We're in town to visit Congaree National Park and Italian sounded good. The place is clean, the staff friendly and prompt. We ordered bruschetta as an appetizer. It was not what I expected...Texas toast with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella on top. I expected something homemade, chunky with olive oil and Italian spices. We ordered spaghetti with salads and garlic bread. Again, it was tomato sauce over pasta, something I think I could've made myself. But the portions were generous, the food hot and we were well served. My husband ordered baklava for dessert. It was not exceptional but it was good. If you're looking for a filling meal in a clean environment with good service, Tony's fits the bill! read more

Tony's Pizzalicious - This sounded good and was close to our hotel. Eat in pizza and Italian food. Clean and prompt service! - Pizza Near Me - Cayce, South Carolina

Good food and service. Ambiance is ok. It's abouthe pizza, right? Would certainly recommend.

Five stars all the way . I first ate at Tony's Pizzalicous over eight years ago, the pizza is hand made by Steve and his family. Lots of love goes into every food item you eat. I went back to eat take out , spaghetti and meatballs. Outstanding. Shout out to Steve, the head of this family owned restaurant. Steve, I told you that I was a Google Guide and your place has been viewed 1,836 times. Don't change anything. read more

Mom and Pop shop... i am all about supporting small and local businesses... that woman is busting her butt in there and she is so nice. The food is great and lots of food for such a cheap price. Keep up the great work! great to see you guys are back from vacation read more

Highly recommend this place if you love authentic Greek food! It's so many great choices so I will give you my top 3 picks! 1.The meat lovers pizza 2. The spaghetti meat sauce with the homemade meatballs, so good and delicious! 3. Spaghetti Caruso made with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, pepperoni, Italian, sausage, and ham covered with meat sauce! read more

Ordered 2 orders of Mozzarella sticks, 4 drinks, 2 large cheese Pizzas and a Chicken Alfredo pizza (personal size) to go. The first pizza was fine the second pizza was over cooked and doughy. The manager asked what do you want me to do about it? I replied remove it from my bill and he said he would take 5 dollars off the bill. When I went to pay the bill was 93 dollars. The waitress was very apologetic but the owner was rude and the pizza was horrible. We will never go back again. read more

I miss the old place, and the pizza they used to make. I don't like the pizza they make, now. I do like the salads, though. I don't like a lot of the changes they made, but I do like how most of the building has mostly stayed the same. I used to go there a lot before the newer owners bought the place. My grandparents started taking me there when I was a small kid. Was it always called Pizzalicious? read more

As always the pizza was awesome. Sadly they have a sign that reads please be kind to the employees that showed up. Well we did extend kindness to the only waitress they had. So ready to leave her an awesome tip since the place was empty. Unfortunately the only server didn't care for us and provided the worst service we have ever had there. We go to Tony's Pizzalicious at lease twice a month and get the same pizza every time. The service was always on point. Perhaps they wouldn't need to post a sign to be kind if the waitress would return the kindness. We'll be back but if she's serving we'll go Duke's across the street. read more

Meatball Overload... I walked in and it immediately brought me back to my childhood. My senses brought me back to hanging out at the local pizza place and having dinner after a baseball game. I'm looking forward to trying the pizza. read more

Tony's Pizzalicious - Meatball Parmigiana Sub Extra Toasted - Pizza Near Me - Cayce, South Carolina

If you're looking for a modern, somewhat upscale restaurant. This isn't it. If you want that throwback mom-n-pop experience, this is your place. The staff were all very friendly. We like the old, small town feel to it. The chefs salad was nothing special, but that's ok, we didn't come for salad tasting. The pizza was great. Sometimes my kids won't eat the crust, but they even finished that off. The calzone was good as well, though pizza sauce would've been better for dipping(the sauce tasted more like a light pasta sauce). The lady serving us was very friendly and made sure we always had what we needed. Pros: great pizza, friendly staff, fair price. Cons: calzone sauce, salad was meh, and the ranch in commercially bought packets was a letdown. Definitely still a solid 4/5 overall. read more

