There pepperoni/ fried eggplant pizza is yummy! I did not however like their meatball pizza! The staff is friendly. I especially like Andrew. Although he is usually in the back he does pop out to say hello! Kudos I haven't eaten inside since the move but I will the next time we go! read more

We went here for the first time since they moved into the new building down the street. Got there right at 11AM as they opened and the waitress took our order quickly. We split a large Philly Cheesesteak and had an order of onion rings. The rings came out in about 15 minutes and there really weren't many onion rings in the metal plate they were served in...maybe 6-8 onion rings. She also brought ketchup with them so we asked for some ranch sauce to dip them in....she brought that out to us. The Philly steak came out a bit before 11:30 and we thought it took a little long to make a cheesesteak. Along with the Cheesesteak she brought out another order of onion rings and said she thought the first order really didn't have enough onion rings. I was impressed that she was aware of it. We weren't really impressed with the cheesesteak. It was very "wet" mainly because the cheese was so runny. It was a light colored cheese, not sure what type, and the meat was very finely chopped up. The bread was good and held up to the wetness of the sandwich. My wife ate about half of her half and didn't like it. I considered it just "ok" and probably will try their pizza or another dish next time. I like the atmosphere of the older place more than the new building. It seems very cold..lots of large windows, small metal chairs and tables (no booths), and plywood ceilings (noisy when crowded according to friends that have benen there). They do have a nice patio outside...just wish the inside was more inviting. read more

It is NOT the original owners and the new building is so loud! The food is NOT the same & service takes a long time! We waited almost 40 minutes for them to take our order and another hour & 15 minutes to get our food! Wanted so bad to like this place but just can't. read more

Our ROMEO group (11 of us) went here for the first time since they moved to the new building. We arrived at 11:20 and there was a nice table along the left wall with a long bench and seating for all of us. The restaurant was fairly full. It's quite a bit different than the old place, being well lit with large windows and a real nice deck on the outside. They've got a bar with several tv's and along the left wall are two large televisions. Looks like they've got a little more seating than the old place. The one thing we noticed is that the acoustics were very bad. It seemed awfully loud and hard to hear across the table. Several of us mentioned this. In looking up at the ceiling it was basically just plywood and hadn't been painted yet. Hopefully they will do something with the ceiling to cut down on the noise. Along the top edge of the walls on the left in it looks like it's black painted aluminum about 1.5 to 2 feet down the wall. Seems like this could be changed or something put over it to help dampen the noise also. The waitress took our drink orders and came back and took our lunch orders. Two of us ordered the Philly Cheese sandwich with home fries. We had one hamburger order, about 3 pizza orders, and two sausage sandwich orders along with some more sandwich ordders. They had one cook going and two waitresses. It was 12:30 before we recieved our food. Everyone was getting a little concerned that it took so long to get the food. The pizza was given various ratings...one was a basic plain pizza and the crust was very crisp and topping was quite dark. It was over cooked and the crust was very crisp and almost too hard to bite at the ends. One person ordered the meat pizza and liked it a lot. The Philly Sandwich was good. Ordered it with jalapenos on the side. Three of us tried the home fries and were not pleased with them. They were crisp and not soggy (good thing) but they just didn't taste as good as most home fries. Maybe if they had been warm they would've been better. The waitress was busy and really didn't come back through and check our drink orders for most of the hour we were waiting. She finally did right before our food started coming out. This has been one of our favorite restaurants in Elgin for the previous 4 years, but I think we came away disappointed with the new restaurant...mainly because of the wait time and the acoustics....and the pizza wasn't as good as it was previously. We will come back again but maybe give it some time to get things working better. For this visit our overall rating was a 3.2 where previously it was closer to 4.5 - 5. read more

Hands Down the BEST PIZZA I've had in 5yrs. , Here in Columbia SC. I'm frm NYC So Pizza is a bigBIG DEal to Me. Portion : 10 Outta 10 , Sauce : 10 outta 10 , Crust : 11 Outta 10 ( it looked tasted chews like BRICKOVEN Should) even cold ( Room temperature), 7hrs later Tasted just as good. No need to ReHeat, Just Eat! And the Custom Calzones are just AMAZING !! 10 outta 10 for Sure . Service: Perfectly executed . Timely, and curtous and very patient with us , cuz we wanted everything lol. Ambiance . Cool , inviting, slightly Romantic, big enough but small enough. Just the right size. Casual date night or family night or just to watch the game : 10 outta I'm going back agn read more

See all

If you liked the old tonys you won't be disappointed same food nicer location and clean. 1. Chicken salad was great, fresh crispy. 2. nachos are a hot mess. Edges burned can't pull a Nacho out to eat without 1/4 of the cheese coming to. 3. Ordered wing basket sweet and sour. Got 10 wings wrong flavor no fries. 2nd attempt 6 wings no fries. 3rd attempt got it right minus the blue sauce . Overall nice bar, service good , food below average. Will try in a few months . read more

