Toolbox Men&#x27;s Supply Company

Great clothes but shit customer service. They have unique pieces but now that I have a very good…read morewardrobe I won't be shopping with them. Milblend Supply, Self Edge, Blue Owl, Snake Oil Provisions, and Weathered Fig are some great alternatives.

Same, John B. Do not order online. Item was not listed "Final Sale" as other items on their website…read morewere, but they hand-wrote "Final Sale" on my invoice. Shirt doesn't fit and they won't accept return. Shirt was $145 on sale from $188. I didn't ask for money back, only store credit so that I could buy something that fits. If anyone wants a size large, Jackman Waffle Mid-Neck in Turquoise, let me know. https://jamesdant.com/products/waffle-mid-neck-284-dark-turquoise?variant=44262726762715

See all

Newman &

3.8(45 reviews)

6.7 mi•Broad Ripple

If you are looking for nicer men's apparel like a suit for a wedding, this is an excellent place to…read moreshop. The store feels luxurious when you walk in but also approachable. It isn't huge but has the wide array of items from suits and toes to hats and shoes. Keep in mind it is a consignment shop so nothing is returnable. So I recommend either being certain or trying it on to guarantee satisfaction. I loved the suit I picked for my husband but sadly the measurements we had were off and it doesn't fit. It was disappointing as we need a suit for an upcoming wedding. But I understand the policy. This the warning to try it on in the store! I'd go back (with him this time) and look again as they did have nice items. I was told I could also consign the item with them but that seems like a lot of extra work. I'll wait to see if maybe he can fit it down the road...or someone might need it more than us. But a nice spot for men's formal attire and nice dress shirts.

My experience is that there are a lot of consignment shops around Indianapolis that have women's…read moreclothing, but not as many that have men's clothing. Newman & Company exclusively sells men's clothing. You'll find formal wear, street wear, sweaters and hoodies, t-shirts, jackets and coats, jeans and pants and slacks, shoes, belts and accessories here. The shop is well curated, and all you'll see on the racks are straight-up hits. I visited with hoodies in mind. I was shopping for my teenage son. I really didn't know what to expect from this consignment store, but I found way more than I imagined! My son wears a man's size in sweatshirts, so I found a large variety of hoodies and sweatshirts that he might like. Keep in mind that this is a store for adults, so sizes start at adult small, which is actually pretty big. There are no children's clothing sizes here. I walked away with three hoodies, and because they were gifts, I obviously didn't try them on. Although, if I wanted to, there are changing rooms in the store. Be aware that all purchases are final. No returns! The service is top-notch. The people who work here are friendly and ready to help, but will also hang back and let you do your thing if you don't need them. When it came time to check out, they neatly folded my clothing as if it was their own. They have a no-bag policy, so be prepared to carry your clothing out sans bag. One thing to note: Newman & Company is affiliated with Amanda's Exchange, so if you have a rewards account with one, it is honored at the other.

Shoes

This guy

See all

Shoes

Heritage Clothier and Home

4.7(15 reviews)

5.2 mi•SoBro

I have to say, I love the selection and want to buy local but I have gone by three different times…read moreand each time it was closed for a different reason during regular business hours. I ended up buying at Bonobos because I simply can't keep driving back there.

This is a mens clothing shop on 54th in SoBro. Parking is somewhat limited. If your looking for…read morecasual wear that you're not going to see in the typical mall stores, this place is for you. Stan was managing the store on my visit. Stan was very pleasant and knowledgeable. Two things caught my eye, the selection of socks and the quality of the shirts. Stitch Note is a brand that I had not heard of before this trip. I like them because they had Egyptian Cotton and they were slim cut. I will visit this store again.

Something for everyone. Including fine linens and loungewear

See all

Voted "Best of Indy" 2017,2018 and 2019

A.Mina Fine Clothier & Tailors

4.7(32 reviews)

0.8 mi•Mile Square

Tony got me out of a pickle.... In and out in 10 min with a great sport coat! Highly recommend!read more

I haven't worn a tux since high school, so when I had to get one for a work black tie event, I was…read morenervous about what to do. I had a vague idea that I wanted something a little non-traditional but besides that I had no clue what I was after. Anthony was quick to make a great recommendation for a navy blue tux with a great cut for a slimmer guy, shawl collar, and black silk and satten accents. He was also patient. I thought I wanted a vest and when it came in I didn't like it and went with a cumberbun. I thought I wanted a certain shirt and he got it for me, but it turns out it didn't work and he had a plan B ordered for me just in case that happened. Everything was far more affordable than I anticipated, also. Anyway, I looked great last night. I snapped a few photos that I've attached (it's hard to capture a navy blue suit with black accents in dim light!), and I had a flood of compliments from everyone. Go see Anthony and he'll take care of you.

