Tony's is an absolute gem! We came in for the first time a few weeks ago, and Tricia greeted us warmly and told us about the history of the place (it's been in Marblehead for 45 years!). The pizza was fresh and delicious. Although we did not grow up here, it reminded us of family pizza places we frequented as kids. The prices were also very reasonable. We will be back soon! read more

When I come to this establishment, I can say that I am satisfied with the customer service the food is fresh upon order so if you're in the Marblehead area, please stop by. It's worth a try. read more

See all

The go to spot for Pizza and subs in Marblehead. Central location and great seating. Popular with kids after school.

Good pizza, friendly staff, quick service and fair pricing. We grabbed a pie and ate it down at the beach. Parking is also better that other places in the area (not perfect, but better). read more

NEVER in my time of having a service animal have I been so disrespected. I came to Tony's pizza as a kid all the time. Today, I went to pick up a small cheese pizza with my emotional support dog. As soon as I entered, I was met with hostility and disregard from a woman, who I'm assuming is the owner. She told me to get out with the dog and I wasn't allowed to enter with him. I told her that he is a service animal, which she responded with, "I don't care, he doesn't have a vest on or paperwork, you need to get out" UNDER THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT "...a person cannot be denied access or ejected from the premises unless (1) the animal is causing an undue hardship to the business or (2) the animal poses a direct threat to the health or safety of others." WHICH WAS NOT THE CASE. It does not matter whether he has a vest on or not, proof of training or that he is a service animal is NOT required in the state of MA. She told me to call Board of Health if I had a problem, which I will I called Tony's and asked to speak with her to let her know that she discriminated against me, AND SHE HUNG UP ON ME. Real classy. I have never been more embarrassed in my life just trying to pick up a pizza. I will not be returning and am appalled that the owner would speak to any paying customer that way. Unbelievable. read more

Absolutely horrible hostile treatment on a Tuesday early afternoon, noon to be exact by the Angry woman at the Counter and her staff. we had 3 happy giggling three year olds with us and they were immediately scolded by this woman and her staff . Quite sad actually and looks like I'm not the first to experience this based on the other reviews. She was demeaning rude and downright nasty. Really shocking for such a cute family oriented town like Marblehead. What a sad way to treat customers and during a pandemic! Happy to spend our $50.00 elsewhere. Avoid this place at all costs! How sad read more

I would give 0 if I could. This was the worst pizza I have ever eaten. Not well baked. Hardly any cheese and not good quality. The sauce was just awful. I don't even think it should be called pizza. The Greek salad just as bad. They don't even have their own dressing. I know these are tough times but I won't be buying Tony's again. read more

Worst italian food ive ever had in my life. Chicken parmesan was so bland and soaked in grease. Spend your money elsewhere.

Ive places an order to go for a Greek salad with Grilled chicken. The grilled chicken was baked. I wished I knew that. I'm not going to order it again The salad was good read more

Tony's Pizza - chicken wings in a foil pan - Pizza Near Me - Marblehead, Massachusetts

Decent food, good service, but they charged me 75 cents for a paper cup of tap water?? Not a huge deal but seriously?

Service is great! Pizza is average. Can purchase by the slice or whole. Very convenient location.

awful service. The owner is yelling at kids, workers ealways moody. the food isn't too bad it just is sometimes cold. The ambiance isn't bad. The outside is clean the town is clean but the inside has boxes and boxes of pizza all over the place. My daughter sand her friends went once and the owner was yelling at my daughter where to sit which she doesn't do that with others. Overall a bad place for kids to go downtown and hang out in. read more

Excellent staff. Not from the area and was very impressed with the efficiency! Food came out quick and they were all very helpful. Will come back next time I have a job nearby read more

We've tried all the pizza places in Marblehead and liked Tony's the best. We wish they were open on Sunday's because that's when we most often want to get pizza, but otherwise, great pizza, friendly staff. They deserve a better star level then they have. read more

If you want filling pizza try Tricia special- grilled chicken, spinach, peppers, olives, and mozzarella plus tomatoes make this a winner. Only challenge is parking around 5 corners read more

Best pizza in Marblehead. Always consistent and always quality. A favorite among the teenage crowd in town.