I rarely, if ever, publicly express my dissatisfaction with another business, especially a local business, but my experience today at Tony's Pizzalicious on Knox Abbott Drive was like nothing I've ever experienced. It started 2 nights ago when I picked up an order to go totaling approx $23. I opened the top on my manicotti, took a bite and immediately felt hair in my mouth. I pulled out a hair at least 12" long. (My hair is no more than 2 inches, so it wasn't mine). I took a picture of it. I called up to Tony's and spoke to the manager. I very nicely explained that my husband and I were not going to be eating the meals, would be glad to bring them back, but I wanted a refund. She was very kind and apologetic, but told me she would have the owner call me the next day. I never got a call. So, today I went into the restaurant. The owner told me that the other 2 ladies there would help me, but I told him that I needed to talk to him. He moaned, rolled his eyes and said, "what do you want". I explained what happened and asked for my money to be refunded. He told me that he wouldn't give it back to me because I probably planted the hair to get money and that people do that to him all the time. He said if I had brought the meals back, so he knew that they hadn't been eaten, that he would have given me my money back. I told him that I would go get the meals out of my trash and bring them there. He said okay. When I returned with the uneaten meals, he pushed them back at me, told me that he talked to his "girls" and none of them had spoken with me about this. I told him he could open the containers and see that all the food was there and even see the hair, but he refused to take a look. He called me a scammer. He started using the F word with me. He told me to get off his property or he would call the police. This is the worst business encounter that I have ever dealt with in all of my years. I mean, I don't need the $23, but it was the principle of the thing. Of course, I will never go back there, but beware of this owner's business ethics. Unacceptable. Total fail. read more

Tony's Pizzalicious - Long hair in food that I pulled out of my mouth! - Pizza Near Me - Cayce, South Carolina

I ate today at Tonypizzalicious in Cayce for the first time in about 15 years. Before that I ate many years ago at their predecessor, Tony's Pizza, which had extremely good Spaghetti and fantastic home cooked Roast beef sandwiches with their special sauce they called bbq sauce. Today I got the famous spaghetti with meatsauce and a salad for a little over $10. Not a bad deal and the spaghetti was good. I gave it a 4 star because it was heavy on pasta and the meat sauce was good but not fantastic. It was hot, as you can see the steam in the picture. I will eat here again until I find a fantastic tasting spaghetti somewhere else. read more

Tony's Pizzalicious - Salad - Pizza Near Me - Cayce, South Carolina

See all

Not the greatest pizza around but not terrible either, basic pizza parlor with very small but not the cleanest bathrooms. As far as service there's no issues from my experience. Food comes out hot and ready. It's well known to the area of the location and it's worth a try. read more

I came in to come eat with my family. I had my little niece with me, we sat down and ordered our food and my niece started to get upset and crying. We were trying to calm her down and we were told by an older male worker that my niece was being too loud and that they had other customers. My family and I felt uncomfortable by the way we were treated so we left. I can't review on the food because we were not able to eat, but customer service wise I believe the entire situation could've been handled in an alternative way. read more

"best pizza in any town" more like worst tastes like straight cardboard they don't have meat in there greek salad ??? and no oil and vinegar ??? absolutely outrageously priced for some pizza that tastes like digorno read more

Great place very friendly, The food is great I had a calzone that took me two days to complete read more

Tony's Pizzalicious - Cala zone - Pizza Near Me - Cayce, South Carolina

Six of us went here for lunch today. First time for all of us. My friend had recommended it, saying you go here for the spaghetti, not the pizza. Arrived at 11:30 and there was plenty of booths. Two of our friends got there first and had a table set up for six. They had on waitress working and she immediately took our drink orders and came back for our entrees. I asked her what she preferred, spaghetti or pizza, and she said they were both good but liked the pizza better. It seems that most of the Yelp reviewers have had the pizza over the spaghetti. I really wanted to try the spaghetti, but the pizza did look good, so two of us decided to split a small pizza and a spaghetti and meatball entree. We ordered a small pizza (all meat) and an order of spaghetti with meatballs. The spaghetti came with a side salad. We ordered a side house salad also. The salad was fresh and good. Pizza came out on a hot metal plate and looked great. It was very good. Nice cheese pull, lots of meat, and the crust was just right. Not real thin or thick, but nicely done so it was crispy and the crust was also done right. Two of the guys ordered Hawaiian pizzas and said they were good also. One ordered a curatta spaghetti (or something like that). It had cheese baked on top of it and really looked good. It had onions, green peppers, italian sausage (no meatballs). This guy has never said anything was good...it's always "Oh, it was okay". This was the first time I've heard him say an item was "Good". I thought the spaghetti and meatballs was just "okay". Meatballs were good, tender, and the sauce was good. Nothing special about it...and realized after I saw the Curatta that they did have a "Baked Spaghetti" on the menu. I think I should've ordered that. I'd like to give this four stars...I think it may deserve four stars. The service was good, waitress very good, but I have a feeling that when it's crowded things could be possibly slow. It did take a while to get our order, and one of the guys did bring up about it taking long to get the food. I definitely will go back. read more

If you want great pizza, this is the best place in town. It has a great atmosphere to it. My party was seated and greeted immediately, and our waitress was polite and prompt in taking our order. It was as if our pizzas were made by Tony himself, and it was arguably the best pizza I've ever had. We will definitely be coming back soon. read more

We love the spinach dip here! And the pizza is always delicious! Great overall experience with this restaurant.