From the exterior, you would never know how spacious and relaxing this restaurant is. Amazingly delicious pizza, fresh salads all in a low key bar atmosphere but perfectly suitable for families. My only issues were with our service. The servers were super sweet but no silver ware was provided with our salads even when we asked we still waited and had to retrieve our place settings. The wrong salad size was brought and the server had no idea on wine offerings. It's the difference between a good restaurant and a great one. Minor changes that would make all the difference. read more

See all

On the fence. Tried it for the first time at their new location (02/18/26) - nicely done inside and out including parking, a good variety of menu options, lots of TV's showing the Olympics, and the patio will be great place to sit and enjoy this spring and summer Im sure. I'm on the fence because the 10" pizza was made using a pre made/frozen crust. The toppings were good but the crust was rock hard at the edges when baked. Fresh dough made in house is not an option for a pizza place, and a deal breaker for me. When it was served I was not given or offered utensils or a plate. I ordered a side salad as well. It didn't come out before or with the pizza. I was told "it will be out soon" and I didn't want it as a dessert, so I just asked for it to be taken off the bill. It wasn't. I caught that before I paid and they took it off. It's an almost 30 minute drive so I don't know that I would go out of my way to go there for pizza, but might try something else if I'm passing through. A few kinks to work out with the service too, but overall a nice place. read more

Visited 5/1/26 for the first time and the last time! I ordered a LARGE meatball sub and the meat was in thin slices. There were no meatballs, and if you totaled the slices of meat, I would say that I had 4 small meatballs at most. Additionally, there was very little cheese. I'm used to a meatball sub where you get some meat and some stretchy, pulley, drool-worthy cheese when you bite into your sandwich. What little I had tasted okay, however, the bread was soggy. The product was not commensurate with the cost. I felt like we got a bait-n-switch. Also, although my husband and I placed our orders at the same time, my husband had eaten over one-half of his pizza before my sub arrived. So disappointed such that I am heading to Marco's Pizza now to satisfy my meatball sub craving! read more

Great pizza! Has recently relocated to a new address at 1217 Rose Street - just a few blocks from the old Main Street address. Highly recommended! read more

My first impression of Tony's, is a very good one. My family and I dined in a very cozy corner. I enjoyed the rustic feeling it had when we walked in. We started off with some mozzarella sticks that were absolutely delicious! My waitress was attentive at bringing my beer with our appetizers. For our main event, I had a 10 inch chicken bacon ranch pizza, my daughter and son-in-law had the Philly cheese steak sandwich and wings. My grandson had his own little cheese pizza. We all enjoyed our food immensely. I definitely need to go back to try their burgers. read more

See all

Calzones not what they used to be at original location....bottom burnt and not chewable with little to no cheese & meat. New location is nice. Sweet tea is good service was good tho. read more

We've ordered from them a bunch! Always good! The pizza is always fresh and hot. The employees are always friendly and thoughtful!

Just about a year ago they switched to Pepsi from Coke and since then the drinks have been flat. We are told, oh, it's the ice machine. Wtf, it's 2025 these things can be fixed...but apparently not at Tony's. Our habits went from several times a week to every couple weeks and today was our first time in months and likely our last. Drinks are still flat. read more

It was our first time here. We did delivery and had three pies, garlic bread, fried mushrooms, chocolate cake and tiramisu. Food was absolutely delicious and so were the desserts. Unfortunately my tiramisu looked like someone ate half of it on the way to my house. It was the tiniest and sloppiest little piece, which was unfortunate because it was fantastic, I sure would've loved a full portion to enjoy. read more

See all

Ordered takeout. Pepperoni pizza 16in extra pepperoni for only 1.00 and 10 buffalo wings cooked well done. Both were excellent!! I might would like the wings crispier but I'm sure they didn't want to dry it out. Just wish they came with celery. But eat there at least monthly and always get the Pizza as it beats everyone else! read more

Not good pizza unfortunately. They show strong effort but this recipe needs a rework. They did have this nice McLaren out front though. read more

Tony's Pizza Palace - Pizza Near Me - Elgin, South Carolina

Overall great experience! Food is absolutely delicious! I would definitely come back again! The service is really good! They are very attentive! read more

The pizza was good (for SC pizza). Chicken wings were very tasty and meaty. Top perk was they were open on a Sunday. I will return.

They know what they're doing at Tony's! Happy to support a local business and order delivery regularly. The Santorini veggie pizza is delicious and the ricotta cheese puts it over the top. The white calzone is awesome as are their burgers. Don't hesitate to try the fried mushrooms. The food is always on time and the orders are always correct. Can't go wrong ordering from Tony's. read more

My husband and I just moved to the area, so we decided to give Tony's a try. We ordered our pizza at 6:23PM and we didn't receive our pizza until 8:50PM, and the pizza was cold (not even slightly warm). read more

Tony's Pizza Palace - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elgin, South Carolina

Marinara sauce is good. That's about the highlight. Cheese bread is average. Calzones are tuff and overcooked. Seriously...it's like a brick. They don't have any ground beef in the sauce for the lasagna or the spaghetti sauce. Service was not impressive today. Overcharge on our side of meatballs today. Spaghetti noodles are thick and mushy. Pizza is lacking in flavor and skimpy with the toppings. Just not a great place. P.S. Don't forget to bring a Fly Swatter. More flies than a picnic at a family reunion. read more

