I had the amazing pleasure of finding out about Papa Gio's. Their authentic and homemade sauces, garlic knots, New York style pizza and gourmet pizza was awesome. They also have pizza by the slice and calzones, pasta dishes to list a few. We ordered the garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, chicken parmigiana pizza, philly cheesesteak and onions sub, and a meatboli. The service was great and everyone who worked there was personable and cared about their food and customer satisfaction. [[HIGHLIGHT]]They do have seating which we did utilize since we drove 30 minutes to get there and most definitely will return again.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

We stopped in while visiting the area and unfortunately the experience was pretty underwhelming overall. The staff didn't seem very welcoming -- in fact, they appeared annoyed by even the smallest customer interactions, which made ordering and dining in feel uncomfortable. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The restaurant itself has that classic New York / New Jersey-style pizza parlor vibe -- small, cramped, and a bit run-down -- but in this case it leaned more toward dirty and damp than charmingly old-school.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Because I have significant issues with traditional gluten, I ordered the gluten-free pizza. It's made on a pre-packaged cauliflower crust that was largely flavorless and had a somewhat uninspired texture. The sauce was bland and really needed seasoning, and the cheese was simply... cheese. Nothing particularly good or bad, just very average. That said, I'm grateful that I didn't have any negative reactions after eating, which is always a concern for me when dining out. While the food itself wasn't impressive, it does seem to be a relatively safe option for those who need gluten-free choices while traveling. read more

Good pizza at a decent price. Papa Gio's is one of our go to spots for take out when we are home.

We love this place. The food and service are great! The pizza and Chicken Parm are my favorite, and don't forget to try the MEATBALLS!

When a pizza place won't take an to-go order 30 minutes before close, there are some major customer service issues to be resolved. I won't be trying to spend my money here again read more

Got the gluten free and it was probably one of the best gluten frees I've gotten! I love there sauce tho I'm an extra sauce kinda gal so I always get extra on the side for dipping! Great service as always and [[HIGHLIGHT]]the place is so cozy and clean as always![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Love this place! Great people and wonderful food. Everything is good! The Pizza, Stromboli, Spaghetti. The sandwiches are great too. Try the Philly Cheesesteak as well! read more

Go for the pizza, not the pasta. I ordered the chicken Marsala and it was not creamy and delicious like I have had it at other Italian places. It was dry noodle and an ok chicken filet. I tried my daughter's pizza and it was delicious! Garlic knots are also yummy. So if we go back we'll be getting pizza. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The place is kinda small, so you may have to wait for a table.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]The vibe is very family/casual, with TVs on and the kitchen open behind a counter where people come get takeout orders - quaint enough, but not high ambiance or fancy if that's what you want.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

This was an emergency backup for the failure of Za in Columbia. We were starving. Stopped in for a quick early dinner. They had slices premade and topped off in the oven. The garlic knots were exceptionally tasty. Copious amounts of garlic. Only downside was lack of variety of beverages. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Nice little spot.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

WOW AMAZING! I have never had such a great dine in experience, the staff are amazing and the food was made fresh! I came in on Monday there were two girls, the one that helped me said her name was Sophie, she had an excellent smile and tremendous service. I did notice she was very efficient and was doing a lot. She waited our table then made our pizza and was on her orders quickly! Papa gios has really gotten great! read more

A friend and I went on a pizza tour today, hitting 4 shops for a slice each. We started at papa gio's and couldn't pass up trying the sicilian too. It was my personal favorite crust of the day. Perfectly crunchy, on the outside and soft on the inside. The sauce was not my favorite of the day, but I will be back for that Sicilian treat at some point! read more

Papa Gios - Sicilian Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Irmo, South Carolina

See all

Good lunch deal, enjoyed the calzone. I don't know what else to type so now I'm going to discuss how weird it is that veggie chips are just made from potatoes. Ha, we've all been duped! read more

Ordered Penne a la Vodka and Spaghetti with Sausage both were Superb! Garlic knots were fresh and plenty of garlic butter Cheesecake and Tiramisu were excellent! read more

Good food, nice size portions. All the food came out hot and fresh, especially the garlic knots. Would return.

