This is a kid and/or adult's dream--regardless of what you're looking for. They have a bit of…read moreeverything for the kid who wants to play or find some unusual toys for their ever-expanding collection, or an adult who wants to revel in some nostalgia. In addition, the staff are kind, helpful, and knowledgeable about their various products. Finally, if you are looking to sell or trade some items, they are fair and considerate when reviewing your items. Every city needs a "Toy Pit."

As an Elder Millennial raising little 90's wannabees, this shop has quickly become a family…read morefavorite. Everyone working there is really friendly and helpful. There's always been at least one employee that will geek out with us about our favorite characters. I recently purchased a Coraline doll for my youngest from The Toy Pit, and she was so thrilled. She's carried her everywhere for the last week. Their Barbie collection is pretty impressive. You can also find Labubu and My Little Ponies from the 80's. There's always something new to check out.

Absolutely wonderful place. The staff was super helpful when we needed to pick out a double…read morestroller. She was super understanding when my daughter was being fussy. This place is VERY clean. They clean all their products before putting them out which is a huge bonus when shopping for consignment items. I highly recommend checking this place out! We will definitely be going back!!

From the owner: For Tots, Teens and In-between. We carry toys, baby gear, feeding necessities, baby carriers,…read morecloth diapers, video games and so much more.

My four year old and I had a blast here eventful picking out his fifth birthday present. I gave him…read more$20 and let him pick something out. Good news is, this spot has a variety of price points and nearly everything is educational in some way, shape or form. I felt like we couldn't go wrong here. It was also so nostalgic to explore all the items and recall early elementary years- science kits, phonics, outdoor play, learning books, you name it. This store packs a punch. I also appreciated how clean and organized everything was. We ended up with a mini robot kit and a drill set. Can't wait for our next visit!

Very interested in coming back. I was not let down by my online research on this store. There was a…read morevery large selection of educational tools and/or educational toys. We are very excited to come back for more visits. The staff member that helped us (wish I could remember her name) was super helpful and patient as she walked us through some of the sections.

The Toy Chest will make you feel like a kid again no matter what your age! I swung by Nashville…read moreafter a day spent at Brown County State Park and luckily got to drop into the Toy Chest before their 6pm closing. I had so much fun shopping for books for my niece, and even picked up some Smiskis for myself. They are the only authorized Smiski seller in the state of Indiana, so I'm happy I got to drop in. The prices are great and the staff are super friendly. It's definitely worth checking out!

Warning: Don't take your grandchildren, or you will come out broke! This is a cute little…read moreindependent toy store located in an old house in Nashville. The rooms are packed with higher quality toys for toddlers up to teenagers. There was an interesting assortment of books including early readers. They carry many Melissa and Doug toys. Expect premium pricing. The Toy Chest is an excellent place to pick up quality gifts while supporting a locally owned business. There is limited (free) street parking, so get there early or plan on walking.

Possibly the largest and greatest toy store in the tristate. You can find what you're looking…read morefor...and more! From infant to "child at heart", you are guaranteed to find the perfect gift. They even have a keurig if you'd fancy a cup of coffee while your children make their choices. And don't forget the birthday club and get your little one signed up! Stop at the counter and ask any of the friendly employees for info. Money well spent!

It's a neat little shop to go into and got a lot of little toys and drink it you can buy look at I…read morethink I have the kids area too

First time going into this toy store, amazing service! The lady behind the counter was super…read morefriendly, greeted us when we walked in and made an effort to get to know us and what ours needs were. She was very warm and welcoming, showed us in the right direction of what we were shopping for. Highly recommend and will definitely be back! Thank you for such a great experience! She also has the best selection of toys!

Such a gem! After being in town a few days and driving past Blue Turtle Toys multiple times, we had…read moreto pop in! They carry the best selection of unique toys for all ages and interests! High quality brands at fair prices - you can't leave without buying a few goodies! We will be back next time we're in town!

They are very strange on what they will take & wont. One day it's one thing another day it's…read moresomething else. When they are giving you back what they wouldn't take they are very rude. I lost my grand babies in a car accident and don't appreciate some of their comments. Don't ever say something you wouldn't want a customer to hear you never know what situation they are in. Funny thing is some items we had just bought from them and they wouldn't take them because they were out of style. I worked very hard washing and making sure the clothes had no stains. Plus they were all high end name brands. It didn't matter to this snooty woman and by the way. What she was wearing was out of style. Do unto others as you would have done to yourself.

I'm a regular at this Once Upon A Child location. I buy almost all of my kids clothes there and…read morealso take clothes and other items to sell. I spend way less than I would elsewhere to get their clothes for the next season and I love purchasing 2nd hand to reduce impact.

Great local store with a nice selection of toys for younger children. Some unique items. Neatly…read moreorganized displays.

I went here again because I have great nieces and nephews of all ages. I don't always know what to…read moreget for them, so I just tell them whether it's for a boy or a girl and what age they are. They show me what they recommend, and I choose one gift from those choices and one gift that I just like myself- and this works perfectly! They told me about a card game I was not familiar with, and she loved it! I have been going here (at its various locations) for decades!

Only went in for a few minutes. The store is big, but lots of empty space. There is a dedicated…read morearea for gamers to assemble and hang out. There are hobby model paints available for $4.00 each. A good stock of board games. There is lots of parking outside. A nice game shop!

I was there 2 months ago but never got the chance to write a review but I had a great time. The…read moreemployees asked me if I needed anything. Overall great service. Thank you Wizard's Keep.