Excellent food! Large portions. Friendly staff. Comfortable dining experience. Several menu options. Sit inside or order out. Love the Greek salads read more

Pizza is good and the wings are pretty good also. The service is always friendly and attentive. For a small local place, they do a good job! I prefer to support local business and Tony's delivers every time. They also make my kids feel special and they love going also. Highly recommend this location in Elgin. read more

Tony's has good pizza and garlic cheese bread. I haven't tried any of their other items but i was very pleased with pizza. If you're looking for delivery in Elgin or parts of Lugoff, this is your best bet. read more

The pizza is as close you can get to a decent Northeastern style taste down in SC. Very small place and not the cleanest outside for a location but don't let it fool you. The inside is clean and you're greeted when you walk inside. read more

We have been going there for years ,the past couple of times it's been going down Hill , and NOTHING to do with the food , It's All the Service they need to hire people who Work and talk less and showing less them socializing, it's A restaurant customer come in to Eat the good food not to see them playing on there cell phone . Flirting on the guys . On may 8th 2;15 owner check your tapes we walk in 2 tables had customers ok new waitress talking with a truck driver we ordered our drinks and still not busy she goes back talking with the guy more then 10 minutes go by still no drinks , still hasn't taken order . And yes she is still up there talking with the guy .Tony's if you want it to be a self service Let everyone know and then a waitress wants a tip this is not the way to go about it . .. so many business are going hill and closing and customers service is # 1 read more

Great food (Tony's special pizza.) The price was fair. Waitress was attentive, pleasant, and accurate. The room was a little dark for my old eyes, but typical for a pizza place. We'll be back again soon! read more

Probably the best pizza I've had in Columbia metro area! Sauces and crust were amazing quality and taste- read more

Only ordered pizza from here a few times and we love it. If the food says pick up in 30 minutes it's gonna be ready. Service has always been good. Will keep coming back. read more

Quicker delivery than they quoted. Some of the best pizza, I've had since moving from up North! Will definitely order again and tell friends

Hit them up for dinner recently and it was delicious. My son and I had a large meat lovers pizza and an order of wings. Initially I called it in for a delivery but the young lady told me it's be almost 2 hours! When I told them I'd come pick it up it was reduced to an hour. When I finally got to the restaurant I still had to wait about 29 minutes! If there was a negative this would be it. The food was good and even when I went to the restaurant the staff was nice and friendly. It was just the wait for the food that was drawback. I'd eat there again but next time I'd have gauge it to make sure it'll be ready in a more timely fashion. read more

This pizza place is a hidden gem in Elgin, SC. We stop to grab at least 2 large pizzas everytime we leave Columbia. Don't worry these are the type of custom pizzas that taste good even if you have to reheat in the oven. Must try: The Santorini Veggie extra eggplant! My house is pure carnivore and we love this. It's also good with pepperoni. Chicken Alfredo Cajun Steak Lovers read more

I'm new to the area and looked up a pizza place for dinner. I took a chance and ordered and I'm glad I did the pizza was very tasty and the wings were flavorful! I will definitely order again they won't disappoint you . The delivery person was very professional and handle everything with care . I recommend you try them. read more

Our first time here (sunday) and had great service and food. It's a small restaurant but the waitress was so nice and even the customers were friendly so they had a nice atmosphere. We ordered the sweet n sour wings, the wings are good and crispy. I'm looking forward to trying the other flavors. We also got fries with them for my son and he loved them. We tried the Cajun steak pizza, the pizza was pretty good. My husband and I loved the dough and crust which to me makes the pizza. I'm really happy about the pricing especially compared to Pontiac pizza that is closer to us but way too pricy! Overall the food is good, great prices and a nice atmosphere! read more

Excellent pizza, grinders, fries, and homemade ranch dressing. No beer on tap, but bottles are ice cold. Service is excellent! Ambiance has a very hometown feel. Perfect spot! read more

The wings never have that undercooked feel like other pizza places do. And the Calzones are amaaaaaazing read more

Tony's Pizza Palace - The meat lovers calzone and buttery hot buffalo wings. - Pizza Near Me - Elgin, South Carolina

I'd recommend this place to anyone who's a fan of pizza and wings. Only because those are what I typically what I order when I go. When you go you can always expect super friendly service, you can also expect your food out in a timely manner also! This place is one of my "go-to"s because they are extremely reliable! Highly suggest trying it out! read more

So, had the best nachos the other day! Sat outside at Tony's Pizza Palace in Elgin, with a glass of the house reisling and watched the world go by. The staff was so accommodating and pleasant, the patio clean and comfortable. Will be returning soon! read more

My favorite pizza in the area! I am originally from New Jersey and have not had good pizza in ten years! I was so happy when we found this place. The pizza is awesome and the staff are so friendly. read more

Tony's Pizza Palace - Half Pepperoni half pepperoni and onion. My favorite pizza place. Have been there 3 times since we found It. - Pizza Near Me - Elgin, South Carolina