Food was excellent. Got a grandma slice and cheese and pepperoni. Super nice undercarriage and solid flavor from the pie. The owner was there and he was super nice. Wasn't too busy and they had the games on for march madness. Def would recommend. Best pizza I've had in Colorado Springs! Cool sports jerseys and stuff on the walls. Nice clean tables. read more

Legit slice! Felt like pizza and wanted to try some place I hadn't tried before. Opted for the hot honey pepperoni and was happy to see a variety of pepperoni, ample cheese, delicious sauce, NY style crust, cooked perfectly and finished with the hot honey which adds just the right bit of heat and sweet! It was delivered hot and fresh and though it took an hour to arrive it was worth it. I'll certainly try this place again. read more

Upstate Pizzeria - Hot honey pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

Best pizza in Colorado Springs. Great ingredients, tasty dough, cheese, and sauce. We only wish the dining area had a little more ambiance like its downtown location did. read more

Great pizza! Now this is what pizza should taste like. I ordered thru door dash so I'm not sure about a lot of things but I can say our pizza was fresh, good quality & we all agree that we want to order from here from now on. read more

See all

We came here on Saturday night and surprisingly it wasn't too crowded. They are located on the second floor of a food court setting. Love the ambiance as soon as you walk in, they have live music, a pool table, and seating inside and on the balcony area too. As we approached the counter, the two men working greeted us and assisted us with ordering. My family and I were each ordering our pizzas and they suggested we do a 20 inch pizza. They were willing to split it into quarters so each one was different. I've never been to a place that recommended this and was so pleased. Our food came out in an appropriate time and we enjoyed it on their balcony. We all loved it and will definitely be back when we're craving for some good NY style pizza. read more

Upstate Pizzeria - Meat Lovers, Hawaiian, Cheese and Chicken Bacon pizza - Pizza Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

Solid pizza, could use more sauce but overall I'd definitely recommend trying it. I'm a crust man and this crust is well prepared

Best pizza in the Springs and the staff is amazing. This pizza has a perfect crust and all the toppings are fresh and perfectly portioned. It's not fancy inside but it makes up for it by taking you to Flavorville, population YOU. read more

Food was really good. Order was ready quick. Great spot. Had a really cool vibe. We ordered takeout.

Descent pizza but nothing exceptional that's served in a bar that's not really designed for eating a full pizza. Pizza has some good crust, good hold and not too floppy, with a nice crisp on the bottom. The crust is not salted enough and you can tell when eating the crust edges. Cheese was plenty as well as the toppings. Sauce had too much oregano and you can really tell on the edge spots where there were toppings or cheese. Garlic knots were good. Not too dry, crispy outside and soft inside. Nice amount of butter covering the knots. While it is nice to be in a bar if you want to get drinks or play some pool the tables are really designed for the bar experience and not for getting a lot of food. Service is just a walk up counter and you pick up your food from there so not much to talk about. Not necessarily bad food, probably great for a lunch slice but not the best for a whole pizza. read more

Upstate Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

My husband and I got a large supreme pizza but added hot honey to it. The pizza was HUGE and so mouthwatering delicious! We totally could have gotten a medium but we enjoyed the leftovers! We ate out on the patio and grabbed a blood orange beer from the downstairs bar. I would definitely go back next time we are in the Springs! read more

Upstate Pizzeria - Supreme pizza, we added hot honey - Pizza Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

Really friendly service here! Walk through the food court and head upstairs to find another bar and Upstate Pizzeria. You can order slices or from their full menu. We opted to order a freshly-made pie and the large was huge! The three of us could barely make a dent in it. We also enjoyed a house salad that was also generous enough for the 3 of us to enjoy. Note: the bar is a separate entity from the restaurant. Not an issue, just know that you're buying from different providers. I thought the pizza was good: nice flavor to the sauce and fresh toppings; the crust is more dense than some I've had. It was out of the oven and on our table in less than 15 minutes! Definitely check it out if you're in the neighborhood and looking for a slice or a full pie. read more

Upstate Pizzeria - Large pepperoni and green pepper pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

Great NY style pizza place in the Springs with lots of variety! I've enjoyed my food every time.

My 6 year old chose to take me here for Mother's Day along with the rest of our fam. Super laidback environment with the nicest owner and staff. They all provided the warmest and attentive service. We ordered 2 different pizzas, salads, and 2 different kinds of wings. The house salads were delicious for how generic that order seems. Wings were really well seasoned and crispy without being oily. My whole family loves the pizza (I thought the crust was great but with toppings it was a little salty and under seasoned for me). The cheesecake, well it's made in house and my husband said it's the best cheese cake he's ever had. All and all we are excited to continue to support this small business in the future. Hope they're around for a long time. read more

Really good NY style slices in Colorado Springs, possibly the best of its pizza type. It's thin, has a little crunch, but is still foldable and the cheese to sauce ratio is just right. The people at the stall are also very nice, especially because you'll be back a couple times to get another slice. It's hard to go wrong with good pizza in a food hall, and this is a great spot when you need a NY pizza fix in the springs. read more

Upstate Pizzeria - Slice - Pizza Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

Best New York Style in town!!! Staff has always been awesome and they are very knowledgeable in their menu! I love their mango habanero wings!! It has a kick which I absolutely love! Pizza slices are a must (fold as needed ;) read more