See all

The Shop

4.2(29 reviews)

6.4 mi•Broad Ripple

Biiiggg fan of The Shop and have been for years. They're usually a stop if I need Indiana merch to…read morehaul back with me to AZ- I love all of their designs (especially anything not in black/gold colors) and they offer more than your standard screen print on a cheap cotton Gildan tee (used to work in merchandise dev). For many years the colors, designs were not "official team" apparel which kept prices fairly low. Now that they've gotten into licensed team apparel, I've noticed some prices have gone up.. but it's the price of business. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ At any moment you'll see IU, Xurdue, Butler, Colts, Pacers and Indy 500 brands all over the store and online, with occasional touches into OSU, ISU (#LarryLegend), and retro brand fandom. The only less Hoosier Hopsitality thing about them is their staff - the guy working when I most recently stopped in did not appear approachable nor care to talk... but hello-- that is part of your job. The hipster Broad Ripple "I could care less" vibe he gave off left a sour taste in my mouth.

Stopped here during a trip to Indianapolis for the Taylor Swift Eras Tour. We heard from someone…read morethey were carrying some TS merch and we decided to check it out and so glad we did. They had 2-3 shirts that were Taylor themed and a cute sticker. The prices were affordable and I paid $24 for a shirt and $3 for a sticker. I wish they had a larger selection of designs on different types of shirts. For example, the design I really wanted was only available on a very think cotton shirt and I would have preferred a lighter and softer material.

0.9 mi•Mile Square, Wholesale District

This Indy tee is soft and comfy. This is exactly what I wanted in a shirt to represent my home.

See all

J Benzal Menswear

5.0(19 reviews)

Fabulous menswear store! My husband and I dropped in to check out the store downtown on a night…read moreout, and were impressed by the selection and the store owner, Ben. We went back the following week and Christine (store manager) outfitted my husband with a suit, shirts, shoes, belt and sports jacket. She is fantastic: friendly and knows her merchandise. Not pushy, just helpful and professional. Great store: fair prices, good quality and excellent service.

5 stars doesn't even begin to show how amazing Ben and the whole staff at JBenzal are. They made…read moreall the things happen and with such style and flair. We got our groomsmen and dad suits here as well as a custom suit for the groom. Best fit and best customer service. We will be back at any chance we get!!!

Tons of cuff links

See all

Vintage Vibe

5.0(1 review)

5.0 mi•SoBro

The selection is incredible, constantly changing, and RARE. Every visit leads to an amazing find…read more The owner is friendly, helpful, and clearly takes pride in keeping the store welcoming and stocked with nostalgic pieces. I walked out with some things I wore in '95 and a few other vintage treasures I didn't even know I needed. Go in and unlock some core memories.

See all

Raleigh Limited Menswear

3.7(3 reviews)

9.6 mi

•$$$$

Overpriced and bad quality. I bought my wedding suits there. The material wrinkled on the way to…read morethe ceremony. I paid a lot of money and the pictures looked horrible. I went back and the staff just shrug their shoulders and said humidity can do that. I have given them a chance before and this experience ended any hope I have of the quality of the clothes and service you get here.

Yup....great guys....even after spending on a tux, shirt, sox, pre-tied tie....and that thing that…read moregoes around your waste to make you look svelte....more damn money than I usually spend on a fine used automobile....but WTH ? GF's daughters debutante cotillion thingy with bands, rich people, caviar, white gloves....and moi ! What ? No open bar ???? and I popped for a Limo ??? Thanks to Raleigh for helping to erase the "Rube" factor and reducing the embarrassment suffered by the GF and her extended and gracious family .... Wow ???? There is something called a salad fork ?