Great place for a nice comfortable lunch/dinner. Staff is friendly, fun, and attentive. We had the salmon, and it was AMAZING! So full of flavor. Just melts in your mouth like butter. Portions are generous, rice with gravy, and side salad- all delicious! Even the owner, Steve came by to say hello and make sure we were all happy. Pizza is fantastic, too- and I'm a picky New York "pizza snob" lol! You won't be disappointed- HIGHLY RECOMMEND- read more

Pizzalicious is DELICIOUS! Everything is always outstanding and comes out hot. Highly recommend for a date night or a night out with friends

We had plans to go to another restaurant, but it was closed so we decided with Tony's. Recently moved to the area and trying to find my go to restaurants. We sat down at a booth and the waitress was very attentive. We ordered the meatlovers and Dimi pizzas. While we waited we sipped on our drinks enjoyed the complimentary coloring pictures and crayons, my son especially enjoyed the coloring. Pizza soon came out hot and fresh just the way I like it. There was a Mediterranean explosion in my mouth. The sauce had a very good balance of seasonings, vegetables, cheese, and meat was not burned, but deliciousness. We all ate in silence as we each ate 4 slices. Normally, I just eat two slices, but that day i couldn't help myself. It was so good that I ordered another meatlovers to go. If you haven't tried this place you should because the pizza slaps! Before you choose other big name competitors feast on Tony's you won't regret it. This place has become one of my staples. We will be back soon! read more

Family owned restaurant. I've eaten there for several years. Steven and his wife Valarie have always maintained a high quality in their food. They have also managed to keep their prices very affordable. read more

It was just okay, nothing special really. I liked the appearance of the place, some may call it dated, but for me it was kind of like going back in time. Everything was clean. I got a meatball sub, but it was so messy, I just ate it with a knife and fork. My wife got a calzone, and she thought it was pretty good. I don't think you can go wrong with this place, there just wasn't much about it that had me craving more. read more

Starting in the 1970's, I use to eat here with my family and I kept going as the years went along. One of the things I liked about it was that it never changed. When you went to Tony's, you knew what you were going to get. I always ordered the sandwich plate with two sides. You could choose: ham, roast beef or turkey and two sides from: spaghetti, tossed salad, congealed salad or chips. It was always delicious, but then a few years ago something happened. I don't know what it was, but everything changed and not for the better. Gone were the sandwich plates and the spaghetti sauce we loved. I stopped going and did not return for several years. Yesterday, I decided to give it another try and boy I am glad I did! It was all back!! Like it never left!! I am so happy. This will probably be my "go to" place at least once a week now. Would Recommend again!!! read more

Pizza was okay at best. The crust was thick and chewy and the sauce lacked flavor, but the cheese ratio was on point and toppings were fresh. read more

Rude Owner, Not Family Friendly, Average Food. Our family met up here and our young son and his young cousin were yelled at by the owner who then kicked our large party out. There was only one other couple in the restaurant and he said the 21 month old was being too loud. After attempting to discipline the toddler by coming out of the kitchen aggressively, he told us to leave. The grandmother and mother were in tears at the rudeness of this owner. The food is average at best. We went for the family friendliness and he failed. Do Not Go here. See the other reviews, he is a very rude new owner who insults people. As we left, the waitress apologized and said she hated it, the cook made "I hate him motions" to the owner behind his back. The owner refused to apologize. There are other Italian places within a few blocks. Go there. Nothing here for anyone to enjoy. read more

Call me naive, but the name "Tonys" implies New York Style to me. Wrong. I ordered my usual Pepperoni and Sausage and to my horror, I watched as the preparer went into a walk in fridge and appeared with a pre-prepped crust already on a cookie sheet. I felt obligated at this point but suffice it to say the crust was not very good. The quantity of meat toppings was adequate but the cheese was bland and very scarce. I do not think I will return considering the option in the city of Columbia read more