Best Pizza Joint in the Springs Hands Down! Food is always fresh and always filling! Customer service is top notch and I'm so glad they are opened for lunch. read more

See all

Underseasoned, too salty. Salt alone is not a seasoning nor spice. No fresh ingredients. No flavor, unless you count salt. read more

So yummy! I'm from upstate New York and it was pretty much spot on. We will be returning to this place for our pizza while living in Colorado Springs. Two slice special with a drink for ~$10.50 not NY prices but still worth it to me to return. The cashier was really nice and the service was pretty quick. Also the restaurant itself is located in Avenue Nineteen which also contains other restaurants, a bar and plenty of seating - tables and more casual seating like oversized couches and chairs. We went for lunch but would love to come back in the afternoon / evening as I feel it would be a great spot to grab a few drinks and a slice of pizza. read more

Upstate Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

See all

We ordered a large pepperoni pizza and garlic knots. The pizza was delicious and the garlic knots were the best we've had! Make sure and get a side or 2 of the garlic parm sauce!! Service was great too! read more

This is our third time ordering delivery from here and they never disappoint! We decided to try the white pie this time and I am so glad we did! I like it better than the traditional one, but both are delish! Our go to spot for NY style pizza in the springs! read more

Upstate Pizzeria - Forgot to take a photo before digging in. White pie with spinach, tomato, and bacon. Incredible!!! - Pizza Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

This place is disgusting, we ordered through DoorDash and we got a burnt pizza when we called them they blamed DoorDash for their burnt pizza and told us to call them. DoorDash said they'd redeliver, of course they never did but claimed that they gave us another pizza. These people are nothing but trash and so is their food. See picture, it was a gorgeous burnt pizza. read more

Upstate Pizzeria - Burnt pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

Good slice. Great crust. In and out quick lunch. Won't break the bank. Staff is very friendly and fun to talk with.

Great pizza, better service. Someone stole my pickup order and they promptly remade it and apologized to me even though it wasn't their fault. I am so happy they're on my side of town now after their move, I will always support this place. read more

I have craved north east pizza since I've lived here and this place is as close as it gets! Owner is an awesome guy too. Got a little nervous when they moved cause you never know if it's going to be the same, but it's just as good every time! read more

The 20 inch pie! It is as it should be in the pizza universe. Great tasting crust and toppings. Thin as can be and well made. I'm happy. Give them a go. They open at a little late in the day but that is ok. I do the white pie and add meatball. Happy eating! read more

I'm from NJ and I was expecting typical NYC style pizza. It's not what we got, I guess upstate NY pizza is different than NYC pizza. But with that being said the pizza was excellent!!!! Quality ingredients and flavor. Worth it if you want to try something new. Would 100% order from them again. read more

Absolutely delicious!! Great service!! They gave the best home made pizza I've had in years!!

New pizza place from upstate New York just opened up as one of the new vendors at the te-opened Avenue 19. I don't know how this owner does everything himself but he's only been open three or four weeks. And the pizza is the best around here! The crust was perfect, as was the sauce and fresh/abundant ingredients! The pizza itself was perfect!! definitely my go to pizza place. I've been looking for a good consistent pizza place for a while that was consistent with a New York pizzeria! The atmosphere is great, it's in the food hall, so everybody can get anything they want and there's a full bar. $28 for 5 slices either 3 ingredients, including tip! he offers full pies, of course, but we are in a hurry, so just grabbed a couple slices! even though they weren't ultimate fresh right out of the oven, they were reheated and came out still tasty and not dry! Definitely, my go to pizza place now! read more

Upstate Pizzeria - pepperoni and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

See all

Food was awful. Service nonexistent. Ambiance... uhhh there was a basketball game in that's cool.

Delicious pizza, fast service, cool location and the owner is super friendly. Definitely recommend trying and we will be back frequently!

Great pizza! The staff is great and the upstairs location is unique. I will recommend this restaurant / bar!

Fantastic pizza and atmosphere, super nice people... I love the whole food court atmosphere, if you can't find something, you're not trying read more

Upstate Pizzeria - a pizza with pepperoni and onions - Pizza Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

Great food and great service. Loved it! The slice of pizza was huge so more then enough for me.

Really chill and lowkey place with nice and friendly service. I purchased a 2 slice lunch special, but the slices were pretty burnt. Judging by the pictures and reviews, you'd probably have more luck getting a good slice if you order an entire pie for dine-in. read more

Pizza is very regional. I cut my teeth on Long Island (NY style) pies, and once you move away, finding a match can be tricky. The sauce and crust are key- Rich from upstate NY won me over at the first bite, and what a nice guy! New fave in the Springs read more

Born and bred NYer, now call Colorado Springs home. This is New York QUALITY Pizza. Kudos, reminds me of NY and how Pizza should taste! read more

Incredible pizza, not many other places in the Springs offer food this great at this reasonable of a price. Upstate deserves its own brick and mortar building. read more

Disgustingly greasy pizza. Not even palatable. Pizza box looked like it had been in a war. . Expensive. Moved from Texas over the weekend sand could not even eat it after being dog tired and starving. read more

Upstate Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Colorado Springs, Colorado

Wow! This is by far the very best NY style pizza in Colorado Springs! I highly recommend

Taste is fantastic and location is great. Only reason this is not 5 star is due to the additional topping prices and amount of toppings added to the pie. Would come back for sure. read more