choice when those ingredients are your Joy. We got smaller size with 4 huge square pieces. The under carriage of this pizza was pure perfection. Third up was New York Style Pesto, Vodka Sauce and Red Sauce with the perfect blend of Mozzarella, We chose to have them not add the pepperoni. This pizza delivers every flavor imaginable. I'm going to ask them if they can recreate on Detroit crust which is my new favorite. This pizza was tied for my favorite.... Fourth and final the tie for first place pizza.. Detroit Style Greektown ... Between the fresh spinach and the creamy Feta add olives hot peppers and light Mozzarella this pizza was Epic. The under carriage was perfect. The pizza delivered crunch after crunch bite after bite. It doesn't really get better than this. Our waitress was wonderful. We had her bring each pizza out in its box as we really only shared one square of each pizza. I am New York Born and live in Ohio. Truly here There are very few pizza establishments that truly bring it. Red Plum 100% delivers. Quality, Taste and price. Excited they will be in My neighborhood when the new location opens. This is a truly hidden gem. I plan on going back very soon. Hands Down Best of the Best!!!!!

Food was great and pizza is the best. The server Melissa was amazing. She took care of us like…read morefamily

The worst service we've had , I ordered chicken Parmesan and both chicken and pasta was cold ,…read morehubby's order was incorrect (twice) the three cheese Mac and cheese was delicious that's the only good thing that came out of that kitchen. The antipasti salad was awful..

My absolute favorite pizza place!!! I'm not in this area too much anymore and I miss it! Chewy…read morecrust, plenty of cheese and toppings! Served up in an amazingly friendly kitchen by a local Italian family. Truly the best pizza shop in the Valley!

I can't believe I never wrote a review for this place. We don't go here nearly as often as we…read moreshould but it's definitely some of the best pizza around. The ingredients are fresh, the sauce is delicious and the crust.....oh mamma the hand tossed dough that makes the crust is phenomenal. It's also a plus that the owner usually greets you at the counter to take your order of whom has an obvious Italian/broken English accent. We've had the three styles they offer of New York, Sicilian and Chicago over the last few visits and all are great. I find myself partial to the New York style but all are equally as delicious. They offer salads, subs, wings, pepperoni rolls, Stromboli and other dinner options (i.e. Cannelloni, Manicotti, etc.). While I've only had the pizzas they offer, I am looking forward to trying some of the other options they have. You will not be disappointed in the pizza, that's for sure.

Best pizza in town!!! I love the red/regular pizza with cheese and pepperoni. The sauce is out of…read moresight! Also the veggie pizza is spectacular as well as the potato!!! Yum!

The pizza here is god-awful. The cheese and pepperoni are molded into a single piece of fleshy,…read morerough crap, which tastes foul. Not to mention, take one bite, and expect a mouthful of the entire piece's fleshy cheese. The crust cuts your teeth if you eat it wrong. Not sure how they managed that when the crust beneath the cheese is doughy and uncooked. Never tried their wings or other food, but I wouldn't recommend this poor excuse for pizza to my worst enemy.

We absolutely love the house pizza. Pepperoni and green peppers. Good fast delivery and ordering…read moreover the phone or online both are available and great service. The restaurant is clean and updated.

Sparse toppings. Minimalist service and product. Not memorable or in any way above and beyond. Bare…read morenecessities.

A Warren staple that has been around since 1965 and is at its best since the relaunch earlier in…read more2026. All the food our party purchased for our Father's Day celebration was exceptional. Very tasty and exceeded our expectations. Each component of the meal was better than the last. We wanted to ensure we included images of the food and menu to help ensure prospective customers understand the value that Carmen's delivers for each of their customers. The establishment is pickup only, but absolutely worth the wait to dine at home or out and about town. We absolutely recommend Carmen's for your Northeast Ohio epicurean desires.

Today is January 30th 2026 I want to report that they are open and doing business and still have…read moredamn good pizza