The pizza is here is GREAT and they have online ordering! I get tired of chain pizza restaurants so this place is not only convenient to my business yet also tasty and just what I need for some bomb a** pizza! I haven't tried their wings yet or any of the other menu items, however, wings are next on the list with pizza. I always get the veggie add pineapple on my pie. I love this place! read more

First time eating there. Pizza was great. Will now be our go to pizza spot. Service was also amazing!

Love me a cheese pie. First time I got one at Papa Gio's it was the real deal. Stromboli same. Since then it's been hit or miss. Few times OK, few times not. Haven't been in a couple months because of the inconsistency. Truthfully, I'd just as soon make the trek to Dano's where I can get great pizza EVERY TIME. Gio's service seems a little abrupt. Not the most welcoming place around. Could be the NY vibe, I dunno. read more

Pizza was good! They have a lunch special 2 slices of pizza and a fountain soda for $6.95! Slices are large!! read more

Papa Gios - Cheese Pizza 2 Slices of Cheese Pizza and Soda Lunch Special - Pizza Near Me - Irmo, South Carolina

We waited 10 extra minutes and they gave us a huge free dessert love the food definitely recommend please go there

This place is so yummy!!! The Stromboli is huge for the price, their thin crust pizza is now our favorite! Excellent service & great atmosphere! Will definitely be back. read more

Papa Gios of Irmo is consistently delicious! The past few times I have ordered (via Uber eats), everything is meticulously packed and the perfect temperature. Thank you for the attention given to the little details! It does not go unnoticed! read more

Yummy pizza. Large selection of other dishes. Small eat in dinning area. They were way behind when I came to pickup our pizza , so offered us a complimentary drink for the extra wait time read more

First time at Papa Gios in Irmo. Food was GREAT, service was a little slow, staff very cordial & helpfu

Great Italian food! Just like New York, the big slices, the authentic pasta it's all great! They play Italian music but not too loud, so you can still hear people at your table. And the service has improved so much over the past year, you can tell these guys really care about their customers and their service. The wait time is well worth the food they provide! Happy to be a returning customer! read more

We ordered take out on a Friday night around 7pm. There were two parties eating inside and several to go orders. We were told the wait would be about 30 minutes and it took that amount of time. I felt like that was an appropriate time to wait. The garlic bread knots were delish. Huge order! It was an entire to go box filled with a side of marinara. Truthfully, I liked them more than the pizza. They get 5 stars! Perfect dough and plenty of garlic and cheese. Delish! We got a large pepperoni pizza. It was good, but I wasn't blown away. I prefer veggie pizza but kids won on the order request. Kids enjoyed the pizza and gave it 4 stars. My oldest son agreed the garlic knots were his favorite... I will give them another shot but based on our last order I don't think they're worth the price... read more

My new favorite pizza spot ! Try the Sicilian slice or the garlic and shrimp pizza it's dynamite..... read more

See all

Food wasnt awful but it wasnt good. the shrimp in the alfredo had the tails still on it and tasted bland. the garlic knots were bland and overcooked. all and all 3/10. read more

Awesome pizzas!! Wonderful pasta dishes!! You definitely get your money's worth and the best leftovers!! So much food!!

If your looking for that thin New York style pizza this is Deff it. I never really had any bad experience here. Staff is always super friendly. Even when it's busy, you wait a little longer but it's a small business just have to make it work sometimes. Keep up the good work read more

We love there Stromboli!!! Food is always hot and fresh!! Highly recommend !! It never takes long to get our food

Fantastic small quaint family owned pizza location. We were from out of town and it came highly recommended. I have eaten lots of pizza, and this one is on the top 5! Fantastic pizza and service. Pizza was served hot and fresh, all the ingredients were fresh too. Prices were good for the food your receiving! Highly recommend, this place is amazing! read more