Tony's Pizzalicious - Pizza Near Me - Cayce, South Carolina

I read the reviews, by figured I'd try it anyway. We got a small Pizza and wings. The wings were actually quite good, not a lot of fat and cooked well. If definitely get those again. I liked the convenience of the drive thru window for pick up, I have an infant, so if I can avoid taking my baby out of the car, it's a plus. The pizza however, was a bust. They cook their Pizza on one of those rotating racks that goes through the oven, kind of like the toaster at a hotel. The pizza dough was raw inside still. And I don't mind thin crust, but it was inconsistent on the edges. It appeared to have seeped into the grate a bit on the edge and was cracker-ish/dry. I would not get the pizza again. read more

See all

I think Tony's has some of the best pizza in Columbia! While I have only ever ordered pizza and salad from Tony's, we go back often! The staff is incredibly friendly and interested in making your experience as enjoyable as possible. Great prices and great portions! Since going there for the 1st time last year, it is by far the pizza placer we now go the most! As for the other reviews, everyone is entitled to their opinion, I supposed. But to Nascar M, the fact that you are trashing a restaurant b/c it is not what you thought it would be b/c of its name...talk about judging a book by its cover! Go in...give it a try...I can almost guarantee you will go back :) read more

Discovered this fantastic eatery and their pizza is truly a "work of art"! From the staff to the owner-they are nice people! This is my second visit and when in town, my only spot read more

Greatest pizzeria that my boyfriend and I have ever been too! Pizza was beyond delicious and staff were very friendly. Had a wonderful family oriented feel to it. Highly recommend! read more

We LOVE pizza and like trying new pizza joints. We drove by and decided to stop in and order a small side salad, garlic cheese bread sticks, and a small Dimi's pizza to go. We left to run a few errands, and we when we came back 30 minutes later to pick up our order, we waited for about 10 minutes before being acknowledged. The salad was the best item, but there was as much cheese as there was lettuce. The bread sticks were made from the bread of a sub sandwich. It was sliced and topped with chewy cheese, and served with, what tasted like canned, red sauce. The pizza was completely burned as the crust and toppings were charred. The crust had a funny sour taste. Frozen pizza is better. Not sure we will give this place a second try. read more

Tony's Pizzalicious - Pizza Near Me - Cayce, South Carolina

Some of the best pizza, tried the Sausage Pizza and the wings while watching football this weekend and so very good and the service was awesome. Will be one of my regular spots from now on. read more

The service is fast, very friendly and family oriented. What a pleasure to be greeted by smiling faces. The food is absolutely delicious, the BEST pizza I've had since leaving New Jersey 8 years ago. My dining partner had the baked spaghetti, loaded with melted cheese, which was impressively tasty - they make their own sauce! The prices are low considering the quality of what we had. My small pizza, enough for 2-3 meals was only $6.99, and the pasta dish was only $7.99. My new favorite dining spot, save me a booth please! read more

Ordered cheese sticks and a large pizza 20 minutes later I inquired about our cheese sticks which only should take a short time to come out...they waitress said she would look and a second later she delivered a tray of cheese sticks that were cold and had been sitting obviously, we got up and left...I guess they don't mind serving old cold food that's been sitting, this was my second attempt to eat here so will NEVER be back. And they wait staff sucks read more

This is a good family restaurant with excellent pizza. Nothing too fancy but friendly staff and good food.

I ordered bruschetta and it was horrible. It was an absolute disgrace to the original creator of this otherwise known to be tasty snack. I will NEVER eat here again because if you can't make a simple chopped tomatoes and cheese over bread snack than you surely can't make an extravagant meal. I wouldn't feed my dog the leftovers from their kitchen. read more

Tony's Pizzalicious - Pizza Near Me - Cayce, South Carolina

Got to say this is some pretty darn good food. I had the benefit of having a couple slices of pizza and I loved it. Not sure what the other reviews are about. Simply put I enjoyed this pizza more than I have a lot of other places that I've been to in the country. You have to respect it when a restaurant provides quality customer service and quality food. Don't be afraid to try it. read more

Worst Pizza Ever!!! Overpriced,tasteless,cardboard. they use pre made crust, and sauce has no flavor. eggplant Parm was just as bad. Tasteless, not enough sauce or any flavor. Waste of money! We were starving so we just ate, otherwise we would have sent food back. Don't know how this place stays in business. read more