Suits Indianapolis

Custom Suits Indianapolis IN

See all

Formal Wear Indianapolis IN

5.11 Tactical

5.0(2 reviews)

10.2 mi•Allisonville

Large selection. Great deals. Friendly staff. The store is clean and inviting. I love the quality…read moreof the 5.11 brand and the store is great to try fits and see what works. The people who work there are always friendly and knowledgable.

Best local option for people looking for solid apparel and accessories for more functional and…read moretactical uses. Solid staff who are serving not peddling and you get what you pay for and it lasts.

See all

Andrew Davis Clothiers

4.4(18 reviews)

47.0 mi

Best menswear shop in Bloomington and Indy, no contest. I've been coming here for years. Richie and…read morethe team give honest, personal style advice and bring in great international brands you won't find anywhere else.

First class experience and selection! The advantage of the tangible experience cannot be…read moreunderestimated in the clothier business. I look forward to my next visit... Perry Mervar

See all

Toolbox Men's Supply Company - menscloth - Updated September 2026

People found Toolbox Men's Supply Company by searching for…

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Toolbox Men's Supply Company also viewed

Good Neighbor

4.6

(13 reviews)

An absolute gem in the heart of mass ave! They have the cutest selection of clothes, handbags, and…read morejewelry from local vendors! The sales associates are always friendly, and help pick out their recommendations! Overall, I'd rather spend my money here than at the mall.

Good Neighbor is a great little boutique in the Bottleworks Hotel building. Their motto is "good…read moreclothes make good neighbors." It's pretty trendy and carries both women and mens clothing. It you want something you won't see everywhere else give it a try.

Nap Or Nothing

4.8

(11 reviews)

Nap Or Nothing is a good addition to Mass Ave and a great ambassador to what Indy creatives has to…read moreoffer. In addition to its namesake brand, the store carries apparel and streetwear from other Indianapolis companies. It was originally a pop-up but has now secured a three-year commitment at the location through a city initiative. The initiative was meant to promote Black-owned businesses at prominent locations across the city. The store carries T-shirts, hoodies, pants, and hats at various price points. It's nice to see some retail options in addition to all the food establishments on Mass Ave. Because of the high foot traffic, I hope Nap Or Nothing does well and showcase what Indy has to offer.

Don't ask me why I am JUST now purchasing & supporting Nap or Nothing. Just know I'm a fan and they…read morehave a customer in me. While on my lunch break I decided to put some extra time for my spot to browse for an item. I walked in and was immediately greeted and given a quick brief rundown of the store since it was my first time in. I was appreciative of the context as it made me be more intentional to enjoy the artwork, as it's all local. I was looking for something to be able to rock this summer and in the airport as I have several trips planned. Although Maxie was assisting another customer, it was nice to see him present and to still make a quick touch point with me. I found 2 great pieces and LOVED that the hat I got came with buttons. All in all...VISIT & SUPPORT this local business. Great things are happening and when you walk in, rather you're from Indy or not, it will feel like home My only suggestions: -invest in a few mirrors for customers to see the look -DONT STOP GOING!

Newman &

3.8

(45 reviews)

If you are looking for nicer men's apparel like a suit for a wedding, this is an excellent place to…read moreshop. The store feels luxurious when you walk in but also approachable. It isn't huge but has the wide array of items from suits and toes to hats and shoes. Keep in mind it is a consignment shop so nothing is returnable. So I recommend either being certain or trying it on to guarantee satisfaction. I loved the suit I picked for my husband but sadly the measurements we had were off and it doesn't fit. It was disappointing as we need a suit for an upcoming wedding. But I understand the policy. This the warning to try it on in the store! I'd go back (with him this time) and look again as they did have nice items. I was told I could also consign the item with them but that seems like a lot of extra work. I'll wait to see if maybe he can fit it down the road...or someone might need it more than us. But a nice spot for men's formal attire and nice dress shirts.