Papa Gios - Front - Pizza Near Me - Irmo, South Carolina

This place has garbage customer service. I came in 40 mins before close for a stromboli and asked for specfic ingredients (pepperoni and beef). I get home and see that they added peppers, onions, and mushrooms. While initially pissed, I calmed down and called the restaurant to ensure my refund for the next time I come in. Never before have I gone through an interrogation at a restaurant for a mis-prepared meal. They told me that I told the cashier incorrectly what I wanted, despite me insisting that I asked the cashier if I can have specific ingredients (pepperoni and beef) with my wife as a witness. Reluctantly they said I can get a refund if came back that same night (by this time, 6 minutes before they close), or they will remake me another one tomorrow. I told them I'm not coming back tonight, and that I will bring it back tomorrow for my money back. Again, they reluctantly agreed. Fast forward to the next day, I bring the stromboli back and I'm getting interrogated again! Placing the blame on me on how I ordered the stromboli and how they are going to refund it today (as if it was a favor towards me). They proceeded to try and refund me the subtotal of the stromboli ($22.95) until I pointed out the sales tax that was also due (about $2.30). A new disagreement came about with them claiming the tax is included despite me showing them the receipt, subtotal, and overall tax for the purchase (we also had a cheesesteak and fries). Four employees/managers in the restaurant and I'm looked at like I don't know what I'm talking about. Eventually they caved in and gave me $24 (still the incorrect amount). At this point, I didn't feel like arguing. I took the money and left. While Papa Gios food is pretty decent, the customer service I experienced was despicable. I will never go back, and I urge you all to find a place that will value you as a customer. read more

Pizza was different than what I've gotten from there before. Nothing spectacular. The pizza from the Lexington location was so good so it was a let down. read more

Great pizza! I feel like I'm back home in New Jersey! Super nice people. Even though they were extremely busy (it was a Friday night) the workers kept me updated on the status of my order. Definitely suggest calling ahead because dinner rush because it is a very popular place and you will be waiting. Can't wait to go back!! read more

Papa Gios - Meat Meatlovers Pizza; add green peppers - Pizza Near Me - Irmo, South Carolina

I'm trashing this garbage on every site I can find!!! A tiny salad and awful customer service is about to cost this raggedy excuse for a pizzaria more than they bargained for!!! Slow service, rude management, and down right not paying attention to simple details!!! This Place Is TRASH And I'm Telling Anyone Who Will Listen!!! read more

Fantastic! Haven't had Sicilian style pizza since I lived in NYC. This totally hit a bullseye. My wife loved to too but she's from Queens. Hey, what does she know. Haha. Thanks so much for bringing us back to the Lower East Side goomba. read more

Great food coming from NY it has been difficult to find good Italian food... I gave them four stars because they're delivery is slower than slow twice I waited over an hour and a half. read more

the pizza was booty licking good the pizza was booty licking good the pizza was booty licking good the pizza was booty licking good the pizza was booty licking good the pizza was booty licking good the pizza was booty licking good the pizza was booty licking good the pizza was booty licking good the pizza was booty licking good read more

I just discovered this place, recently. The food has been great, and the service has been super. Everyone has been sweet and helpful! I love this place!! read more

This place used to be great but now it's just a disappointment. The prices used to be competitive, delivery used to be free, & the staff used to be competent. Now, however, the prices seem to keep rising, they started charging for delivery (& were, quite frankly, very rude when asked about it) and the girl ringing up the order couldn't figure out how to change a one topping pizza in the family meal deal to a specialty pizza. These places never seem to make it for long once they start making these kinds of changes & quality drops. I know I won't be recommending them to anyone like I was before. There'll be another good pizza place to replace them eventually... Update...tried to give this place another chance. Called in and order and was told it would be ready for pick up in 20 minutes. We showed up to pick it up on time and paid then were made to wait an additional 20 minutes before we asked why it was taking so long. The same girl lied and said she wouldn't have told me 20 minutes she would have told me 30. (Even though it had been 40 at that point) Lied as if I wouldn't know the difference. FINALLY at the 52 minute mark it was read. No apology for it taking more than twice the time we were quoted. Last time I'll ever come here! read more