There are few things in this world I love as much as pizza. I've traveled the world seeking out the best--from pizza tours in NYC and New Haven to Chicago Tavern style and the birthplace of pizza in Italy. I love every style and variant. That said, true New York style is notoriously hard to replicate outside of NYC. I've been to so many out-of-state spots where the owners swear they're from NY, but the pie just doesn't hit right. Few places outside of the five boroughs are on par with NY... but Burnt Pizza is the real deal. We ordered a Margherita round pie and a Grandma pie (half cheese and basil, half pepperoni). The entire meal, I just kept repeating out loud, "Dude, this is crazy good." The crust had zero flop with a perfectly crispy undercarriage, and the edge slices on the Grandma pie were incredibly crunchy. There was a perfect amount of cheese, and you can literally taste the quality of the ingredients--the flavor profile actually has layers to it. Listen to me: I've been to the absolute best of the best. Lucali, L'Industrie, John's of Bleecker, Di Fara... I've tried them all. This little shop in Naples, FL absolutely holds its own. read more

Burnt Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

Probably my 5th time here. Garlic knots 4 out of 5- delish delight EVERY pizza I've ordered has been phenomenal. While waiting for my to-go, I usually grab a slice of their white pie. This time I'm leaving with an 18" (XL) White Pie which comes with mozzarella, ricotta, and garlic. It's just that good!!! During EVERY visit, I've been treated like a family member try haven't seen for a while. read more

Burnt Pizzeria - 18" White Pie- DELISH !!! - Italian Near Me - Naples, Florida

I think they take their name literally . The sauce and cheese was good on the pizza, but be sure to add how you would like the crust. I'm not a burnt crust guy. Good clean location for them. Hard working family business. read more

Casual pizza joint with not only delicious pizza but had surprisingly great salads. We ordered 2 types of salad - Caprese and House (both with and without chicken). We also ordered 4 types of pizza with varying crust types. The favorite was the Sweet and Spicy (pepperoni and hot honey), regular crust. We also ordered sausage pizza grandma square crust, BBQ chicken regular crust, and margarita pizza grandma crust. I wasn't a fan of the grandma crust (thicker square cut) but our friends love them. We didn't try any of the pastas, but we will next time. It's a fairly small family owned establishment that has seating inside and outside. The staff was very welcoming and tolerant of how loud our group of 13 people. Great place for a family outing with great food and comfortable atmosphere. read more

See all

Just left Burnt Pizzeria and this is easily the best pizza I've had in the entire state of Florida. Being from CT, this is very New Haven/NY style pizza and incredibly good. Anthony is a great guy and knows what he's doing. Staff is across the board great as well. If you're in Naples and get pizza from anywhere but Burnt you're a stunad!! read more

Burnt Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Naples, Florida

We had the Margherita Pizza. The sauce was garlicky perfection!!! This was one of the best pizzas I've ever had. It's the real deal!!! read more

See all

Ordered delivery (delivered through third party) and the ordering and delivery were seamless. This was my first time trying this restaurant and I was extremely impressed by the quality and price of the food. We ordered two XL pizzas, 3 Cesar salads, and some wings. There were 7 of us and everyone loves all the food. The pizza is definitely one of the best we have had in the area if you like a thinner, NY style pie. The wings were also very good, although the hot honey wings could have had a little more sauce on them. The online order tracking was very informative and kept me up to date with the status and arrival time. I will definitely be ordering again from this restaurant and would love to go and eat at the restaurant because I bet the pizza is even better straight out of the oven! read more

Stopped in for a quick bite ! Had chicken and sausage pizza with a small Caesar Salad -it was delish . The server Sasha was Fantastic extremely nice and engaging . I will definitely be going back read more

Burnt Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Naples, Florida

In Naples on vacation from the northeast and was craving some good italian food. So glad I found Burnt Pizzeria because it was EXACTLY what I was looking for and then some. I saw a review that they reminded someone of the pizza they get in New York and I 100% agree. The chicken marsala was so delicious too, tender, great flavor, tasted like something your family would make and not from a restaurant. Wish I could stop in again before heading home. We got our dinner to go because we arrived a little before closing but were greeted immediately and our food was ready quick. All of the employees were very friendly. There is a small dining area inside but great atmosphere! Most seats were still filled even right before closing. Highly recommend trying this spot. read more

Burnt Pizzeria - chicken marsala - Italian Near Me - Naples, Florida

See all

What a great pizza place! I have very high standards for pizza and Burnt Pizza e'Passione nailed it. Clearly high quality ingredients, great dough flavor, crunch and chew. Not quite NY style, not quite Neapolitan but some delicious spot in between. I had a large Sweet and Spicy (pepperoni with hot honey). Really great. Next time (soon!) I'll go for a more basic pepperoni and sausage for a better comparison with other places I love. Check them out!! read more

Burnt Pizzeria - Large Sweet and spicy (hot honey and pepperoni) - Italian Near Me - Naples, Florida

Very good pizza. Ordered pick up. Ready in 20 minutes. Sauce is good- sweet-ish style. Cheese ratio just right for margherita pizza. Especially like the julienne of fresh basil and definitely love the garlic/oil on top. The to-go toppings are very generous portions. The crust was crispy and oiled - perfect for grandma style. The crust is NOT THIN on this pizza - but not thick and chewy like a Sicilian and not like Chicago or Detroit deep- dish. It is a crispy, fairly thick crust. Friendly service. There are multiple slices and knots and ? Is that Pepperoni bread with sesame seeds on top ? in the display case ready to go - and a few good looking desserts . Wish they were open on Sundays! Football and Pizza - "Forget about it!!! " would be perfect! There are tables and chairs to sit inside/ VERY casual. Located on the Trail East- not too far from Flo's and Go Pita, beside the "Fine Cigars". Next time I'm trying thin style - but probably will stick with Margherita since I'm still thinking about the flavor!! read more

Burnt Pizzeria - Grandma Style Margherita - Italian Near Me - Naples, Florida

My wife and I came here for a traditional New York pizza. It did not disappoint. Price was very reasonable as was a bottle of wine for $30.

