The best pizza in town. The breadsticks are great. They have a lot on their menu but it's hard to choose anything other than the amazing pizza. read more

Top Hat Two - Pepperoni with extra Cheese - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

I know I am weird, but I love crustless pizza. I love how they put it in a nice little metal pan and it comes out tasting just like a pizza. Today I asked them for extra green pepper and onion and they accommodated. The service was fast and friendly and I love the people who helped me. I just love it when a staff is friendly and you can chat a little bit and they really seem happy to be where they are. Love this location. It is pick up only. read more

See all

Wow! What a great surpriseTop Hat Two was. I'm not sure why the name is Top Hat Two but it is a Pizza King drive thru. This is by far the best Pizza King that I have had. Great pizza. The lady taking the order and making the pizza was very nice. All around great experience I ordered a large Kings Feast and didn't make a dent in it. There will be enough for dinner and then some. read more

Top Hat Two - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

Excellent food Excellent service fresh ingredients I love the royal feast no matter how much it cost

I can't imagine anyone ever rating this pizza anything other than 5 star+++!!!! Best and most unique pizza in the world. There is no other pizza like this so it's a top priority if you live out of the area when you hit the NC limits. read more

I grew-up in New Castle but moved to L.A. for many years. Family matters have brought me back to my hometown for a few weeks, so being that I have very happy memories of my parents ordering yummy pizza from Top Hat II, exclusively, I have been to this very restaurant three times to pick-up a pizza for dinner. The first two times back, the pizza was all right, greasy but a ton of pepperoni will emit this. This last time, me and my family chose to order just a 16' double cheese pizza which tasted good, except for the cardboard (and the black char) we had to peel off in chunks from the bottom of the crust. I want to point out in this review that if you are used to the small-mind-close-knit mentality of those running a small business like this one, then the rudeness of the people who seem to always be managing this place should not anger you too much. However, if you are like myself and you only need a couple of times of being treated as though your patronage is not welcome due to the fact that these people working here do not not like people whom they aren't in good with, then you'd probably do well to never stop in this place. I know that I won't ever again. read more

Top Hat Two - Have fun peeling that $30.00 pizza off the cardboard! - Pizza Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

Heard so much about how wonderful it was that I was really expecting to be blown away. It was good. But I'm not sure it was all the rave!

Best pizza anywhere... the sausage and pep is amazing. Don't even get extra cheese because you never need it. The royal feast is good also.

These ladies really know how to make a pizza! Get ur monies worth In toppings and have the best crust!

I hate their food. Pizza King is some of the worst Pizza I have ever had. They are very nice at this one though. That is why they got 3 stars for their customer service not for their food. read more

This is the best pizza in new castle royal feast is awsome. This is a must have in new castle

I really hate this pizza. The sauce is bland. The cheese is good but the crust is not. The people at this location are very nice as previous reviews have pointed out. Sadly they have great service and great people they just lack a quality product to push them past 2 stars. read more

Growing up in New Castle, everyone knows that Pizza King is the best pizza ever!. My favorite is the sausage, onion and extra cheese. Yum! This is the only place I will eat sausage on my pizza because it is crumbled. Everyone else wants to put on those big pieces which I think is nasty. For those who have moved out of town and out of state, Top Hat Pizza King 1 and/or 2 are a must visit place when going back to NC. read more

A local take-out favorite. Check out their hot sub sandwich and don't forget to ask them to "King" your pizza!

I totally agree with Nancy...this is absolutely the best pizza ever...whenever I hit NC, I have to have my Royal Feast. It just doesn't get any better! read more

I wanted to try a new pizza place in town so I looked on Yelp and was confused by Shi K's review until I went to this location. It is called Top Hat Two but it is just another Pizza King! I agree with Shi K the people were very nice but Pizza King is not good pizza! read more

Do not go here. Ordered two large pizza's one topping, over the phone; when in town camping. The bill was $48.00. The pizza was terrible. It was orange from all the grease. The crust was good, like the first reviewer said. The rest of it, was not worth $48.00. read more