My experience is that there are a lot of consignment shops around Indianapolis that have women's…read moreclothing, but not as many that have men's clothing. Newman & Company exclusively sells men's clothing. You'll find formal wear, street wear, sweaters and hoodies, t-shirts, jackets and coats, jeans and pants and slacks, shoes, belts and accessories here. The shop is well curated, and all you'll see on the racks are straight-up hits. I visited with hoodies in mind. I was shopping for my teenage son. I really didn't know what to expect from this consignment store, but I found way more than I imagined! My son wears a man's size in sweatshirts, so I found a large variety of hoodies and sweatshirts that he might like. Keep in mind that this is a store for adults, so sizes start at adult small, which is actually pretty big. There are no children's clothing sizes here. I walked away with three hoodies, and because they were gifts, I obviously didn't try them on. Although, if I wanted to, there are changing rooms in the store. Be aware that all purchases are final. No returns! The service is top-notch. The people who work here are friendly and ready to help, but will also hang back and let you do your thing if you don't need them. When it came time to check out, they neatly folded my clothing as if it was their own. They have a no-bag policy, so be prepared to carry your clothing out sans bag. One thing to note: Newman & Company is affiliated with Amanda's Exchange, so if you have a rewards account with one, it is honored at the other.

Frances+Parke

5.0

(5 reviews)

Francis+Parke is a lovely little boutique in downtown Zionsville that sells men and women's casual…read morewear. The shop is locally owned and operated. The business relocated recently to this new storefront to expand. The interior is decorated in an industrial style with a few repurposed items as decor. The store is immaculate and well organized. They carry seasonal clothes and currently have a nice selection of colorful tops and dresses for women. The high-end men's bathing suits caught my eye and would make great Father's Day presents. They also carry a few specialty bar items, such as bourbon cherries. The clerk was friendly and welcoming. Worth checking out.

Best boutique in the state, truly top notch merchandising! Impeccably curated collection that is…read morealways "classically current" per their motto! The shelves are always stocked with tasteful inventory that suits most that would find themselves walking on Main Street in Zionsville. The brands are all high quality with many brands you'll recognize and quite a few you'll be pleasantly introduced to. I've been twice with my girlfriend while waiting on our table at Rosie's and we found great stuff both times. The owner Tracy Dull has amazing taste, takes great care in helping you shop (without being pushy) and just makes you enjoy the experience from the second you walk in until the moment you leave!

Heritage Clothier and Home

4.7

(15 reviews)

I have to say, I love the selection and want to buy local but I have gone by three different times…read moreand each time it was closed for a different reason during regular business hours. I ended up buying at Bonobos because I simply can't keep driving back there.

This is a mens clothing shop on 54th in SoBro. Parking is somewhat limited. If your looking for…read morecasual wear that you're not going to see in the typical mall stores, this place is for you. Stan was managing the store on my visit. Stan was very pleasant and knowledgeable. Two things caught my eye, the selection of socks and the quality of the shirts. Stitch Note is a brand that I had not heard of before this trip. I like them because they had Egyptian Cotton and they were slim cut. I will visit this store again.

James Dant

4.2

(39 reviews)

Great clothes but shit customer service. They have unique pieces but now that I have a very good…read morewardrobe I won't be shopping with them. Milblend Supply, Self Edge, Blue Owl, Snake Oil Provisions, and Weathered Fig are some great alternatives.

Same, John B. Do not order online. Item was not listed "Final Sale" as other items on their website…read morewere, but they hand-wrote "Final Sale" on my invoice. Shirt doesn't fit and they won't accept return. Shirt was $145 on sale from $188. I didn't ask for money back, only store credit so that I could buy something that fits. If anyone wants a size large, Jackman Waffle Mid-Neck in Turquoise, let me know. https://jamesdant.com/products/waffle-mid-neck-284-dark-turquoise?variant=44262726762715

Younique Culture Boutique

4.0

(12 reviews)

Google says they open at noon on Sundays so I drove here. Door says it opens at 1. Waited until…read more1:40 with some other people and no one ever showed up. Great advertisement on TikTok but can't buy anything if you're not open.

I have been to this boutique so many times and I nearly always buy something. I regularly get asked…read morewhere I get these clothes from and get compliments on them. They have unique selections at affordable prices. The staff are always posting pictures of outfits on themselves which I love and they are incredibly friendly and helpful when I'm there!

Sage Boutique

4.1

(23 reviews)

Walked for over 40 min to arrive at your store when it opened at 11am. Sadly it was still not open…read moreat 1130am. Looked very cute from the window.

Totally recommend! Quality clothing! Great customer service ! A gem on mass ave. There needs to…read morebe more boutiques in the area. Parking is the only drawback - downtown meters are a pain!

Blue Peppermint Boutique

4.1

(14 reviews)