The food was fantastic. The service from Maria was even better. It was my first time and it will not be my last. The value was unbelievable read more

Tony's NY Pizza - A massive calzone. Fully loaded - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

Are family went there for the first time the food was great pizza was amazing and the service was over and beyond!!! Madison was amazing!!! She helped us order we never wanted for anything we had so an awesome time!! I would just like to say that the service at Tony's was amazing I don't feel it's the same since the pandemic!!!! So tip your servers especially when you get one like Madison!!!!! read more

So my gym is next to this location and they have a sign NY pizza, so let's check it out. Indoors very deceiving from outside, it's actually pretty roomy and clean. The pizza display was ok, there were some slices that should not have been displayed, other items looked pretty good. So my order consisted of a med pie with peppers and onions and sausage and mushrooms, garlic knots and a house salad. Sooo, the pizza was better than what I expected, the pizza maker was a nice lady and made it with live, the salad was ok the tomatoes were to ripe but the rest was ok, the garlic knots were ok just to thick and doughy. But one thing I need to point out that Isabel provided great customer service. I will return to try some of the other items on the menu. read more

Tony's NY Pizza - Inside location - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

Great friendly fast service! If you want to grab a slice or some good heavy garlics knits- this place is greats.

Quality of the pizza seems to have gone down since the opening, would have left it at a 4, but the $20+ per pie you should at Least get a consistent cheese pie- not to mention went in for a quick lunch the other day- no cheese slices available at 12 pm? Wierd- def Thought that was odd. Meatball sub is good, chicken roll good too a bit doughy but good- but imo the pizza should be a staple and it's just been off the mark the last few months, from sloppy lopsided cuts- to minimal sauce, to today's pickup of a thick breaded pie- it's just not really leaving me feeling like there's a reason to come back- even the slices look meh lately- I haven't seen Tony there on my drop Ins, so maybe that's the missing link idk- read more

Tony's NY Pizza - The Bronx pie and a Cheese Pie - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

This pizza spot is not only delish, hmm must have the garlic rolls. They have the best accomodations when no other pizza spot can take a big party. Twice I hosted my son and his soccer team to bday celebration here and always a success! Boys love it enjoy it and we are well taken care of. Thank you holly! read more

Food and service here was amazing. Maria was super busy and absolute fantastic. She took care of our table of eight for my father's 90 th birthday celebration. Thank you!!! Keith D. ( from Tampa). read more

We've been coming to Tony's Pizza for years, it's always been amazing and the staff has been friendly, tonight my kids took me here for Mother's Day because I always rave about the pizza. Tonight the service was terrible & the pizza very mediocre. The whole vibe at the pizzeria was off and uncomfortable. I'm hoping it was just an off night. read more

After reading the reviews on Tony's NY Pizza, I knew it would be on my list of places to eat. It's always fun to try and find real NY style pizza. The restaurant impressed me with its cozy brick wall and wood tables. The menu has a great selection of Italian favorites and of course, pizza. We decided on a pizza called The Bronx, with meatballs, ricotta cheese and fresh basil. The toppings were delicious although the crust was a little too crispy. Some of the best pizza I've eaten in New York had softer crusts. A crisp crust doesn't have much flavor and usually tastes like cardboard. I've noticed that a soft crust brings out the tasty bread flavor of the dough. Still, their crust was good, although not quite to my liking. The server was quick with our drinks and food, the restaurant was clean and surprisingly reasonable, considering this restaurant is located in the heart of expensive Tamiami Trail. I'd recommend checking out Tony's, especially if you enjoy authentic New York style pizza. read more

Tony's NY Pizza - The Bronx pizza - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

I've been driving over the south. I just left the Everglades. I needed something to eat. I saw this pizza joint. Got a nice slice of pizza pepperoni it was good a nice cold beer and then ordered the anti pasta salad. It wasn't for friendly Madison. I would give it four stars because the AC is way too high. lol read more

We are full time residents and this WAS ALWAYS our Go To pizza place until we picked up a pizza that literally smelled "Musty" once we got home and opened the box it was SO GROSS! After researching online it said Do Not eat the pizza that it's bacteria in the cheese or dough....in the trash went a $20 pizza! The crust was all dried out and the cheese was curdled....off our pizza place list! First time EVER to throw a pizza away so BEWARE! read more