Excellent pizza and very fair pricing Unlike 5th Ave which would of easily cost $36, 3 slices and a drink here was $17. The crust is amazing. all fresh ingredients. Really a + for our community and I live close by so I plan to be a regular! But don't take my word for it as Padre Pio hangs on the wall. Owners from Puglia and Sicilia by way of NY. Grazie. la Tua Pizza era buonissima! read more

See all

If you're looking for NY style pizza and Italian food then this place is a must try. Their selection of pizza and calzones are amazing. The menu includes the usual Italian fares and are delicious and very reasonably priced. The family has been in the restaurant business for years and they know how to make great food. Wishing them many years of success! read more

Delicious, great selection, quick service. Will definitely be back to try all the slices and other options read more

See all

Wonderful pizza, wonderful salads and wonderful staff to work with!!! Had a 90th Birthday Party for my husband and he chose Burnt Pizza because he loves it from there. They were such a pleasure to work with. The establishment is also very clean and very well run. Thank you to everyone there for providing us with great food for our party. We will be back!!!!! read more

Friends of friends recommended this place because of their great Philly cheese steak sandwich, but I was drawn to the veal Marsala. Should I order veal in a place known for sandwiches and pizza? I took a chance... MAN!!! They hit it out of the park! It was so perfect! Juicy and tender and full of flavor! I will be back and check out the rest of the menu! read more

Hooray! Brooklyn in the house! Or is it Jersey? Whichever. It is Fantastic pizza finally. After searching around and being disappointed I've found the gem. You just need to give me a call when you make a clam pizza like they do in New Haven. read more

Excellent pie, calimari, salad and service. I did mention to the owner that the pizza dough tasted like it didn't have any salt and he appreciated that and said he was aware of it and they rectified the problem. I heavily recommend to try out their food and service. I will go back. read more

Amazing pizza and food, service is great and the location is really convenient. Nice outdoor seating. Good Italian wines a beers to pair with anything on the menu. A must try pizza in Naples. Authentic traditional old school nostalgic NY Style. read more

See all

Really great pizza. We wanted to try the place since all the reviews so far have been great. We actually dined in. "Gio" the waiter was super nice and helpful. The atmosphere is simple-- the focus is definitely on the food. Good selection of drinks including wine by the glass. They also have pizza by the slice which I haven't seen many places here. We ordered the large Margarita and asked for some additional ingredients. Everything came out perfectly delicious, hot, and NOT Burnt. ;). Plenty of other pasta and calzone, etc. options. Our new favorite pizza place! read more

Pizza had no taste. The pizza sauce had no taste, the crust was fair but too many failures to go back

Best pizza in Naples and we have tried numerous restaurants here. Crust perfectly baked and not too thick or thin. Great amount of pepperoni and thinly sliced mushrooms , great taste. Restaurant is small but service was excellent. Serve wine and beer. Our choice to order from menu but there is a mouthwatering display filled with pizza by the slice, making it easy to try different toppings. Great appetizer selections and salads. Will definitely return. read more

My name is Maryann . I am from New York. For the past 4 years I have been on a quest to find really good pizza here in Naples , Fl. Last night went to BURNT PIZZA and just want say It's the best pizza here in Naples. you all need to try it especially if you are New Yorker. it's the BEST read more

Recommended by friends- glad I tried. Just ordered pizza for pickup- next time will try my luck at eating at location. Was expecting pizza to be good and it was. Tried the San Gennaro, knew it was good when folded the slice in half (20 minutes after it was done) and heard a crack. Nice and crispy, but not overdone. Will go back! read more

Doordash forgot my pizza at the store and said policy insisted they send a second driver. The store called at the same time the driver was here and when he told them that, they immediately dispatched, who I believe to be the owner, with my pizza to my door. The food was spot-on, the owner is real NY people, and bah-fungool to Doordash! read more

Tried this new pizza place on 41 in East Naples. Had the grandma slice and an upside down slice. The grandma slice was excellent. Love the flavors and the crust is exceptional (as good as a NY pizza crust). Loved both slices and looking forward to trying others. Great new addition to the neighborhood. read more

I have been trying all pizza / Italian food places in Naples since moving here 4 years ago and Burnt Pizzeria is by far the best - so happy to have tried it! Having grown up near NYC and always preferred NY style pizza, Burnt is LEGIT NY style pizza and you can taste the quality of ingredients! We did take out and got two pies - a veggie pie and decided to try the unique The Goose pie. Wow what a wonderful flavor profile combination of vodka sauce and pesto! And I have especially been on the hunt for a good meatball sub and finally found a clear and absolutely authentic winner! The meatballs are so tender, flavorful, with perfect combo of sauce and cheese on wonderful bread! And it is a very generous portion given (we got a whole for 2 to split but it easily feeds 4). My entire family is so happy we found such a great, quality, authentic NY pizzeria. We cannot wait to explore the full menu of items! read more