This has become our go to place for a pizza craving. The food is wonderful - great pizza with nice and varied topping options. We usually go for a side of perfectly crispy buffalo chicken fingers, too! And the service is wonderful - always friendly staff and quick pickup times. Super grateful for Tony's ever since we moved to Marblehead ! read more

Tony is the master! His talk of retirement is a constant source of debate in our house. I am from New York, and this is the best pizza I have had outside of there. I can close my eyes and not be able to tell the difference between then and now. Awesome meatballs, great lasagna, basically anything on the menu is made with love and years of intense skill. Go while you can! read more

I was happy to see Tony's Pizza decided to rebuild after a 2003 fire destroyed their business. Tony's has a few advantages over rival Marblehead House of Pizza across the square: 1. Delicious calzone 2. A sit down family atmosphere 3. Entree choices The pizza is good. It's a great place to hang and hide from the cold. Glad to see they are back in business. read more

Since moving to Marblehead two years ago I've tried every pizza place in town and Tony's is definitely the best. Phenomenal pizza, friendly service and the pizza is always ready when I'm there to pick it up. My daughter and I share a pepperoni pizza every Thursday, Tony's has become a staple in our home! read more

The woman owner of this place should be absolutely ashamed of herself. I had three 11 year olds there, laughing and having a great time, when she started YELLING at them to be quiet (I should add in that there were 2 other people eating there). After eating, I said to her "hey they are just kids having fun." Her response "they'll be in jail in no time with that attitude." Oh and the pizza is gross and the pasta salad wasn't cooked. read more

I moved to Marblehead over 5 years ago. Tony's was right across the street from me and as a pizza-addict was excited to try this place and it was the first spot in town I ordered from. Complete disappointment. The pizza was awful; talking even worse than what I remember having at the school cafeteria in elementary school. The woman working (I'm guessing the owner from the comments I'm seeing) was extremely unwelcoming. I since gave them a few chances to try other menu items, but nothing I've ever eaten from here--subs, salads, pizza--was good. And the attitude from the owner/staff is just not great. If you don't want business, then don't open a business! SO many other great choices in town to chose from, and I always steer visitors towards them. Really unsure how this place stays in business. I would've been a multiple times a week customer if they were kinder and had better quality read more

I really like this place.. The food is really good and the family who runs it are really nice as well. The pizza is delicious, but it's also too thin. That's the only reason I gave Tony's 4 stars instead of 5. For pizza I'd recommend Marblehead House, for anything else go with Tony's. read more

I've been going to Tony's sence it first opened, not sence the reopening following the fire, The food is always what you'd expect from a 5 star sit down restuarant, Fresh, Delicious, and Plentiful. Excellent Thin Crust "To Die For" Pizza with many tasty variations, excellent parm's, Pastas, Salads And on and on. A must Try if you have not been to Tony's and while your there, your only a minute from the Old Marblehead Waterfront, Take your pie to the wharf and enjoy a Sunset. Mangi!!!! read more

Tony's Pizza - Great Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Marblehead, Massachusetts

A fantastic local place. This place is hard to beat on any level. I travel way out of the way to come here for the pizza, calzones, and meatballs. The pizza is in my top three (with Regina's and Engine House). Thin crust, light sauce, fresh ingredients, and not super greasy. The calzone is fantastic especially with the sauce on the side. Tony and his staff (some family) give a real welcoming and authentic atmosphere here. They take care of you. I only wish they were open on Sundays but everyone needs a day off I guess. A real asset to Marblehead. read more

I went to the place for a quick bite to eat. The staff seemed very nice. I was happy with my food and the place looked nice. I've never really went to many places in Marblehead but this was a good one. read more

I always enjoy a chicken parm sub and a place to sit and enjoy it. Quick service, decent prices, and a good location in Marblehead. You can even look across the street at all the Caffe Italia diners paying over $20 for their chicken parm - ha! Recommended for hot subs - I haven't tried anything else. read more

Tony's is the finest pizza restaurant in Marblehead. Thin crusted delicious dough and fine ingredients are the secret. The sauce is never acid - sweet with that authentic Italian flavor, complemented by tasty cheeses and friendly, efficient service. It truly is a family restaurant. Just being there is a delightful experience. I have had pizza in Naples, Italy and Tony's pizza is like the ones there. We have been going to Tony's for about 28 years, except for the time that the fire destroyed the building. read more

See all

Tony's is a whole new experience of a pizza place in Massachusetts tastes like It could come from either New York or Italy this is definitely a must try restaurant service is good and food comes fast definitely five stars. read more