I've been going to Tony's many times and we have never been treated the way that we were treated since this new guy came in the spanish male that takes orders we have to yell to get his attention to take our order its truly ridiculous I don't need to come here I come because I like it but since he's been working here I don't like coming anymore because what a horrible service the worst of the worst he needs to be fired truly we just had another customer pass by us and say they aren't coming back either I don't blame them horrible just horrible it's disgusting truly it's very saddening we aren't coming back either until he's dealt with get a new worker or lose your customers. read more

Busy, did carry out online web, was a little confusing picking up, but great pizza . . Had the Greenwich and added pepperoni

Easily the worst food and customer service I've had. Our pizza didn't show up for 45 minutes after it was supposed to and we had to call and go pick it up ourselves. The employees were rude and less than helpful when asking for help. read more

We stopped in for light lunch /snack before a movie. We each had a slice. 2 of square marguarita (silician). 2 ny slices all 5/5. Perfect and true ny style So good that we ordered dinner for pick up at end of movie. Chicken parm, lasagna with excellent meatballs.. eggplant parm. These were all PERFECT. Especially the eggplant, which was nice and crispy not soggy. Dessert chocolate cake, and canolli. Cool. Highly recommended. Complements to tony. Apparently, this is his 3rd restaurant. And opening week here. He has brought his Bronx expertise to Florida. Friendly too read more

This has got to be one of the poorest ran businesses I've ever seen in my life. I am from New York and waited for 20 min to order a pizza without any service and they still didn't take my order. Gladly will take my business elsewhere this place is so inept they don't deserve a dollar. Pizza isn't half bad but what a joke I think they have a Spaniard runnin the place with an iq of 12. read more

TONY WHERE ARE YOU???! It's been over a week and you haven't been there. Are you on vacation? Everything changed??!! Pizza is horrible. Something is wrong. Been there 3 times since you weren't there. Did you sell the business??! I promoted your food, your pizza was incredible !! It was unbelievably delicious. I'm so disappointed. The dough is chewy and floppy. The sauce is not the same. 0 flavor. Very sad! Come back!! read more

Great pizza and good dudes. They fkd up my order but made it all good and overcompensated for the small miscommunication. The pizza and salad was legit and prices seems very reasonable. Will definitely go back. read more

Been going there since they opened last summer. Food has never changed and it is always on point. It is our new pizza place and we are back every week. It is unfortunate to read so many bad reviews but who cares , we still come and enjoy our pizza!! read more

Tony's NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Naples, Florida

Our online order didn't 'show up', according to the employees. The employee kept saying it wasn't their fault, and asked us to wait another 15 -20 minutes while they made our pizza. They forgot to add the pepperoni to the pizza. The whole thing was a disaster. Find a different pizza parlor read more

All the ny ambiance, including pictures of the Manhattan bridge and Madison Square Garden doesn't make this NY or. Brooklyn pizza. Unlike krispy pizza a Brooklyn/nj staple, this pizza flops and droops. Fresh mozzarella means making it fresh not Grande cheese which looks like plastic. I asked for fresh mozzarella and was to,d the grande is fresh. Th crust was too bready and not done enough even though it looked burned on the edges. read more

Delicious pizza and great staff! So happy to have found this amazing hidden gem! We had pizza by the slice - vegetarian, buffalo chicken and sausage. Each was amazing! I can't wait to try other menu items! read more

Super big and tasty salad. Great pizza. Friendly family atmosphere. Will for sure go again.

GREAT thin crust pizza, quality ingredients. BBQ Wings were great as well! Holly and Jason were very friendly and personable. We look forward to going back! read more

Tony's pizza was provided during an event, and without knowing this was from Tony's "NY" Pizza - my first thought after finishing a cheese slice was that it tasted just like a NYC slice (like the foldable, on-the-go slices you pick up at a local spot "lemme get a slice, extra hot"). The slices are thin with the right amount of cheese and sauce. I'll def. be ordering or visiting to try what else they have to offer. It's hard to find these NY pizza gems in Naples. read more

I ordered pizza takeout on Friday night 2/20/26. Its one of our favorite pizza placed in Naples. Unfortunately, after we finished out first slice of pizza a "cockroach" ran out from under the pizza on the box. To say we felt sick and horrified is an understatement. I proceeded to call Tonys to make them aware and the response I received was equally horrifying. I told her what happened, her response was "your not getting your money back". My response was "I'm not asking for my money back" "I want to make you aware as this a problem." " Again your not getting your money back " Never an apology and my boyfriend called back and he received a similar response. I will never eat or order again from Tony's ! read more

Tony's was great when the first opened, but I think he must be distracted. The staff is apathetic. The food is average and the ambience again nothing special. read more

First time , ordered medium pepperoni sausage onion pizza. And a Caesar salad. Salad was good. The pizza crust had absolutely no flavor no bread type dough. I don't know what the crust was made of, but I should've eaten the box and thrown the pizza out. Three out of the six slices of pizza had no sausage and the pepperoni was scattered very thinly over the remaining of the pizza no more than two tasteless pieces on each slice. Total disappointment. Thank you ,Jerry read more

Wow! I can't speak to whatever hangups other people have. But this Pizza was amazing. The bread, the toppings. Doughy, crispy, smooth, all at the same time. This is a new offering in the old site of The Crust. So you get the same neighborhood flavor. This is possibly the best Pizza in the county. read more

Real deal. Pizza like Spumoni gardens in Brooklyn., very good eggplant dishes and pasta fagioli.

This is NOT NY pizza It was not bad but had little flavor NY pizza does not crack when you fold it... and you always fold it. The plan pie was ok, we also ordered a special pizza, no flavor at all , bland Hopefully it will improve read more

Pizza and atmosphere is fantastic! Best NY pizza So good give a try!! Go for it Yummy read more

Can't review the food never got served. Very few customers sat outside for 29 minutes never got approached . Went inside sat in a both all others were empty, still never got approached . . I then asked the zombie walking around " what do I need to do to get service" he looked at me walked to the back where I assumed he was getting a menu and then he never returned. He must have been a relative of owners who was forced to hire because he was related. I really wanted to have their grandmas pizza. read more

We are so happy to have found Tony's NY Pizza. It's our third visit, they have amazing Italian food! We have had the lasagna, pepperoni roll and pizzas!! It's like eating at Grandmas house! read more

Awesome pizza! Great service. My go to pizza! If you are near Vanderbilt and 41, check it out.

IF I COULD GIVE THIS A NEGATIVE SCORE I WOULD THE WORST SERVICE I HAVE EVER RECEIVED! We ordered 3 pizzas just 3 on a Sunday night. At first they told us it would be 30 minutes, then told us it would be an hour, totally fine I understand it was a Sunday night it's very busy. We called around the time that the pizza should be delivered and asked them how long it would be, they said the driver was leaving now and it should be around 10 minutes. We then called 15 minutes later asking the status and they said it would be another 10 minutes, they did say they would refund 50% of our order which was nice. At this point it had been 2 hours since we ordered so we decided to go to the store and pick up the order. We walked in the store and asked for our pizzas, they proceeded to tell us they NEVER MADE OUR ORDER?!?!?!? They "never got a driver" so they never made the pizzas but lied to us over the phone saying it was on the way. They genuinely looked at us like we were insane as we tried to be as cordial as possible. Genuinely the worst customer service I've ever received as someone who's worked multiple customer service jobs. I am never coming back here EVER! The worst food experience I've ever had these people did not have common human decency. read more

Obviously they have changed owners. Use to be the best pizza in Naples, ordered it tonight not so great. It's now more crust than I've ever seen on any pizza, toppings light. It's not the same as it was when they first opened. We use to order it least once a week. We won't be back. On top of that when we got there the pizza we ordered wasn't even correct., thank god, I opened the box. read more

Friendly, accommodating staff. Great environment with delicious, large portions. Our family all think it's great.

Pizza great Crispy Thin Sauce wonderful Service was excellent Music superb Very busy on Friday read more

Hands down a must try. Tony sauce is in a world of its own. I've now had the lasagna, the "Square" and "regular" pies. It might very well be the best pizza in 100 miles and I feel that may be under selling it. I am from NY and this really brings me home. Thank for showing up Tony!! read more