This restaurant is located across the street from Caffe Italia Trattoria, which seems to be the happening place in town. Unfortunately, it was out of my budget for the evening so we went over to Tony's Pizza. We shared a Venetian Wrap made of spinach, mozzarella, and tomato. It was good. We added a bit of olive oil and salt for more taste. The pizza had a nice crispy crust which was really flavorful. The sauce and cheese were really tasty too. The staff were very friendly, and the service was pretty quick. I just wish the decor were a little more homey. I am kind of tired of commercial pizza/sub shop decor. read more

Consistently delicious food, every time I order out. Tony's is a great, fast place to grab lunch, and I find myself ordering a sub or salad, and am always pleased. The vegetables in the salad are always fresh, with the lettuce nice and crispy- you can tell it is freshly made. I love the chicken kebab salad ($7.49), as the chicken is lightly marinated but enough to give it a nice flavor. There is plenty of chicken on the salad, and the feta cheese in addition makes it a filling meal! My other go-to is the turkey sub ($5.79). The sub rolls are always soft and fresh and I enjoy that they use shredded lettuce with diced tomatoes on the sub. The turkey deli meat is tasty and not slimy as it is at some places. I recommend Tony's as a great lunch spot! There is booth seating for those looking to eat there rather than take out. read more

Wow, surprised to see so many negative reviews for Tony's. Although I must admit, I used to not like Tony's. Back before the fire, I never went there. Since they re-built my husband has taken me here many times and it is always amazing. He grew up on Tony's. The only item I didn't enjoy was the BLT sub I got. Their pizza is amazing. Of course you get the best quality food when Tony is working. read more

Fantastic pizza! Tony's is the go-to place if you're in the area - try the pizza, grinders (chicken parm - yum), calzones, and pasta. There is a good atmosphere and it's always crowded but never lacking a place to sit. Priced reasonably with reasonably large portions. Right in the heart of a great town center! read more

service was absolute dog shit, lady kicked out party of 6 becuase only ordered 4 pizza slices, lady working was extremly rude and had horrible attitude, food was cold and not worth the trouble or the money read more

Love Tony's Pizza. Pizzarita is my fav but everything there is good. Great atmosphere, friendly service, parking along the street, good prices and good portion sizes. read more

As a potentially snobby NYer... This pizza was ok. I had to over-oregano and red pepper my pizza to get any flavor out of it at all. Canned mushrooms, presliced pepperoni .... Not elite. read more

The food is pretty good, service is beyond slow and the employees down right rude. As I waited 45 mins for a veggie melt wrap and buffalo chicken wrap I repeatedly heard and saw this cook and cashier scream and boss around another employee who appeared to have some disabilities. He was nothing but nice and helpful bringing orders to peoples tables while trying to complete the 10 tasks they were yelling out to him. Personally would not go back if you as a business owner think that's appropriate to do in front of customer. As well you may want to work on your own production levels due to how long me wait was. read more

Apparently, money that comes from adults is more valuable than it is from children. My kids chose to spend their day off from school going to Tony's and a movie, but when they reached the counter to place their order, the woman at the register asked them to wait so she could take the order of the gentleman behind them. And, from what I hear, that is not the first time they have been either mistreated or ignored. If children are respectful, they deserve to be treated with respect in return. As a child advocate, it looks like I will be recommending that they spend their money somewhere they will be welcomed. The kids typically look forward to going to Tony's, but they are starting to be frustrated by the way they are treated. Maybe Tony's will start caring about the experience kids have at their establishment if the kids decide to start spending their money elsewhere on half days and days off. read more

I eat here at least once every two weeks sometimes once a week.. Food is always the same which is fresh and tasty. Pizza reminds me of the pizzerias i ate at growing up in a city where they have one every other block or so.. Tony is always hard working making pizzas but never to busy to say hello from his cooking area even coming up to us.. Keep up the good work!! By far the best place in town.. read more

I was looking forward to eating at this place because we walk by it all the time, and it looks friendly inside. Unfortunately, I found the food extremely subpar (cheap, cafeteria-quality), and the service was even worse: (1) they mis-charged us for the special, and, when asked, said they had actually just tacked on the $0.50 per cup charge for tap water!, and (2) *they* dropped our credit card between the counter and case, and we had to drive back later that evening to pick it up. For the inconvenience, they offered us nothing - not even free tap-water. We have no reason to return to or recommend this place. read more